WBAUnofficial
Allardyce. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Allardyce. (/showthread.php?tid=16079)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16


RE: Allardyce. - Sliced - 03-14-2021

(03-14-2021, 11:18 AM)Baggy Bruin Wrote: If we played with 2 up front, with Grant left hand side of Diagne... both would benefit.

Grant from Diagne knock-downs and hold-up play. And Diagne from having Grant passes and mis-cues.

It isnt rocket science. Playing with Grant out of position (or not at all) and Diagne as a lone front man is - and has now been proven to be - a disaster.

To make it worse, we could also have played with Robinson, Pereira, AMN and Gallagher all feeding the ball to that front two.

Then OK sitting in front of a back 3.

Sam never even tried out that line up. Not even when losing vital games to Palace or crawling to a point against Newcastle.

No wonder we never fugging score!

If it makes you feel better; we wouldn't have even got close to staying up with any of the combinations  you've mentioned above.

Especially as having Grant and Diagne up front with Robinson, Pereira, AMN and Gallagher feeding them and OK sitting in front of the back four would only leave room for 3 defenders in the starting 11......


RE: Allardyce. - Madness - 03-14-2021

Here's how i see the squad next season

GK

Johnstone- Will be sold I feel is too good for the championship

I would also get rid of Longegan as it was a pointless signing. And have Button & Palmer battle out for the number 1 spot with Griffiths providing backup.

Defenders

Gibbs, Ivanovic, Pelter should all leave the club. I would keep Kyle Bartley and make him captain for next season, With Townsend, O'Shea, Furlong, Ajayi thats a decent core with an addition of another 1-2 players

Midfielders

None of the loan signings will be staying next year, So lets get this out of our heads. This is an area where we need to do a lot of work in the summer. I can't see Pereira staying But we need to bring in 3-4 players. I would look to see Livermore, Sawyers as soon as possible as they are done at this club and despite them being able to play better in the championship we could have a problem going forward.

Forwards.



Grant & Robinson Will do well in this division. I assume Austin will be sold. So a couple of new signings needed as Robson-Kanu needs to be sold as well, We need to start afresh no good keeping players who have had 2 relegations for us. Matt Philips possibly should stay

Overall players who should/will stay

GK: Palmer, Griffiths, Button
Def: O'Shea, Bartley, Furlong, Townsend, Ajayi,
Mid: Phillips, Diangana, Harper, Edwards, Tulloch, Snodgrass
For: Robinson, Grant

As you can see some major work is needed and i think its vital


RE: Allardyce. - Baggeridgebaggy - 03-14-2021

Playing Grant in a two with Diagne would definitely make us worse in my opinion - Grant to me brings very little to the team at Premier League level

By far our most effective proven second striker is Pereira, but in his wisdom the manager isn’t playing him there despite not ever looking like scoring


RE: Allardyce. - Squid - 03-14-2021

(03-14-2021, 10:52 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I welcomed the appointment of Sam because he's a good coach and would not stand for any nonsense. So I've been disappointed that his impact has been so limited. Covid meant he had little contact time with the players, and the resistance to change by the squad was pretty obvious. Livermore's idle sending-off and Sawyers' ridiculous own goal were huge "fuck you" statements to get Sam off to the worst possible start. But now, I wonder what motivates the players.
 
Playing for a contract? Not really, no-one is desperate to stay with us in current circumstances.
Living the dream? I guess Bartley and Townsend, maybe Ajayi, are getting a run in the Premier after paying their dues all over the leagues. Pereira, Okay and Diagne must be pleased to be here.
Playing for a move? Hmmm. 
Playing for their future? O'Shea, Gallagher, AMN are getting some good exposure at the top level.
Playing for the club? Who do we have with a few years and a 100 games for us under their belt? Phillips, HRK? No-one in the Superbob, Paul Robinson, Brunt, Morrison, McAuley, Olsson die-for-the-club category.

And here's the thing. Robinson, Grant and Diangana are our players, guys who've committed to the club and who might give us the goal-scoring edge we lack in Sam's setup. But they seem to be frozen out, not part of the plan at all. They surely would have a vested interest in avoiding the drop, unlike older or loan players, and will be important next season in the Championship. I've cut Allardyce a lot of slack over the painful weeks, but I just don't think he's done everything possible to wring good performances and results out of his squad.

A lot I would agree with in this. 

I would say that the likes of Bartley, Townsend, O'Shea and Ajayi are players of the sort where they endeavour to give a decent performance every time they play, because they have that level of professionalism. All of them have a mistake in them (otherwise they wouldn't be playing for us), but even when Bartley was being asked to do things he cannot do under Moore and Jones, he always tried and tried hard.

Of the players frozen out, Robinson is the one that baffles me most. He singlehandedly tore Chelsea apart, is one of our fastest players and yet can't get a game. Wrong.


RE: Allardyce. - hudds - 03-14-2021

(03-13-2021, 05:58 PM)Everything Zin Wrote:
(03-13-2021, 05:49 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Drawing 0-0 or getting beat 1-0 is ultimately preferable to getting spanked 4 or 5-0 which is what was happening under Bilic. Our defence is much improved and neither manager could make us score goals.

It happened under Allardyce too - in fact our only 5-0 losses came under him. The difference now is that for the last few weeks we've played teams around us knowing we had to win, but seem to have set out to get 0-0 draws. To win games you have to score and it's apparent that Allardyce doesn't have a clue how to do this.

Sorry, he does have a clue - launch the ball into the box and hope something happens. Trouble is, it rarely works - 10 goals in 16 matches (including 2 penalties) says it all.

It isn't launching balls into the box - it's not getting enough good balls in the box or trying to pass too much in the box/not shoot.  What are you watching?  It's not the Albion, that's for sure!


RE: Allardyce. - Pragmatist - 03-14-2021

(03-14-2021, 12:01 PM)Madness Wrote: Here's how i see the squad next season

GK

Johnstone- Will be sold I feel is too good for the championship

I would also get rid of Longegan as it was a pointless signing. And have Button & Palmer battle out for the number 1 spot with Griffiths providing backup.

Defenders

Gibbs, Ivanovic, Pelter should all leave the club. I would keep Kyle Bartley and make him captain for next season, With Townsend, O'Shea, Furlong, Ajayi thats a decent core with an addition of another 1-2 players

Midfielders

None of the loan signings will be staying next year, So lets get this out of our heads. This is an area where we need to do a lot of work in the summer. I can't see Pereira staying But we need to bring in 3-4 players. I would look to see Livermore, Sawyers as soon as possible as they are done at this club and despite them being able to play better in the championship we could have a problem going forward.

Forwards.



Grant & Robinson Will do well in this division. I assume Austin will be sold. So a couple of new signings needed as Robson-Kanu needs to be sold as well, We need to start afresh no good keeping players who have had 2 relegations for us. Matt Philips possibly should stay

Overall players who should/will stay

GK: Palmer, Griffiths, Button
Def: O'Shea, Bartley, Furlong, Townsend, Ajayi,
Mid: Phillips, Diangana, Harper, Edwards, Tulloch, Snodgrass
For: Robinson, Grant

As you can see some major work is needed and i think its vital

There’s Kipre and Joshua Stuart as well (signed on Friday) who you haven’t mentioned


RE: Allardyce. - Everything Zin - 03-14-2021

(03-14-2021, 01:05 PM)hudds Wrote:
(03-13-2021, 05:58 PM)Everything Zin Wrote:
(03-13-2021, 05:49 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Drawing 0-0 or getting beat 1-0 is ultimately preferable to getting spanked 4 or 5-0 which is what was happening under Bilic. Our defence is much improved and neither manager could make us score goals.

It happened under Allardyce too - in fact our only 5-0 losses came under him. The difference now is that for the last few weeks we've played teams around us knowing we had to win, but seem to have set out to get 0-0 draws. To win games you have to score and it's apparent that Allardyce doesn't have a clue how to do this.

Sorry, he does have a clue - launch the ball into the box and hope something happens. Trouble is, it rarely works - 10 goals in 16 matches (including 2 penalties) says it all.

It isn't launching balls into the box - it's not getting enough good balls in the box or trying to pass too much in the box/not shoot.  What are you watching?  It's not the Albion, that's for sure!
Sadly it is. Corners, long throws, free kicks, the occasional punt into the box from 25 yards out, though I agree with you about the lack of quality.


RE: Allardyce. - Sliced - 03-14-2021

Do all clubs talk about their way of football. It seems like it and it's always fast and attacking.

I guess that's just the Forest Green Rovers way.


RE: Allardyce. - hudds - 03-14-2021

(03-14-2021, 05:02 PM)Everything Zin Wrote:
(03-14-2021, 01:05 PM)hudds Wrote:
(03-13-2021, 05:58 PM)Everything Zin Wrote:
(03-13-2021, 05:49 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Drawing 0-0 or getting beat 1-0 is ultimately preferable to getting spanked 4 or 5-0 which is what was happening under Bilic. Our defence is much improved and neither manager could make us score goals.

It happened under Allardyce too - in fact our only 5-0 losses came under him. The difference now is that for the last few weeks we've played teams around us knowing we had to win, but seem to have set out to get 0-0 draws. To win games you have to score and it's apparent that Allardyce doesn't have a clue how to do this.

Sorry, he does have a clue - launch the ball into the box and hope something happens. Trouble is, it rarely works - 10 goals in 16 matches (including 2 penalties) says it all.

It isn't launching balls into the box - it's not getting enough good balls in the box or trying to pass too much in the box/not shoot.  What are you watching?  It's not the Albion, that's for sure!
Sadly it is. Corners, long throws, free kicks, the occasional punt into the box from 25 yards out, though I agree with you about the lack of quality.
No, we use the opportunities for long throws (and I like that) and so forth but we actually play football.  We OUGHT to sling the ball in  the box from corners - what else ought we do?  It's when we take it short that it is painful to watch. We don't routinely punt it into the box, either.  We piss about too much or fumble when we ARE in the box (like Phililips trying to pass it in yesterday).   As folk commented it's it's the final execution that has been poor.  

I think you have a dogmatic fixed idea in your mind about Allardyce, not what actually occurs.


RE: Allardyce. - Peachy - 03-14-2021

Can we just clear something up on Grady. We paid a £12m fee for him with another £6m is on add ons (England call up, Prem survival etc) which isn't that likely to get paid any time soon.

Of the £12m fee I believe our initial outlay was £4m up front. Given how good he was last season then at the time we signed him I can 100% see why the club moved for him. The anger from West Ham fans and players also backs up what they thought of him too.

With the age he is and the undoubted talent he has I'm convinced he will become a great signing for us. He has no chance in an Allardyce side to show anything this season mind.

Let's just hope the new man, whoever it is, can see what a great player he can be.