WBAUnofficial
Little Rishi - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Little Rishi (/showthread.php?tid=31492)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: Little Rishi - Pontificator - 10-25-2023

https://www.ft.com/content/b9864c63-08dc-4942-b2b3-2fe20146c81f

Interesting

The writer is former chief of MI6 and UK Ambassador to the UN
In the Yom Kippur war, 50 years ago this month, the attacking armies from Egypt and Syria had a clear goal — to recover some of their territory and their dignity from the defeat by Israel six years earlier. Had Jordan’s King Hussein sent his forces into the conflict, Israel’s very existence could have been at stake. Israel faced a fight to defend itself.
The brutal Hamas assault on October 7 had a different purpose. Through attacks like these, terrorist organisations want three things: to instil fear, to draw attention to their cause and to provoke overreaction. Terrorism alone doesn’t undermine an established state.
Israel has every right to respond. Now the immediate rage has passed, prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his war cabinet are thinking through their options more carefully. We should expect search and destroy missions inside Gaza City to take down as much of Hamas’s military as they can and to try to rescue hostages. But Israel’s security chiefs know the goal of destroying Hamas is probably beyond their reach. Hamas has a political base and extensive external support from Iran.
Urban warfare is tough. We witnessed in Aleppo and Mariupol whole cities being flattened to defeat a dug-in force. Retaking Mosul from Isis — the only recent attempt to conduct such a campaign within the rules of war — took US-led forces nine months and cost thousands of civilian deaths. Israel doesn’t have that time: its military knows it will be up against demands for an early ceasefire.
The second challenge will be, what comes after? The priority after a major terror attack is to prevent a repeat. I understand that one option Israelis are considering is to seal off the whole Gaza Strip with a double barrier, a new one some distance inside Gaza territory in addition to the current border wall, and to close all the crossings into Israel.
But that leaves the question of who will administer Gaza and its citizens. Israel has no appetite to occupy it again. The West Bank’s Palestinian Authority can’t ride in on the back of Israeli tanks. Egypt, understandably, refuses to absorb 2mn refugees, a step that would serve the agenda of some hard-right Israelis who want to drive Palestinians out of their homes.
Some international administration of Gaza is called for. The UN has done this before in Namibia, Cambodia, Bosnia and East Timor. The US did it in Iraq after their ill-fated invasion. Mistakes were made, but in each case an administration kept the country going and an international military force held the ring so a new government with local support could emerge.
In Gaza, the challenges would be huge. Any such presence would have to be led by Arab countries such as Egypt, Morocco and Saudi Arabia that would be acceptable to Israel and have standing with the people of Gaza. Others like Pakistan, Indonesia and the Gulf States could contribute. A UN-approved administration would require a Security Council mandate, and Russia and China would only sign up if this was an Arab-led initiative. An alternative would be an Arab League mandate, but that alone may not carry the necessary authority.
Meanwhile, Israel faces severe threats from Iran and its proxies, especially Hizbollah in Lebanon. The current crisis may expand to embroil the wider region, though both Tehran and Hizbollah have talked tough while behaving with caution. Rocket exchanges across the Israel-Lebanon border have stepped up dangerously but neither side will want to open a new front.
Iran will go on supporting Hamas and Hizbollah, and proxies in Iraq, Syria and Yemen too, as long as it pursues an ideology of Islamic revolution. Change of some sort is coming, however: the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khamenei, is 84 and the regime is preparing for a transfer of power with no agreed successor in sight. It’s fantasy to think that a liberal figure might emerge. But as we have seen with Mikhail Gorbachev in the Soviet Union and Deng Xiaoping in China, new autocratic leaders can upend established policies, especially when the economy is crying out for it.
The Middle East is already changing for the better — an evolution which Hamas’s assault is trying to reverse. Israel is becoming an accepted part of the region with closer ties to the Gulf. After making a series of mistakes in his early year, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is now transforming Saudi Arabia. He has also cut funding for Wahhabi mosques around the world which removes one driver of extremism.
As military action steps up, the awful humanitarian crisis in Gaza deepens and we face the risk of violence from misguided groups in our own countries, we must keep in mind the longer-term goals of stabilising Gaza and finding a path to an enduring solution.


RE: Little Rishi - Borin' Baggie - 10-25-2023

Which goes back to my original question, what is the Israeli government's end game? Nobody that thinks what Israel is doing with respect to Gaza is unequivocally right is answering this, and you can't keep ignoring that not having an end game is a serious issue.

Flattening northern Gaza and hoping that Hamas go away is not a plan to reach an end game. Scrutinising what appears to be the Israeli government's strategy is not challenging their right to self defence, it's saying that what they're doing isn't a coherent strategy and if they want to react in self defence in a coherent way they need to think of something else as hope doesn't cut it.

"But Israel’s security chiefs know the goal of destroying Hamas is probably beyond their reach. Hamas has a political base and extensive external support from Iran."

- Key line for Proth that he keeps ignoring. This is very unlikely to destroy Hamas. Hoping they go away isn't a strategy, it's delusion. You want to get rid of Hamas? You need to displace them.


RE: Little Rishi - Tom Joad - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 11:47 AM)Pontificator Wrote: https://www.ft.com/content/b9864c63-08dc-4942-b2b3-2fe20146c81f

Interesting

The writer is former chief of MI6 and UK Ambassador to the UN
In the Yom Kippur war, 50 years ago this month, the attacking armies from Egypt and Syria had a clear goal — to recover some of their territory and their dignity from the defeat by Israel six years earlier. Had Jordan’s King Hussein sent his forces into the conflict, Israel’s very existence could have been at stake. Israel faced a fight to defend itself.
The brutal Hamas assault on October 7 had a different purpose. Through attacks like these, terrorist organisations want three things: to instil fear, to draw attention to their cause and to provoke overreaction. Terrorism alone doesn’t undermine an established state.
Israel has every right to respond. Now the immediate rage has passed, prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his war cabinet are thinking through their options more carefully. We should expect search and destroy missions inside Gaza City to take down as much of Hamas’s military as they can and to try to rescue hostages. But Israel’s security chiefs know the goal of destroying Hamas is probably beyond their reach. Hamas has a political base and extensive external support from Iran. 
Urban warfare is tough. We witnessed in Aleppo and Mariupol whole cities being flattened to defeat a dug-in force. Retaking Mosul from Isis — the only recent attempt to conduct such a campaign within the rules of war — took US-led forces nine months and cost thousands of civilian deaths. Israel doesn’t have that time: its military knows it will be up against demands for an early ceasefire.
The second challenge will be, what comes after? The priority after a major terror attack is to prevent a repeat. I understand that one option Israelis are considering is to seal off the whole Gaza Strip with a double barrier, a new one some distance inside Gaza territory in addition to the current border wall, and to close all the crossings into Israel. 
But that leaves the question of who will administer Gaza and its citizens. Israel has no appetite to occupy it again. The West Bank’s Palestinian Authority can’t ride in on the back of Israeli tanks. Egypt, understandably, refuses to absorb 2mn refugees, a step that would serve the agenda of some hard-right Israelis who want to drive Palestinians out of their homes.
Some international administration of Gaza is called for. The UN has done this before in Namibia, Cambodia, Bosnia and East Timor. The US did it in Iraq after their ill-fated invasion. Mistakes were made, but in each case an administration kept the country going and an international military force held the ring so a new government with local support could emerge. 
In Gaza, the challenges would be huge. Any such presence would have to be led by Arab countries such as Egypt, Morocco and Saudi Arabia that would be acceptable to Israel and have standing with the people of Gaza. Others like Pakistan, Indonesia and the Gulf States could contribute. A UN-approved administration would require a Security Council mandate, and Russia and China would only sign up if this was an Arab-led initiative. An alternative would be an Arab League mandate, but that alone may not carry the necessary authority. 
Meanwhile, Israel faces severe threats from Iran and its proxies, especially Hizbollah in Lebanon. The current crisis may expand to embroil the wider region, though both Tehran and Hizbollah have talked tough while behaving with caution. Rocket exchanges across the Israel-Lebanon border have stepped up dangerously but neither side will want to open a new front. 
Iran will go on supporting Hamas and Hizbollah, and proxies in Iraq, Syria and Yemen too, as long as it pursues an ideology of Islamic revolution. Change of some sort is coming, however: the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khamenei, is 84 and the regime is preparing for a transfer of power with no agreed successor in sight. It’s fantasy to think that a liberal figure might emerge. But as we have seen with Mikhail Gorbachev in the Soviet Union and Deng Xiaoping in China, new autocratic leaders can upend established policies, especially when the economy is crying out for it. 
The Middle East is already changing for the better — an evolution which Hamas’s assault is trying to reverse. Israel is becoming an accepted part of the region with closer ties to the Gulf. After making a series of mistakes in his early year, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is now transforming Saudi Arabia. He has also cut funding for Wahhabi mosques around the world which removes one driver of extremism.
As military action steps up, the awful humanitarian crisis in Gaza deepens and we face the risk of violence from misguided groups in our own countries, we must keep in mind the longer-term goals of stabilising Gaza and finding a path to an enduring solution.

But this is exactly what I said. I can't do a link but BBC Sounds/The World at One today had an interview with a veteran of Israel's last assault on Gaza. He said it was the best recruitment drive Hamas ever had.


RE: Little Rishi - Protheroe - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 04:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: - Key line for Proth that he keeps ignoring. This is very unlikely to destroy Hamas. Hoping they go away isn't a strategy, it's delusion. You want to get rid of Hamas? You need to displace them.

That's the classic double bind BB. The Palestinians won't rise against Hamas because they see what always happens in Arab states when citizens rise - those in power kill them.

The ideal solution is for the Arab League to sort out Gaza. However, they don't seem to want the problem either as having taken the easy way out by calling for Israeli restraint already it would then be Arab League peacekeepers that would see the true colours of Hamas.

I've spent a lot of time in Northern Cyprus where the Turks drove the Greeks back through the Kyrenia Pass and out of Karpas and Morphou. There's been a lasting peace there after decades of communal violence. People have been dispossessed and displaced on both sides. Memories run deep. But that island won't be reunified whilst I'm alive because of the trouble it will cause.

The difference between the two peoples separated by a bit of water? Well neither the Greeks not the Turks are backed by Iran for a start.


RE: Little Rishi - Derek Hardballs - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 04:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 11:47 AM)Pontificator Wrote: https://www.ft.com/content/b9864c63-08dc-4942-b2b3-2fe20146c81f

Interesting

The writer is former chief of MI6 and UK Ambassador to the UN
In the Yom Kippur war, 50 years ago this month, the attacking armies from Egypt and Syria had a clear goal — to recover some of their territory and their dignity from the defeat by Israel six years earlier. Had Jordan’s King Hussein sent his forces into the conflict, Israel’s very existence could have been at stake. Israel faced a fight to defend itself.
The brutal Hamas assault on October 7 had a different purpose. Through attacks like these, terrorist organisations want three things: to instil fear, to draw attention to their cause and to provoke overreaction. Terrorism alone doesn’t undermine an established state.
Israel has every right to respond. Now the immediate rage has passed, prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his war cabinet are thinking through their options more carefully. We should expect search and destroy missions inside Gaza City to take down as much of Hamas’s military as they can and to try to rescue hostages. But Israel’s security chiefs know the goal of destroying Hamas is probably beyond their reach. Hamas has a political base and extensive external support from Iran. 
Urban warfare is tough. We witnessed in Aleppo and Mariupol whole cities being flattened to defeat a dug-in force. Retaking Mosul from Isis — the only recent attempt to conduct such a campaign within the rules of war — took US-led forces nine months and cost thousands of civilian deaths. Israel doesn’t have that time: its military knows it will be up against demands for an early ceasefire.
The second challenge will be, what comes after? The priority after a major terror attack is to prevent a repeat. I understand that one option Israelis are considering is to seal off the whole Gaza Strip with a double barrier, a new one some distance inside Gaza territory in addition to the current border wall, and to close all the crossings into Israel. 
But that leaves the question of who will administer Gaza and its citizens. Israel has no appetite to occupy it again. The West Bank’s Palestinian Authority can’t ride in on the back of Israeli tanks. Egypt, understandably, refuses to absorb 2mn refugees, a step that would serve the agenda of some hard-right Israelis who want to drive Palestinians out of their homes.
Some international administration of Gaza is called for. The UN has done this before in Namibia, Cambodia, Bosnia and East Timor. The US did it in Iraq after their ill-fated invasion. Mistakes were made, but in each case an administration kept the country going and an international military force held the ring so a new government with local support could emerge. 
In Gaza, the challenges would be huge. Any such presence would have to be led by Arab countries such as Egypt, Morocco and Saudi Arabia that would be acceptable to Israel and have standing with the people of Gaza. Others like Pakistan, Indonesia and the Gulf States could contribute. A UN-approved administration would require a Security Council mandate, and Russia and China would only sign up if this was an Arab-led initiative. An alternative would be an Arab League mandate, but that alone may not carry the necessary authority. 
Meanwhile, Israel faces severe threats from Iran and its proxies, especially Hizbollah in Lebanon. The current crisis may expand to embroil the wider region, though both Tehran and Hizbollah have talked tough while behaving with caution. Rocket exchanges across the Israel-Lebanon border have stepped up dangerously but neither side will want to open a new front. 
Iran will go on supporting Hamas and Hizbollah, and proxies in Iraq, Syria and Yemen too, as long as it pursues an ideology of Islamic revolution. Change of some sort is coming, however: the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khamenei, is 84 and the regime is preparing for a transfer of power with no agreed successor in sight. It’s fantasy to think that a liberal figure might emerge. But as we have seen with Mikhail Gorbachev in the Soviet Union and Deng Xiaoping in China, new autocratic leaders can upend established policies, especially when the economy is crying out for it. 
The Middle East is already changing for the better — an evolution which Hamas’s assault is trying to reverse. Israel is becoming an accepted part of the region with closer ties to the Gulf. After making a series of mistakes in his early year, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is now transforming Saudi Arabia. He has also cut funding for Wahhabi mosques around the world which removes one driver of extremism.
As military action steps up, the awful humanitarian crisis in Gaza deepens and we face the risk of violence from misguided groups in our own countries, we must keep in mind the longer-term goals of stabilising Gaza and finding a path to an enduring solution.

But this is exactly what I said. I can't do a link but BBC Sounds/The World at One today had an interview with a veteran of Israel's last assault on Gaza. He said it was the best recruitment drive Hamas ever had.

I’ve said it repeatedly but apparently that’s not true… it is but let’s pretend it is t just in case we are accused of anti-semitism, defunding the police and getting a white feather through the post.


RE: Little Rishi - Tom Joad - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 05:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 04:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 11:47 AM)Pontificator Wrote: https://www.ft.com/content/b9864c63-08dc-4942-b2b3-2fe20146c81f

Interesting

The writer is former chief of MI6 and UK Ambassador to the UN
In the Yom Kippur war, 50 years ago this month, the attacking armies from Egypt and Syria had a clear goal — to recover some of their territory and their dignity from the defeat by Israel six years earlier. Had Jordan’s King Hussein sent his forces into the conflict, Israel’s very existence could have been at stake. Israel faced a fight to defend itself.
The brutal Hamas assault on October 7 had a different purpose. Through attacks like these, terrorist organisations want three things: to instil fear, to draw attention to their cause and to provoke overreaction. Terrorism alone doesn’t undermine an established state.
Israel has every right to respond. Now the immediate rage has passed, prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his war cabinet are thinking through their options more carefully. We should expect search and destroy missions inside Gaza City to take down as much of Hamas’s military as they can and to try to rescue hostages. But Israel’s security chiefs know the goal of destroying Hamas is probably beyond their reach. Hamas has a political base and extensive external support from Iran. 
Urban warfare is tough. We witnessed in Aleppo and Mariupol whole cities being flattened to defeat a dug-in force. Retaking Mosul from Isis — the only recent attempt to conduct such a campaign within the rules of war — took US-led forces nine months and cost thousands of civilian deaths. Israel doesn’t have that time: its military knows it will be up against demands for an early ceasefire.
The second challenge will be, what comes after? The priority after a major terror attack is to prevent a repeat. I understand that one option Israelis are considering is to seal off the whole Gaza Strip with a double barrier, a new one some distance inside Gaza territory in addition to the current border wall, and to close all the crossings into Israel. 
But that leaves the question of who will administer Gaza and its citizens. Israel has no appetite to occupy it again. The West Bank’s Palestinian Authority can’t ride in on the back of Israeli tanks. Egypt, understandably, refuses to absorb 2mn refugees, a step that would serve the agenda of some hard-right Israelis who want to drive Palestinians out of their homes.
Some international administration of Gaza is called for. The UN has done this before in Namibia, Cambodia, Bosnia and East Timor. The US did it in Iraq after their ill-fated invasion. Mistakes were made, but in each case an administration kept the country going and an international military force held the ring so a new government with local support could emerge. 
In Gaza, the challenges would be huge. Any such presence would have to be led by Arab countries such as Egypt, Morocco and Saudi Arabia that would be acceptable to Israel and have standing with the people of Gaza. Others like Pakistan, Indonesia and the Gulf States could contribute. A UN-approved administration would require a Security Council mandate, and Russia and China would only sign up if this was an Arab-led initiative. An alternative would be an Arab League mandate, but that alone may not carry the necessary authority. 
Meanwhile, Israel faces severe threats from Iran and its proxies, especially Hizbollah in Lebanon. The current crisis may expand to embroil the wider region, though both Tehran and Hizbollah have talked tough while behaving with caution. Rocket exchanges across the Israel-Lebanon border have stepped up dangerously but neither side will want to open a new front. 
Iran will go on supporting Hamas and Hizbollah, and proxies in Iraq, Syria and Yemen too, as long as it pursues an ideology of Islamic revolution. Change of some sort is coming, however: the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khamenei, is 84 and the regime is preparing for a transfer of power with no agreed successor in sight. It’s fantasy to think that a liberal figure might emerge. But as we have seen with Mikhail Gorbachev in the Soviet Union and Deng Xiaoping in China, new autocratic leaders can upend established policies, especially when the economy is crying out for it. 
The Middle East is already changing for the better — an evolution which Hamas’s assault is trying to reverse. Israel is becoming an accepted part of the region with closer ties to the Gulf. After making a series of mistakes in his early year, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is now transforming Saudi Arabia. He has also cut funding for Wahhabi mosques around the world which removes one driver of extremism.
As military action steps up, the awful humanitarian crisis in Gaza deepens and we face the risk of violence from misguided groups in our own countries, we must keep in mind the longer-term goals of stabilising Gaza and finding a path to an enduring solution.

But this is exactly what I said. I can't do a link but BBC Sounds/The World at One today had an interview with a veteran of Israel's last assault on Gaza. He said it was the best recruitment drive Hamas ever had.

I’ve said it repeatedly but apparently that’s not true… it is but let’s pretend it isn t just in case we are accused of anti-semitism, defunding the police and getting a white feather through the post.

Aye, I was more than a little annoyed at that!


RE: Little Rishi - Borin' Baggie - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 05:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 04:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: - Key line for Proth that he keeps ignoring. This is very unlikely to destroy Hamas. Hoping they go away isn't a strategy, it's delusion. You want to get rid of Hamas? You need to displace them.

That's the classic double bind BB. The Palestinians won't rise against Hamas because they see what always happens in Arab states when citizens rise - those in power kill them.

The ideal solution is for the Arab League to sort out Gaza. However, they don't seem to want the problem either as having taken the easy way out by calling for Israeli restraint already it would then be Arab League peacekeepers that would see the true colours of Hamas.

I've spent a lot of time in Northern Cyprus where the Turks drove the Greeks back through the Kyrenia Pass and out of Karpas and Morphou. There's been a lasting peace there after decades of communal violence. People have been dispossessed and displaced on both sides. Memories run deep. But that island won't be reunified whilst I'm alive because of the trouble it will cause.

The difference between the two peoples separated by a bit of water? Well neither the Greeks not the Turks are backed by Iran for a start.

The ideal solution is for the PA to take over political control in Gaza with international backing and for Israel to finally send Netanyahu to prison while voting in a liberal Zionist, Arab and secular coalition that actually supports the two-state solution.

And the UN speeches highlight that the Israel government are not thinking rationally, the Arab League (led by Saudi) were pretty explicit over them wanting the two-state solution and the Israeli ambassador (presenting the Israeli government position a k.a the far right and Netanyahu) was pretty explicit that they didn't want a two-state solution.

And ethnic displacement and forced repatriation should not be on the table, Cyprus is a shitshow held together by two countries that would 100% go to war if not for NATO holding them back. That applies to every state, not just Israel. I'm already pissed off at the pathetically weak UK government response to the Bengalis being kicked out of Myanmar.


RE: Little Rishi - Squid - 10-26-2023

(10-25-2023, 11:47 AM)Pontificator Wrote: https://www.ft.com/content/b9864c63-08dc-4942-b2b3-2fe20146c81f

Interesting

The writer is former chief of MI6 and UK Ambassador to the UN
In the Yom Kippur war, 50 years ago this month, the attacking armies from Egypt and Syria had a clear goal — to recover some of their territory and their dignity from the defeat by Israel six years earlier. Had Jordan’s King Hussein sent his forces into the conflict, Israel’s very existence could have been at stake. Israel faced a fight to defend itself.
The brutal Hamas assault on October 7 had a different purpose. Through attacks like these, terrorist organisations want three things: to instil fear, to draw attention to their cause and to provoke overreaction. Terrorism alone doesn’t undermine an established state.
Israel has every right to respond. Now the immediate rage has passed, prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his war cabinet are thinking through their options more carefully. We should expect search and destroy missions inside Gaza City to take down as much of Hamas’s military as they can and to try to rescue hostages. But Israel’s security chiefs know the goal of destroying Hamas is probably beyond their reach. Hamas has a political base and extensive external support from Iran. 
Urban warfare is tough. We witnessed in Aleppo and Mariupol whole cities being flattened to defeat a dug-in force. Retaking Mosul from Isis — the only recent attempt to conduct such a campaign within the rules of war — took US-led forces nine months and cost thousands of civilian deaths. Israel doesn’t have that time: its military knows it will be up against demands for an early ceasefire.
The second challenge will be, what comes after? The priority after a major terror attack is to prevent a repeat. I understand that one option Israelis are considering is to seal off the whole Gaza Strip with a double barrier, a new one some distance inside Gaza territory in addition to the current border wall, and to close all the crossings into Israel. 
But that leaves the question of who will administer Gaza and its citizens. Israel has no appetite to occupy it again. The West Bank’s Palestinian Authority can’t ride in on the back of Israeli tanks. Egypt, understandably, refuses to absorb 2mn refugees, a step that would serve the agenda of some hard-right Israelis who want to drive Palestinians out of their homes.
Some international administration of Gaza is called for. The UN has done this before in Namibia, Cambodia, Bosnia and East Timor. The US did it in Iraq after their ill-fated invasion. Mistakes were made, but in each case an administration kept the country going and an international military force held the ring so a new government with local support could emerge. 
In Gaza, the challenges would be huge. Any such presence would have to be led by Arab countries such as Egypt, Morocco and Saudi Arabia that would be acceptable to Israel and have standing with the people of Gaza. Others like Pakistan, Indonesia and the Gulf States could contribute. A UN-approved administration would require a Security Council mandate, and Russia and China would only sign up if this was an Arab-led initiative. An alternative would be an Arab League mandate, but that alone may not carry the necessary authority. 
Meanwhile, Israel faces severe threats from Iran and its proxies, especially Hizbollah in Lebanon. The current crisis may expand to embroil the wider region, though both Tehran and Hizbollah have talked tough while behaving with caution. Rocket exchanges across the Israel-Lebanon border have stepped up dangerously but neither side will want to open a new front. 
Iran will go on supporting Hamas and Hizbollah, and proxies in Iraq, Syria and Yemen too, as long as it pursues an ideology of Islamic revolution. Change of some sort is coming, however: the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khamenei, is 84 and the regime is preparing for a transfer of power with no agreed successor in sight. It’s fantasy to think that a liberal figure might emerge. But as we have seen with Mikhail Gorbachev in the Soviet Union and Deng Xiaoping in China, new autocratic leaders can upend established policies, especially when the economy is crying out for it. 
The Middle East is already changing for the better — an evolution which Hamas’s assault is trying to reverse. Israel is becoming an accepted part of the region with closer ties to the Gulf. After making a series of mistakes in his early year, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is now transforming Saudi Arabia. He has also cut funding for Wahhabi mosques around the world which removes one driver of extremism.
As military action steps up, the awful humanitarian crisis in Gaza deepens and we face the risk of violence from misguided groups in our own countries, we must keep in mind the longer-term goals of stabilising Gaza and finding a path to an enduring solution.

That's their big idea?! Make Gaza an even bigger prison and get the Arabs to run it!

1) The surrounding Arab countries will not, for any money, be cleaning up Israel's messes. There is zero benefit for them to do so and a high chance of a national uprising in each country. If the US even thinks about pushing them to do so, it will instead push the region towards Iran, Russia and China. 

2)Israel being an accepted part of the region is gone for the next ten years, if not longer. The only thing that would change that is an actual viable political solution.  

Not mentioned in the article, but clearly ongoing is the attempt to now claim Palestinians are lying about the number of dead, which is exactly the same sort of thing Russia accuses the Ukrainians of and Assad accuses those fighting the Syrian regime of doing. It is the bleakest of propaganda, particularly when the US was happy to use Palestinian health authority statistics only a few months ago: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/10/24/gaza-death-toll-palestinian-health-ministry/


RE: Little Rishi - Pontificator - 10-26-2023

(10-25-2023, 05:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 04:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 11:47 AM)Pontificator Wrote: https://www.ft.com/content/b9864c63-08dc-4942-b2b3-2fe20146c81f

Interesting

The writer is former chief of MI6 and UK Ambassador to the UN
In the Yom Kippur war, 50 years ago this month, the attacking armies from Egypt and Syria had a clear goal — to recover some of their territory and their dignity from the defeat by Israel six years earlier. Had Jordan’s King Hussein sent his forces into the conflict, Israel’s very existence could have been at stake. Israel faced a fight to defend itself.
The brutal Hamas assault on October 7 had a different purpose. Through attacks like these, terrorist organisations want three things: to instil fear, to draw attention to their cause and to provoke overreaction. Terrorism alone doesn’t undermine an established state.
Israel has every right to respond. Now the immediate rage has passed, prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his war cabinet are thinking through their options more carefully. We should expect search and destroy missions inside Gaza City to take down as much of Hamas’s military as they can and to try to rescue hostages. But Israel’s security chiefs know the goal of destroying Hamas is probably beyond their reach. Hamas has a political base and extensive external support from Iran. 
Urban warfare is tough. We witnessed in Aleppo and Mariupol whole cities being flattened to defeat a dug-in force. Retaking Mosul from Isis — the only recent attempt to conduct such a campaign within the rules of war — took US-led forces nine months and cost thousands of civilian deaths. Israel doesn’t have that time: its military knows it will be up against demands for an early ceasefire.
The second challenge will be, what comes after? The priority after a major terror attack is to prevent a repeat. I understand that one option Israelis are considering is to seal off the whole Gaza Strip with a double barrier, a new one some distance inside Gaza territory in addition to the current border wall, and to close all the crossings into Israel. 
But that leaves the question of who will administer Gaza and its citizens. Israel has no appetite to occupy it again. The West Bank’s Palestinian Authority can’t ride in on the back of Israeli tanks. Egypt, understandably, refuses to absorb 2mn refugees, a step that would serve the agenda of some hard-right Israelis who want to drive Palestinians out of their homes.
Some international administration of Gaza is called for. The UN has done this before in Namibia, Cambodia, Bosnia and East Timor. The US did it in Iraq after their ill-fated invasion. Mistakes were made, but in each case an administration kept the country going and an international military force held the ring so a new government with local support could emerge. 
In Gaza, the challenges would be huge. Any such presence would have to be led by Arab countries such as Egypt, Morocco and Saudi Arabia that would be acceptable to Israel and have standing with the people of Gaza. Others like Pakistan, Indonesia and the Gulf States could contribute. A UN-approved administration would require a Security Council mandate, and Russia and China would only sign up if this was an Arab-led initiative. An alternative would be an Arab League mandate, but that alone may not carry the necessary authority. 
Meanwhile, Israel faces severe threats from Iran and its proxies, especially Hizbollah in Lebanon. The current crisis may expand to embroil the wider region, though both Tehran and Hizbollah have talked tough while behaving with caution. Rocket exchanges across the Israel-Lebanon border have stepped up dangerously but neither side will want to open a new front. 
Iran will go on supporting Hamas and Hizbollah, and proxies in Iraq, Syria and Yemen too, as long as it pursues an ideology of Islamic revolution. Change of some sort is coming, however: the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khamenei, is 84 and the regime is preparing for a transfer of power with no agreed successor in sight. It’s fantasy to think that a liberal figure might emerge. But as we have seen with Mikhail Gorbachev in the Soviet Union and Deng Xiaoping in China, new autocratic leaders can upend established policies, especially when the economy is crying out for it. 
The Middle East is already changing for the better — an evolution which Hamas’s assault is trying to reverse. Israel is becoming an accepted part of the region with closer ties to the Gulf. After making a series of mistakes in his early year, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is now transforming Saudi Arabia. He has also cut funding for Wahhabi mosques around the world which removes one driver of extremism.
As military action steps up, the awful humanitarian crisis in Gaza deepens and we face the risk of violence from misguided groups in our own countries, we must keep in mind the longer-term goals of stabilising Gaza and finding a path to an enduring solution.

But this is exactly what I said. I can't do a link but BBC Sounds/The World at One today had an interview with a veteran of Israel's last assault on Gaza. He said it was the best recruitment drive Hamas ever had.

I’ve said it repeatedly but apparently that’s not true… it is but let’s pretend it is t just in case we are accused of anti-semitism, defunding the police and getting a white feather through the post.

Our governments 1st duty is the security and defence of our people. Equally it's Israel's. Except that Israel is always held to higher scrutiny for the collateral that occurs when they carry out that duty. 

It's the default, orthodox position of so many Lefties who naturally support minorities and don't do the same for Jews. The effects of so many tropes embedded. Jews here are held accountable for the Israeli governments actions in a way that Muslims are not held to account for the despicable despotic autocratic regimes in the Middle East. Explain it to me? 

The view that violence leads to more violence; can you distinguish for me between those who perpetrate violence & those who resist it, please? I include the Police, because Lefties seem always to have it in for them too


RE: Little Rishi - Shabby Russian - 10-26-2023

This is in reply to Pontificator's last post.

I have not seen one post on here criticising the Jewish religion or Jewish people in general and specifically UK Jews for the actions of the Israeli Govt.

I have seen posts which suggest that Hamas is representative of Muslims and the religion of Islam.

In short your post couldn't be more wrong.