WBAUnofficial
Live Budget Thread - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Live Budget Thread (/showthread.php?tid=35503)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14


RE: Live Budget Thread - man in the corner shop - 10-31-2024

(10-31-2024, 06:15 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: At least the mechanic who services the dog’s car will be able to put food on the table.

It was looking pretty hairy for a minute there.

1 "they're coming for me " boo hoo
2 "they're coming for me and they're coming for you" boo double hoo
3 Mewl, puke.
4 STILL WINNING

Honestly, with this BS added to the Israeli bias, I just dont think Proth is very credible.

At least, before you went all Jeff Prestridge and Bibi, you would make a good fist of an intelligent argument. You now appear to be simply a sock puppet of shit whatsapp groups.


RE: Live Budget Thread - baggy1 - 10-31-2024

I think the panic caused by the press impacting on the health of people like Chunk (has anyone heard from him?) gives us an indication of how the next few years will be reported. Looking at the figures there are few surprises but we are going to have to disagree on the 'there's no black hole' Proth - there is clearly 12Bn that hadn't been accounted for with the payouts to postmasters and the blood scandal, where was that going to come from? And the promises of a boost to investigative teams to get back covid fraud was not included either. I would suggest that the difference here is semantics - the Tory promises were never costed or included because they never intended in following them through (as they knew they would lose the election).

It is surprising about the rhetoric around the cost to business that appears to have been accepted comfortably with Brexit, and the hit on consumers with any price rises was not deemed as worrying when real wages for lorry drivers was being discussed.

It's a typical 1st budget for an incoming government - build in some cushion to feed back to the electorate in tax reductions over the next few years with commentary that will be along the lines of 'our plans are working so we can give you some back'.

Nowhere near the pant wetting levels of some on here, but also not as much as others wanted. From a personal point of view, I just need to make sure I spend the money / pension I've saved or give it away which is what I intended on doing anyway.


RE: Live Budget Thread - Protheroe - 10-31-2024

Reeves flailing on R4 Today about the "black hole" - as for the twat Darren Jones - well worth watching his appearance on Newsnight yesterday, out of his depth doesn't go anywhere near describing it.

"Build in some cushion"? There's virtually no fiscal headroom at all. Less than under Hunt.

You may not be wetting your pants because, respectfully, you don't understand the implications for living standards. When the OBR, IFS, Resolution and even that MMT nutter Richard Murphy agree then it really ought to concentrate your mind - none of them are friends of the previous regime but all of them are standing back looking in horror at what she's delivered. The leader in The Economist (no friend of the Tories) puts it thus:

"Rachel Reeves, Britain’s chancellor of the exchequer, will never have a better moment to make bold changes than the budget she presented on October 30th. She had a mandate to fix public services, a huge Parliamentary majority and four months to work out how to raise taxes and encourage growth. In the end, she offered an odd mix of eye-popping numbers and small-bore thinking. She has taken steps to fix Britain’s crumbling public services, chronic underinvestment and fairy-tale fiscal forecasts. But she has lost her best chance at reform.

The figures in the budget were certainly audacious. Ms Reeves announced an increase in the level of taxation worth £40bn ($52bn; just over 1% of GDP), mostly by raising employers’ national-insurance contributions as well as by making some smaller increases in taxes on inheritance and wealth. That, along with an increase in borrowing of roughly £30bn, will fund a £70bn rise in government spending. The state will swell to a size not seen outside an emergency or war.

Tax rises to fix the state and stabilise the public finances were always going to be necessary. And the chancellor did usefully break with the past on government investment. Britain has one of the lowest rates of public and private capital spending in the G7. About a third of the increase in government expenditure will go towards new infrastructure. Although some of this money may be wasted, that is a worthwhile gamble. Any route out of stagnation will require Britain to do something about its terrible investment record.

Much else about the budget was disappointing. An old quip says that Britain tries to combine low American taxes with a high-cost European welfare state. Labour has decided to have European levels of taxation and welfare spending but to keep the foibles and inefficiencies of the British tax system.

This incentivises self-employment over employment and penalises small businesses that grow. Ms Reeves has exacerbated these distortions, by raising the level of employers’ national-insurance contributions and exempting more small businesses from paying them. The claim that this meets Labour’s manifesto pledge not to raise taxes on “working people” is sophistry. The Office for Budget Responsibility, a fiscal watchdog, says that workers will end up paying anyway, through higher prices and lower wage growth. Raising income tax would have been more honest and more efficient.

Other than national insurance, the budget concentrated on the highest earners. Loopholes in inheritance tax for small businesses and owners of farmland were narrowed. The “carried interest” tax break for private equity was reduced. Some of these changes are defensible. But cumulatively, they risk sending the wrong message to the footloose wealthy in return for only trifling extra revenue. European-sized welfare states need to be funded with broad-based taxes.

Choices on spending, too, were lopsided in a British way. The National Health Service (NHS) received a two-year £22.6bn increase in its day-to-day funding; education, transport and defence saw smaller increases. But beyond these departments, funding will remain tight. The danger is that an unreformed NHS absorbs the increase in money without doing much better, while the rest of Britain’s dreary public realm, from its failing prisons to its creaking social-care system, imposes a heavier burden by dragging people down.

Those who wish the government well in its mission to boost growth and repair the British state, this newspaper among them, must hope that the budget was a down payment on public-sector reform. But Ms Reeves did not inspire confidence. Whether failing to raise a levy on petrol or weaselling her way out of commitments not to raise taxes on working people, the chancellor ducked hard choices. Reforming the state requires taking on the unions and interest groups. Yet if Labour is too timid to do that, it will not create the growth to pay for services. And after this budget, it will not be able to impose further huge tax rises. What will it do then?"


RE: Live Budget Thread - baggy1 - 10-31-2024

Your concern for living standards appears sharper than it was in 2016. This is where we are after years of failed rhetoric from politicians that built their dynasties on bullshit and scaremongering. We had decent living standards, as it's been pointed out that isn't just from money in your pocket, austerity started the rot, Brexit turbocharged it and left us completely unprepared for Ukraine and Covid. When you take away the support mechanisms of good schooling, social care for all ages (young and old), justice structures from Policing to Courts to Prisons and you still talk of reform then you are reading from the wrong script. This isn't about pouring money onto the problem or ripping up the rules and reforming, it's about survival now and getting through the next few years and rebuild from the foundations.


RE: Live Budget Thread - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-31-2024

(10-31-2024, 09:07 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I think the panic caused by the press impacting on the health of people like Chunk (has anyone heard from him?) gives us an indication of how the next few years will be reported. Looking at the figures there are few surprises but we are going to have to disagree on the 'there's no black hole' Proth - there is clearly 12Bn that hadn't been accounted for with the payouts to postmasters and the blood scandal, where was that going to come from? And the promises of a boost to investigative teams to get back covid fraud was not included either. I would suggest that the difference here is semantics - the Tory promises were never costed or included because they never intended in following them through (as they knew they would lose the election).

It is surprising about the rhetoric around the cost to business that appears to have been accepted comfortably with Brexit, and the hit on consumers with any price rises was not deemed as worrying when real wages for lorry drivers was being discussed.

It's a typical 1st budget for an incoming government - build in some cushion to feed back to the electorate in tax reductions over the next few years with commentary that will be along the lines of 'our plans are working so we can give you some back'.

Nowhere near the pant wetting levels of some on here, but also not as much as others wanted. From a personal point of view, I just need to make sure I spend the money / pension I've saved or give it away which is what I intended on doing anyway.

Don't worry I'm still here.

I'm just processing what the OBR told us, that Thieves omitted. Inflation will not fall as quickly by half a percent, and neither will interest rates. The £22bn "black hole" cannot be validated.

Meanwhile £40bn has been raised and will be invested without any reform on the recipients. How long before the Tories start quoting a £40bn black hole? 

Tax and Spend is back again.


RE: Live Budget Thread - baggy1 - 10-31-2024

I think the Tory's would be daft to push a point that highlights how much they have promised things they never intended on delivering. But then again when have the Torys ever worried about looking daft.


RE: Live Budget Thread - Protheroe - 10-31-2024

(10-31-2024, 09:56 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Your concern for living standards appears sharper than it was in 2016. This is where we are after years of failed rhetoric from politicians that built their dynasties on bullshit and scaremongering. We had decent living standards, as it's been pointed out that isn't just from money in your pocket, austerity started the rot, Brexit turbocharged it and left us completely unprepared for Ukraine and Covid. When you take away the support mechanisms of good schooling, social care for all ages (young and old), justice structures from Policing to Courts to Prisons and you still talk of reform then you are reading from the wrong script. This isn't about pouring money onto the problem or ripping up the rules and reforming, it's about survival now and getting through the next few years and rebuild from the foundations.

Again, removing the polemic - living standards have stagnated since 2008 and the UK's response to the financial crisis, which in turn enabled Brexit. I was very vocal on here for the whole of the previous decade about suppressed wages, suppressed interest rates, zombie companies etc.

As it is non-protected departments will hardly see any rise in expenditure - and probably cuts. Increases in spending are partly predicated on an unlikely £6bn being found from Tax Avoidance measures and an even more unlikely 2% efficiency savings across Whitehall.

All this from a government who came to power promising growth. There is ZERO indication of where this growth is coming from - the Chief Secretary (I'll give him 5 minutes in frontline politics) suggested the OBR shows growth accelerating in years 5-10. The only function of economic forecasting is to make astrology look respectable”, as Jack Galbraith once said.

One of my business partners has already taken action; a £10,000 chip on a property he was buying to make up for the SDLT hit, encouraging 5 of his employees to become self-employed by next April, swapping out his double-cab for a used van and laughing like a drain at the thought of taking green apprentices on for £10 per hour. I assume there will be businesses up and down the country doing exactly the same. You'll have to help me out with where that aids the growth agenda. 

Hardly a surprising Budget from a cabinet with no experience whatsoever in running a business.


RE: Live Budget Thread - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-31-2024

(10-31-2024, 10:21 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I think the Tory's would be daft to push a point that highlights how much they have promised things they never intended on delivering. But then again when have the Torys ever worried about looking daft.

They worry as much about looking daft as Labour do. They've lied through their teeth, and the British public will remember this for a long time.

My bigger worry now is who will govern next. It won't be Labour, the Tories are a mess, so who does the job next term, and what direction will they take?


RE: Live Budget Thread - Protheroe - 10-31-2024

If living standards stagnate as every commentator is suggesting then all bets are off.

Rachel Reeves this morning:

"It will mean that businesses will have to absorb some of this through profits and it is likely to mean that wage increases might be slightly less than they otherwise would have been."

A good friend of mine quoted in the Times today comments:

"Not only has the Chancellor brushed proper business rates reform under the carpet, but the reduction in property tax relief will result in an 140 % rise in business rates bills for more than 250,000 highstreet premises next April. And that before the sector experiences a further rise with the 2026 Revaluation. This could well lead to further store closures and job losses. Far from saving the high street we have a potential disaster looming."


RE: Live Budget Thread - richbaggie - 10-31-2024

FAO KKK
We're excited to announce rate reductions across our Residential product ranges, effective today, Thursday 31st October.

This includes 5 year fixes.

That's from Foundation today.