![]() |
|
GB News - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: GB News (/showthread.php?tid=18633) |
RE: GB News - Birdman1811 - 06-17-2021 (06-17-2021, 10:46 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(06-17-2021, 10:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:(06-17-2021, 10:38 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(06-17-2021, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: So. Agree. I come from a well off, if not wealthy background and quite right wing with it, I'm the family oddity in many ways, but then for a lot of reasons I had the most diverse teenage, early adult years. RE: GB News - steviedm - 06-17-2021 I've been following this thread with great interest. As someone who teaches media, it's fascinating to see so many informed viewpoints on both sides of the argument. The first thing to say is that the word 'plural' is important - a plural media is absolutely crucial for a functioning democracy. Unfortunately, plurality is lacking in the British print media with 80% of mainstream titles owned by a handful of billionaires, who push a right wing agenda and are mostly non-domiciled and pay no tax in the UK. There are some obvious exceptions but overall the press in the UK is indisputably biased to the right. Now, while newspapers can push whatever political agenda they choose, broadcast news is regulated differently and must be objective and non-political. Clearly, GB News is going to struggle here but presumably plans to avoid censure by planting a shill in each debate who appears to offer an alternative viewpoint but is simply there as a stooge to be shot down. This doesn't seem particularly mature, responsbile or an attempt to do something to elevate the standard of political discourse in this nation. I've tuned in a couple of times and haven't seen anything objectionable as yet, but it's obviously early days. The other thing to say is that people's in-built biases clearly feed into the way they react to this particular channel. And I have to say that the polarisation of politics in this nation (possibly driven by Brexit) is unhealthy in the extreme. I imagine I'll pretty much hate every opinion expressed on GB News as I am ideologically on the left and believe that better societies are created through equality of opportunity and policies that level the playing field for all. Contrary to cheap-shots about 'politics of envy', I am well aware that my brother and I, born to working class parents in Coseley, have been extraordinarily lucky and privileged to be in the positions in which we now find ourselves. I want everyone to have that opportunity. As a teacher I've seen this with my own eyes, but I know instinctively that the huge council estate situated half a mile from where I'm now sat houses some individuals with more brains, talents and ability than many of the privileged few who find their names on the Eton admission lists seconds after their birth. Anyway, I digress - my point is that I also acknowledge alternative viewpoints, appreciate that there are people on the right who equally believe in social justice and believe the policies they espouse can achieve it. Debating the merits of both arguments is what political discourse is about, not closing yourself off to other viewpoints simply because you don't agree with them. As Birdy points out, the majority of people hold some views that can be classed as left and some as right. A recent survey indicated that many people who are socially conservative hold more left-wing views on issues such as the economy. Perhaps I'm just getting old, but I'm pretty sure I remember a time when we didn't completely ostracise or berate people simply because they held a different opinion to our own. So it seem to me there is space for an enlightened, genuinely open platform to discuss major issues without bias. Unfortunately, GB News will not be that platform. It is simply a mechanism by which right wing millionaires seek to control public discourse - none of the channel's funders (who hail from enlightened places such as Dubai) have any history in television but plenty of history in funding right wing causes. The aim is to pull other channels to the right and promote right wing ideology. The requirement for balance in the UK means it will appear tamer than the unabashed Fox News in the US, but it doesn't mean the channels don't have similar purposes. Ultimately, we're back to plurality and the existence of GB News does absolutely nothing to make the British media more plural. In fact, the opposite is true. RE: GB News - Squid - 06-17-2021 (06-17-2021, 11:24 AM)steviedm Wrote: I've been following this thread with great interest. As someone who teaches media, it's fascinating to see so many informed viewpoints on both sides of the argument. The first thing to say is that the word 'plural' is important - a plural media is absolutely crucial for a functioning democracy. Unfortunately, plurality is lacking in the British print media with 80% of mainstream titles owned by a handful of billionaires, who push a right wing agenda and are mostly non-domiciled and pay no tax in the UK. There are some obvious exceptions but overall the press in the UK is indisputably biased to the right. Now, while newspapers can push whatever political agenda they choose, broadcast news is regulated differently and must be objective and non-political. Clearly, GB News is going to struggle here but presumably plans to avoid censure by planting a shill in each debate who appears to offer an alternative viewpoint but is simply there as a stooge to be shot down. This doesn't seem particularly mature, responsbile or an attempt to do something to elevate the standard of political discourse in this nation. I've tuned in a couple of times and haven't seen anything objectionable as yet, but it's obviously early days. Does that mean it should not exist though? Because that's what those trying to pull advertising from it are trying to do and I think that sets a very worrying precedent. That isn't debate or discussion, it's censorship via twitter mob. And for those who don’t care, because they're coming after people you don't like, be very aware that the winds of prevailing public opinion can change very rapidly. A useful tool for monitoring the prevailing trends of cancel culture (and yes, I agree that both the left and right use it) is the US FIRE website which monitors free speech on campus issues: https://www.thefire.org/ RE: GB News - DJPunkRoc - 06-17-2021 The GBeebies advertising issue is basically one of business risk. Will companies make more money from advertising on a channel than by "consciously withdrawing"? If you will then you continue advertising. Will GBeebies need to be clearer in their editorial policy about balance in order to attract sufficient advertising revenue to be viable (notwisthstanding the deep pockets of their funders)? If not, then they can follow the editorial line most people expect them to follow and who cares about the Twitter mob. Much like this thread, the pant wetters on twitter do nothing much more than give the "enemy" air to breath. Case in point, my wife who reads the news, watches it, but doesn't do social media, didn't know who Tommy Robinson is (!). If people didn't retweet their fury at people they'd just be like your common garden twats on social media. To the point where I wondered, last night, if the callers "Mike Hunt" etc had been placed by GBeebies themselves in order to gain exposure. It was bound to go viral - great free advertising... "Those lefty pricks" etc. RE: GB News - Derek Hardballs - 06-17-2021 (06-17-2021, 10:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:(06-17-2021, 10:38 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(06-17-2021, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: So. Exactly I am very aware that I have red lines such as the vaccine take up, anti-social behaviour etc where it could be argued that I am quite aligned to a complete lack of tolerance but on social justice etc I am very left wing by this countries standards. Supporting a political party like a football team is a very odd way to act. RE: GB News - bradesbaggie - 06-17-2021 So the people who told you Brexit means Brexit are now telling you that the biggest threat to your freedom is a Swedish furniture firm – and you believe them. RE: GB News - Protheroe - 06-17-2021 (06-17-2021, 06:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(06-16-2021, 08:35 PM)bill_baggie Wrote: The interview with Rishi Sunak followed by a high class discussion with Michael Portillo and I have long considered you terminally daft, but I can only guess that you didn't watch any of that hour. Neil skewered a visibly uncomfortable Chancellor on inflation expectations, debt, sound money, the ridiculous Triple Lock and the costs of net zero (amongst others). He got Sunak to claim that he was a "fiscal conservative" when all the evidence points to the contrary. The rigour with which that interview was conducted has been wholly missing from all other news channels for years, and to be fair Neil did a better job of scrutinising the nation's finances than the Opposition has done in 11 years. For the first time in my adult life, a Chancellor was being asked why the government was spending so much rather than why he wasn't spending enough. There then followed a thoughtful analysis of what Sunak had said, and importantly what he hadn't said. The fact that this interview took place at all on British TV provides your balance. No one else had done it in this manner, nor would do it in this manner. If you can't see that then you really are the fool I took you for. RE: GB News - Kit Kat Chunky - 06-17-2021 (06-17-2021, 11:43 AM)Squid Wrote:(06-17-2021, 11:24 AM)steviedm Wrote: I've been following this thread with great interest. As someone who teaches media, it's fascinating to see so many informed viewpoints on both sides of the argument. The first thing to say is that the word 'plural' is important - a plural media is absolutely crucial for a functioning democracy. Unfortunately, plurality is lacking in the British print media with 80% of mainstream titles owned by a handful of billionaires, who push a right wing agenda and are mostly non-domiciled and pay no tax in the UK. There are some obvious exceptions but overall the press in the UK is indisputably biased to the right. Now, while newspapers can push whatever political agenda they choose, broadcast news is regulated differently and must be objective and non-political. Clearly, GB News is going to struggle here but presumably plans to avoid censure by planting a shill in each debate who appears to offer an alternative viewpoint but is simply there as a stooge to be shot down. This doesn't seem particularly mature, responsbile or an attempt to do something to elevate the standard of political discourse in this nation. I've tuned in a couple of times and haven't seen anything objectionable as yet, but it's obviously early days. It's interesting. GB News aligns to the right, but I have no desire to watch it. I would much rather watch a channel that leans to the left, and draw my own conclusions, than be brainwashed by a right wing channel. I have the same issue with Mark Dolan and Julia Hartley-Brewer on Talk Radio. There is no balance, and I don't need to be patronised. RE: GB News - Derek Hardballs - 06-17-2021 (06-17-2021, 11:24 AM)steviedm Wrote: I've been following this thread with great interest. As someone who teaches media, it's fascinating to see so many informed viewpoints on both sides of the argument. The first thing to say is that the word 'plural' is important - a plural media is absolutely crucial for a functioning democracy. Unfortunately, plurality is lacking in the British print media with 80% of mainstream titles owned by a handful of billionaires, who push a right wing agenda and are mostly non-domiciled and pay no tax in the UK. There are some obvious exceptions but overall the press in the UK is indisputably biased to the right. Now, while newspapers can push whatever political agenda they choose, broadcast news is regulated differently and must be objective and non-political. Clearly, GB News is going to struggle here but presumably plans to avoid censure by planting a shill in each debate who appears to offer an alternative viewpoint but is simply there as a stooge to be shot down. This doesn't seem particularly mature, responsbile or an attempt to do something to elevate the standard of political discourse in this nation. I've tuned in a couple of times and haven't seen anything objectionable as yet, but it's obviously early days. Wins thread! (06-17-2021, 12:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(06-17-2021, 06:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(06-16-2021, 08:35 PM)bill_baggie Wrote: The interview with Rishi Sunak followed by a high class discussion with Michael Portillo and Now, now Proth no need to get personal I could call you a useful idiot for your Conservative associates but I won't. I guess you haven't seen the state of the country for the last decade and counting. You are obsessed with cutting spending, relying on charity for even the most vulnerable in society and think food banks are the result of people wanting them, not needing them. There are numerous radio shows, the majority of the printed press and their online counterparts. A BBC scared of it's on shadow elevating people like Farage to every political debate for 'balance', not to mention many from the Tory back benches. To say that you and the likes of Hard Man Steve Baker's opinion for example isn't heard in the media is complete nonsense. This station is there as a previous post said to drag discourse further right and without a similar station on the left of politics to add that ahem balance you think GB News brings to TV broadcasting. RE: GB News - bradesbaggie - 06-17-2021 Amateur time. |