![]() |
|
Border force - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Border force (/showthread.php?tid=27900) |
RE: Border force - baggy1 - 12-09-2022 Bollocks and you know it. The range of state pensions is massive, you’re lumping them all into one to suit your point. RE: Border force - Protheroe - 12-10-2022 (12-09-2022, 05:58 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Bollocks and you know it. The range of state pensions is massive, you’re lumping them all into one to suit your point. Rubbish. There are many public service schemes but they demonstrate one of more elements in common that do not apply to defined contribution provision: 1. Zero investment risk whereas all defined contribution pensions can go down as well as up. 2. Index Linked benefits whereas the cost of buying them in a defined contribution scheme will virtually halve the pension you can take on day one. 3. Huge contributions either made or implied by employers - far and above the statutory contributions required in the private sector under auto-enrolment. 3. Risk free growth after you've left public sector employment - my public sector pension which I ceased paying into over two decades ago is worth almost half the private provision I've made since. 4. Linked death in service benefits. 5. Spousal pension rights on the death of the pension holder. The *only* benefits of a defined contribution scheme is control of withdrawals via drawdown and the management of IHT liability - though the latter matters to almost no one. You won't find an actuary in the country to support your contention. I've read some crap on here over the years, but that really takes the biscuit. RE: Border force - baggy1 - 12-10-2022 You, as ever, miss the point in trying to make out your outdated stance is still right. Defined benefit pensions aren’t the massive improvement on the investment pensions that they were. This is mainly down to the employer contributions these days being, in most cases, much higher than they were. And added to that the decade of minimal or zero pay rises has eroded the competitiveness of the DBS simply because the final amount will have stood still whilst contributory pensions have grown. The main contention of the strikers is the decade of minimal, if any, pay rises which has left our public services stripped down to the bones. Add to that the attacks on working conditions and inflation meaning that there is better lifetime rewards outside of the public sector then you end up in the position we are. I can see that you are a decent bloke at heart because when you see the inequalities and damage caused you will step in to do what you can (the present scheme in Dudley being an example), but you appear blind to the causes of these inequalities of which public sector pay and conditions is one of them. Using a future self benefit to justify stifling present self struggles is not addressing the problem. (12-10-2022, 01:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(12-09-2022, 05:58 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Bollocks and you know it. The range of state pensions is massive, you’re lumping them all into one to suit your point. RE: Border force - Protheroe - 12-10-2022 You just need to look at the size of the fund an individual on DC would need to invest *themselves* to get an equivalent pension, even with the erosion of some DB pensions. That is all I am saying. Most people who've spent or spend the majority of their career in the public sector have absolutely no idea how generous their provision is. |