![]() |
|
Fellows - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Fellows (/showthread.php?tid=38487) |
RE: Fellows - MrBater - 08-28-2025 Also selling tom to a competitor is silly...and that alone should have increased what we wanted... Maybe Shilen is paying the loan off with this money after all? Maybe he didn't get the jokes on here and thought we were being serious!? RE: Fellows - Tom Joad - 08-28-2025 (08-28-2025, 02:17 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:(08-28-2025, 01:49 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: If it is a £10M its a joke and a criminal loss of value, what I really don't understand is that we have a young player with years left on his contract, happy here, whose value trajectory is steeply going up with assists and involvement in the England U21s. Whatever he is worth now will be double this time next year and we don't have to sell him (unless an accountant says something different) The value and the timing of this is seriously fucked up, don't get it at all. Exactly. At £15m I would understand but still be disappointed. With the sale of Furlong I was settling to the idea we were keeping TF. As Jeremy Peace used to say, the best time to sell is when you don't have to. RE: Fellows - TartanRug - 08-28-2025 (08-28-2025, 02:25 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:(08-28-2025, 02:17 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:(08-28-2025, 01:49 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: If it is a £10M its a joke and a criminal loss of value, what I really don't understand is that we have a young player with years left on his contract, happy here, whose value trajectory is steeply going up with assists and involvement in the England U21s. Whatever he is worth now will be double this time next year and we don't have to sell him (unless an accountant says something different) The value and the timing of this is seriously fucked up, don't get it at all. It's just baffling to me how we allegedly turned down 10 million for him, he then has a great season and at the end of it his value has gone down RE: Fellows - Bob Fossil - 08-28-2025 (08-28-2025, 02:24 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:(08-28-2025, 02:11 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:(08-28-2025, 01:59 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote:You still need to play someone in the role Fellows occupied, so without him we are weaker in that area. Could have the best back 4 in the league but we will still be weaker on the right wing. Point still stands either way. Wherever the money goes, if it's well spent it will be a good deal, if it isn't, it won't.(08-28-2025, 01:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: We all get a bit bogged down with the money, but it's not really about that, it's about the squad. If we sell Tom for £10m and replace for £2m and the replacement is as good or better, good deal. If we sell him for £20m and replace for £10m, but the replacement is shite, bad deal, even though we made more money. I'm neither a naysayer nor a doom monger, I agree wholeheartedly that this transfer could be a good thing for the club. The point I'm making is, it's not about the fee we get, but what we do with it. And I was there in 81 and as a heartbroken kid, was assured that Robson going was essential for us to kick on as a club. Very few knew at the time how very, very badly it would turn after that. Not saying for a minute this will happen again, as I also agree that we are now much better run. RE: Fellows - Ted Maul - 08-28-2025 A lot of people are overstating the value teams are giving to assists from wide areas in modern football. If he had last seasons record from RB - similar to Davis at Ipswich (but from LB) in their promotion season then maybe you'd be asking for £15-20m. Tom would also be worth more if he had 8 goals and 8 assists from last season. Lots of the players he's being compared with e.g. Philogene, Hutchinson both made double-figures for goals scored in their last Championship season. It's more valuable. It's a touch low, but my God can't we wait until we see what his replacement looks like first?! RE: Fellows - Seat109 - 08-28-2025 Totally agree with the general consensus that the rumoured fee is ridiculous but Bilkul haven’t really put a foot wrong so far ( apart from the 1 major disaster last season) so I tend to think that they know what they are doing . Does anyone actually know if, in terms of PSR what Tom’s alleged fee is worth to the club finances in comparison to say selling Price for example at a higher fee? They must have been planning for this scenario for a good while so you would expect/hope there is a strong contingency plan, probably best to save any meltdowns until Monday night. RE: Fellows - TartanRug - 08-28-2025 (08-28-2025, 02:40 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A lot of people are overstating the value teams are giving to assists from wide areas in modern football. If he had last seasons record from RB - similar to Davis at Ipswich (but from LB) in their promotion season then maybe you'd be asking for £15-20m. Tom would also be worth more if he had 8 goals and 8 assists from last season. Lots of the players he's being compared with e.g. Philogene, Hutchinson both made double-figures for goals scored in their last Championship season. It's more valuable. I'd hope we're smart enough to have someone lined up to replace him as time is running out for that along with other positions we need to strengthen. RE: Fellows - Lurker#3 - 08-28-2025 (08-28-2025, 02:40 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A lot of people are overstating the value teams are giving to assists from wide areas in modern football. If he had last seasons record from RB - similar to Davis at Ipswich (but from LB) in their promotion season then maybe you'd be asking for £15-20m. Tom would also be worth more if he had 8 goals and 8 assists from last season. Lots of the players he's being compared with e.g. Philogene, Hutchinson both made double-figures for goals scored in their last Championship season. It's more valuable. This is a very good post TBF, Ted. I also wonder if we have targets, they are going to cost us 'x' amount, we need to raise 'x' amount and this sale allows us to conclude our business. RE: Fellows - MrBater - 08-28-2025 (08-28-2025, 02:43 PM)Seat109 Wrote: Totally agree with the general consensus that the rumoured fee is ridiculous but Bilkul haven’t really put a foot wrong so far ( apart from the 1 major disaster last season) so I tend to think that they know what they are doing . Tom will be pure profit I think? Price whatever we'd got would have to account for whatever was left on his original fee... RE: Fellows - Jacko - 08-28-2025 (08-28-2025, 02:46 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(08-28-2025, 02:40 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A lot of people are overstating the value teams are giving to assists from wide areas in modern football. If he had last seasons record from RB - similar to Davis at Ipswich (but from LB) in their promotion season then maybe you'd be asking for £15-20m. Tom would also be worth more if he had 8 goals and 8 assists from last season. Lots of the players he's being compared with e.g. Philogene, Hutchinson both made double-figures for goals scored in their last Championship season. It's more valuable. It is a good post, but the players are handpicked, what about Kasey McAteer, Romain Esse? Don't get me started on Lewis Dobbin (yes I know the circumstances of that). |