WBAUnofficial
PSR breach reported by John Percy - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: PSR breach reported by John Percy (/showthread.php?tid=41270)



RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Sliced - 04-13-2026

Response:

"West Bromwich Albion acknowledges media reports relating to the club’s compliance with the EFL’s Profitability & Sustainability (P&S) rules.

The club considers that it has fully complied with the P&S rules. The club will continue to co-operate with the EFL’s Club Financial Reporting Unit and looks forward to resolving this matter.

Albion understands the concerns of supporters and thanks fans for their unwavering support of the team, whose success on the pitch during the final four games of the season remains our absolute priority.

It would not be appropriate for the club to comment further at this stage."


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - KRO - 04-13-2026

(04-13-2026, 11:15 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: I am shocked at this one.

I thought WBA narrowly within because there was a Business Plan or an informal agreement.

Now the Reading case shows that it isn't just about what is spent but what is lost ie stuff like Amortisation, Player Sales Targets. Possibly the item offsetting Losses ie Patel paying the Interest of MSD and classng it as Income was suspect under the Rules but I don't really know.

Given the transparency which was and is commendable I'm surprised.

I'm also surprised that Birmingham with Pre Tax Losses of  -£25m, -£25m and -£16m to -£16.5m and £34m are aok.

-£66m to -£66.5m or £75m in their last two 3 year cycles.

Lots of spending on the rebuilding of two stands, doing up hospitality areas and building fan parks, the training ground and academy, on the women’s team so I presume we’re ok. But glad you’ve busted the myth that our League One figures will count in the 3 year cycle as plenty said they’d not count and you can spend what you like and get away with it after promotion. You can’t.
Our wages to turnover is a worry at 107% but that’s lower than previously but League One revenues of £36.5m is superb and that’s with a £7m drop in tv money which means we should hit £45m plus revenue this season which is huge in comparison to lots of teams in the league


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - wba13 - 04-13-2026

So club denying anything wrong. Let’s wait and see.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Jacko - 04-13-2026

So we're in open dispute with the EFL? At least it shows we won't be a pushover. Think they should be offering more detail for the sake of the fans tbh.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - CIM - 04-13-2026

The club considers that it has fully complied with the P&S rules.

Fugg the EFL


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Mr Vertical 26 - 04-13-2026

It would not be good for the EFL if three relegated teams went down due to point deductions. Not sure what to make of it tbh.. I'd understand it if we'd thrown caution to the wind and kept all our players.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Man from delmonte - 04-13-2026

We've just got to put faith in the club and that they have got everything right in terms of complying with the guidelines. Provided we stay up I'll be so glad when this season is over. I can't take too much more of this constant tension!


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - HawkingsHalfpint - 04-13-2026

Everyone is going on about how great Bilkul are, and how they’ve ‘saved’ us. The WBA damsel in distress, rescued from the jaws of liquidity by hunky hero Shilen and his magnanimous investment.

When the truth is:

- He didn’t rate CC;
- He appointed a has-been flop, still being paid by the club;
- He appointed, and then in a heartbeat promoted to ‘President’ the utter fucktard who is Nestor;
- He appointed a Spurs serial loser kid and then stripped his right side bare days before the campaign began. And is still paying him;
- He appointed a Soccerball no-mark who couldn’t win a game of padel against a leper on a windy day, and is still paying him too;
- Therefore, beyond Nestor’s somewhat meaningless and self-serving statement to the contrary, done fuck all to save us. We were a play-off team when he came in. Where are we now?

I’m sorry to say it, but however well-meaning their intentions may be, their competence remains MASSIVELY in question. And if people are going to use such conjecture as ‘someone at the EFL really doesn’t like us’, well we really are clutching at straws. The fact of the matter is that he’s failed in every appointment he’s had to make, and we’ve only begun improving again with a guy in charge who’s been here all along.

Forgive me for not thinking he’s Flash Gordon. Even if he only has 14 days to save the Earth, he’d probably save Mars instead, because he still seems pretty clueless from where I’m sitting.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Jacko - 04-13-2026

If Bilkul had pulled out of the deal, we would have immediately entered administration, there wasn't time for another preferred bidder to avoid that scenario, further they could have allowed us to enter administration and then bought the club, only our strong league position meant that would be like shooting themselves in the foot.

The charges you lay are all on Andrew Nestor, for me Patel hasn't done anything wrong other than trust the wrong man. Something he has very quickly rectified.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - wba13 - 04-13-2026

(04-13-2026, 12:41 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Everyone is going on about how great Bilkul are, and how they’ve ‘saved’ us. The WBA damsel in distress, rescued from the jaws of liquidity by hunky hero Shilen and his magnanimous investment.

When the truth is:

- He didn’t rate CC;
- He appointed a has-been flop, still being paid by the club;
- He appointed, and then in a heartbeat promoted to ‘President’ the utter fucktard who is Nestor;
- He appointed a Spurs serial loser kid and then stripped his right side bare days before the campaign began. And is still paying him;
- He appointed a Soccerball no-mark who couldn’t win a game of padel against a leper on a windy day, and is still paying him too;
- Therefore, beyond Nestor’s somewhat meaningless and self-serving statement to the contrary, done fuck all to save us. We were a play-off team when he came in. Where are we now?

I’m sorry to say it, but however well-meaning their intentions may be, their competence remains MASSIVELY in question. And if people are going to use such conjecture as ‘someone at the EFL really doesn’t like us’, well we really are clutching at straws. The fact of the matter is that he’s failed in every appointment he’s had to make, and we’ve only begun improving again with a guy in charge who’s been here all along.

Forgive me for not thinking he’s Flash Gordon. Even if he only has 14 days to save the Earth, he’d probably save Mars instead, because he still seems pretty clueless from where I’m sitting.
Each to their own you think what you want. Yes managers have been crap and Nestor a disaster but he still saved the club.