WBAUnofficial
Not a very sure start to life - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Not a very sure start to life (/showthread.php?tid=32595)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13


RE: Not a very sure start to life - Protheroe - 02-10-2024

Great. So those that replace domestic students contribute nothing to the Treasury either. What a marvellous policy.


RE: Not a very sure start to life - baggy1 - 02-10-2024

(02-08-2024, 10:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You could. But they don’t have the option of supporting themselves by selling places to the Chinese, Malaysian and Eastern European elite as places like Bromsgrove do.

(02-10-2024, 08:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Great. So those that replace domestic students contribute nothing to the Treasury either. What a marvellous policy.

Which way do you want to argue this? Nobody is contributing to the treasury at the moment?


RE: Not a very sure start to life - CaptainFantastico - 02-10-2024

(02-09-2024, 08:31 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-09-2024, 08:24 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Between 2003 and 2023, and as I already mentioned the 6-7% tracks for a lot longer than that - going back to the mid-1980s despite the makeup of fee payers moving away from the upper middle classes over that time (see below from a UCL study from 2017):

[Image: a-Share-of-Private-Schools-Pupils-and-Te...4-2010.ppm]

The evidence that they say is weak is related to revenue raising and labour and the impact that will have on total revenues, not demand.

My prediction is the trend of 6-7% participation rates of total full-time pupil enrollment will continue, fees more than doubling over a ten year period made no difference so I doubt this will. And quite frankly I am already of the opinion that independent schools are the preserve of the exceptionally wealthy owing to how much they've risen over the last 35 years (and that's why I want reform of charitable status with respect to tying eligibility to both access to facilities - especially sporting facilities - to nearby state schools and scholarships/bursaries as a percentage of enrollment).

I disagree, naturally.

What you'll find is that scholarships / bursaries will completely disappear. Access to facilities (which my kids used to use at Bromsgrove for instance) will be withdrawn and smaller schools will simply close.

We'll see who's right again, won't we?

Or…..

In having to finally contribute in a way they always should have done, they might learn to innovate a little bit rather than resting on the historical advantages they have long held continuing to prop up the facade they produce.

As with Brexit, we’ll see who is right again


RE: Not a very sure start to life - Protheroe - 02-10-2024

(02-10-2024, 10:34 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: As with Brexit, we’ll see who is right again

I doubt we'll have to wait a couple of decades or so to find out about the effect of VAT on independent schools though.

(02-10-2024, 11:29 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sacrifices though… sacrifices.

You really ought to read the articles you cite in your reactionary shrill posts:

"Last week employment minister Jo Churchill clarified that DWP guidance did not require hospital inpatients to attend jobcentre meetings"

That would hardly support your spurious claim would it?

Twit.

(02-10-2024, 09:34 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-08-2024, 10:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You could. But they don’t have the option of supporting themselves by selling places to the Chinese, Malaysian and Eastern European elite as places like Bromsgrove do.

(02-10-2024, 08:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Great. So those that replace domestic students contribute nothing to the Treasury either. What a marvellous policy.

Which way do you want to argue this? Nobody is contributing to the treasury at the moment?

I think it's fairly clear isn't it? 

If you want independent schools to become the preserve of the supremely wealthy and foreign students you should introduce VAT on school fees.

If you don't, you shouldn't.

In either event you will raise fuck all in significant additional revenue. It's just whether you rather raise fuck all revenue whilst permanently locking out British kids at the margin of affordability, or not. Like I say - I believe it's a pointless and vindictive policy designed to appeal to the lowest common denomintaor prejudices of the left.


RE: Not a very sure start to life - baggy1 - 02-10-2024

(02-10-2024, 12:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-10-2024, 09:34 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-08-2024, 10:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You could. But they don’t have the option of supporting themselves by selling places to the Chinese, Malaysian and Eastern European elite as places like Bromsgrove do.

(02-10-2024, 08:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Great. So those that replace domestic students contribute nothing to the Treasury either. What a marvellous policy.

Which way do you want to argue this? Nobody is contributing to the treasury at the moment?

I think it's fairly clear isn't it? 

If you want independent schools to become the preserve of the supremely wealthy and foreign students you should introduce VAT on school fees.

If you don't, you shouldn't.

In either event you will raise fuck all in significant additional revenue. It's just whether you rather raise fuck all revenue whilst permanently locking out British kids at the margin of affordability, or not. Like I say - I believe it's a pointless and vindictive policy designed to appeal to the lowest common denomintaor prejudices of the left.

Which all sounds perfectly reasonable until you actually look behind the figures. There are about 500k students in private schools in the UK of which about 60k are scholarships. If, and here is your assumption to make your point sound reasonable, all of the scholarships are taken away then we are talking about max 60k kids. And when you look a bit deeper then you will find that this scholarships will probably stay in place because they are funded from donations or long standing provided by trusts or estates. 

Chances are it will be very limited in how many kids at the 'margins of affordability' and any lets have less dramatics here thinking that the alternatives will cut them out from society. My kids went to state school and have survived quite well.


RE: Not a very sure start to life - Protheroe - 02-10-2024

(02-10-2024, 04:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote:  lets have less dramatics here thinking that the alternatives will cut them out from society

When did I say that?


RE: Not a very sure start to life - Derek Hardballs - 02-10-2024

And here’s the reality for those who have are having to make real sacrifices…

Better shrill than supercilious


RE: Not a very sure start to life - Ossian - 02-10-2024

(02-10-2024, 08:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: And here’s the reality for those who have are having to make real sacrifices…

Better shrill than supercilious

That's before you even get into the matter of TAs increasingly being required to carry out duties well above their dismally low pay-grade. 

I could be here all night on that one.


RE: Not a very sure start to life - Protheroe - 02-11-2024

(02-10-2024, 08:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: And here’s the reality for those who have are having to make real sacrifices…

Better shrill than supercilious

Good, you trawled through the Guardian to find something that’s actually happening. I agree that it’s outrageous. Now Derek, the question is - what would you do about it?


RE: Not a very sure start to life - CaptainFantastico - 02-11-2024

I doubt he “trawled” it was in yesterdays edition. Which tells you you don’t have to look very hard.

Doesn’t surprise me at all - threadbare system from top to bottom at the minute.

Another interesting insight into a broken system

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/courts-backlog-delays-criminal-trials-b2473179.html