WBAUnofficial
Gary's Economics - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Gary's Economics (/showthread.php?tid=42041)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12


RE: Gary's Economics - petty sniper - 08-13-2026

Inequality has grown over the last 20 years at the very top. It has also grown in terms of ages differentials. I am not sure he talks about the affect of wealth taxes on behaviour. As for assets not being finite - define why this is so in the UK

I STILL agree about the land tax

I watch Dan Needle, I watch Gary Stevenson, I watch TRIP, I watch Triggernomitry, I watch Andrew Gold, I watch (clips of) GB news. I consume what is out there so I dont present a miopic view.

In the 1970s the government owned steel, cars, railways, power, water, houses etc etc. It is now in debt. I wonder if someone did a study of who now owns all of that plus the bonds I wonder how many of those holdings would be with HNW individuals with wealth over 100m


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 08-13-2026

At the very very top, yes - and this as I've previously stated is through the growth in business assets - it's all detailed here https://www.thetimes.com/sunday-times-rich-list

None of these people are competing with you or me for a 2-bed terrace in Cradley Heath. All the propco wealth is commercial - and mostly decades in the making from people I did deals with back in the day like Gerald Ronson, Roy Richardson and Tony Gallagher. Assets are not finite because I created them with people like Ronson, Roy and Tony. What type of asset was Round Oak before it became Merry Hill? What type of asset were the playing fields at Junction 2 before I built the Centrica HQ there?

Primark didn't exist before ABF created it. Revolut? Amazon, Tesla, Google? Every single house ever built? Of course assets are not finite. The development of assets is only limited by the innovation of entrepreneurs and the consumption of said business assets by willing customers.

How many own steel? car manufacturing? rail? power? water? ex-council houses? None.

As for Bonds - google is your friend - 40% held by domestic private financial entities (like pension funds, insurance companies, and banks), around 30% by overseas investors, and over 20% by the Bank of England through quantitative easing.

That latter 20% being the problematic bit, as there's nothing that illustrates currency debasement better than a country buying its own paper.

Even the Equality Trust illustrate that Wealth Inequality has been largely static for a generation - with the wealth of the bottom 50% peaking under Dear Margaret (partly due to Right to Buy):
[Image: WealthDistributionUKNew-1024x496.png]
https://equalitytrust.org.uk/scale-economic-inequality-uk/


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 08-13-2026

Here's another perspective PS:
https://voices.fightingforafreefuture.com/p/credit-expansion-how-new-money-broke?fbclid=IwY2xjawTq2jhwZG9mAWV4dG4DYWVtAjExAHNydGMGYXBwX2lkEDIyMjAzOTE3ODgyMDA4OTIAAR56g7EGimmistki1XQRr-T9L4CfOqto3xdJbwW4igSS4ivlregMgFtEV2kYog_aem_oAfII16AkSpoCMrLju1ZGg


RE: Gary's Economics - petty sniper - 08-14-2026

Proth you argue against a wealth tax by telling me the housing market is broken. Its like saying Im shit at tennis because my golf clubs bent. Both are right but not at the detriment of each other. The inbalance in equality I am taking about is the top 0.1%. HNW individuals with assets over 100m that have doubled in 10 years. If the economy grows at 2%and they grow at 10% then eventualy unchecked they will have everything.

In the link you posted I can see one guy owns the Royal Mail that we used to own and I cannot believe that none of the others dont own ex government assests in some capacity

As for your agrument about assets being infinite. Take 2 examples.

Primark - what existed before primark - C&A, Debenhams, etc etc - One asset replaced another
What existed before you built the centrica hq - where ever the people worked before and dont work now

So for example if assets are infinate and I can just follow whatever model you used to build another centrica HQ and repeat if - the answer is no because the assets are not needed. Whilst I agree that there will always be new things even they are finate - we have anthropic, deap seek, google ai et all some of them will dissapear and become unused or obsolete and no longer an asset. I totally agree with you that assets are limited by the innovation of entrepreneurs and the consumption of said business assets by willing customers. That makes them finite. When there are enough houses or no more land to build them on then they are done.

Move on from Gary Stevenson and think about this in terms of solving a crisis. We have a section of the economy that is growing at a much greater rate and we need to slow that rate down as it is hoarding assets. A small leveling tax that adresses those who pay little will bring in money and encouage some disposal of assets by these HNW individuals.


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 08-14-2026

But like I say, >£100m is NOT what GS is discussing. He's talking about wealth a tenth of that.

The contention "If the economy grows at 2%and they grow at 10% then eventually unchecked they will have everything" is just plain wrong. I target a net 6% long term average annual return on a blended portfolio of equities, bonds, real estate. I don't own much more than I did this time last year - but that portfolio has increased in value by 9% so far this year. I bought in to Tep.l a month ago and now it's 22% up - I don't own any more of the company, I just bought into it after a market overreaction to annual results. It also yields 6% income. At present it's a wholly unrealised gain.

There are homes on the old AA HQ in Halesowen, new assets for families which they can leverage up against to invest in other assets. The old Dudley BG HQ has been redeveloped too.

As for HNWs "hoarding assets" it might have been true in 1900, but even the Equality Trust's data proves it's not now. There is absolutely no evidence anywhere ever that taxation will lead to HNWs disposing of assets. They'll simply cut investment in the UK and redirect it elsewhere to achieve their target yield which doesn't help anyone in the UK.

The key criterion is housing affordability. We're two million homes short in this country. This is nothing to do with individual wealth and everything to do with government rationing via planning and currency debasement driving nominal prices higher (even as the value of houses has fallen in real terms). Begin solving the housing problem in this country and everyone will forget about HNWs.

Similarly, solve the illegal immigration into this country and everyone will forget about net migration.


RE: Gary's Economics - petty sniper - 08-14-2026

100m is what I am discussing based on Gabriel Zucmans proposal

Your statement - I dont own much more than I did last year. Now say that as a billionaire. Of the 10% my assets grew I spent half aquiring new ones after all what else do I have to spend on. I dont own much more - just the 50m more


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 08-14-2026

(08-14-2026, 07:55 AM)petty sniper Wrote: 100m is what I am discussing based on Gabriel Zucmans proposal

Your statement - I dont own much more than I did last year.  Now say that as a billionaire.  Of the 10% my assets grew I spent half  aquiring new ones after all what else do I have to spend on.  I dont own much more - just the 50m more

Oh OK.

And that's the proposal that even Zucman admits could never happen unless adopted globally. Which will never happen.

I prefer to spend my time advocating for things that could actually happen and would actually make a difference - like the radical liberalisation of the planning system, housing bonds for social housing, SDLT reform etc.


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 09-17-2026

I held my nose when listening to these two awful hosts, but thankfully Neidle is quality. 

He's a Labour supporter, but I agree with him completely about the real problem of inequality - intergenerational inequality. In fact I've been banging on about it for a decade.




RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 09-17-2026

Great listen thanks Proth, some good sensible commentary in there for where we should be focussing on taxation. Forget this wealth tax sound bite, it simply wouldn’t raise anywhere needed without even getting into the ‘how’ element of it. Agree with the application of IHT and CGT to be an effective wealth tax. Agree with raising income tax for the middle earners but also tidy up the thresholds and, as you bang on about, disincentives

It does raise a question to those that advocate for a wealth tax - does that commentary change your view at all?


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 09-17-2026

If you restored thresholds in real terms and got rid of the ridiculous cliff edges I doubt there's anyone sentient in the country who'd complain about a penny on each rate.