WBAUnofficial
National Service - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: National Service (/showthread.php?tid=33890)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21


RE: National Service - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-27-2024

(05-27-2024, 11:59 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Well quite. I think many NHS Trust boards would love to stick to healthcare provision. However, Andrew Lansley decided in 2012 to reconfigure the NHS and put budgetary, planning and commissioning in the hands of clinicians. Add to this the diabolical decision to limit pay for execs and make their salaries publishable (limiting the talent pool) meant you have have public organisations the size of large companies (Guys and St Thomas’ budget is £2.5bn) in the hands of leaders lacking experience, capability and understanding due to the aforementioned constraints.

To fix the NHS you need:
- leaders who are credible and experienced
- reduce the budget by 15% (focus on change not continuation of outdated practices)
- reduce the range of services away from nice to have to invest in need to have
- an honest conversation with the public on what can and will be funded.
- to stop saying free at the point of care, it takes the value away from delivery and people forget they pay for it.

To fix the NHS you have to make them accountable for their failings - across successive Governments.

Leaders need to lead on clinical matters, and take finance away from them.

Agree on what can be funded. 

Perhaps a European model where money is not invested directly from our taxes into a centralised system, but instead an insurance based approach?

I don't think there are honestly any right or wrong approaches, but other countries are dealing with it better than the UK is.


RE: National Service - DemonicBaggie - 05-27-2024

(05-27-2024, 12:23 AM)1952 Wrote:
(05-26-2024, 11:03 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:
(05-26-2024, 09:16 PM)1952 Wrote: Definitely a great solution to the feral kids problem. Also being back corporal and capital punishment. It never did anyone any harm.

Genuinely the funniest post I've ever read on here.

Thanks, I appreciate that.


My pleasure. You're on a roll.



RE: National Service - Borin' Baggie - 05-27-2024

(05-27-2024, 12:15 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 11:59 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Well quite. I think many NHS Trust boards would love to stick to healthcare provision. However, Andrew Lansley decided in 2012 to reconfigure the NHS and put budgetary, planning and commissioning in the hands of clinicians. Add to this the diabolical decision to limit pay for execs and make their salaries publishable (limiting the talent pool) meant you have have public organisations the size of large companies (Guys and St Thomas’ budget is £2.5bn) in the hands of leaders lacking experience, capability and understanding due to the aforementioned constraints.

To fix the NHS you need:
- leaders who are credible and experienced
- reduce the budget by 15% (focus on change not continuation of outdated practices)
- reduce the range of services away from nice to have to invest in need to have
- an honest conversation with the public on what can and will be funded.
- to stop saying free at the point of care, it takes the value away from delivery and people forget they pay for it.

To fix the NHS you have to make them accountable for their failings - across successive Governments.

Leaders need to lead on clinical matters, and take finance away from them.

Agree on what can be funded. 

Perhaps a European model where money is not invested directly from our taxes into a centralised system, but instead an insurance based approach?

I don't think there are honestly any right or wrong approaches, but other countries are dealing with it better than the UK is.

"European approach"

Other countries in Europe have Beveridge model healthcare systems, and they're better than the vast majority of social insurance models. German healthcare, the oft touted "golden child" of Bismarck model countries has the exact same problems as the NHS does (because of money not going far enough with the more expensive cost of treatment, the fact that people are living longer and the median population age is increasing), and the best performing area of German healthcare is the publicly operated research hospitals.

The issue with the healthcare system in the UK is, ironically, the under resourcing of the private healthcare operations (dental, primary care, social care) which are holdovers from when we used the Bismarck model and would therefore be identical in operation if we moved back to a social insurance model. I fail to see how or why the funding model is the problem.


RE: National Service - Woodman scoreboard - 05-27-2024

You lot on here are more itk about health care etc as it looks you work at that area .

How much more in taxes would we pay to make a difference to the NHS or totally start from scratch and start again with part NHS part Insurance......if I thought it would make a difference I would gladly pay more but who else would and would you sacrifice a season ticket at the albion for the cause .....

Would love to know how it could work


RE: National Service - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-27-2024

(05-27-2024, 01:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 12:15 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 11:59 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Well quite. I think many NHS Trust boards would love to stick to healthcare provision. However, Andrew Lansley decided in 2012 to reconfigure the NHS and put budgetary, planning and commissioning in the hands of clinicians. Add to this the diabolical decision to limit pay for execs and make their salaries publishable (limiting the talent pool) meant you have have public organisations the size of large companies (Guys and St Thomas’ budget is £2.5bn) in the hands of leaders lacking experience, capability and understanding due to the aforementioned constraints.

To fix the NHS you need:
- leaders who are credible and experienced
- reduce the budget by 15% (focus on change not continuation of outdated practices)
- reduce the range of services away from nice to have to invest in need to have
- an honest conversation with the public on what can and will be funded.
- to stop saying free at the point of care, it takes the value away from delivery and people forget they pay for it.

To fix the NHS you have to make them accountable for their failings - across successive Governments.

Leaders need to lead on clinical matters, and take finance away from them.

Agree on what can be funded. 

Perhaps a European model where money is not invested directly from our taxes into a centralised system, but instead an insurance based approach?

I don't think there are honestly any right or wrong approaches, but other countries are dealing with it better than the UK is.

"European approach"

Other countries in Europe have Beveridge model healthcare systems, and they're better than the vast majority of social insurance models. German healthcare, the oft touted "golden child" of Bismarck model countries has the exact same problems as the NHS does (because of money not going far enough with the more expensive cost of treatment, the fact that people are living longer and the median population age is increasing), and the best performing area of German healthcare is the publicly operated research hospitals.

The issue with the healthcare system in the UK is, ironically, the under resourcing of the private healthcare operations (dental, primary care, social care) which are holdovers from when we used the Bismarck model and would therefore be identical in operation if we moved back to a social insurance model. I fail to see how or why the funding model is the problem.

The funding model isn't the problem per se, it is how the funds are utilised. I agree the use of private resources need to be used more.

That's been a problem of successive governments of both sides. The NHS has become a cash cow, and is not held accountable for how it spends its resources in the way that a private company would be to its shareholders.


RE: National Service - Borin' Baggie - 05-27-2024

(05-27-2024, 02:00 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 01:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 12:15 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 11:59 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Well quite. I think many NHS Trust boards would love to stick to healthcare provision. However, Andrew Lansley decided in 2012 to reconfigure the NHS and put budgetary, planning and commissioning in the hands of clinicians. Add to this the diabolical decision to limit pay for execs and make their salaries publishable (limiting the talent pool) meant you have have public organisations the size of large companies (Guys and St Thomas’ budget is £2.5bn) in the hands of leaders lacking experience, capability and understanding due to the aforementioned constraints.

To fix the NHS you need:
- leaders who are credible and experienced
- reduce the budget by 15% (focus on change not continuation of outdated practices)
- reduce the range of services away from nice to have to invest in need to have
- an honest conversation with the public on what can and will be funded.
- to stop saying free at the point of care, it takes the value away from delivery and people forget they pay for it.

To fix the NHS you have to make them accountable for their failings - across successive Governments.

Leaders need to lead on clinical matters, and take finance away from them.

Agree on what can be funded. 

Perhaps a European model where money is not invested directly from our taxes into a centralised system, but instead an insurance based approach?

I don't think there are honestly any right or wrong approaches, but other countries are dealing with it better than the UK is.

"European approach"

Other countries in Europe have Beveridge model healthcare systems, and they're better than the vast majority of social insurance models. German healthcare, the oft touted "golden child" of Bismarck model countries has the exact same problems as the NHS does (because of money not going far enough with the more expensive cost of treatment, the fact that people are living longer and the median population age is increasing), and the best performing area of German healthcare is the publicly operated research hospitals.

The issue with the healthcare system in the UK is, ironically, the under resourcing of the private healthcare operations (dental, primary care, social care) which are holdovers from when we used the Bismarck model and would therefore be identical in operation if we moved back to a social insurance model. I fail to see how or why the funding model is the problem.

The funding model isn't the problem per se, it is how the funds are utilised. I agree the use of private resources need to be used more.

That's been a problem of successive governments of both sides. The NHS has become a cash cow, and is not held accountable for how it spends its resources in the way that a private company would be to its shareholders.

But it's not really the NHS itself that's the issue with regards to the funding of healthcare resources, it's the DHSC and Treasury that's more bothered by putting money into the NHS for hospital care at the expense of other areas of healthcare funding.

And it's a self-fulfilling prophecy, the less money going into GPs or social care means more money needs to be given to the NHS to deal with patients going to hospital for problems that could have been dealt with early or even prevented through primary care and the more money needs to be spent on beds as there's no adequate social care structure to release patients that need social care support but don't need to be in a hospital into.


RE: National Service - BurleyBaggie - 05-27-2024

I can stand by the fact most public healthcare systems do not have the systemic and endemic issues we have here. This is my field and where I’ve worked for 20 years. I’ve been very lucky to travel to many different healthcare systems from the Nordics to Singapore or Hong Kong to the US and everywhere in between.

The German model which is actually a two tier model, pay basic get a decent service, pay more get seen more quickly etc, has the same challenges we have (elderly population, growing underlying health issues etc etc) however they come form a much higher base. Better infrastructure, better run services and leadership that is best of type and not just what they can afford in a faux pay structure.

So while they have problems they are better equipped to deal with it.

Also, it is not Nye Bevan model, it’s basically its insurance based like Ireland.

(05-27-2024, 02:09 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 02:00 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 01:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 12:15 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 11:59 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Well quite. I think many NHS Trust boards would love to stick to healthcare provision. However, Andrew Lansley decided in 2012 to reconfigure the NHS and put budgetary, planning and commissioning in the hands of clinicians. Add to this the diabolical decision to limit pay for execs and make their salaries publishable (limiting the talent pool) meant you have have public organisations the size of large companies (Guys and St Thomas’ budget is £2.5bn) in the hands of leaders lacking experience, capability and understanding due to the aforementioned constraints.

To fix the NHS you need:
- leaders who are credible and experienced
- reduce the budget by 15% (focus on change not continuation of outdated practices)
- reduce the range of services away from nice to have to invest in need to have
- an honest conversation with the public on what can and will be funded.
- to stop saying free at the point of care, it takes the value away from delivery and people forget they pay for it.

To fix the NHS you have to make them accountable for their failings - across successive Governments.

Leaders need to lead on clinical matters, and take finance away from them.

Agree on what can be funded. 

Perhaps a European model where money is not invested directly from our taxes into a centralised system, but instead an insurance based approach?

I don't think there are honestly any right or wrong approaches, but other countries are dealing with it better than the UK is.

"European approach"

Other countries in Europe have Beveridge model healthcare systems, and they're better than the vast majority of social insurance models. German healthcare, the oft touted "golden child" of Bismarck model countries has the exact same problems as the NHS does (because of money not going far enough with the more expensive cost of treatment, the fact that people are living longer and the median population age is increasing), and the best performing area of German healthcare is the publicly operated research hospitals.

The issue with the healthcare system in the UK is, ironically, the under resourcing of the private healthcare operations (dental, primary care, social care) which are holdovers from when we used the Bismarck model and would therefore be identical in operation if we moved back to a social insurance model. I fail to see how or why the funding model is the problem.

The funding model isn't the problem per se, it is how the funds are utilised. I agree the use of private resources need to be used more.

That's been a problem of successive governments of both sides. The NHS has become a cash cow, and is not held accountable for how it spends its resources in the way that a private company would be to its shareholders.

But it's not really the NHS itself that's the issue with regards to the funding of healthcare resources, it's the DHSC and Treasury that's more bothered by putting money into the NHS for hospital care at the expense of other areas of healthcare funding.

And it's a self-fulfilling prophecy, the less money going into GPs or social care means more money needs to be given to the NHS to deal with patients going to hospital for problems that could have been dealt with early or even prevented through primary care and the more money needs to be spent on beds as there's no adequate social care structure to release patients that need social care support but don't need to be in a hospital into.

Top post this. 

The overall combined budget is enough, c£230bn, we should be spending £20bn less on the NHS and more on social care inc third sector. 

A lot of the problems I see daily in big NHS orgs (aside from never wanting to change ‘we’ve always done it this way’) is an inability to discharge or create integrated care across the ‘care’ community. 

We are pretty much alone in Europe in this funding model of funding.

I know I know ICSs/ICBs are supposed to help with this but guess where most of the money sits and guess what type of people run the ICS…NHS people.

(05-27-2024, 01:56 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: You lot on here are more itk about health care etc as it looks you work at that area .

How much more in taxes would we pay to make a difference to the NHS or totally start from scratch and start again with part NHS part Insurance......if I thought it would make a difference I would gladly pay more but who else would and would you sacrifice a season ticket at the albion for the cause .....

Would love to know how it could work

It’s not more taxation really, it honestly needs to start with a recognition the NHS as it is, is unsustainable. 

The government needs to have an honest conversation with us. 

The German model of NHS and NHS+ might be a way forward. I think core NHS needs to reduce its scope as I said, needs to only provide necessary care not the additions we have today. That way a majority of people, especially those on lower incomes get the care they need more quickly and to a higher quality. If people want an increased scope, or wider access they can contribute more but that’s for the wants not needs of healthcare. 

That was you have a core service that would be better for 95% of the populous. 

However it involves serious change and it won’t happen while clinicians strike over any suggestion of change, or the gov of the day faces public outcry for changing their NHS.


RE: National Service - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-27-2024

I agree BB, that it needs an adult discussion, and all parties need to buy into this. Sadly, I can't see it happening, and the can will continue to be kicked down the road.


RE: National Service - Woodman scoreboard - 05-27-2024

(05-27-2024, 02:33 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I agree BB, that it needs an adult discussion, and all parties need to buy into this. Sadly, I can't see it happening, and the can will continue to be kicked down the road.

I know it's a bit ott but a proper referendum on this needs to be done.....or like you have said a adult discussion with honesty by doctors etc without the threat of being a whistle-blower and getting the sack .


RE: National Service - Psalm23 - 05-27-2024

(05-27-2024, 04:16 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(05-27-2024, 02:33 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I agree BB, that it needs an adult discussion, and all parties need to buy into this. Sadly, I can't see it happening, and the can will continue to be kicked down the road.

I know it's a bit ott but a proper referendum on this needs to be done.....or like you have said a adult discussion with honesty by doctors etc without the threat of being a whistle-blower and getting the sack .

Fuck that, the last referendum we had didn't go the way Decka hoped, & he's still fucking moaning 8 years later.      Big Grin