WBAUnofficial
Swans match fred - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Swans match fred (/showthread.php?tid=32193)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12


RE: Swans match fred - Fido - 01-01-2024

(01-01-2024, 08:59 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(01-01-2024, 08:09 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Honestly, watching this thread today was depressing.

Managed like a novice? One of the best managers we've had ion recent years, a couple of games after a game players busted a gut for, during an injury crisis (Which seems relentless.) Yeah, nice, easy situation for him.

Molumby, doesn't even look like a footballer, again, gave his all a couple of days ago and got out there today in pain because he was needed. Honestly, it's getting stupid recently, and I can't be bothered to read it much anymore, why I am posting less, so many times I wrote and deleted posts today basically ridiculing people in this thread.

It’s barmy to criticise. We are playing poker but without any Aces, Kings, Queens and Jacks.

To still be in the play offs is amazing considering the size of the squad and the injuries we have.

The takeover can’t come quick enough and without being in the know let’s hope it can be finalised this week.

The only thing we can do is give them a full house.


RE: Swans match fred - Cuzer - 01-01-2024

Today for me was super frustrating as we lost to a side we really shouldn’t have lost to and if we take the lead I’m confident we would have seen it out

Second half they shuffled their system and we struggled to adapt, we then had to make changes to protect players which ultimately made us weaker as we were trying to search for an equalizer

The swift situation was unfortunate and couldn’t be helped. I do think he should have given Higgins 10 minutes or as others have said why are we taking the youngsters if CC has no intention of using them? Seen it this year with Higgins, Love, Cleary etc not getting even a run out when the game is done, today’s game was still there to get something and he brings a Pieters on? Made little sense that one

Crumb of comfort is we have 2 weeks until the next meaningful fixture, hopefully Wallace and Swift are fit, Dike gets some minutes against Aldershot, we rest those we need to rest and being super ambitious we get in the two players were looking to get in by the time Blackburn rock up

Quick marks

Palmer 7
Furlong 6
Townsend 5
Kipre 7
Bartley 6
Mowatt 6
Okay 7
Fellows 8*
Grady 4
Molumby 5
BTA 5

Subs

Chalobah 7
Semi 6
Reach 6
Pupa 6
Pieters 6


RE: Swans match fred - Johnny akes - 01-01-2024

Agree with most of those marks Cuzer although I think an 8 for Fellows is too generous, yes he had a very good 1st half but was largely anonymous 2nd from what I could see on my dodgy stream. 7 a more reasonable score for me.


RE: Swans match fred - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-02-2024

Well plenty of keyboard warriors have shat on my opinions, so at least I've provided an opportunity to vent your frustration. Happy New Year BTW.

But seriously folks, given the "what would you do?" conundrum, would any of you have made those changes?

Ajayi for Barts, definitely. More pace, mobility, potential impact going forward. Unless Kipper was carrying a knock, why take him off? Take Okay out of the midfield and surrender any element of control? Surely you leave him in there and introduce Chalobah later when he fades?

Reach for Grady? Why not Pipa, more pacey and direct? Keep Reach back to hold onto it if we get back into the game, or to replace the tiring Molumby.

I've checked the rules of engagement on this 'ere bored, and I'm pretty sure I'm allowed to ask these questions. The subs were eccentric today, and it didn't work. I've watched football for 60+ years - I've never seen both centre backs subbed off at once, barring injury. It was weird.


RE: Swans match fred - Everything Zin - 01-02-2024

(01-02-2024, 12:00 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Well plenty of keyboard warriors have shat on my opinions, so at least I've provided an opportunity to vent your frustration. Happy New Year BTW.

But seriously folks, given the "what would you do?" conundrum, would any of you have made those changes?

Ajayi for Barts, definitely. More pace, mobility, potential impact going forward. Unless Kipper was carrying a knock, why take him off? Take Okay out of the midfield and surrender any element of control? Surely you leave him in there and introduce Chalobah later when he fades?

Reach for Grady? Why not Pipa, more pacey and direct? Keep Reach back to hold onto it if we get back into the game, or to replace the tiring Molumby.

I've checked the rules of engagement on this 'ere bored, and I'm pretty sure I'm allowed to ask these questions. The subs were eccentric today, and it didn't work. I've watched football for 60+ years - I've never seen both centre backs subbed off at once, barring injury. It was weird.

No. Perfectly reasonable people who have a different opinion to you and rather more patience. Your ‘novice manager’ comment was, in my very humble opinion based on 60 years of watching football, ridiculous.


RE: Swans match fred - Cuzer - 01-02-2024

(01-02-2024, 12:00 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Well plenty of keyboard warriors have shat on my opinions, so at least I've provided an opportunity to vent your frustration. Happy New Year BTW.

But seriously folks, given the "what would you do?" conundrum, would any of you have made those changes?

Ajayi for Barts, definitely. More pace, mobility, potential impact going forward. Unless Kipper was carrying a knock, why take him off? Take Okay out of the midfield and surrender any element of control? Surely you leave him in there and introduce Chalobah later when he fades?

Reach for Grady? Why not Pipa, more pacey and direct? Keep Reach back to hold onto it if we get back into the game, or to replace the tiring Molumby.

I've checked the rules of engagement on this 'ere bored, and I'm pretty sure I'm allowed to ask these questions. The subs were eccentric today, and it didn't work. I've watched football for 60+ years - I've never seen both centre backs subbed off at once, barring injury. It was weird.

It’s purely down to injury prevention 

All the players wear monitors and when they hit the ‘red zone’ i.e. risk of muscle injury CC brings them off, he’s not shy in explaining this, it’s how he works

The changes tactically made little sense but if it mens he has them available for Blackburn,  rather than not, then he’s justified the calls

Cuzer


RE: Swans match fred - Brentbaggie - 01-02-2024

(01-02-2024, 01:44 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 12:00 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Well plenty of keyboard warriors have shat on my opinions, so at least I've provided an opportunity to vent your frustration. Happy New Year BTW.

But seriously folks, given the "what would you do?" conundrum, would any of you have made those changes?

Ajayi for Barts, definitely. More pace, mobility, potential impact going forward. Unless Kipper was carrying a knock, why take him off? Take Okay out of the midfield and surrender any element of control? Surely you leave him in there and introduce Chalobah later when he fades?

Reach for Grady? Why not Pipa, more pacey and direct? Keep Reach back to hold onto it if we get back into the game, or to replace the tiring Molumby.

I've checked the rules of engagement on this 'ere bored, and I'm pretty sure I'm allowed to ask these questions. The subs were eccentric today, and it didn't work. I've watched football for 60+ years - I've never seen both centre backs subbed off at once, barring injury. It was weird.

It’s purely down to injury prevention 

All the players wear monitors and when they hit the ‘red zone’ i.e. risk of muscle injury CC brings them off, he’s not shy in explaining this, it’s how he works

The changes tactically made little sense but if it mens he has them available for Blackburn,  rather than not, then he’s justified the calls

Cuzer

This +1

There's no doubt in my mind that Carlos is very concerned about any more injuries to a paper thin squad and he's shuffling the pack continually trying to get players through games. I suspect a couple more players will get injured in the next few weeks. The festive season has multiplied these problems and I wouldn't be surprised if a host of youngsters take the pitch against Aldershot.


RE: Swans match fred - Tom Joad - 01-02-2024

(01-02-2024, 09:45 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 01:44 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 12:00 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Well plenty of keyboard warriors have shat on my opinions, so at least I've provided an opportunity to vent your frustration. Happy New Year BTW.

But seriously folks, given the "what would you do?" conundrum, would any of you have made those changes?

Ajayi for Barts, definitely. More pace, mobility, potential impact going forward. Unless Kipper was carrying a knock, why take him off? Take Okay out of the midfield and surrender any element of control? Surely you leave him in there and introduce Chalobah later when he fades?

Reach for Grady? Why not Pipa, more pacey and direct? Keep Reach back to hold onto it if we get back into the game, or to replace the tiring Molumby.

I've checked the rules of engagement on this 'ere bored, and I'm pretty sure I'm allowed to ask these questions. The subs were eccentric today, and it didn't work. I've watched football for 60+ years - I've never seen both centre backs subbed off at once, barring injury. It was weird.

It’s purely down to injury prevention 

All the players wear monitors and when they hit the ‘red zone’ i.e. risk of muscle injury CC brings them off, he’s not shy in explaining this, it’s how he works

The changes tactically made little sense but if it mens he has them available for Blackburn,  rather than not, then he’s justified the calls

Cuzer

This +1

There's no doubt in my mind that Carlos is very concerned about any more injuries to a paper thin squad and he's shuffling the pack continually trying to get players through games. I suspect a couple more players will get injured in the next few weeks. The festive season has multiplied these problems and I wouldn't be surprised if a host of youngsters take the pitch against Aldershot.

+2. The subs do look a little bizarre but Carlos is a man whose subs normally make complete sense so in this instance I assume he knows more about the squad than we might want toi do.