![]() |
|
NI Fund Surplus - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: NI Fund Surplus (/showthread.php?tid=38175) |
RE: NI Fund Surplus - baggy1 - 08-12-2025 (08-12-2025, 01:25 PM)Jacko Wrote: If you put a red rosette on Yaxley-Lennon, B1 would be straight on here saying he was misunderstood and probably suffered childhood trauma. What a weird comment - I'm guessing that you are really stretching to offend here. I'd give up and keep your focus on hanging those flags to try and get a response. RE: NI Fund Surplus - Ossian.02 - 08-12-2025 (08-12-2025, 09:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: What has any of that got to do with the practicality of valuing property for a wealth tax? It’s like saying they’ve got the resources to put speed cameras everywhere therefore they can fill all the potholes. Hi B1, I've just come back from a couple of weeks away. I did briefly look in a couple of times and read some of your contributions (those of selected others as well). There seemed, at times, to be a wilful determination to misinterpret some of your posts, but that could be just my view of things. Anyway, I think I've managed to squeeze all of the responses I might have made into a single, rambling narrative below... It’s possible that I should have been careful what I wished for, or at least more precise. For a long time the demise of the revolving door, two party, FPTP hegemony had felt overdue for replacement, and it now seems possible that - to quote the great Sam Cooke - “change is (finally) gonna come”. Unfortunately, not quite the type of change I’d naively fantasised. Oh well… I’ll acknowledge Starmer’s achievement as Leader of the Opposition: to move Labour from the electoral defeat of 2019 (and even its unimproved position for a long time after that) to last July’s landslide seemed just about unthinkable. But then what? It seems to have escaped them that fighting an election campaign from opposition is a different skillset from the one required for government; but - since one is intended to lead to the other - they ought to at least to have been ready. I’m now left thinking that with - 4 years still left of this parliament - it’s already too late for expectations. There’s little left to be squeezed from the lower paid, so it seems inevitable that middle and higher earners will be bearing the brunt of whatever changes we see in the autumn. Seems to me a bit like aiming for the next easier target as a means of avoiding radical confrontation; a cocktail of embedded inertia and lack of political will. Meanwhile the really wealthy will likely see their acquisitions and assets gain in both diversity and value. We’ve done the Land Value Tax debate before on this forum, and at times almost approached consensus. But the only certainly about that is that it’s not going to happen in this parliament; it would have needed to be planned and ready for implementation from day one. To be fair I suppose Labour only had 14 years to work something out. Come 2029 and it will be nowhere near the agenda. The political right are fond of the term ‘property rights’: it’s nothing new; it was particularly popular with the old Confederate plantation owners - refusing to accept the outcome of the Civil War and insisting they should be able to hang on to their slaves. We have our own modern day version when it comes to the less than 1% of the population who own more than half of England*. Even if there were legal routes to redress this embedded inequality there would never be the political will, but we should never overlook the nature of some of these acquisitions - enclosures; clearances; patronage; seizures and gifting of estates dating back to the carve-up post 1066. All of these enduring and apparently sacrosanct in 2025! Whatever happens next, I’m pretty sure my hope of this being the first faltering steps in embracing European style Social Democracy will have turned out to be somewhat misguided. So, for the second time, Oh well… * That statistic in Scotland is even more stark, but at least there the problem is being addressed - albeit slowly - by opportunities for community buyouts. RE: NI Fund Surplus - baggy1 - 08-12-2025 I'd agree with the majority of that Oss and good to hear the comment on wilful misinterpretting, thanks. It is extremely disappointing that Labour haven't brought any radical workable proposals to the party, as you say, after having years to put them in place. But I am always pragmatic and know that the alternative was (is) worse. However we may now be in that position where the public have to learn and the only way is to give them what they appear to want in the ultimate FAFO of Farage. RE: NI Fund Surplus - Protheroe - 08-12-2025 You deal with your issue with LVT Oss. |