WBAUnofficial
Molomby - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Molomby (/showthread.php?tid=38959)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13


RE: Molomby - Birdman1811 - 10-10-2025

(10-10-2025, 09:32 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-10-2025, 06:26 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm still at a loss as to why Molumby has been singled out and why his inclusion as a regular in the XI suddenly means we won't make the play-offs. I've not seen one post that explains those two statements.

Again, I'm not saying he's perfect, but he's good at what he does.

If we don't make the play-offs it will be because our squad and/or head coach isn't good enough, not because of one player.

Not sure what you find so difficult to understand here Josh. 

Not every player in our squad is at an identical level, some are poorer than others, and in order to win promotion, you need to generally have players good enough for the task in every position, or at least in the key positions.

No one is saying Molumby is the only reason we won’t get promoted, however he is one of the weaker players currently in our XI, and one we ideally would have replaced had budget allowed, and his weaknesses are further enhanced by the lack of options we have available to complement him.

So no, Molumby is not the only problem in our XI, and no he is not the reason we won’t get promoted this season, however our reliance on him will be a contributing factor to why I believe we will fall short of the playoffs, the same way as we have in the 2 seasons previous when he’s played more than half the games.

I wouldn't say Molumby is at all the reason we didn't achieve it the last couple of seasons, even knowing his faults. In fact, a few times he's been the reason we've got close since he's one player that doesn't seem to crack under pressure and hideaway, scoring some crucial goals in the process.

As I've always said, he has a place in the squad; he shouldn't start every single game. The problems we have run far, far deeper than any one player, and it's just the fans' way to find a scapegoat and hammer them relentlessly, then when they aren't played and things don't improve, another reason is determined. Mowatt is just as guilty of not offering enough, but he does enough of the pretty stuff fans aren't harsh on him, ideally we need to improve on both of them, but as much as we missed Mowatt last time, if Molumby misses out next game and we inevitably lack energy and his workrate in the middle, there'll be new excuses thought up. 

If we can get some more output from the fullbacks, essentially if Gilchrist steps up on the right for example, it's less of a problem. I'd like Styles to play in the middle but I've been distinctly unimpressed with Taylor who I typically rated until he played for us, so we need Styles at left back.


RE: Molomby - Cheshire East Baggie - 10-10-2025

There's a lot of good football analysis on here, but the fundamental issue is that many posters just don't like Jayson Molumby. It's a bit like the Karlan Grant situation - he was an unpopular and expensive signing, so will never really be given full credit for his value to the squad. Adam Reach - why were we buying such a nobody on such high wages? He was doomed never to play a good game for us, in the eyes of some fans. There are many more examples.

These guys don't choose to sign for us rather than any other club, they don't decide what they get paid, they don't pick the team and they very rarely go out there and give less than their best. Reasoned analysis of players' capabilities is but a short step from scapegoating. Some of the anti-Molumby comments in this fred are definitely the latter, not the former.


RE: Molomby - Lurker#3 - 10-11-2025

(10-10-2025, 09:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Mowatt is just as guilty of not offering enough, but he does enough of the pretty stuff fans aren't harsh on him, ideally we need to improve on both of them, but as much as we missed Mowatt last time, if Molumby misses out next game and we inevitably lack energy and his workrate in the middle, there'll be new excuses thought up. 

This bit I can't help but disagree with.

Mowatt, by pretty much every metric for a holding midfielder, who's job it is to recycle possession and progress us through the lines. Is as good as anything in the league for the last 2 years.

The issue is the pairing. And the continuous argument that there are "no other choices". There is. But we haven't been brave enough to try it.

We are top of the table for passes and passes into the final third. But we've done shag all with it. We could easily adjust the balance. Sacrifice perhaps 10% of that deep, comfortable stuff, that frankly doesn't achieve anything go going either way.

Corberan knew this, and tried to limit JM's playing time. Other managers haven't, and it is to the detriment of the team under those coaches. Especially as the squad is so limited and unbalanced, even more so that it was for the last few years.

JM is the easy and comfortable pick. Runs around and tries hard. But frankly never achieves much.


RE: Molomby - Shabby Russian - 10-11-2025

(10-10-2025, 06:26 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm still at a loss as to why Molumby has been singled out and why his inclusion as a regular in the XI suddenly means we won't make the play-offs. I've not seen one post that explains those two statements.

Again, I'm not saying he's perfect, but he's good at what he does.

If we don't make the play-offs it will be because our squad and/or head coach isn't good enough, not because of one player.

There is nothing i disagree with in this post.

That said this is a thread specifically about this player.

My view is he is a good championship player, but probably not a great one. There are a lot of players of that standard in the squad.

As you say if we don't go up this season it won't be because of him. It's never that simple. There is far too much commentary on football which amounts to "if we dropped this player and played that player instead we would be brilliant". It's never true.


RE: Molomby - Jacko - 10-11-2025

(10-11-2025, 12:58 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-10-2025, 09:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Mowatt is just as guilty of not offering enough, but he does enough of the pretty stuff fans aren't harsh on him, ideally we need to improve on both of them, but as much as we missed Mowatt last time, if Molumby misses out next game and we inevitably lack energy and his workrate in the middle, there'll be new excuses thought up. 

This bit I can't help but disagree with.

Mowatt, by pretty much every metric for a holding midfielder, who's job it is to recycle possession and progress us through the lines. Is as good as anything in the league for the last 2 years.

The issue is the pairing. And the continuous argument that there are "no other choices". There is. But we haven't been brave enough to try it.

We are top of the table for passes and passes into the final third. But we've done shag all with it. We could easily adjust the balance. Sacrifice perhaps 10% of that deep, comfortable stuff, that frankly doesn't achieve anything go going either way.

Corberan knew this, and tried to limit JM's playing time. Other managers haven't, and it is to the detriment of the team under those coaches. Especially as the squad is so limited and unbalanced, even more so that it was for the last few years.

JM is the easy and comfortable pick. Runs around and tries hard. But frankly never achieves much.

Another superb post about our embattled CM pairing. In a nutshell. One pulls his weight, the other doesn't. Our only top class head coach during his time at the club is the only one who spotted it.


RE: Molomby - Birdman1811 - 10-11-2025

My hope is that Collyer steps up and can partner Mowatt well, leaving Molumby to be the squad option he should be, as he was under Corberan.

Price doesn't fit into a midfield two for me, Diakate has never shown enough and clearly doesn't in training to take the other position, and Styles is very much needed at left back.

I'm not saying, and have never said Molumby should be playing every game, I'm explaining why managers go for him because I get it. Personally I do agree that he's a big part of our problems, but this idea drop him and everything is fixed is deluded, I promise, the difference will be miniscule unless we also change the full backs and find a way of getting our wide players more involved.


RE: Molomby - Sliced - 10-11-2025

We lose something by having Diakite in a midfield two, in a three he's a big asset.

I just don't see anything from Collyer so far, but he was at United so there must be something there.


RE: Molomby - SW4Baggie - 10-11-2025

(10-11-2025, 12:58 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-10-2025, 09:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Mowatt is just as guilty of not offering enough, but he does enough of the pretty stuff fans aren't harsh on him, ideally we need to improve on both of them, but as much as we missed Mowatt last time, if Molumby misses out next game and we inevitably lack energy and his workrate in the middle, there'll be new excuses thought up. 

This bit I can't help but disagree with.

Mowatt, by pretty much every metric for a holding midfielder, who's job it is to recycle possession and progress us through the lines. Is as good as anything in the league for the last 2 years.

The issue is the pairing. And the continuous argument that there are "no other choices". There is. But we haven't been brave enough to try it.

We are top of the table for passes and passes into the final third. But we've done shag all with it. We could easily adjust the balance. Sacrifice perhaps 10% of that deep, comfortable stuff, that frankly doesn't achieve anything go going either way.

Corberan knew this, and tried to limit JM's playing time. Other managers haven't, and it is to the detriment of the team under those coaches. Especially as the squad is so limited and unbalanced, even more so that it was for the last few years.

JM is the easy and comfortable pick. Runs around and tries hard. But frankly never achieves much.

100% agree.

And I’m not saying Molumby is the reason we haven’t/won’t make the playoffs, I’m simply saying that for me he is currently the player that we need to improve on most if we are to make the top 6 this year because central midfield is the position we’ve had an issue with for several years now, and is the main reason why we have continued to struggle to create good quality chances and score enough goals to win games.

Yes we need to add more variety into our fullback positions too, but the easiest, more effective fix is adding a better player than JM into the midfield. 

Ironically if we were to get promoted Molumby is probably the midfielder I’d most want to have in the squad next year, not as a starter but as a spoiler and battler to disrupt certain teams.


RE: Molomby - Brentbaggie - 10-11-2025

(10-11-2025, 10:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-11-2025, 12:58 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-10-2025, 09:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Mowatt is just as guilty of not offering enough, but he does enough of the pretty stuff fans aren't harsh on him, ideally we need to improve on both of them, but as much as we missed Mowatt last time, if Molumby misses out next game and we inevitably lack energy and his workrate in the middle, there'll be new excuses thought up. 

This bit I can't help but disagree with.

Mowatt, by pretty much every metric for a holding midfielder, who's job it is to recycle possession and progress us through the lines. Is as good as anything in the league for the last 2 years.

The issue is the pairing. And the continuous argument that there are "no other choices". There is. But we haven't been brave enough to try it.

We are top of the table for passes and passes into the final third. But we've done shag all with it. We could easily adjust the balance. Sacrifice perhaps 10% of that deep, comfortable stuff, that frankly doesn't achieve anything go going either way.

Corberan knew this, and tried to limit JM's playing time. Other managers haven't, and it is to the detriment of the team under those coaches. Especially as the squad is so limited and unbalanced, even more so that it was for the last few years.

JM is the easy and comfortable pick. Runs around and tries hard. But frankly never achieves much.

100% agree.

And I’m not saying Molumby is the reason we haven’t/won’t make the playoffs, I’m simply saying that for me he is currently the player that we need to improve on most if we are to make the top 6 this year because central midfield is the position we’ve had an issue with for several years now, and is the main reason why we have continued to struggle to create good quality chances and score enough goals to win games.

Yes we need to add more variety into our fullback positions too, but the easiest, more effective fix is adding a better player than JM into the midfield. 

Ironically if we were to get promoted Molumby is probably the midfielder I’d most want to have in the squad next year, not as a starter but as a spoiler and battler to disrupt certain teams.

As long as you accept he'd only be available for about two thirds of games due to suspension.  Big Grin


RE: Molomby - SW4Baggie - 10-11-2025

(10-11-2025, 12:14 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(10-11-2025, 10:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-11-2025, 12:58 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-10-2025, 09:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Mowatt is just as guilty of not offering enough, but he does enough of the pretty stuff fans aren't harsh on him, ideally we need to improve on both of them, but as much as we missed Mowatt last time, if Molumby misses out next game and we inevitably lack energy and his workrate in the middle, there'll be new excuses thought up. 

This bit I can't help but disagree with.

Mowatt, by pretty much every metric for a holding midfielder, who's job it is to recycle possession and progress us through the lines. Is as good as anything in the league for the last 2 years.

The issue is the pairing. And the continuous argument that there are "no other choices". There is. But we haven't been brave enough to try it.

We are top of the table for passes and passes into the final third. But we've done shag all with it. We could easily adjust the balance. Sacrifice perhaps 10% of that deep, comfortable stuff, that frankly doesn't achieve anything go going either way.

Corberan knew this, and tried to limit JM's playing time. Other managers haven't, and it is to the detriment of the team under those coaches. Especially as the squad is so limited and unbalanced, even more so that it was for the last few years.

JM is the easy and comfortable pick. Runs around and tries hard. But frankly never achieves much.

100% agree.

And I’m not saying Molumby is the reason we haven’t/won’t make the playoffs, I’m simply saying that for me he is currently the player that we need to improve on most if we are to make the top 6 this year because central midfield is the position we’ve had an issue with for several years now, and is the main reason why we have continued to struggle to create good quality chances and score enough goals to win games.

Yes we need to add more variety into our fullback positions too, but the easiest, more effective fix is adding a better player than JM into the midfield. 

Ironically if we were to get promoted Molumby is probably the midfielder I’d most want to have in the squad next year, not as a starter but as a spoiler and battler to disrupt certain teams.

As long as you accept he'd only be available for about two thirds of games due to suspension.  Big Grin

That’s probably still more than I think he should feature in Wink

(10-11-2025, 09:18 AM)Sliced Wrote: We lose something by having Diakite in a midfield two, in a three he's  a big asset.

I just don't see anything from Collyer so far, but he was at United so there must be something there.

Diakite was a real disappointment - I thought we were getting the box to box, energetic, ball carrying, pacy midfielder we’ve been lacking for years. It really sounded like he was a Naby Keita style player, but it seems his injuries have deprived him of that mobility and energy, and now he’s trying to retrain as a ball winner.