WBAUnofficial
England v WI - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: England v WI (/showthread.php?tid=24503)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16


RE: England v WI - SW4Baggie - 03-27-2022

(03-27-2022, 07:40 PM)Ossian Wrote: It doesn't help that newer players introduced into a struggling side frequently under-perform and quickly get jettisoned, while the equally under-performing nucleus of the squad remains intact and the whole process just rolls on.

We talking about England, or us!?


RE: England v WI - Cheshire East Baggie - 03-27-2022

(03-27-2022, 09:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-27-2022, 07:40 PM)Ossian Wrote: It doesn't help that newer players introduced into a struggling side frequently under-perform and quickly get jettisoned, while the equally under-performing nucleus of the squad remains intact and the whole process just rolls on.

We talking about England, or us!?

Good point - -


RE: England v WI - Pragmatist - 03-27-2022

(03-27-2022, 03:51 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(03-27-2022, 11:48 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-27-2022, 10:20 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(03-27-2022, 10:05 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I agree with Cuz that Vaughan was an excellent captain. Arguably only Strauss has come close to him since he packed it in. It took them a while to give Strauss the job, there was the failed experiment with Flintoff and after Strauss the Pieterson fiasco. With Cook they settled into a routine of giving the job to the next most obvious candidate within the clique - which is why a poor captain like Root gets to captain the side 60 times.

When Cook took over, he had Anderson and Broad just getting into their prime, the last couple of years of Swann and Matt Prior behind the pegs. Batting wise there was Trott, Bell and Pieterson.

Fast forward to Root, he had Broad and Anderson still at their peak, plus Moeen with bat and ball, Cook still in the side as well. Stokes and Bairstow were starting to tantalise us with their potential. So he got off to a storming start.

Now where are we? The supply of solid batsmen has dried up. The way the game is now, players get no preparation for Test cricket and many don't want to play it. With the dominance of Broad and Anderson, there has been no real effort to replace them. Failed experiments with true quick bowlers (Roland-Jones, Finn, Ball) none of whom have stood the test of time, Wood being the only partial success but painfully injury prone. Woakes has been a fringe player, which is why he struggles to step up now as he gets older. Potential replacements like Robinson have been left in county cricket when maybe they were worth a look sooner. And the attempts to ignore Mahmood in the last couple of seasons have been quite remarkable.

So Root doesn't any longer have the players to boss the opposition. This tour was when captaincy skills were needed, and we've seen that Root doesn't have any. Time to appoint a genuine captain from outside the clique, someone with plenty of County cricket experience. Give them time to grow into the job.
Difficult to disagree with much of that Chesh.

We need a genuine captain that will lead the team and try different tactics. The morning session yesterday summed up the approach under Root. Great batsman, top bloke, but an average captain.

Not sure who's out there in the county game, and good enough to step up, but we need to try someone else. What's Mike Brearley up to these days  Smile

James Vince.  I’d happily take a number 3 who can average 35 at this level as a 2-year interim captain.  Possibly Tom Abell at Somerset if he has established himself in the Test team by then.

Except Vince isn’t a number 3, not even for his county. He goes in at number 5 for them which I think says a lot about his bottle. If you aspire to bat at international level you’ve got to be batting top 4 for your county

Totally accept re number 3, but 5 would be equally fine. Nonsense to say that someone shouldn’t be happy to bat at 5 or even 6.  Lamb, Bell, Steve Waugh?


RE: England v WI - KratosBaggie - 03-27-2022

Can someone who knows more about cricket than I explain why Root has never been given the gig as an opener (properly).

I assume the answer is he doesn't want to. But our opening batsmen have been so poor he has seemingly spent the majority of his England career batting at 3 or 4, but has basically opened for us, as our opening batsmen throw their wickets away within 5 overs.

I know there's more to it than this, but if your openers are constantly leaving 3 and 4 exposed, then why not try 3 and 4 as openers? Especially when they're used to facing opening bowlers with the new ball?


RE: England v WI - Ted Maul - 03-28-2022

(03-27-2022, 11:50 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Can someone who knows more about cricket than I explain why Root has never been given the gig as an opener (properly).

I assume the answer is he doesn't want to. But our opening batsmen have been so poor he has seemingly spent the majority of his England career batting at 3 or 4, but has basically opened for us, as our opening batsmen throw their wickets away within 5 overs.

I know there's more to it than this, but if your openers are constantly leaving  3 and 4 exposed, then why not try 3 and 4 as openers? Especially when they're used to facing opening bowlers with the new ball?

Root did open the batting very early in his test career and probably has one of the best records as an opener since Strauss retired. I remember him making 180 at Lord's v Australia. 

The enduring thought is that your openers are there to set a platform for your best batsmen who should be 3 and 4 to come in and pile on the runs. Root is by far an away our best batter and he seems to have a preference to bat four. I'm not sure in time if the move to three will make much difference as he's that good. 

You're not far off though, he pretty much has been opening the batting on this tour. How much should he be expected to sacrifice due to the inadequacy of his teammates though?


RE: England v WI - rsbaggy2 - 03-28-2022

English cricket has endured an horrific last 12 months, on and off the pitch. Surely this is now rock bottom. Pointless in resurrecting the careers of Anderson and Broad unless they use their experience to bring through and help to nurture a fairly toothless attack. The batting coaches need to be replaced ... Trescothick should never have been picked given his gutless antics whilst abroad and Thorpe never struck me as the coaching type. The hierarchy needs to pick on ability and that doesn't necessarily mean someone from within their clique. If they can't then all should be removed from their remit and allowed to continue their cricket participation only as watchers as they sip their sherry.


RE: England v WI - Cheshire East Baggie - 03-28-2022

(03-28-2022, 07:22 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: English cricket has endured an horrific last 12 months, on and off the pitch. Surely this is now rock bottom. Pointless in resurrecting the careers of Anderson and Broad unless they use their experience to bring through and help to nurture a fairly toothless attack. The batting coaches need to be replaced ... Trescothick should never have been picked given his gutless antics whilst abroad and Thorpe never struck me as the coaching type. The hierarchy needs to pick on ability and that doesn't necessarily mean someone from within their clique. If they can't then all should be removed from their remit and allowed to continue their cricket participation only as watchers as they sip their sherry.

It has become something of a closed circle, both in terms of hierarchy and players. As has been posted before by others, I wonder if the central contracts system has a down side as it seems to limit the horizons of the selectors. It's very difficult to break in just by playing good cricket - players need to be "on the radar" otherwise they don't get a chance.

Yorkshire have made an interesting move appointing Darren Gough to their coaching staff. He's certainly not an "insider" in the Ashley Giles tradition of English cricket administration and coaching. They need to make a similar appointment at national level.


RE: England v WI - Pragmatist - 03-28-2022

(03-28-2022, 07:22 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: English cricket has endured an horrific last 12 months, on and off the pitch. Surely this is now rock bottom. Pointless in resurrecting the careers of Anderson and Broad unless they use their experience to bring through and help to nurture a fairly toothless attack. The batting coaches need to be replaced ... Trescothick should never have been picked given his gutless antics whilst abroad and Thorpe never struck me as the coaching type. The hierarchy needs to pick on ability and that doesn't necessarily mean someone from within their clique. If they can't then all should be removed from their remit and allowed to continue their cricket participation only as watchers as they sip their sherry.

Trescothick’s “gutless antics whilst abroad”?  Go and give your head a good wobble.  He had a mental illness for Christ’s sake!!


RE: England v WI - Cuzer - 03-28-2022

(03-28-2022, 07:22 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: English cricket has endured an horrific last 12 months, on and off the pitch. Surely this is now rock bottom. Pointless in resurrecting the careers of Anderson and Broad unless they use their experience to bring through and help to nurture a fairly toothless attack. The batting coaches need to be replaced ... Trescothick should never have been picked given his gutless antics whilst abroad and Thorpe never struck me as the coaching type. The hierarchy needs to pick on ability and that doesn't necessarily mean someone from within their clique. If they can't then all should be removed from their remit and allowed to continue their cricket participation only as watchers as they sip their sherry.

Gutless antics?

Try reading his book you fuckwit

Cuzer

I laugh at the comments re the likes of Vaughan, he's just what's needed right now, Nasser was similar and again, just what we need

Country cricket needs a new remit, quality is piss poor so frankly it's hardly a surprise the calibre of player coming through isn't great, question for me would be why do the U19's perform so well against their world counterparts and then struggle when playing at a higher level? Pope a great example

Broad and Anderson shoudl play this summer, they are the best players we have with ball in hand, I had no issue leaving them out for this series and have no issue we've lost a series 1-0 when generally we played the better cricket, it's a learning curve and a few had a rehersal they've failed miserably. I've no problem with that, if they don't get the chance you won't see what they're made of

Likes of Overton needs to be told he needs to put 5mph on his bowling and improve his batting or he won't make the grade, Robinson needs to get fucking fit, Lawrence needs to be consistent - the list goes on

Stokes should take the reigns and a new head honcho should come in and shake the whole thing up from the top down

We've rebooted before see Nas and Fletcher post NZ, just needs doing again and no prisoners taken

Cuzer


RE: England v WI - Beachboysbaggie - 03-28-2022

(03-27-2022, 11:10 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-27-2022, 03:51 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(03-27-2022, 11:48 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-27-2022, 10:20 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(03-27-2022, 10:05 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I agree with Cuz that Vaughan was an excellent captain. Arguably only Strauss has come close to him since he packed it in. It took them a while to give Strauss the job, there was the failed experiment with Flintoff and after Strauss the Pieterson fiasco. With Cook they settled into a routine of giving the job to the next most obvious candidate within the clique - which is why a poor captain like Root gets to captain the side 60 times.

When Cook took over, he had Anderson and Broad just getting into their prime, the last couple of years of Swann and Matt Prior behind the pegs. Batting wise there was Trott, Bell and Pieterson.

Fast forward to Root, he had Broad and Anderson still at their peak, plus Moeen with bat and ball, Cook still in the side as well. Stokes and Bairstow were starting to tantalise us with their potential. So he got off to a storming start.

Now where are we? The supply of solid batsmen has dried up. The way the game is now, players get no preparation for Test cricket and many don't want to play it. With the dominance of Broad and Anderson, there has been no real effort to replace them. Failed experiments with true quick bowlers (Roland-Jones, Finn, Ball) none of whom have stood the test of time, Wood being the only partial success but painfully injury prone. Woakes has been a fringe player, which is why he struggles to step up now as he gets older. Potential replacements like Robinson have been left in county cricket when maybe they were worth a look sooner. And the attempts to ignore Mahmood in the last couple of seasons have been quite remarkable.

So Root doesn't any longer have the players to boss the opposition. This tour was when captaincy skills were needed, and we've seen that Root doesn't have any. Time to appoint a genuine captain from outside the clique, someone with plenty of County cricket experience. Give them time to grow into the job.
Difficult to disagree with much of that Chesh.

We need a genuine captain that will lead the team and try different tactics. The morning session yesterday summed up the approach under Root. Great batsman, top bloke, but an average captain.

Not sure who's out there in the county game, and good enough to step up, but we need to try someone else. What's Mike Brearley up to these days  Smile

James Vince.  I’d happily take a number 3 who can average 35 at this level as a 2-year interim captain.  Possibly Tom Abell at Somerset if he has established himself in the Test team by then.

Except Vince isn’t a number 3, not even for his county. He goes in at number 5 for them which I think says a lot about his bottle. If you aspire to bat at international level you’ve got to be batting top 4 for your county

Totally accept re number 3, but 5 would be equally fine. Nonsense to say that someone shouldn’t be happy to bat at 5 or even 6.  Lamb, Bell, Steve Waugh?

I didn’t say they shouldn’t be happy to bat 5 or 6 at test level, I said that they shouldn’t be doing that at county level. I believe Lamb and Bell batted at 3 for Northhamptonshire and Warwickshire respectively