WBAUnofficial
Just stop oil protests - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Just stop oil protests (/showthread.php?tid=30595)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21


RE: Just stop oil protests - Protheroe - 07-20-2023

(07-20-2023, 08:58 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 08:55 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: We have a very 'let's protect our damaging ways of life ' bunch on this BORED.

When we run out of desalinated water to drink we should trawl folks' social media posts to see who took this shit seriously and who wanted their shorthall flight to the med to bask in 45 degree heat.

You can deny them a bank account if you like too.


RE: Just stop oil protests - CarlosCorbewrong - 07-20-2023

(07-20-2023, 12:21 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:34 AM)Morley Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:17 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I find the whole “debate” with JSO, and other climate issues, incredibly oversimplified tbh.

What most people want to know, IMO, is if society needs to change to “save us from extinction”, what does this actually mean? Actual real world changes. Is stopping new oil going to increase our costs? Are there genuine viable alternatives? Is switching to electric cars going to price the poor out of driving? Are we going to have travel restricted in any way? People want to know real world impacts IMO. How it’ll actually affect their quality of life.

These are an example of the things that don’t get discussed much. It all seems to be you’re either for or against with no detail or cost benefit analysis.

And of course, there’s a high percentage of people who say “i support the cause” but they’re just paying lip service and don’t give it a second thought in reality, or certainly don’t take any steps to change anything. I mean neither do I, I love driving and holidays, but I don’t say “I support the cause” either. I want to know detail of actual effects to people’s lives before I claim to support stopping oil etc.

And I think there’s plenty of people like me. What’s the actual real world result of getting to net zero by 2040, 2050 etc etc? This is the key.

The biggest impact on climate is people.  How many would support a ban on having more than 1 child?

But, how do you ban people from having more than 1 child? We only have 1, that was because we could not afford child care for another, grandparents were into their seventies etc, so we left it at that. But, any woman can fall pregnant, `it was by accident` etc. How do you enforce a ban ?
But, you then get the opposite in Western countries politicians talk about a falling birth rate, loonies like Rees -Mogg saying everyone should have more kids, but doesn`t say how you can afford to keep them, but, Sub Saharan Africa, South America etc, still have families with 6 or 7 kids,.
Hence loads come here in boats, but English (and Swedish, Danes, Poles etc ) don`t want them, as , `They are taking our jobs` etc. But, those European people don`t want jobs like cleaning toilets, sweeping streets etc.
Honestly don`t know the answer.

Fully Automated Luxury Communism.  In 100 years nobody will work more than a day a week.  Farming techniques will adapt to overcome mother nature however mother nature will curb fertility rates as she has been doing for some time now.  End Stage Capitalism will have defeated itself and sitcoms will be made up of characters like Musk, roaming the dessert, eating and burning money to survive - mocked by the "new rich" who are fed, cool and with lots of time on their hands.  Albion will be on course for their 4th successive Champions League final having overcame an AI generated Sam Allardyce's Red Bull Venus in the semis.  This bored is still going.


RE: Just stop oil protests - backsidebaggie - 07-20-2023

(07-20-2023, 12:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:05 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:02 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: CA baggie… What do you mean by the government implementing restrictions? I think this is the detail people want to know. Actual impacts on their lives. What sort of restrictions?

I don't know, I'm happy to state I don't know enough about what's truly required.  But clearly some changes or restrictions to the way we currently live will have to be implemented as we can't continue as we are.

It may be something as simple as accepting that we can't have strawberries all year round as they grow in the summer!  Why are we importing them?  Why are we importing flowers from around the world?   We may have travel restrictions placed on us, such as air-miles per annum in order to cut air traffic.  

We will have to adapt.

I don’t think there’s a chance in hell that the public will ever accept air mile restrictions. Or the businesses it would bankrupt and the impact on jobs etc. the public already watch the rich and politicians etc fly round in private jets and that pisses people off enough (and quite rightly).

What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin

I think you're totally going against human nature. We managed as a species in medieval times, but that doesn't mean quality of life was as good as now. People want to enjoy life!

"Accept that we have to eat less red meat". I'd wager there's a huge proportion of the population that won't accept that. Its not North Korea (I know this phrase gets overused, but my point is people like to have choice).

Plus, if we get to air mile restrictions and red meat restrictions on the public, that's effectively 'carbon credits' for the population isn't it?

I agree regarding producing our own things and not flying stuff round needlessly BTW. But all these things have impacts on jobs etc. Its complex.


RE: Just stop oil protests - Loanee - 07-20-2023

(07-20-2023, 12:31 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:27 PM)Loanee Wrote: Assume those complaining don’t walk in the middle of the brummie road after a match blocking cars ?  Lots appear to do this…

I bet they're the very same people that get all aggy with car drivers beeping at them to walk on the pavement or behind the cones.

The culture know is "all about me".

Of course they are, as mentioned by someone else earlier they’ll also be the ones advocating disruptive protest against Lai.


RE: Just stop oil protests - Protheroe - 07-20-2023

(07-20-2023, 12:02 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: New BEVs are better than new ICEs for carbon emissions, but driving an old car for as long as possible and buying used are also better than buying new ICEs. There's still a point where the manufactured emissions of a BEV go below the operational emissions of an ICE though.

As for the "eco-friendly" solutions, that's walking, cycling and electrified public transport.

As the owner of 4 used (and 2 ancient) ICEs I'm glad I'm doing my bit for the planet.

I still maintain that EVs will hasten the end of cheap, convenient personal transportation. The price of late model small turbo petrol engined cars will soar post 2030.


RE: Just stop oil protests - DemonicBaggie - 07-20-2023

(07-20-2023, 12:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:05 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:02 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: CA baggie… What do you mean by the government implementing restrictions? I think this is the detail people want to know. Actual impacts on their lives. What sort of restrictions?

I don't know, I'm happy to state I don't know enough about what's truly required.  But clearly some changes or restrictions to the way we currently live will have to be implemented as we can't continue as we are.

It may be something as simple as accepting that we can't have strawberries all year round as they grow in the summer!  Why are we importing them?  Why are we importing flowers from around the world?   We may have travel restrictions placed on us, such as air-miles per annum in order to cut air traffic.  

We will have to adapt.

I don’t think there’s a chance in hell that the public will ever accept air mile restrictions. Or the businesses it would bankrupt and the impact on jobs etc. the public already watch the rich and politicians etc fly round in private jets and that pisses people off enough (and quite rightly).

What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin

Good posts, CAB. I'm probably teaching my gran to suck eggs here, but over-population isn't the root of the problem per se. There are enough resources on Earth to feed 9 billion people but enormous wastage at the production and consumption ends means that the process is unbelievably inefficient - about a third is lost. Just look how much waste a single supermarket produces. I understand why people are getting so fed up of governments like this Tory shower kicking the can down the road that they feel the need to take action.


RE: Just stop oil protests - CarlosCorbewrong - 07-20-2023

(07-20-2023, 12:42 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:02 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: New BEVs are better than new ICEs for carbon emissions, but driving an old car for as long as possible and buying used are also better than buying new ICEs. There's still a point where the manufactured emissions of a BEV go below the operational emissions of an ICE though.

As for the "eco-friendly" solutions, that's walking, cycling and electrified public transport.

As the owner of 4 used (and 2 ancient) ICEs I'm glad I'm doing my bit for the planet.

I still maintain that EVs will hasten the end of cheap, convenient personal transportation. The price of late model small turbo petrol engined cars will soar post 2030.

Hopefully they'll keep up with the exponential rise in the price of gold.


RE: Just stop oil protests - WorcsWBA - 07-20-2023

(07-20-2023, 12:38 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin

I think you're totally going against human nature. We managed as a species in medieval times, but that doesn't mean quality of life was as good as now. People want to enjoy life!

"Accept that we have to eat less red meat". I'd wager there's a huge proportion of the population that won't accept that. Its not North Korea (I know this phrase gets overused, but my point is people like to have choice).

Plus, if we get to air mile restrictions and red meat restrictions on the public, that's effectively 'carbon credits' for the population isn't it?

I agree regarding producing our own things and not flying stuff round needlessly BTW. But all these things have impacts on jobs etc. Its complex.

Attitudes like this have brought us to the cliff-edge with the climate and it's the same attitudes that will drive us over it like lemmings.


RE: Just stop oil protests - Borin' Baggie - 07-20-2023

(07-20-2023, 12:42 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:02 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: New BEVs are better than new ICEs for carbon emissions, but driving an old car for as long as possible and buying used are also better than buying new ICEs. There's still a point where the manufactured emissions of a BEV go below the operational emissions of an ICE though.

As for the "eco-friendly" solutions, that's walking, cycling and electrified public transport.

As the owner of 4 used (and 2 ancient) ICEs I'm glad I'm doing my bit for the planet.

I still maintain that EVs will hasten the end of cheap, convenient personal transportation. The price of late model small turbo petrol engined cars will soar post 2030.

Good for you, I maintain that the apex of cheap, convenient personal transportation is the bicycle and cars don't even get close.


RE: Just stop oil protests - backsidebaggie - 07-20-2023

(07-20-2023, 12:46 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:38 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin

I think you're totally going against human nature. We managed as a species in medieval times, but that doesn't mean quality of life was as good as now. People want to enjoy life!

"Accept that we have to eat less red meat". I'd wager there's a huge proportion of the population that won't accept that. Its not North Korea (I know this phrase gets overused, but my point is people like to have choice).

Plus, if we get to air mile restrictions and red meat restrictions on the public, that's effectively 'carbon credits' for the population isn't it?

I agree regarding producing our own things and not flying stuff round needlessly BTW. But all these things have impacts on jobs etc. Its complex.

Attitudes like this have brought us to the cliff-edge with the climate and it's the same attitudes that will drive us over it like lemmings.

Attitudes like people want to enjoy life? That's hardly unusual!

People like to have choice? Again, hardly unusual!

What sort of society do you want to live in, where people don't want to enjoy life or have choice?