RE: Reform - SW4Baggie - 07-06-2024
(07-06-2024, 10:22 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: Can anyone answer the question about 685,000 legal immigrants to the UK and what we should do with them? As opposed to the 52,000 illegals who can be deported back to their home countries.
This is the question no one wants to or can answer and yet never seems to come up.
If 52000 is too many, why is 685000 not too many - or is that a bit … er … complicated?
I’ll have a stab.
We have control over our borders - I believe we have no free movement agreements with any other major country so we currently have the ability to control exactly how many legal migrants enter the country.
So;
1. I allow asylum and refugee claimants to work as soon as they arrive. A scheme where they are given vocational training in social work and elderly care, or are given community roles in maintenance, litter picking, graffiti clean up, and they are paid a living wage. Some of this - in line with standard housing costs - is deducted to cover the costs of training and housing. It gives a sense of purpose and integrates into the community.
In a slight nod to the right side of the electorate I would also ensure migrant children were taught separately until their English reached a level sufficient enough to adapt into the British educational system, at which point they are assessed and enter the educational system at a level commensurate with their ability - I am sure this is a controversial view, but the costs of accommodating non-English speakers in the DoE is huge and children should not be held back due to needs of others.
2. Restrict the courses student visas give working visas to at the end of study periods - I have a friend who works in the University sector and the lies told to mislead foreign students into how easy it will be to find a job in the U.K. upon completion of studying is a scandal just waiting to blow up. By all means study in the U.K. but you will not be immediately eligible to remain after studying unless it is in a much needed field.
3. Do not allow student visas to bring any family members - it is a choice to pursue academic studies. Plenty of people work separate to their family, this is no different.
4. One idea I don’t disagree with from Reform’s contract is the idea of tax breaks for certain professions. I would offer the same option for certain professions, both domestic and migrant workers, to attract much needed skills. This would gradually decrease over time.
5. If a migrant worker applies for a job that is not an in demand skill, then in order to fulfil the Visa the employer should have to provide full private medical and private educational costs for this person and any family member. If you want the hire enough, you cover the costs.
RE: Reform - Woodman scoreboard - 07-06-2024
(07-06-2024, 10:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-06-2024, 10:04 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (07-05-2024, 06:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-05-2024, 06:29 PM)Bartley_baggie Wrote: Five MP’s now, for Reform , after a recount, fair play to the new boys ( and girls obviously) the msm have tried every trick in the book to stop them
Have they? I'd suggest the MSM have given Farage a platform far greater than they've given the Greens or any other niche party?
Calling people far right ,nazis ,bigots etc is not giving them a platform nothing learnt from the referendum.....its just gatherers momentum to stick 2 fingers up at them
I guess the solution would be for those people not to make comments and share hate filled and unworkable policies that can be construed as racist and bigoted if they don’t want to be called that.
And, the people who support them could call them out as being too far to the right to represent their views and encourage a more moderate and functional set of policies.
If it talks like a Nazi, if it used to be affiliated with a party that sympathises with neo-Nazi’ism, there’s a damn good chance it could well be a…
Total bollocks
RE: Reform - man in the corner shop - 07-06-2024
(07-06-2024, 10:04 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (07-05-2024, 06:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-05-2024, 06:29 PM)Bartley_baggie Wrote: Five MP’s now, for Reform , after a recount, fair play to the new boys ( and girls obviously) the msm have tried every trick in the book to stop them
Have they? I'd suggest the MSM have given Farage a platform far greater than they've given the Greens or any other niche party?
Calling people far right ,nazis ,bigots etc is not giving them a platform nothing learnt from the referendum.....its just gatherers momentum to stick 2 fingers up at them
I keep saying it over and over. If the Tories and Labour had delivered anything over the past 40 years Reform wouldn't be a thing. Nor would have Momentum. Certainly, people are looking in the wrong place if they think Reform have the solutions. But I dont blame them for looking. Time to step up and deliver something Stramer and Co
RE: Reform - Woodman scoreboard - 07-06-2024
(07-06-2024, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-06-2024, 10:22 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: Can anyone answer the question about 685,000 legal immigrants to the UK and what we should do with them? As opposed to the 52,000 illegals who can be deported back to their home countries.
This is the question no one wants to or can answer and yet never seems to come up.
If 52000 is too many, why is 685000 not too many - or is that a bit … er … complicated?
I’ll have a stab.
We have control over our borders - I believe we have no free movement agreements with any other major country so we currently have the ability to control exactly how many legal migrants enter the country.
So;
1. I allow asylum and refugee claimants to work as soon as they arrive. A scheme where they are given vocational training in social work and elderly care, or are given community roles in maintenance, litter picking, graffiti clean up, and they are paid a living wage. Some of this - in line with standard housing costs - is deducted to cover the costs of training and housing. It gives a sense of purpose and integrates into the community.
In a slight nod to the right side of the electorate I would also ensure migrant children were taught separately until their English reached a level sufficient enough to adapt into the British educational system, at which point they are assessed and enter the educational system at a level commensurate with their ability - I am sure this is a controversial view, but the costs of accommodating non-English speakers in the DoE is huge and children should not be held back due to needs of others.
2. Restrict the courses student visas give working visas to at the end of study periods - I have a friend who works in the University sector and the lies told to mislead foreign students into how easy it will be to find a job in the U.K. upon completion of studying is a scandal just waiting to blow up. By all means study in the U.K. but you will not be immediately eligible to remain after studying unless it is in a much needed field.
3. Do not allow student visas to bring any family members - it is a choice to pursue academic studies. Plenty of people work separate to their family, this is no different.
4. One idea I don’t disagree with from Reform’s contract is the idea of tax breaks for certain professions. I would offer the same option for certain professions, both domestic and migrant workers, to attract much needed skills. This would gradually decrease over time.
5. If a migrant worker applies for a job that is not an in demand skill, then in order to fulfil the Visa the employer should have to provide full private medical and private educational costs for this person and any family member. If you want the hire enough, you cover the costs. Some good ideas there
Proof of somewhere to live and enough money to cover your rent for 6 months if not your work guarantee it as a bond .
Have at least £10.000 in the bank for at least 6 months .
If not you are not allowed here .
RE: Reform - CaptainFantastico - 07-06-2024
They’d be great ideas if we didn’t need many people and were in an economically choosy position. Unfortunately, neither are true.
RE: Reform - Brentbaggie - 07-06-2024
(07-06-2024, 10:42 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (07-06-2024, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-06-2024, 10:22 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: Can anyone answer the question about 685,000 legal immigrants to the UK and what we should do with them? As opposed to the 52,000 illegals who can be deported back to their home countries.
This is the question no one wants to or can answer and yet never seems to come up.
If 52000 is too many, why is 685000 not too many - or is that a bit … er … complicated?
I’ll have a stab.
We have control over our borders - I believe we have no free movement agreements with any other major country so we currently have the ability to control exactly how many legal migrants enter the country.
So;
1. I allow asylum and refugee claimants to work as soon as they arrive. A scheme where they are given vocational training in social work and elderly care, or are given community roles in maintenance, litter picking, graffiti clean up, and they are paid a living wage. Some of this - in line with standard housing costs - is deducted to cover the costs of training and housing. It gives a sense of purpose and integrates into the community.
In a slight nod to the right side of the electorate I would also ensure migrant children were taught separately until their English reached a level sufficient enough to adapt into the British educational system, at which point they are assessed and enter the educational system at a level commensurate with their ability - I am sure this is a controversial view, but the costs of accommodating non-English speakers in the DoE is huge and children should not be held back due to needs of others.
2. Restrict the courses student visas give working visas to at the end of study periods - I have a friend who works in the University sector and the lies told to mislead foreign students into how easy it will be to find a job in the U.K. upon completion of studying is a scandal just waiting to blow up. By all means study in the U.K. but you will not be immediately eligible to remain after studying unless it is in a much needed field.
3. Do not allow student visas to bring any family members - it is a choice to pursue academic studies. Plenty of people work separate to their family, this is no different.
4. One idea I don’t disagree with from Reform’s contract is the idea of tax breaks for certain professions. I would offer the same option for certain professions, both domestic and migrant workers, to attract much needed skills. This would gradually decrease over time.
5. If a migrant worker applies for a job that is not an in demand skill, then in order to fulfil the Visa the employer should have to provide full private medical and private educational costs for this person and any family member. If you want the hire enough, you cover the costs. Some good ideas there
Proof of somewhere to live and enough money to cover your rent for 6 months if not your work guarantee it as a bond .
Have at least £10.000 in the bank for at least 6 months .
If not you are not allowed here .
Good go SW4. I think several of these proposals are reasonable but teaching children separately would be very costly. Training people would again be costly and time-consuming against the use of ready trained care-workers etc.
Students and their families is fine but restricting their right to settle thereafter would decrease the numbers attending and add to University lack of finance - already parlous - and many universities would not survive. (Btw Blair's opening up and expanding Universities and encouraging half the student population to go there was a stupidly reckless and ill-advised idea imo.)
As to Woody's suggestion re. having £10k in the bank - Care Workers, Hospitality, let alone people in farming? Hm - good luck with that one.
The fact is there is a huge dearth in the numbers of jobs in certain sectors that simply can't or won't be done by UK citizens. Any amount of tinkering will not restrict the necessity of foreign born workers to fill these places. Putting restrictions on those workers will only exacerbate an already pressing problem.
RE: Reform - Squid - 07-06-2024
ID cards would have made it considerably easier to track who was in the country and stop illegal employment. Many other countries have an ID card system. We nearly did but many of the same people who are currently squealing about boats and "illegals" claimed it was a police state tactic.
As has been discussed, immigration is an incredibly complex issue, which the media discusses very poorly. However, my starting point would be:
1)Far better border control and tracking and managing who is actually in the country. Far too many people slip off radar. Fix processing systems to manage asylum claims promptly. Try to clear the claims backlog ASAP.
2)Invest in schemes in countries of origin to try to stop people wanting to migrate. I've seen some interesting work in west Africa around this. People will always flee warzones, but anything that we can do to keep economic/climate migrants in their homes countries through carrot means as opposed to stick should be tried.
RE: Reform - CA Baggie - 07-06-2024
I think the problem for some is
A) the acceptance we need a + net migration to ensure we have enough resource to cover the ageing population and skills gap;
B) they don’t look or talk like us.
A - this can be covered by facts and a sensible conversation.
B - is the ignorance and basic racist views that too many hold.
I’ve not reviewed recently but “tolerant” Sweden’s approach was to house people in asylum centres and not let them work. However, they taught them Swedish and processed their claims quickly. Once they had their claims passed and had been taught Swedish to an appropriate level they were allowed to join society.
My first thought was the moaners claiming they’re getting a better education than our Tommy at school.
They have a similar approach to convicts. Provide education and a trade/skill so that when they’re released they have a better opportunity to settle back into society. I’m sure in their last period of prison service they’re allowed to take a job, whilst effectively living in prison. They pay board to the prison system and in due course are fully released to society when they confirm having a place to live.
I would imagine a Venn diagram of people voting Reform and Brexit would just be a circle. Have people learnt nothing from NF’s lies?
RE: Reform - Woodman scoreboard - 07-06-2024
(07-06-2024, 11:08 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: (07-06-2024, 10:42 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (07-06-2024, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-06-2024, 10:22 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: Can anyone answer the question about 685,000 legal immigrants to the UK and what we should do with them? As opposed to the 52,000 illegals who can be deported back to their home countries.
This is the question no one wants to or can answer and yet never seems to come up.
If 52000 is too many, why is 685000 not too many - or is that a bit … er … complicated?
I’ll have a stab.
We have control over our borders - I believe we have no free movement agreements with any other major country so we currently have the ability to control exactly how many legal migrants enter the country.
So;
1. I allow asylum and refugee claimants to work as soon as they arrive. A scheme where they are given vocational training in social work and elderly care, or are given community roles in maintenance, litter picking, graffiti clean up, and they are paid a living wage. Some of this - in line with standard housing costs - is deducted to cover the costs of training and housing. It gives a sense of purpose and integrates into the community.
In a slight nod to the right side of the electorate I would also ensure migrant children were taught separately until their English reached a level sufficient enough to adapt into the British educational system, at which point they are assessed and enter the educational system at a level commensurate with their ability - I am sure this is a controversial view, but the costs of accommodating non-English speakers in the DoE is huge and children should not be held back due to needs of others.
2. Restrict the courses student visas give working visas to at the end of study periods - I have a friend who works in the University sector and the lies told to mislead foreign students into how easy it will be to find a job in the U.K. upon completion of studying is a scandal just waiting to blow up. By all means study in the U.K. but you will not be immediately eligible to remain after studying unless it is in a much needed field.
3. Do not allow student visas to bring any family members - it is a choice to pursue academic studies. Plenty of people work separate to their family, this is no different.
4. One idea I don’t disagree with from Reform’s contract is the idea of tax breaks for certain professions. I would offer the same option for certain professions, both domestic and migrant workers, to attract much needed skills. This would gradually decrease over time.
5. If a migrant worker applies for a job that is not an in demand skill, then in order to fulfil the Visa the employer should have to provide full private medical and private educational costs for this person and any family member. If you want the hire enough, you cover the costs. Some good ideas there
Proof of somewhere to live and enough money to cover your rent for 6 months if not your work guarantee it as a bond .
Have at least £10.000 in the bank for at least 6 months .
If not you are not allowed here .
Good go SW4. I think several of these proposals are reasonable but teaching children separately would be very costly. Training people would again be costly and time-consuming against the use of ready trained care-workers etc.
Students and their families is fine but restricting their right to settle thereafter would decrease the numbers attending and add to University lack of finance - already parlous - and many universities would not survive. (Btw Blair's opening up and expanding Universities and encouraging half the student population to go there was a stupidly reckless and ill-advised idea imo.)
As to Woody's suggestion re. having £10k in the bank - Care Workers, Hospitality, let alone people in farming? Hm - good luck with that one.
The fact is there is a huge dearth in the numbers of jobs in certain sectors that simply can't or won't be done by UK citizens. Any amount of tinkering will not restrict the necessity of foreign born workers to fill these places. Putting restrictions on those workers will only exacerbate an already pressing problem.
Exactly that's my point. we only want the best qualified people over here
RE: Reform - CA Baggie - 07-06-2024
(07-06-2024, 11:43 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (07-06-2024, 11:08 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: (07-06-2024, 10:42 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (07-06-2024, 10:35 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-06-2024, 10:22 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: Can anyone answer the question about 685,000 legal immigrants to the UK and what we should do with them? As opposed to the 52,000 illegals who can be deported back to their home countries.
This is the question no one wants to or can answer and yet never seems to come up.
If 52000 is too many, why is 685000 not too many - or is that a bit … er … complicated?
I’ll have a stab.
We have control over our borders - I believe we have no free movement agreements with any other major country so we currently have the ability to control exactly how many legal migrants enter the country.
So;
1. I allow asylum and refugee claimants to work as soon as they arrive. A scheme where they are given vocational training in social work and elderly care, or are given community roles in maintenance, litter picking, graffiti clean up, and they are paid a living wage. Some of this - in line with standard housing costs - is deducted to cover the costs of training and housing. It gives a sense of purpose and integrates into the community.
In a slight nod to the right side of the electorate I would also ensure migrant children were taught separately until their English reached a level sufficient enough to adapt into the British educational system, at which point they are assessed and enter the educational system at a level commensurate with their ability - I am sure this is a controversial view, but the costs of accommodating non-English speakers in the DoE is huge and children should not be held back due to needs of others.
2. Restrict the courses student visas give working visas to at the end of study periods - I have a friend who works in the University sector and the lies told to mislead foreign students into how easy it will be to find a job in the U.K. upon completion of studying is a scandal just waiting to blow up. By all means study in the U.K. but you will not be immediately eligible to remain after studying unless it is in a much needed field.
3. Do not allow student visas to bring any family members - it is a choice to pursue academic studies. Plenty of people work separate to their family, this is no different.
4. One idea I don’t disagree with from Reform’s contract is the idea of tax breaks for certain professions. I would offer the same option for certain professions, both domestic and migrant workers, to attract much needed skills. This would gradually decrease over time.
5. If a migrant worker applies for a job that is not an in demand skill, then in order to fulfil the Visa the employer should have to provide full private medical and private educational costs for this person and any family member. If you want the hire enough, you cover the costs. Some good ideas there
Proof of somewhere to live and enough money to cover your rent for 6 months if not your work guarantee it as a bond .
Have at least £10.000 in the bank for at least 6 months .
If not you are not allowed here .
Good go SW4. I think several of these proposals are reasonable but teaching children separately would be very costly. Training people would again be costly and time-consuming against the use of ready trained care-workers etc.
Students and their families is fine but restricting their right to settle thereafter would decrease the numbers attending and add to University lack of finance - already parlous - and many universities would not survive. (Btw Blair's opening up and expanding Universities and encouraging half the student population to go there was a stupidly reckless and ill-advised idea imo.)
As to Woody's suggestion re. having £10k in the bank - Care Workers, Hospitality, let alone people in farming? Hm - good luck with that one.
The fact is there is a huge dearth in the numbers of jobs in certain sectors that simply can't or won't be done by UK citizens. Any amount of tinkering will not restrict the necessity of foreign born workers to fill these places. Putting restrictions on those workers will only exacerbate an already pressing problem.
Exactly that's my point. we only want the best qualified people over here
But what if the best people want to bring their family along too? I’m sure you’d want to take yours as would I.
|