![]() |
|
The last day of Tory so-called government - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: The last day of Tory so-called government (/showthread.php?tid=34255) |
RE: The last day of Tory so-called government - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-08-2024 (10-08-2024, 10:52 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:(10-08-2024, 10:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Not certain that’s right Chunk, it’s in earnings and not income and it’s 8% over 12.5k so if they have earnings of £20k that works out about £650 (about 3.25%), on £30k it’s about 4.5%Yes, that's how it looks to me. If so, it's a bit of a complication to offer a pension then take some of it back in NI. In my opinion, state pension is sacred. It is what kept me going through years and years of shite jobs until I somehow made the jump into working for myself. Right now millions are on zero hours contracts and working for companies that won't be around by the time they retire. I believe state pension is necessary right up until someone can think of something better. That's why I don't believe there is anything wrong with a tax threshold at a similar rate to that of anyone currently working. I agree State Pension is sacrosanct for all the reasons you mention. You can't hit Pensioners yet again though, so soon into a socialist government that is supposed to look after the poorest of the population RE: The last day of Tory so-called government - baggy1 - 10-08-2024 Agree on the state pension and I would like to see the threshold moved up to or above the state pension figure. It makes no sense to give it in one hand and then take it away in tax. You’re conflating two separate issues chunk - anyone who gets the WFA won’t be one of those falling into NI. RE: The last day of Tory so-called government - Borin' Baggie - 10-08-2024 The dependency ratio is getting tighter despite low birth rates due to our aging population, if you want to keep the state pension and raise thresholds to avoid people being dragged into paying tax on low incomes - pensioner or otherwise - then it's only fair that national insurance be levied on all applicable incomes (particularly those with voluntary schemes as the Baby Boomers and older cohorts of Generation X are the last generations with access to final salary public sector schemes and private sector defined benefit schemes). Taxing the shit out of people with 50% marginal rates at £27k or cutting benefits from disabled people or people on £380 a month isn't going to work. RE: The last day of Tory so-called government - Tom Joad - 10-08-2024 (10-08-2024, 12:36 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The dependency ratio is getting tighter despite low birth rates due to our aging population, if you want to keep the state pension and raise thresholds to avoid people being dragged into paying tax on low incomes - pensioner or otherwise - then it's only fair that national insurance be levied on all applicable incomes (particularly those with voluntary schemes as the Baby Boomers and older cohorts of Generation X are the last generations with access to final salary public sector schemes and private sector defined benefit schemes). Taxing the shit out of people with 50% marginal rates at £27k or cutting benefits from disabled people or people on £380 a month isn't going to work. Firstly, I don't think the state pension should even be mentioned (as being kept). Along with disability pay and certain other benefits surely this is what makes a civilised society. Second, I don't see a problem with those that have supplemented their income with private pensions and investments being taxed above the same threshold all other workers do. Regarding N.I.C.s though, wouldn't this simply reduce the net state pension amount, probably to a level where more people would receive pension credits? It seems an unnecessary complication. Perhaps, as Baggy1 suggested, it would be simpler to scrap N.I.C.s and just collect through a simpler tax system? Tax does seem to be a complex system whereby any changes are so bogged down in bureaucracy there is little benefit. Just my simple opinion. RE: The last day of Tory so-called government - Borin' Baggie - 10-08-2024 (10-08-2024, 01:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:(10-08-2024, 12:36 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The dependency ratio is getting tighter despite low birth rates due to our aging population, if you want to keep the state pension and raise thresholds to avoid people being dragged into paying tax on low incomes - pensioner or otherwise - then it's only fair that national insurance be levied on all applicable incomes (particularly those with voluntary schemes as the Baby Boomers and older cohorts of Generation X are the last generations with access to final salary public sector schemes and private sector defined benefit schemes). Taxing the shit out of people with 50% marginal rates at £27k or cutting benefits from disabled people or people on £380 a month isn't going to work. I am fully supportive of folding in NICs into a single income tax, as I said the dependency ratio is getting tighter (expected to be approaching 50% by 2050 in the UK compared to 20% in 2005) despite a falling birth rate (dependency ratio is calculated as (under 15s + over 65s)/(16-64 year olds)) which is going to put a higher strain on the Exchequer to fund the state pension as well as services that older people are more reliant on (healthcare, subsidised transport etc.) and the fairest way to increase revenues to cover for that is to income equitably so that those on a final salary public sector pension or a defined benefit private sector scheme pay tax on their incomes in line with everyone else. You can then use that to supplement threshold increases, especially at the bottom end by increasing the personal allowance. If you increase the personal allowance threshold then you can account for issues relating to the full state pension being greater than the tax-free allowance. The only feasible ways to make the state pension viable in the medium term is to massively incentivise immigration to counter our low birth rates in order to reduce the dependency ratio (risks empowering the nativists on the far right and labour protectionists on the far left), somehow make people have more children (good luck with that, even resolving the housing crisis is unlikely to be the golden ticket there) or massively increase the total tax take well above inflation (easier said than done, especially given the political priorities of this country). We also need to encourage as many people and businesses as possible in work to put money into their pension pots to turn the cliff edge into a softer landing, as well as encourage younger people to take more risky investments with their pensions as there's no point in someone in their 20s having their pension pot tied in safe investments like bonds as it won't grow that much. RE: The last day of Tory so-called government - Protheroe - 10-08-2024 (10-08-2024, 12:36 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The dependency ratio is getting tighter despite low birth rates due to our aging population, if you want to keep the state pension and raise thresholds to avoid people being dragged into paying tax on low incomes - pensioner or otherwise - then it's only fair that national insurance be levied on all applicable incomes (particularly those with voluntary schemes as the Baby Boomers and older cohorts of Generation X are the last generations with access to final salary public sector schemes and private sector defined benefit schemes). Taxing the shit out of people with 50% marginal rates at £27k or cutting benefits from disabled people or people on £380 a month isn't going to work. This. Current taxpayers of working age largely fund the State Pensions of today's pensioners. Today's pensioners retired on State Pension earlier than current taxpayers of working age will (if many do at all). I expect that Auto Enrolment will mean in the future that the State Pension becomes a residual sum losing value in real terms year on year. Of course no government will tell you that as Auto Enrolment saving would collapse overnight. Don't have nightmares. (10-08-2024, 02:21 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I am fully supportive of folding in NICs into a single income tax At a stroke you'd eradicate one of the very few incentives left to small company directors. That's not a policy for growth. RE: The last day of Tory so-called government - Borin' Baggie - 10-08-2024 Drawing shareholder dividends isn't classed as "earned income". Why would that be affected by a single income tax? RE: The last day of Tory so-called government - Protheroe - 10-08-2024 (10-08-2024, 03:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Drawing shareholder dividends isn't classed as "earned income". Why would that be affected by a single income tax? You have an exceptional amount of faith in that remaining the case. I remember the days before the Dividend Tax. The direction of travel is perfectly clear to us, it's why I worry an awful lot about the escape route of company pension contributions being loaded with Employers NI. No one cares about the self employed, dividend remunerated Directors of PSCs and small businesses at all. That was abundantly clear when the Tories set up the Covid relief which excluded 3.8 million of us from any assistance at all. RE: The last day of Tory so-called government - Borin' Baggie - 10-09-2024 (10-08-2024, 07:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(10-08-2024, 03:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Drawing shareholder dividends isn't classed as "earned income". Why would that be affected by a single income tax? Faith? I'm the one proposing it and the only politician I've seen proposing it is Ed Davey 25 years ago which was explicitly about "earned income". |