RE: Palmer on the way? - NewWanker - 07-29-2023
(07-29-2023, 11:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (07-29-2023, 10:57 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Itk bollocks all over the shop all of a sudden.
In short we'll sell anyone for far less than they are worth, we'll get sub-standard replacements in. CC did OK before but was lacking when O'Shea and Palmer were out. So why will be OK now without them?
This season is going to be one super long struggle, we simply have no quality at the back to stop goals going in, we have no quality up front to score enough consistently... And as for the middle they're as likely to score as an ugly fucktard in a club at 2am. This is going to be a fuggin' painful season, not itk not insider knowledge just having a pair of eyes.
3m even 5m for Palmer is a fuggin' joke, 7m for O'Sgea was a joke... No replacements for either... Ajayi and Kipre as central defence, FFS. Button as number 2. This club has been run into the ground. The way it's going 15th will be a half decent season.
Blues and Coventry will overtake us, we're competing with Walsall.
CC is decent, but what manager is going to hang around if this kind of shit keeps happening? How many are still saying Val's project should have been given time?
I want to be entertained, but I'd also like to have a club. The way this is going neither will be a thing.
Sad, sad times ahead.
If we don’t sell several players we are far more likely to not have a club.
£7m for O’Shea was not “a joke”. He had a release clause in the new contract he signed last year. If he hadn’t signed it he would have been walking away for free on a Bosman next year.
He had an 8m release and we sold for 7, that is a joke. Old Baldy would probably have got 10.
What happened to the 20m loan that was tide us over? What happened to the saving parachutes in case our projects never got promotion? Where's all that gone eh?
RE: Palmer on the way? - Birdman1811 - 07-29-2023
8 was low for O'Shea but to get less than that is gross negligence.
RE: Palmer on the way? - NewWanker - 07-29-2023
(07-29-2023, 11:09 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: 8 was low for O'Shea but to get less than that is gross negligence.
Exactly. I've never heard of a club taking less than the release value, ever. Most seem to get more as it kicks a bidding war off
RE: Palmer on the way? - Tom Joad - 07-29-2023
(07-29-2023, 09:46 PM)Squid Wrote: (07-29-2023, 08:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: There is no going concern at this level without investment. There is a slow, lingering and inevitable decline, then administration then who knows what. We are now right back to just before Megson came with a slightly better youth set-up.
Turns out it was important to win promotion when we had parachute payments instead of some fucking stupid, pie in the sky 3, 4, 5yr ‘project’.
I grasp the situation it’s not exactly difficult to work out but we are selling players that are the difference between administration and relegation potentially imo by the end of this season and perhaps the forlorn hope of selling the club before it gets to that point.
The only people ever talking about a project instead of getting promoted were a small selection of fans. For all the many, many negatives of the people running this club, the remit has always been promotion. Hence, with the exception of Bruce, any manager who looked like they were letting us drop out of the playoffs got sacked, as happened to Big Dave and Val. The only reason Bruce didn't go sooner is thay the club decided to do something other than sack the manager immediately, with the (misguided) hope he had the experience to turn things around.
Prag et al are right, we were all told that everyone was for sale. What concerns me is that we don't seem to be operating shrewdly.
We were told we needed to sell, I wasn't thinking we needed to sell anyone and everyone with a smidgeon of quality. Surely you don't sell if you can't replace with better, cheaper? O 'Shea and Palmer can't be adequately replaced cheaper than the derisory fees allegedly received. You are right when you say we're not run shrewdly.
As for those saying this will stave off of administration, what's the point? Surely bring it on if this is any kind of alternative, it looks pretty much the same to me.
I warned of asset stripping some time ago ( after I was first told of Lai attempting to extract cash), and was told in derisory terms, it wasn't possible because it is illegal. It is illegal, but it is possible, I know of people that have done it as a career. So if anyone now wants to explain the decisions of recent years, and tell me our assets have been sold at their true value and the money invested in the club, now is a good time to reassure me because it looks pretty solid to me, our assets are being sold around us for less than their worth.
RE: Palmer on the way? - Birdman1811 - 07-29-2023
(07-29-2023, 11:12 PM)NewWanker Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:09 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: 8 was low for O'Shea but to get less than that is gross negligence.
Exactly. I've never heard of a club taking less than the release value, ever. Most seem to get more as it kicks a bidding war off
No bidding war with a release clause, any club that offers it can talk to the player, then it's getting him max wages and such.
But to sell him for less, considering without a releas clause he'd have got double figures is painful. We're run by idiots, idiots destroying this club in any way they can. We're fucked, and I can't get why some can't see it.
Even Grant, he's a goal scorer at this level in a team at the bottom or mid table who can cover his weaknesses, we loan him out with no fee and still paying some wages.
If Palmer goes for anything less than Dara it's an insult considering what he's worth to us right now.
RE: Palmer on the way? - Pragmatist - 07-30-2023
(07-29-2023, 11:05 PM)NewWanker Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (07-29-2023, 10:57 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Itk bollocks all over the shop all of a sudden.
In short we'll sell anyone for far less than they are worth, we'll get sub-standard replacements in. CC did OK before but was lacking when O'Shea and Palmer were out. So why will be OK now without them?
This season is going to be one super long struggle, we simply have no quality at the back to stop goals going in, we have no quality up front to score enough consistently... And as for the middle they're as likely to score as an ugly fucktard in a club at 2am. This is going to be a fuggin' painful season, not itk not insider knowledge just having a pair of eyes.
3m even 5m for Palmer is a fuggin' joke, 7m for O'Sgea was a joke... No replacements for either... Ajayi and Kipre as central defence, FFS. Button as number 2. This club has been run into the ground. The way it's going 15th will be a half decent season.
Blues and Coventry will overtake us, we're competing with Walsall.
CC is decent, but what manager is going to hang around if this kind of shit keeps happening? How many are still saying Val's project should have been given time?
I want to be entertained, but I'd also like to have a club. The way this is going neither will be a thing.
Sad, sad times ahead.
If we don’t sell several players we are far more likely to not have a club.
£7m for O’Shea was not “a joke”. He had a release clause in the new contract he signed last year. If he hadn’t signed it he would have been walking away for free on a Bosman next year.
He had an 8m release and we sold for 7, that is a joke. Old Baldy would probably have got 10.
What happened to the 20m loan that was tide us over? What happened to the saving parachutes in case our projects never got promotion? Where's all that gone eh?
Burnley were only offering £7m and we needed cash in. Yes we could have held out for £8m and ended up with no deal. Our need for cash was too great.
Our income has dropped by around £35m. A one-off loan of £20m helps with cash flow but the maths are simple. The auditors report made it very clear that in order to remain a “going concern” (ie to avoid administration) we had to make player sales.
The statement a while back that we would be spreading 2 years of parachute payments over 3 years went out of the window with our unsustainable wage bill, and is why we had to take out the £20m MSD loan.
An annual drop of £35m in our income can only be financed through selling players and slashing the wage bill. There are no other ways. The cash flow loan has to be repaid with interest. Anybody who hasn’t realised that this would actually mean player sales has not been paying attention.
(07-29-2023, 11:14 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (07-29-2023, 09:46 PM)Squid Wrote: (07-29-2023, 08:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: There is no going concern at this level without investment. There is a slow, lingering and inevitable decline, then administration then who knows what. We are now right back to just before Megson came with a slightly better youth set-up.
Turns out it was important to win promotion when we had parachute payments instead of some fucking stupid, pie in the sky 3, 4, 5yr ‘project’.
I grasp the situation it’s not exactly difficult to work out but we are selling players that are the difference between administration and relegation potentially imo by the end of this season and perhaps the forlorn hope of selling the club before it gets to that point.
The only people ever talking about a project instead of getting promoted were a small selection of fans. For all the many, many negatives of the people running this club, the remit has always been promotion. Hence, with the exception of Bruce, any manager who looked like they were letting us drop out of the playoffs got sacked, as happened to Big Dave and Val. The only reason Bruce didn't go sooner is thay the club decided to do something other than sack the manager immediately, with the (misguided) hope he had the experience to turn things around.
Prag et al are right, we were all told that everyone was for sale. What concerns me is that we don't seem to be operating shrewdly.
We were told we needed to sell, I wasn't thinking we needed to sell anyone and everyone with a smidgeon of quality. Surely you don't sell if you can't replace with better, cheaper? O 'Shea and Palmer can't be adequately replaced cheaper than the derisory fees allegedly received. You are right when you say we're not run shrewdly.
As for those saying this will stave off of administration, what's the point? Surely bring it on if this is any kind of alternative, it looks pretty much the same to me.
I warned of asset stripping some time ago ( after I was first told of Lai attempting to extract cash), and was told in derisory terms, it wasn't possible because it is illegal. It is illegal, but it is possible, I know of people that have done it as a career. So if anyone now wants to explain the decisions of recent years, and tell me our assets have been sold at their true value and the money invested in the club, now is a good time to reassure me because it looks pretty solid to me, our assets are being sold around us for less than their worth.
We can only sell players that other clubs want to buy. And if other clubs aren’t going to offer the player wages anywhere near what we are overpaying them (ie Reach) then the player is going nowhere.
Anybody who thinks going into administration would be a good thing needs to give their head a very serious wobble. If you think it’s bad now then think again.
It isn’t “illegal” in the criminal sense for the owner to extract cash, but it is “wrong” in a civil law sense. The problem has been that the civil remedies available to prevent it are limited, and if Lai owned 100% rather than 88% than even the civil remedies (for breach of fiduciary duty) wouldn’t exist.
The fact is that since taking out the MSD loan in December no money can leave the club without MSD’s consent until their loan plus interest are repaid in full. If that is breached then MSD can and inevitably would call in the loan, which would trigger administration. Their position is far stronger than the position of the minority shareholders who would have to prove and quantify actual loss to the value of their shares directly attributable to breach of fiduciary duty which is very hard to quantify until it actually crystallises.
RE: Palmer on the way? - Derek Hardballs - 07-30-2023
(07-30-2023, 06:46 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:05 PM)NewWanker Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (07-29-2023, 10:57 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Itk bollocks all over the shop all of a sudden.
In short we'll sell anyone for far less than they are worth, we'll get sub-standard replacements in. CC did OK before but was lacking when O'Shea and Palmer were out. So why will be OK now without them?
This season is going to be one super long struggle, we simply have no quality at the back to stop goals going in, we have no quality up front to score enough consistently... And as for the middle they're as likely to score as an ugly fucktard in a club at 2am. This is going to be a fuggin' painful season, not itk not insider knowledge just having a pair of eyes.
3m even 5m for Palmer is a fuggin' joke, 7m for O'Sgea was a joke... No replacements for either... Ajayi and Kipre as central defence, FFS. Button as number 2. This club has been run into the ground. The way it's going 15th will be a half decent season.
Blues and Coventry will overtake us, we're competing with Walsall.
CC is decent, but what manager is going to hang around if this kind of shit keeps happening? How many are still saying Val's project should have been given time?
I want to be entertained, but I'd also like to have a club. The way this is going neither will be a thing.
Sad, sad times ahead.
If we don’t sell several players we are far more likely to not have a club.
£7m for O’Shea was not “a joke”. He had a release clause in the new contract he signed last year. If he hadn’t signed it he would have been walking away for free on a Bosman next year.
He had an 8m release and we sold for 7, that is a joke. Old Baldy would probably have got 10.
What happened to the 20m loan that was tide us over? What happened to the saving parachutes in case our projects never got promotion? Where's all that gone eh?
Burnley were only offering £7m and we needed cash in. Yes we could have held out for £8m and ended up with no deal. Our need for cash was too great.
Our income has dropped by around £35m. A one-off loan of £20m helps with cash flow but the maths are simple. The auditors report made it very clear that in order to remain a “going concern” (ie to avoid administration) we had to make player sales.
The statement a while back that we would be spreading 2 years of parachute payments over 3 years went out of the window with our unsustainable wage bill, and is why we had to take out the £20m MSD loan.
An annual drop of £35m in our income can only be financed through selling players and slashing the wage bill. There are no other ways. The cash flow loan has to be repaid with interest. Anybody who hasn’t realised that this would actually mean player sales has not been paying attention.
(07-29-2023, 11:14 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (07-29-2023, 09:46 PM)Squid Wrote: (07-29-2023, 08:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: There is no going concern at this level without investment. There is a slow, lingering and inevitable decline, then administration then who knows what. We are now right back to just before Megson came with a slightly better youth set-up.
Turns out it was important to win promotion when we had parachute payments instead of some fucking stupid, pie in the sky 3, 4, 5yr ‘project’.
I grasp the situation it’s not exactly difficult to work out but we are selling players that are the difference between administration and relegation potentially imo by the end of this season and perhaps the forlorn hope of selling the club before it gets to that point.
The only people ever talking about a project instead of getting promoted were a small selection of fans. For all the many, many negatives of the people running this club, the remit has always been promotion. Hence, with the exception of Bruce, any manager who looked like they were letting us drop out of the playoffs got sacked, as happened to Big Dave and Val. The only reason Bruce didn't go sooner is thay the club decided to do something other than sack the manager immediately, with the (misguided) hope he had the experience to turn things around.
Prag et al are right, we were all told that everyone was for sale. What concerns me is that we don't seem to be operating shrewdly.
We were told we needed to sell, I wasn't thinking we needed to sell anyone and everyone with a smidgeon of quality. Surely you don't sell if you can't replace with better, cheaper? O 'Shea and Palmer can't be adequately replaced cheaper than the derisory fees allegedly received. You are right when you say we're not run shrewdly.
As for those saying this will stave off of administration, what's the point? Surely bring it on if this is any kind of alternative, it looks pretty much the same to me.
I warned of asset stripping some time ago ( after I was first told of Lai attempting to extract cash), and was told in derisory terms, it wasn't possible because it is illegal. It is illegal, but it is possible, I know of people that have done it as a career. So if anyone now wants to explain the decisions of recent years, and tell me our assets have been sold at their true value and the money invested in the club, now is a good time to reassure me because it looks pretty solid to me, our assets are being sold around us for less than their worth.
We can only sell players that other clubs want to buy. And if other clubs aren’t going to offer the player wages anywhere near what we are overpaying them (ie Reach) then the player is going nowhere.
Anybody who thinks going into administration would be a good thing needs to give their head a very serious wobble. If you think it’s bad now then think again.
It isn’t “illegal” in the criminal sense for the owner to extract cash, but it is “wrong” in a civil law sense. The problem has been that the civil remedies available to prevent it are limited, and if Lai owned 100% rather than 88% than even the civil remedies (for breach of fiduciary duty) wouldn’t exist.
The fact is that since taking out the MSD loan in December no money can leave the club without MSD’s consent until their loan plus interest are repaid in full. If that is breached then MSD can and inevitably would call in the loan, which would trigger administration. Their position is far stronger than the position of the minority shareholders who would have to prove and quantify actual loss to the value of their shares directly attributable to breach of fiduciary duty which is very hard to quantify until it actually crystallises.
People do realise this it’s not as said before exactly difficult to understand we need to sell but all we are doing is kicking the can down the road by selling our best players key to any success. We aren’t going to do anything but make the squad weaker and weaker until the club has to ‘adjust’ to life at an even lower level. I cannot see with our set-up how we can hope to operate at this level self sufficiently with no investment.
RE: Palmer on the way? - Pragmatist - 07-30-2023
(07-29-2023, 11:27 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:12 PM)NewWanker Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:09 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: 8 was low for O'Shea but to get less than that is gross negligence.
Exactly. I've never heard of a club taking less than the release value, ever. Most seem to get more as it kicks a bidding war off
No bidding war with a release clause, any club that offers it can talk to the player, then it's getting him max wages and such.
But to sell him for less, considering without a releas clause he'd have got double figures is painful. We're run by idiots, idiots destroying this club in any way they can. We're fucked, and I can't get why some can't see it.
Even Grant, he's a goal scorer at this level in a team at the bottom or mid table who can cover his weaknesses, we loan him out with no fee and still paying some wages.
If Palmer goes for anything less than Dara it's an insult considering what he's worth to us right now.
So if we hadn’t accepted £7m for O’Shea, who would have paid £10m for him? Only a newly promoted team in the PL was likely to buy him, and no clubs in the Championship have that sort of money. You can bet your bottom dollar that the 3 promoted clubs and the 3 relegated clubs had all been approached. So that’s £7m that we’d have had to somehow raise from elsewhere. He was our most sellable asset.
Similarly which clubs in the Championship would have been able to afford to pay 100% of Grant’s wages? None.
(07-30-2023, 06:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-30-2023, 06:46 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:05 PM)NewWanker Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (07-29-2023, 10:57 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Itk bollocks all over the shop all of a sudden.
In short we'll sell anyone for far less than they are worth, we'll get sub-standard replacements in. CC did OK before but was lacking when O'Shea and Palmer were out. So why will be OK now without them?
This season is going to be one super long struggle, we simply have no quality at the back to stop goals going in, we have no quality up front to score enough consistently... And as for the middle they're as likely to score as an ugly fucktard in a club at 2am. This is going to be a fuggin' painful season, not itk not insider knowledge just having a pair of eyes.
3m even 5m for Palmer is a fuggin' joke, 7m for O'Sgea was a joke... No replacements for either... Ajayi and Kipre as central defence, FFS. Button as number 2. This club has been run into the ground. The way it's going 15th will be a half decent season.
Blues and Coventry will overtake us, we're competing with Walsall.
CC is decent, but what manager is going to hang around if this kind of shit keeps happening? How many are still saying Val's project should have been given time?
I want to be entertained, but I'd also like to have a club. The way this is going neither will be a thing.
Sad, sad times ahead.
If we don’t sell several players we are far more likely to not have a club.
£7m for O’Shea was not “a joke”. He had a release clause in the new contract he signed last year. If he hadn’t signed it he would have been walking away for free on a Bosman next year.
He had an 8m release and we sold for 7, that is a joke. Old Baldy would probably have got 10.
What happened to the 20m loan that was tide us over? What happened to the saving parachutes in case our projects never got promotion? Where's all that gone eh?
Burnley were only offering £7m and we needed cash in. Yes we could have held out for £8m and ended up with no deal. Our need for cash was too great.
Our income has dropped by around £35m. A one-off loan of £20m helps with cash flow but the maths are simple. The auditors report made it very clear that in order to remain a “going concern” (ie to avoid administration) we had to make player sales.
The statement a while back that we would be spreading 2 years of parachute payments over 3 years went out of the window with our unsustainable wage bill, and is why we had to take out the £20m MSD loan.
An annual drop of £35m in our income can only be financed through selling players and slashing the wage bill. There are no other ways. The cash flow loan has to be repaid with interest. Anybody who hasn’t realised that this would actually mean player sales has not been paying attention.
(07-29-2023, 11:14 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (07-29-2023, 09:46 PM)Squid Wrote: (07-29-2023, 08:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: There is no going concern at this level without investment. There is a slow, lingering and inevitable decline, then administration then who knows what. We are now right back to just before Megson came with a slightly better youth set-up.
Turns out it was important to win promotion when we had parachute payments instead of some fucking stupid, pie in the sky 3, 4, 5yr ‘project’.
I grasp the situation it’s not exactly difficult to work out but we are selling players that are the difference between administration and relegation potentially imo by the end of this season and perhaps the forlorn hope of selling the club before it gets to that point.
The only people ever talking about a project instead of getting promoted were a small selection of fans. For all the many, many negatives of the people running this club, the remit has always been promotion. Hence, with the exception of Bruce, any manager who looked like they were letting us drop out of the playoffs got sacked, as happened to Big Dave and Val. The only reason Bruce didn't go sooner is thay the club decided to do something other than sack the manager immediately, with the (misguided) hope he had the experience to turn things around.
Prag et al are right, we were all told that everyone was for sale. What concerns me is that we don't seem to be operating shrewdly.
We were told we needed to sell, I wasn't thinking we needed to sell anyone and everyone with a smidgeon of quality. Surely you don't sell if you can't replace with better, cheaper? O 'Shea and Palmer can't be adequately replaced cheaper than the derisory fees allegedly received. You are right when you say we're not run shrewdly.
As for those saying this will stave off of administration, what's the point? Surely bring it on if this is any kind of alternative, it looks pretty much the same to me.
I warned of asset stripping some time ago ( after I was first told of Lai attempting to extract cash), and was told in derisory terms, it wasn't possible because it is illegal. It is illegal, but it is possible, I know of people that have done it as a career. So if anyone now wants to explain the decisions of recent years, and tell me our assets have been sold at their true value and the money invested in the club, now is a good time to reassure me because it looks pretty solid to me, our assets are being sold around us for less than their worth.
We can only sell players that other clubs want to buy. And if other clubs aren’t going to offer the player wages anywhere near what we are overpaying them (ie Reach) then the player is going nowhere.
Anybody who thinks going into administration would be a good thing needs to give their head a very serious wobble. If you think it’s bad now then think again.
It isn’t “illegal” in the criminal sense for the owner to extract cash, but it is “wrong” in a civil law sense. The problem has been that the civil remedies available to prevent it are limited, and if Lai owned 100% rather than 88% than even the civil remedies (for breach of fiduciary duty) wouldn’t exist.
The fact is that since taking out the MSD loan in December no money can leave the club without MSD’s consent until their loan plus interest are repaid in full. If that is breached then MSD can and inevitably would call in the loan, which would trigger administration. Their position is far stronger than the position of the minority shareholders who would have to prove and quantify actual loss to the value of their shares directly attributable to breach of fiduciary duty which is very hard to quantify until it actually crystallises.
People do realise this it’s not as said before exactly difficult to understand we need to sell but all we are doing is kicking the can down the road by selling our best players key to any success. We aren’t going to do anything but make the squad weaker and weaker until the club has to ‘adjust’ to life at an even lower level.
We have had no choice but to sell our best players. Nobody wants or can afford our average but seriously overpaid ones! That was always going to be the case this summer. I am astonished that anybody believed otherwise. A £35m drop in income cannot magically be funded any other way.
RE: Palmer on the way? - Peachy - 07-30-2023
(07-30-2023, 07:00 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:27 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:12 PM)NewWanker Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:09 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: 8 was low for O'Shea but to get less than that is gross negligence.
Exactly. I've never heard of a club taking less than the release value, ever. Most seem to get more as it kicks a bidding war off
No bidding war with a release clause, any club that offers it can talk to the player, then it's getting him max wages and such.
But to sell him for less, considering without a releas clause he'd have got double figures is painful. We're run by idiots, idiots destroying this club in any way they can. We're fucked, and I can't get why some can't see it.
Even Grant, he's a goal scorer at this level in a team at the bottom or mid table who can cover his weaknesses, we loan him out with no fee and still paying some wages.
If Palmer goes for anything less than Dara it's an insult considering what he's worth to us right now.
So if we hadn’t accepted £7m for O’Shea, who would have paid £10m for him? Only a newly promoted team in the PL was likely to buy him, and no clubs in the Championship have that sort of money. You can bet your bottom dollar that the 3 promoted clubs and the 3 relegated clubs had all been approached. So that’s £7m that we’d have had to somehow raise from elsewhere. He was our most sellable asset.
Similarly which clubs in the Championship would have been able to afford to pay 100% of Grant’s wages? None.
(07-30-2023, 06:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-30-2023, 06:46 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:05 PM)NewWanker Wrote: (07-29-2023, 11:02 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we don’t sell several players we are far more likely to not have a club.
£7m for O’Shea was not “a joke”. He had a release clause in the new contract he signed last year. If he hadn’t signed it he would have been walking away for free on a Bosman next year.
He had an 8m release and we sold for 7, that is a joke. Old Baldy would probably have got 10.
What happened to the 20m loan that was tide us over? What happened to the saving parachutes in case our projects never got promotion? Where's all that gone eh?
Burnley were only offering £7m and we needed cash in. Yes we could have held out for £8m and ended up with no deal. Our need for cash was too great.
Our income has dropped by around £35m. A one-off loan of £20m helps with cash flow but the maths are simple. The auditors report made it very clear that in order to remain a “going concern” (ie to avoid administration) we had to make player sales.
The statement a while back that we would be spreading 2 years of parachute payments over 3 years went out of the window with our unsustainable wage bill, and is why we had to take out the £20m MSD loan.
An annual drop of £35m in our income can only be financed through selling players and slashing the wage bill. There are no other ways. The cash flow loan has to be repaid with interest. Anybody who hasn’t realised that this would actually mean player sales has not been paying attention.
(07-29-2023, 11:14 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (07-29-2023, 09:46 PM)Squid Wrote: The only people ever talking about a project instead of getting promoted were a small selection of fans. For all the many, many negatives of the people running this club, the remit has always been promotion. Hence, with the exception of Bruce, any manager who looked like they were letting us drop out of the playoffs got sacked, as happened to Big Dave and Val. The only reason Bruce didn't go sooner is thay the club decided to do something other than sack the manager immediately, with the (misguided) hope he had the experience to turn things around.
Prag et al are right, we were all told that everyone was for sale. What concerns me is that we don't seem to be operating shrewdly.
We were told we needed to sell, I wasn't thinking we needed to sell anyone and everyone with a smidgeon of quality. Surely you don't sell if you can't replace with better, cheaper? O 'Shea and Palmer can't be adequately replaced cheaper than the derisory fees allegedly received. You are right when you say we're not run shrewdly.
As for those saying this will stave off of administration, what's the point? Surely bring it on if this is any kind of alternative, it looks pretty much the same to me.
I warned of asset stripping some time ago ( after I was first told of Lai attempting to extract cash), and was told in derisory terms, it wasn't possible because it is illegal. It is illegal, but it is possible, I know of people that have done it as a career. So if anyone now wants to explain the decisions of recent years, and tell me our assets have been sold at their true value and the money invested in the club, now is a good time to reassure me because it looks pretty solid to me, our assets are being sold around us for less than their worth.
We can only sell players that other clubs want to buy. And if other clubs aren’t going to offer the player wages anywhere near what we are overpaying them (ie Reach) then the player is going nowhere.
Anybody who thinks going into administration would be a good thing needs to give their head a very serious wobble. If you think it’s bad now then think again.
It isn’t “illegal” in the criminal sense for the owner to extract cash, but it is “wrong” in a civil law sense. The problem has been that the civil remedies available to prevent it are limited, and if Lai owned 100% rather than 88% than even the civil remedies (for breach of fiduciary duty) wouldn’t exist.
The fact is that since taking out the MSD loan in December no money can leave the club without MSD’s consent until their loan plus interest are repaid in full. If that is breached then MSD can and inevitably would call in the loan, which would trigger administration. Their position is far stronger than the position of the minority shareholders who would have to prove and quantify actual loss to the value of their shares directly attributable to breach of fiduciary duty which is very hard to quantify until it actually crystallises.
People do realise this it’s not as said before exactly difficult to understand we need to sell but all we are doing is kicking the can down the road by selling our best players key to any success. We aren’t going to do anything but make the squad weaker and weaker until the club has to ‘adjust’ to life at an even lower level.
We have had no choice but to sell our best players. Nobody wants or can afford our average but seriously overpaid ones! That was always going to be the case this summer. I am astonished that anybody believed otherwise. A £35m drop in income cannot magically be funded any other way.
I get that but don't fucking give them away. We don't have to drop our knickers at the first tickle. Palmer has 3 years left on his contract. He has no buy out clause. Hes a very good, young british keeper that has progressed his career nicely and won POTS awards along the way. He is now really starting to look the part. Giving him away for £3m would be scandalous. We were told after O'shea that the pressure was off in terms of being held to ransom.
I would be keeping Palmer at the very least until January and see where we are at.
RE: Palmer on the way? - Sliced - 07-30-2023
Spot on Peach.
Also Re: Grant, there were three clubs interested in January, none of which were Cardiff. As ever we blinked at the first opportunity and managed to do a deal with the only club in the Champ that legally can't pay a loan fee.
Yes we need to get rid of players, but our negotiating skills are non existent. No one will ever convince me that 3 million is a good price for Palmer, or that paying one of our two fit strikers hundreds of thousands over the season to go play for someone else is a good idea.
We receive an offer. We accept the offer. That's it.
|