WBAUnofficial
Can interest rises work? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Can interest rises work? (/showthread.php?tid=30482)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16


RE: Can interest rises work? - CaptainFantastico - 08-16-2023

Lets face it Proth, you can spout all the reasoning you like. You helped elect this mess and would be better served apologising for your role in that shambles than patronising us all about what's gone wrong and how.


RE: Can interest rises work? - Protheroe - 08-16-2023

(08-16-2023, 09:18 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: For the patronising but forever wrong Tufty Street

Increased energy prices due to the War in the Ukraine and our over reliance on gas, our lack of storage facilities thanks to poor government planning
Prioritising profits of shareholders and management of energy companies rather than the end user
Bottle necks in supply of goods because of Covid, and the Ukraine particularly food 
Bottle necks in supply exasperated by Brexit 
A lack workers due to long term sickness, early retirement, Brexit causing inflation busting pay rises 
Corporate profits up 70% and in turn inflation busting wages and dividends (I suppose that’s ok though).

What percentage you put on these different elements is debatable, but it isn’t the fault of those whose lives you want to make worse by bringing about a recession. Don’t say that ‘the poorest always suffer the most’ because that’s only true because it’s the choice this government chooses to make. I don’t see you or anyone else on the Libertarian Fruicake side of the debate advocating reducing profits, wages and dividends for the well off or raising taxes on excess profits. Nope, just throw the burden on Maureen the librarian for wanting a wage she and her family can live on, ‘for the good of the country’.

Hmm. Interesting.

So strip energy and food out and you have core inflation of 6.9% now higher than CPI at 6.8%.

You're correct in one respect that we have an exceptionally tight labour market, but no mention of 15 years of printing money, 15 years of suppressed interest rates, the biggest and largely untargeted Covid bungs in the world and the biggest and largely untargeted energy price support in the world.

All that money spaffed at us and you don't consider that to be the root cause of inflation? Interesting.


RE: Can interest rises work? - Derek Hardballs - 08-16-2023

(08-16-2023, 11:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-16-2023, 09:18 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: For the patronising but forever wrong Tufty Street

Increased energy prices due to the War in the Ukraine and our over reliance on gas, our lack of storage facilities thanks to poor government planning
Prioritising profits of shareholders and management of energy companies rather than the end user
Bottle necks in supply of goods because of Covid, and the Ukraine particularly food 
Bottle necks in supply exasperated by Brexit 
A lack workers due to long term sickness, early retirement, Brexit causing inflation busting pay rises 
Corporate profits up 70% and in turn inflation busting wages and dividends (I suppose that’s ok though).

What percentage you put on these different elements is debatable, but it isn’t the fault of those whose lives you want to make worse by bringing about a recession. Don’t say that ‘the poorest always suffer the most’ because that’s only true because it’s the choice this government chooses to make. I don’t see you or anyone else on the Libertarian Fruicake side of the debate advocating reducing profits, wages and dividends for the well off or raising taxes on excess profits. Nope, just throw the burden on Maureen the librarian for wanting a wage she and her family can live on, ‘for the good of the country’.

Hmm. Interesting.

So strip energy and food out and you have core inflation of 6.9% now higher than CPI at 6.8%.

You're correct in one respect that we have an exceptionally tight labour market, but no mention of 15 years of printing money, 15 years of suppressed interest rates, the biggest and largely untargeted Covid bungs in the world and the biggest and largely untargeted energy price support in the world.

All that money spaffed at us and you don't consider that to be the root cause of inflation? Interesting.

You seem reluctant to even acknowledge the vast profits, wage increases and dividends paid out to energy, water and large corporations whose profits are at record levels in many cases and for what? Making money out of misery? Dumping crap in our rivers and seas? No, no let’s punish the Smith family instead for firstly having their local services cut, then for having help during a pandemic and now because you want a recession. You always seem to want to punish the weak and never want to upset the mighty… interesting


RE: Can interest rises work? - Protheroe - 08-16-2023

None of those things are the root causes of inflation are they?


RE: Can interest rises work? - Derek Hardballs - 08-16-2023

(08-16-2023, 06:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote: None of those things are the root causes of inflation are they?

Neither are the Smith family you seem intent on kicking in the financial balls whilst letting the rich get ever richer at others expense. You think further impoverishing the poorest in society is the solution… we get it Tufty.


RE: Can interest rises work? - Protheroe - 08-16-2023

(08-16-2023, 08:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-16-2023, 06:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote: None of those things are the root causes of inflation are they?

Neither are the Smith family you seem intent on kicking in the financial balls whilst letting the rich get ever richer at others expense. You think further impoverishing the poorest in society is the solution… we get it Tufty.

I have no idea what are you're on about. 

Inflation is the fastest way to impoverish us all, the defeat of inflation is the greatest challenge we face as a country.


RE: Can interest rises work? - Derek Hardballs - 08-17-2023

(08-16-2023, 09:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-16-2023, 08:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-16-2023, 06:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote: None of those things are the root causes of inflation are they?

Neither are the Smith family you seem intent on kicking in the financial balls whilst letting the rich get ever richer at others expense. You think further impoverishing the poorest in society is the solution… we get it Tufty.

I have no idea what are you're on about. 

Inflation is the fastest way to impoverish us all, the defeat of inflation is the greatest challenge we face as a country.

You seem very reluctant to do anything about inflation busting wages, bonus’s for the well off but are ok with keeping pay below inflation for others particularly in the public sector. You also seem reluctant to to address excessive profits from companies who could help customers more shareholders less.


RE: Can interest rises work? - Protheroe - 08-17-2023

(08-17-2023, 08:21 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You seem very reluctant to do anything about inflation busting wages, bonus’s for the well off but are ok with keeping pay below inflation for others particularly in the public sector. You also seem reluctant to to address excessive profits from companies who could help customers more shareholders less.

Englihten me. What would you like to "do" about inflation busting wages or bonuses for the well off? What would you like to "do" about so-called "excessive profits"?

The personal and corporate tax take is at or approaching a record level. Personal taxation for those on higher wages is greater than it's been for 30 years, fiscal drag is pulling ever more people into the higher and top rates of tax where marginal rates can be eyewatering. There is windfall tax on oil and gas companies. There is a bank levy.

These taxes (at records levels) don't raise anything like enough to cover existing government commitments, let alone the wage demands of doctors and consultants (already amongst the best remunerated people in the country). So do you want to borrow more? When UK bond yields are higher than Greek bond yields?

You also talk a good mealy mouthed game, but the reality never matches the rhetoric does it? 

Spit it out. Do you want to tax people even more - knowing that burden will fall on the middle classes? Do you want to tax firms even more - knowing that burden will be borne by workers and consumers? Or do you want to borrow even more knowing that burden will fall on our children and grandchildren?


RE: Can interest rises work? - baggy1 - 08-17-2023

I think you may be looking at it the wrong way Proth, you are basically taking a failing system and carrying on with that rhetoric until it disappears down the plughole by every decreasing circles. The current way of thinking is clearly broken - tax individual and corporate earnings to pay for the infrastructure that provides a framework for the individuals and corporations to operate. The problem is that there is ever higher spending on the infrastructure which requires ever higher taxation - I think we both agree that can't continue so there has to be an alternative approach.

This is where we disagree - your view is to reduce taxation which will stimulate investments, create jobs and therefore increase taxation revenue. Simply put like that it sounds ok, the problem comes from the corporations not reinvesting in either jobs or salaries and hiving off ever growing profits to shareholders and other beneficial owners. This has been the model for a few decades now and we are not improving as a country (UK PLC) which leads me to believe that system has failed.

My view is that we have to a) look to raise funds from other sources such as creating nationalised industries for example green industry whereby any future profits go into the coffers of the revenue which is longer term but doesn't solve the immediate problem, and b) renationalise the industries that are either costing UK PLC in subsidies or simply not an industry that has competition (water, railways) and collect the profits from those to increase the income side of the P&L.

There are other measures that need to be looked into, we have to wean the NHS off the use of private healthcare to plug the gap. You have referred to the cost of the NHS in the past but ignore the inflated amounts that go straight through to private providers. That needs to reviewed and a future saving by building the actual capacity of the NHS rather than keep cutting both wages and services.

We need to look at a national housebuilding plan through a government agency funded directly rather than relying on house builders that will sit on land because it isn't profitable enough.

There are many ways to build for the future which will be painful now but unfortunately the current model has failed and that situation isn't going to get any better I'm afraid, we will be working in ever decreasing circles unless we change the direction soon.


RE: Can interest rises work? - CaptainFantastico - 08-17-2023

Proths logic on everything - see Brexit - is it would work properly if it was done how I ideologically see it. If you never learn to take into account (despite all the evidence to the contrary) that thinking on that basis neglects everything that inevitably and repeatedly comes alongside it, then you'll stay stuck in the world of convincing yourself everyone is wrong but you.

Repeat.

To fade.