WBAUnofficial
When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: When will the lockdown get more strict?? (/showthread.php?tid=9860)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - baggiebloke - 04-12-2020

(04-12-2020, 01:55 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-12-2020, 01:35 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: There is always more that any government could do, and indeed do things differently.

But all we can do is be sensible and adapt as things evolve.

For all we know the virus could mutate and we'll all be dead in 12 months time.

Time will tell.

Bloody hell, does this mean I won't have to buy you that pint I owe you  Big Grin

That's a potential financial positive outcome for yourself, in the event of the end of the human race.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Ossian - 04-12-2020

(04-12-2020, 01:55 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-12-2020, 01:35 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: There is always more that any government could do, and indeed do things differently.

But all we can do is be sensible and adapt as things evolve.

For all we know the virus could mutate and we'll all be dead in 12 months time.

Time will tell.

Bloody hell, does this mean I won't have to buy you that pint I owe you  Big Grin

You could send him a bottle of very expensive single malt now, rather than take the risk.

You'd feel better; and even if you didn't, BB would.

Edit: A proper bottle - not a bloody miniature!


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Kit Kat Chunky - 04-12-2020

Passport Office staff are being retrained to process benefits claims.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Derek Hardballs - 04-12-2020

(04-12-2020, 01:26 PM)strawman Wrote:
(04-12-2020, 01:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-12-2020, 12:14 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-12-2020, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We do know that deaths attributed to the virus in hospital numbers. We don’t have a very accurate picture of who has died in their own houses and care homes as those cases aren’t counted in the figures announced at the briefings. We know that 28 at least NHS Dr’s and Nurses have died. We know that 11 bus drivers have died. How many Carers have died? These deaths would not have occurred if it wasn’t for Covid 19 so what price our lives or those of our families? 

Currently the the Passport office is telling its staff to go back to work and quite rightly many are scared for themselves and those they are shielding for example. They are also questioning the contradictory message of stay at home if something isn’t essential and frankly Mr Jones passport renewal so he can’t go on holiday to Benidorm isn’t a priority currently. Then you have have the deputy scientific advisor saying they should go back because we are all going to get it. This is going to cause huge resentment, political fall out should those working there lose their life or those of a loved one as a direct consequence. We already have significant tensions betweentransport bosses, the unions and workers where they have been forced to work without protection and are now being advised not to work if they feel they are not safe. 

It’s not an easy situation but we already have a very relaxed lockdown compared to most European countries and until this is under control nothing including the economy will be back to normal.

I don't think that's the case. Of course, that's not to say that everything's okay and we should go on as normal. Just to show that statistics can be used to backup anything (Something I know you know!) an internal model for the government has put deaths 'caused' as a result of lockdown at 150 000! I'm not saying that's accurate, but it does show the problem with statistics.

Do you think that maybe this will be the way of the world now and like flu, we have to accept we can't 'solve' it? We are maybe used to living in a society where nothing touches us. Maybe this is a wake up call? Lockdown or not, is it possible that in some form or another, it's here to stay?. Perhaps blaming deaths on policy and assuming there's a way we can 'win the war' is sticking your head in the sand and not accepting the reality of the situation?

You don’t think that the deaths of those NHS workers, transport workers etc was a direct result of Covid  19 and their over exposure to it? 

No I don’t accept that there is nothing we could / can do to minimise the deaths, if this was attitude throughout history measles, small pox, Ebola would have just been allowed to fester and kill unimpeded. Where is the testing to get us out of lock down? Why were we so poorly prepared, why did we allow huge get togetherness like Cheltenham to go ahead! Why are people still being allowed to fly into the country unchecked?

Throughout history those have killed people until a cure / vaccination was created. Do you not think they are working on this - Even some cancer research scientists have been diverted to looking for a cure / vaccination against it. How long do you think it takes? - It took 7 years for an antiviral to be developed to treat aids. There is still no validated antibody test - the USA reckon another week, but we have been hearing another week for a month now. A self testing antibody test could be a game changer, but it is still not sure that immunity is created by recovering from the virus.

Of course we as humans have died of disease whilst vaccines are developed. I don’t demand an instant vaccine that as yet may or may not exist and even if it does is still to be fully tested. That said the sooner it is, if it’s possible obviously the better. My point was to Kit Kat you try your very best to find a way to eradicate it as much as possible via a vaccine whilst mitigating the threat over a sustained period not simply accept we just take our chances. This comes back to the idea of Herd Immunity only works properly with a vaccine. 

The testing isn’t just about the antibody test as Germany and Singapore have shown. If you can trace and map where the virus is you can effectively try and isolate those areas and people and deal proactively rather than reactively to situations as they arise. This is why the WHO and experts around the world have said ‘Test, test, test’.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - fuzzbox - 04-12-2020

(04-12-2020, 01:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You don’t think that the deaths of those NHS workers, transport workers etc was a direct result of Covid  19 and their over exposure to it? 

No I don’t accept that there is nothing we could / can do to minimise the deaths, if this was attitude throughout history measles, small pox, Ebola would have just been allowed to fester and kill unimpeded. Where is the testing to get us out of lock down? Why were we so poorly prepared, why did we allow huge get togetherness like Cheltenham to go ahead! Why are people still being allowed to fly into the country unchecked?

For some reason you're misrepresenting what I've written. I've never once suggested that we should do nothing. Your twisting my position and using emotional rhetoric to attack it. It makes for great oratory but it ultimately adds nothing to a debate! Smile

I think from what you've written you think a lockdown will stop the virus, or it's possible to hang on like this until a miracle vaccine is developed. I think it's already too late and relying on something that doesn't exist as a solution is dangerous.

I think we should have lockdown, but with the emphasis on managing resources. For absolute clarification, that doesn't mean we don't bother researching vaccines. Although as a side note, I think what's probably more important, though less glamorous, is researching ways of lowering the death rate.

You could be right, I could be wrong. We just don't know.

A genuine question rather than a continuation of the argument, do you know how much more likely a front line worker in the NHS is likely to contract the virus than say a city commuter that lives in a crowded conurbation or maybe flat-shares with fellow professionals?


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Fulham Fallout - 04-12-2020

(04-12-2020, 05:38 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-12-2020, 01:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You don’t think that the deaths of those NHS workers, transport workers etc was a direct result of Covid  19 and their over exposure to it? 

No I don’t accept that there is nothing we could / can do to minimise the deaths, if this was attitude throughout history measles, small pox, Ebola would have just been allowed to fester and kill unimpeded. Where is the testing to get us out of lock down? Why were we so poorly prepared, why did we allow huge get togetherness like Cheltenham to go ahead! Why are people still being allowed to fly into the country unchecked?

For some reason you're misrepresenting what I've written. I've never once suggested that we should do nothing. Your twisting my position and using emotional rhetoric to attack it. It makes for great oratory but it ultimately adds nothing to a debate! Smile

I think from what you've written you think a lockdown will stop the virus, or it's possible to hang on like this until a miracle vaccine is developed. I think it's already too late and relying on something that doesn't exist as a solution is dangerous.

I think we should have lockdown, but with the emphasis on managing resources. For absolute clarification, that doesn't mean we don't bother researching vaccines. Although as a side note, I think what's probably more important, though less glamorous, is researching ways of lowering the death rate.

You could be right, I could be wrong. We just don't know.

A genuine question rather than a continuation of the argument, do you know how much more likely a front line worker in the NHS is likely to contract the virus than say a city commuter that lives in a crowded conurbation or maybe flat-shares with fellow professionals?

If you shag a hooker bareback, you’re more likely to get aids.  That’s what front line NHS workers are effectively doing without PPE.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Derek Hardballs - 04-12-2020

(04-12-2020, 05:38 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-12-2020, 01:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You don’t think that the deaths of those NHS workers, transport workers etc was a direct result of Covid  19 and their over exposure to it? 

No I don’t accept that there is nothing we could / can do to minimise the deaths, if this was attitude throughout history measles, small pox, Ebola would have just been allowed to fester and kill unimpeded. Where is the testing to get us out of lock down? Why were we so poorly prepared, why did we allow huge get togetherness like Cheltenham to go ahead! Why are people still being allowed to fly into the country unchecked?

For some reason you're misrepresenting what I've written. I've never once suggested that we should do nothing. Your twisting my position and using emotional rhetoric to attack it. It makes for great oratory but it ultimately adds nothing to a debate! Smile

I think from what you've written you think a lockdown will stop the virus, or it's possible to hang on like this until a miracle vaccine is developed. I think it's already too late and relying on something that doesn't exist as a solution is dangerous.

I think we should have lockdown, but with the emphasis on managing resources. For absolute clarification, that doesn't mean we don't bother researching vaccines. Although as a side note, I think what's probably more important, though less glamorous, is researching ways of lowering the death rate.

You could be right, I could be wrong. We just don't know.

A genuine question rather than a continuation of the argument, do you know how much more likely a front line worker in the NHS is likely to contract the virus than say a city commuter that lives in a crowded conurbation or maybe flat-shares with fellow professionals?

I’m not saying lockdown will solve the problem completely but it can make the situation more manageable. As would greater testing to map outbreaks and quarantine those areas and people infected. Other countries are managing things better than ourselves so your rather fatalist outlook isn’t fact it’s just one potential outcome. We cannot with death rates as they are start relaxing the measures that are in place. 

I agree that treating patients with greater knowledge and drugs is obviously just as important currently but no less important is to try and find a vaccine to a virus that is currently stable and could potentially be immunised against before it potentially mutates. 

This is not simply a mathematical / scientific / financial problem it’s also an emotional one. It would be politically damaging to force people back to work until infection levels are much lower regardless of how many stats / facts are thrown around it’s what people believe / feel that determines their behaviour just as much if not more. That maybe a foolish way to decide things but it’s human nature and amply shown by Brexit. 

I don’t have the statistics to say how much more likely but if you’re arguing their isn’t a link to them working with Covid 19 patients without adequate protection and fatalities I’d say you were mistaken and so would many many way more qualified medical practitioners who have gone on record to say so.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - fuzzbox - 04-12-2020

(04-12-2020, 06:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I don’t have the statistics to say how much more likely but if you’re arguing their isn’t a link to them working with Covid 19 patients without adequate protection and fatalities I’d say you were mistaken and so would many many way more qualified medical practitioners who have gone on record to say so.

As I actually said, I wasn't arguing any point. I was asking because I don't know. I been around long enough to know I don't have all the answers - or even all the information! I don't even know how you've quantified 'adequate protection'. You wrote it, so I thought you might know. If it's a lot higher and they know it, then that's a scandal. If it's not, then we should all be relieved. 

To be honest, I don't think I'm being fatalistic - quite the opposite. I think we both believe that with positive action we can save lives, we just differ on the approach.

The passport office is an odd one. Are they saying that people won't get their benefits if they don't bring in additional staff to help? Are they bringing in all the workforce or are they bringing in the minimum as an essential service - like shopworkers?


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Derek Hardballs - 04-12-2020

(04-12-2020, 06:52 PM)You Y Y fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-12-2020, 06:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I don’t have the statistics to say how much more likely but if you’re arguing their isn’t a link to them working with Covid 19 patients without adequate protection and fatalities I’d say you were mistaken and so would many many way more qualified medical practitioners who have gone on record to say so.

As I actually said, I wasn't arguing any point. I was asking because I don't know. I don't even know how you've quantified 'adequate protection'. You wrote it, so I thought you might know. If it's a lot higher and they know it, then that's a scandal. If it's not, then we should all be relieved. 

To be honest, I don't think I'm being fatalistic - quite the opposite. I think we both believe that with positive action we can save lives, we just differ on the approach.

Perhaps we are. I think this is one of those conversations that message boards don’t do well as it’s too laborious to clarify what we both mean. Can I say though, that it’s been nice to have a grown up conversation about the subject rather than what has been happening with people trying to shut down debate for no real reason. 

I was quantifying my point by listening and reading the stories from the health professionals themselves. I trust them more than those making the decisions above them. I dint know if I should but given the choice I will always sydecwirg those doing the job.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - HomersBelly - 04-12-2020

(04-12-2020, 02:43 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Passport Office staff are being retrained to process benefits claims.

Makes sense. Not many applications for passports going in just now and 1.2M and rising UC claims going in is going to take some manpower to process.

Anyone out of work right now an looking should check the civil service jobs website.