![]() |
|
We have all of the cards and all of the cake - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: We have all of the cards and all of the cake (/showthread.php?tid=36158) |
RE: We have all of the cards and all of the cake - man in the corner shop - 06-14-2026 A great deal was never on the table. Only the deluded and hard of thinking ever thought that in the vacancy of their own heads. Even a 6 year old would know the constant message from the EU that " you can't have your cake and eat it" meant. Even now, Labour are now saying they want back in around free movement of goods. As I keep saying, it's all 4 freedoms or none. The EU will have giving up sterling as a politically driven condition. And the UK doesn't meet the convergence criteria to join the Euro. So the EU will be effectively be kicking any reapplication into some very long grass. That is if UK can get its act together to reapply. It is going to take some considerable time to regrow the legs that the UK chopped off in 2016. Fucking lunatics. RE: We have all of the cards and all of the cake - Protheroe - 06-14-2026 The conceit that a sub-optimal deal for trade in goods (for both the UK & EU) is wholly responsible for our economic and political malaise is for the birds. RE: We have all of the cards and all of the cake - Borin' Baggie - 06-14-2026 "sub-optimal" RE: We have all of the cards and all of the cake - man in the corner shop - 06-14-2026 (06-14-2026, 07:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: "sub-optimal" Sub optimal failure of statecraft Wholly responsible? I don't recall saying that. Mostly responsible are the charlatans that were more interested in their own dramas than actually running the country from 2010-2024, those the voted for them and especially those that campaigned for them. RE: We have all of the cards and all of the cake - Protheroe - 06-14-2026 OK. So Brexit is a modest & manageable change then, albeit with a sub optimal trade deal for goods. It isn’t half a convenient excuse for the failure of Parliament this decade though too. RE: We have all of the cards and all of the cake - Borin' Baggie - 06-14-2026 "sub optimal" RE: We have all of the cards and all of the cake - Protheroe - 06-15-2026 Yes, for both parties. RE: We have all of the cards and all of the cake - Borin' Baggie - 06-15-2026 The optimal trade dynamic was staying in the EU. Leaving the EU was always going to lead to a "sub-optimal" trading relationship as the whole point of trade blocs is to simplify trade as a means to optimise it. That is why we joined the EEC. That is why Thatcher pushed for the creation of the Single Market. The lack of an optimised trading relationship with the EU and EEA is the whole point of Brexit. RE: We have all of the cards and all of the cake - Protheroe - 06-15-2026 The EU is not just the Single Market, that's the problem. There was never a Single Market in services, there's another problem. We joined the EEC for trade in goods, not the unaccountable political project the EU has become - we didn't have a vote on that until 2016. That is the whole point of Brexit, at least for me. RE: We have all of the cards and all of the cake - Borin' Baggie - 06-15-2026 We did not just join the EEC in 1973. We also joined the CFSP (unified foreign policy) and the TREVI group (which evolved into the JHA for unified home affairs). The notion that we just joined a trade group in 1973 is a myth, why did you think that the likes of Enoch Powell opposed entry? It wasn't for trade reasons, it was the political structures as mandated by postwar political structures. The evolution over the 1980s further centralised political power with the creation of the Single Market. And what the EU has become is down to reducing barriers on trade of goods, labour and services. That is why membership of it is the optimisation of trade, even Switzerland and Norway have substantial trade barriers being without the Customs Union. You were never getting a better trade deal with the EU outside of it, even as a member of the Single Market. And the Single Market was cut off as we did not want to agree to the Four Pillars, so even that was never going to happen which means we couldn't even get the preferential access of the second countries and had to be treated as a third country where we've got the best trade agreement of any third country. This was made perfectly clear before the 23rd of June 2016, it is why I voted to remain and any notion otherwise is the same argument as the WASPI's plead of ignorance. |