WBAUnofficial
Mrs Chalobah… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Mrs Chalobah… (/showthread.php?tid=31423)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20


RE: Mrs Chalobah… - Woodman scoreboard - 10-11-2023

Until the mindset of Palistinans change and not teach their kids to hate Jews from birth nothing will change . They want to kill them all it's in there DNA .


RE: Mrs Chalobah… - baggy1 - 10-11-2023

(10-11-2023, 12:24 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Until the mindset of Palistinans change and not teach their kids to hate Jews from birth nothing will change . They want to kill them all it's in there DNA .

This simply isn't true and statements like this are why the debate is where it is. It's as real a view as the one's coming from those flying Palestinian flags from their cars having never been near the middle east.


RE: Mrs Chalobah… - Squid - 10-11-2023

(10-11-2023, 10:24 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 08:09 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: [Image: LossOfLandMapCard.png]

Cannot imagine for the life of me why the Palestinians are a bit pissy about things.

I'm with Birdy on this. What happened over the weekend is awful, abhorent, it's war crimes. But for years the Israeli forces tooled up with arms funded by the UK, USA etc have bombed, destroyed and stolen land from people who lived there for years before. It is possible to think what happened over the weekend is bad, but also recognise that Israel are not innocent participants in all this. Easy to point to "Palestinians electing terrorists", then what do you call the Israeli Army bombing Palestinian schools in Gaza and the West Bank? Ironically for some on here it really isn't a very nuanced view to suggest Israel = good, Palestinians = bad. Notice also, how no one suggesting there has been wrongdoing on both sides has supported the actions of Hamas, but merely pointing out the right of the Palestinian people to live freely in their own country.

Sadly, as was mentioned in the thread on the politics bored, the best we can hope for is a return to the stalemate that is broken up by these occasional bouts of conflict rather than all out war.

Those crude maps from the Momentum School of International Relations fail to recognise that there are over 2 million Arabs living pretty much peacefully in Israel proper (exc. West Bank & Gaza). These Palestinians (and other Arabs) live perfectly freely in their own country - that country happens to be Israel. Rather like myriad of nationalities and religious groups that reside perfectly happily here in the UK.

These maps also fail to recognise that the province of Palestine has never been an independent sovereign State, but has been occupied by foreign powers for millenia. It was the Romans who put Jesus on trial FFS. If you want to read about the tribal warfare upon which Hamas bases its claims the Old Testament is full of the stuff.

Similarly the West Bank was under Ottoman rule for 400 years, British for about a fortnight then designed to part of the first Palestinian state before the Arabs fucked all that up by attempting to strangle the Jewish state at birth with the Arab Israeli war in 1948. "Palestine" didn't exist up to 1967 either - it was part of Jordan. The Six Day war followed - again guess who the aggressor were? and Israel, rightly occupied the West Bank to protect its integrity against aggressors.

So what's the difference between Arabs living in Israel and those in Gaza? Representative democracy? the Rule of Law? a lack of summary justice? freedom and equality for women, religious minorities and sexual minorities? And I suppose the fact that Israeli-Arabs aren't represented by despotic leaders who deny Israel the right to exist under any circumstances.

And whilst we're on this subject - when your neighbours have tried to destroy your State in 1948, 1967, 1973 and mass Iranian-backed militia on your borders during several other periods you'd have the right to feel paranoid.

It is not a binary argument of good v bad, but the overwhelming aggressor over the last 80 years has not been Israel. Far from it.

The Arab Israelis are second-class citizens and there are frequent clashes in East Jerusalem. You are ignoring the land Israel has seized and occupied in contravention of international law. The "Palestine doesn't exist" is a facile argument, that the region has been named for centuries. Then you have completely failed to mention the massive rise in Israeli settlements within the West Bank, which has made any two-state solution unworkable.

As for Israel not being the aggressor, I can only find UN stats up until 2020, but this gives the lie to that statement:

[attachment=820]

Everyone on here has condemned Hamas. I have plenty of criticism for the Palestinian leader and nothing but contempt for most of the leaders of the Arab world. 

But those leaders being contemptible, does not give Israel the right to carpet bomb Gaza whenever it wishes. Cutting off water and electricity to an entire terrority is a breach of international law, so is the current bombing campaign. 

And worst of all, it will not bring any kind of peaceful settlement. If anyone, on any side of the argument, thinks that the problem is enough people haven't been killed, they are insane.


RE: Mrs Chalobah… - Protheroe - 10-11-2023

(10-11-2023, 11:57 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Some background as I see it, Isreal were getting close to recognition and agreements with other Arab states. Iran backed Hammas could see the writing on the wall and went all ISIS on the world.

Proth has made some very good points especially that not everyone who lives in Isreal is Jewish. Someone else made a great point that there are a lot of ordinary folks that just want to get on with their lives.

Iran regime is not representative of Iranians in general

Hamas is not representative of Palestinians in general I reckon.

The situation is fucked.

Israel's borders and right to exist have been recognised by Egypt  for decades and more recently by Jordan. You're absolutely right that Iran backs both Hamas & Hezbollah in its proxy wars against Israel. With Israel inching towards accomodation with Saudi Arabia and the UAE the only choice Iran has is to try and destabilise.

The Palestinian people are being played and Hamas needs to be bulldozed into the desert as much for their welfare as for the Israelis.


RE: Mrs Chalobah… - NewWanker - 10-11-2023

(10-11-2023, 12:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 11:59 AM)NewWanker Wrote: No regime anywhere is representative of its people.

I'm not sure what point you're trying to make, nor that it matters.

The de facto situation on the ground is that Hamas has as little regard for its own citizens as it has for the Israeli citizens it butchered.

Just seems to be lots of people saying these don't represent them, my point is nowhere does.

(10-11-2023, 12:24 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Until the mindset of Palistinans change and not teach their kids to hate Jews from birth nothing will change . They want to kill them all it's in there DNA .

TBf you also need to teach the Israelis not to hate the Palestinians...


RE: Mrs Chalobah… - Protheroe - 10-11-2023

(10-11-2023, 12:42 PM)Squid Wrote: The Arab Israelis are second-class citizens and there are frequent clashes in East Jerusalem. You are ignoring the land Israel has seized and occupied in contravention of international law. The "Palestine doesn't exist" is a facile argument, that the region has been named for centuries. Then you have completely failed to mention the massive rise in Israeli settlements within the West Bank, which has made any two-state solution unworkable.

As for Israel not being the aggressor, I can only find UN stats up until 2020, but this gives the lie to that statement:



Everyone on here has condemned Hamas. I have plenty of criticism for the Palestinian leader and nothing but contempt for most of the leaders of the Arab world. 

But those leaders being contemptible, does not give Israel the right to carpet bomb Gaza whenever it wishes. Cutting off water and electricity to an entire terrority is a breach of international law, so is the current bombing campaign. 

And worst of all, it will not bring any kind of peaceful settlement. If anyone, on any side of the argument, thinks that the problem is enough people haven't been killed, they are insane.

You claim that Arab Israelis are "second-class citizens" then refer to East Jerusalem - which is not the Israel "proper" I referred to, but on the occupied West Bank. You claim that it's Jewish settlements that has made a two-state solution unworkable, however the acceleration in the settlement of the West Bank happened after the rise of Hamas and their dismissal of any two-state solution in favour of destruction of the State of Israel.

The two-state solution is dead forever, and neither party comes out smelling of roses.

Israel does not and has not "carpet bombed" Gaza. Hamas does place its rocket launchers and munitions in built up areas, very often close to schools and hospitals. Hamas fires indiscriminately into Israel most days usually at the time kids are walking to school.

Let's have a look at your stats - on 5 March 2014 the Israeli Navy intercepted a ship containing dozens of long range rockets being smuggled into Gaza from Iran. On 10 March Hamas unveiled a monument in Gaza City to its rocket attacks on Israeli cities and towns, a life-sized model of an M75 rocket rocket. Hamas declared  that the attacks "managed to take the battle to the heart of the Zionist entity". Rocket and mortar attacks increased by 9000% on the year before with 2500-3000 rockets fired during six weeks in the summer alone.

If Wales was attacking the Black Country on this basis I'm sure you'd believe action was necessary. Israel took action and by mid-2015 rocket attacks had hit zero. It looks like there were a huge amount of injuries in Gaza in 2014-15 - the solution? Stop firing rockets and mortars you twats then Israel wouldn't need to take action. Who is the aggressor in this situation? Not Israel.

Spikes in Gazan deaths and injuries in 2018 and 2019 follow similar patterns of rocket and mortar attacks followed by retaliation. Who is the aggressor in this situation?

Human Rights Watch issued a report condemning the firing of rockets as "war crimes", stating "None of these rockets can be reliably aimed... Such weapons are inherently indiscriminate when directed towards densely populated areas. The absence of Israeli military forces in the areas struck by the rockets, as well as statements from the leaders of Hamas and other armed groups, indicate that many of these attacks are deliberately intended to strike Israeli civilians and civilian structures... Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups have frequently violated the laws of war by firing rockets from within populated areas.... and on civilians and civilian structures that do not discriminate between civilians and military targets are illegal under international law.

And now killing well over 1,000 unarmed civilians including British & US citizens?  And kidnapping dozens more? Who is the aggressor in this situation?

I'd love to know what you'd propose as a solution to this cycle of violence. Hamas has made it clear that its only aim is the complete destruction of Israel. It has no interest in peace talks, it has very little in common with the Palestinians of the West Bank. There is no prospect of a peaceful settlement with warlords.


RE: Mrs Chalobah… - Squid - 10-11-2023

(10-11-2023, 02:47 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 12:42 PM)Squid Wrote: The Arab Israelis are second-class citizens and there are frequent clashes in East Jerusalem. You are ignoring the land Israel has seized and occupied in contravention of international law. The "Palestine doesn't exist" is a facile argument, that the region has been named for centuries. Then you have completely failed to mention the massive rise in Israeli settlements within the West Bank, which has made any two-state solution unworkable.

As for Israel not being the aggressor, I can only find UN stats up until 2020, but this gives the lie to that statement:



Everyone on here has condemned Hamas. I have plenty of criticism for the Palestinian leader and nothing but contempt for most of the leaders of the Arab world. 

But those leaders being contemptible, does not give Israel the right to carpet bomb Gaza whenever it wishes. Cutting off water and electricity to an entire terrority is a breach of international law, so is the current bombing campaign. 

And worst of all, it will not bring any kind of peaceful settlement. If anyone, on any side of the argument, thinks that the problem is enough people haven't been killed, they are insane.

You claim that Arab Israelis are "second-class citizens" then refer to East Jerusalem - which is not the Israel "proper" I referred to, but on the occupied West Bank. You claim that it's Jewish settlements that has made a two-state solution unworkable, however the acceleration in the settlement of the West Bank happened after the rise of Hamas and their dismissal of any two-state solution in favour of destruction of the State of Israel.

The two-state solution is dead forever, and neither party comes out smelling of roses.

Israel does not and has not "carpet bombed" Gaza. Hamas does place its rocket launchers and munitions in built up areas, very often close to schools and hospitals. Hamas fires indiscriminately into Israel most days usually at the time kids are walking to school.

Let's have a look at your stats - on 5 March 2014 the Israeli Navy intercepted a ship containing dozens of long range rockets being smuggled into Gaza from Iran. On 10 March Hamas unveiled a monument in Gaza City to its rocket attacks on Israeli cities and towns, a life-sized model of an M75 rocket rocket. Hamas declared  that the attacks "managed to take the battle to the heart of the Zionist entity". Rocket and mortar attacks increased by 9000% on the year before with 2500-3000 rockets fired during six weeks in the summer alone.

If Wales was attacking the Black Country on this basis I'm sure you'd believe action was necessary. Israel took action and by mid-2015 rocket attacks had hit zero. It looks like there were a huge amount of injuries in Gaza in 2014-15 - the solution? Stop firing rockets and mortars you twats then Israel wouldn't need to take action. Who is the aggressor in this situation? Not Israel.

Spikes in Gazan deaths and injuries in 2018 and 2019 follow similar patterns of rocket and mortar attacks followed by retaliation. Who is the aggressor in this situation?

Human Rights Watch issued a report condemning the firing of rockets as "war crimes", stating "None of these rockets can be reliably aimed... Such weapons are inherently indiscriminate when directed towards densely populated areas. The absence of Israeli military forces in the areas struck by the rockets, as well as statements from the leaders of Hamas and other armed groups, indicate that many of these attacks are deliberately intended to strike Israeli civilians and civilian structures... Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups have frequently violated the laws of war by firing rockets from within populated areas.... and on civilians and civilian structures that do not discriminate between civilians and military targets are illegal under international law.

And now killing well over 1,000 unarmed civilians including British & US citizens?  And kidnapping dozens more? Who is the aggressor in this situation?

I'd love to know what you'd propose as a solution to this cycle of violence. Hamas has made it clear that its only aim is the complete destruction of Israel. It has no interest in peace talks, it has very little in common with the Palestinians of the West Bank. There is no prospect of a peaceful settlement with warlords.

Firstly, Israel does not recognised East Jerusalem as a separate entity. Again, in contravention of international law, it annexed in 1967 and it views Jerusalem as the "undivided, eternal capital" of Israel.

I am pleased you are looking at the Human Rights Watch website. Here is a 2021 summary titled "A Threshold Crossed
Israeli Authorities and the Crimes of Apartheid and Persecution"
https://www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/27/threshold-crossed/israeli-authorities-and-crimes-apartheid-and-persecution

I don't think there are easy answers, but mass bombing of Gaza (and it is mass bombing, as the media pictures clearly show) will not solve any issues, but will just increase support for Hamas, much as Bloody Sunday lead to PIRA recruitment soaring.


RE: Mrs Chalobah… - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 10-11-2023

I don`t pretend to have any solution, or , TBH, any hope that this will get settled anytime soon. This world is seriously fucked. A lad I work with, of Irish descent, goes over a couple of times a year to visit family. With a black country accent, he is looked at suspiciously by some locals.Likewise, trouble again between Serbia / Kosovo. Still arguing over stuff that happened hundreds of years ago. Us and the Germans had two world wars, millions died. Not all Germans are evil, after a while, we actually became friends / allies and have, generally, got on since.


RE: Mrs Chalobah… - Tom Joad - 10-11-2023

There is no single Original Sin here and no simple solution to "You killed my family, so I will kill yours". Aligning ourselves along right/left wing lines is unhelpful over simplification. Israel carpet bomb Gaza and Hamas use the Palestinians as a human shield to shell Israel. Like Ministry above, I don't know the answer but it would surely help if USA and Iran stopped backing the sides that defy and deny basic human rights. There is a long term answer out there but it would take a brave man to insist upon the compromise required.


RE: Mrs Chalobah… - Mr Nimbus - 10-11-2023

You slaughter ours, we'll slaughter yours. Makes you proud to be s human being doesnt it.

As with most things in this world it's a horrible mess of politics, religion and power. No simple explanation, no simple solution.

Only one thing I can guarantee is that most people, whether Palestinian or Israili just want to go about their day without seeing their friends and family massacred around them.

However, in a region this fragile it has taken the actions of a few hundred fanatics and fundamentalists to potentially cause destabalisation in the region and mass slaughter on both sides, and we know which side ends up with the most casualties.

Israel has been pushing and pushing the boundaries and something had to give. It is the scale of the atrocity that is shocking, I dont think their is any real surprise in the action itself.

There is no good ending to this.