WBAUnofficial
Disability vote - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Disability vote (/showthread.php?tid=37906)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12


RE: Disability vote - baggy1 - 07-02-2025

Membership


RE: Disability vote - tHEgLASSdOORS - 07-02-2025

Have to say I can see them both on the ropes in the near future now and Starmer has only himself to blame for the huge fuck up that has been WFA and PIP

Both have achieved fuck all other than a load of people being pissed off


RE: Disability vote - CarlosCorbewrong - 07-02-2025

(07-02-2025, 05:50 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Membership

Good.  I'll rejoin as soon as the 1st VONC is announced.

BTW B1: I'm putting "Dekka give me the solutions" on the same ridiculous pedestal as 'least worst'; 'glidepath' and 'Harry's kids aren't real'

Hardballs has never applied for or been recruited to the Civil Service or a member of Parliament, as far as I know. Therefore his only responsibility on here is to justify his criticism, he should not be expected to do Reeves' or Starmer's jobs for them.


RE: Disability vote - baggy1 - 07-02-2025

That’s good of you CC, I could do with some infamy. But if I saw some balance then that would apply, he is continuously finding all of the negative and never recognises any of the positives. The quote is to pull him out of his internet world into the real one and recognise that by looking at some facts he might not be so critical. The latest fact I have requested is for him to look at the proposed changes and see if any of the people he advocates for that he knows would be any worse off. I would genuinely be interested because in all of my family cases we have looked at it and found there to be no financial punishment (apart form the one that doesn’t like to talk about it and gets all her cash in hand). The hype surrounding ‘the sky is falling in’ is overstated and media (be that social or traditional) driven to a degree.

As an example of the media focus, there was a bloke on central the other night speaking about the impact and he was that upset by it all he hadn’t been able to go to work that day. The interviewer didn’t ask how he would be impacted, if at all, and I’m guessing that is because he simply hadn’t looked at that.


RE: Disability vote - CarlosCorbewrong - 07-02-2025

(07-02-2025, 06:28 PM)baggy1 Wrote: That’s good of you CC, I could do with some infamy. But if I saw some balance then that would apply, he is continuously finding all of the negative and never recognises any of the positives. The quote is to pull him out of his internet world into the real one and recognise that by looking at some facts he might not be so critical. The latest fact I have requested is for him to look at the proposed changes and see if any of the people he advocates for that he knows would be any worse off. I would genuinely be interested because in all of my family cases we have looked at it and found there to be no financial punishment (apart form the one that doesn’t like to talk about it and gets all her cash in hand). The hype surrounding ‘the sky is falling in’ is overstated and media (be that social or traditional) driven to a degree.

As an example of the media focus, there was a bloke on central the other night speaking about the impact and he was that upset by it all he hadn’t been able to go to work that day. The interviewer didn’t ask how he would be impacted, if at all, and I’m guessing that is because he simply hadn’t looked at that.

I don't doubt that, if only because I haven't had time to read the legislation (as an employed carer), and therefore I don't have the evidence to do forecast how a govt office might apply any legislation. So whilst I think its fair to highlight evidence to support or contrast anyone's points on here, I don't think the counter should be a request for a policy solution to the problem.

It's great if one is offered but a solution cannot be expected if someone doesn't have recourse toothed resources required to make well informed policy decisions - chiefly analytics, system dynamic modelling and an ability to apply them in the current politico economic environment.

I say that, not just in defence of Dekka but also because I look at the problems we face and do not have the solutions. I might do though if a) I had the analytical capability and more importantly b) the political will to make tough decisions.

Unfortunately, too much of A leads to stagnation and too much of B leads to car crash policies like the one we have just witnessed and many on here defended.


RE: Disability vote - baggy1 - 07-02-2025

I would disagree that many on here have defended, probably a couple based on looking at the legislation and the actual scorecards. It really isn’t that difficult to look into and, whereby I agree that scaling that up and giving an overall figure for all claimants is more difficult, it will give the comfort needed, or highlight where there is an actual problem.

The main issue I have with statement such as ‘it will drive x thousand into poverty’ is that the funding is not to get people above the poverty line, it is to provide those with needs the resource that the disability denies them. When we start talking about it as a simple benefit to get food in peoples mouths then we need to reclass it as what it is.

the bigger problem comes when we get a system where people scour the benefits system to get whatever they can out of it. If we then have a situation where we don’t recognise all of the facts, i.e. you believe that fraud is virtually non-existant, then you are not fighting in reality you are fighting someone else’s internet war.

Same applies for WFA, we needed more robust systems in place so that people that didn’t need it didn’t get it. What we have ended up in both cases is a shit sandwich where the winners are those cheating the system.


RE: Disability vote - CarlosCorbewrong - 07-02-2025

It's not about it being difficult to scale up or work out - there were publicly available data showing hundreds of thousands of the poorest being pushed into poverty. You confused, obfuscated and hid behind 'not difficult to look into' documents which were openly cutting benefits from the weakest. No matter how you choose to interpret the 'not difficult to look into' documents thd bottom line was a massive reduction to income from parts of society who most needs it.

Having been called out for that blind loyalism you them ask Derek for a solution as if it's his problem to fix. Which is a trend amongst 'many' on this board.

I'm just calling it out. Thank god Labour backbenchers had the temerity to scrutinise these 'not difficult to look into' documents - because it's their job to do so and they rightly defeated the government when they exposed their treachery.

Thank goodness its not your job to do it.


RE: Disability vote - baggy1 - 07-02-2025

When you say obfuscated you mean pointed out how the system actually works. The example used ‘if someone cannot wash half their body’ would be highly unlikely to be the only scoring element, but it was painted as ‘if someone couldn’t wash half their body and if they didn’t fit any other criteria then they would lose their benefit’. That was from one of the expert papers. I simply pointed out the other criteria that they would very likely fall into if that was one of the scores e.g. they would very likely need help eating and cooking.

And as a btw, I glad you think that the Labour backbenchers scrutinised the documents and came to their decision rather than thought about what public opinion was when making their decisions. We’ve been moaning for years about having politicians that just went with what was the public opinion as defined by the media and it turns out that was exactly what we wanted all along.


RE: Disability vote - tHEgLASSdOORS - 07-02-2025

(07-02-2025, 02:40 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 01:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 10:51 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 10:23 AM)Jacko Wrote: The back benches completely neutered Starmer and therefore Reeves, budget will be funsies! Have to agree, they should have just withdrawn it when further concessions were demanded.

Lame Ducks in No.10 & No.11 after less than a year. Rayner will be PM by next Summer. God help us.

I’ll enjoy the improvement in optics when she is.

That really will be funsies.

The English Language may never recover.

If you’re from an East Brum council estate I’d imagine that should resonate


RE: Disability vote - Protheroe - 07-02-2025

(07-02-2025, 09:20 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: If you’re from an East Brum council estate I’d imagine that should resonate

It's been hard work, but I've managed to lose the Tilton Twang. Angie should make the effort.