![]() |
|
Border force - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Border force (/showthread.php?tid=27900) |
RE: Border force - Protheroe - 12-08-2022 (12-08-2022, 05:31 PM)Ossian Wrote: I'm sure some would choose Thatcher: incomprehensible to me, but it's their right. I was born at home by candlelight in one of Joe Gormley's power cuts, whilst my father was laid off from Pressed Steel Fisher. That's the 1970s in a nutshell. Any less incomprehensible now? (12-08-2022, 10:20 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(12-08-2022, 10:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: These brilliant pensions, can you tell me how good they are? Or are they just ‘gold plated’ ‘brilliant’ type pensions without detail. I’ll give you a clue I’ve got a few years of one so I know how ‘brilliant’ they work out to be in real terms. Like I said Spandau. Many people in the public sector do not know they're born in terms of pension provision. The average size of a defined contribution pot is tiny. For many private sector workers auto-enrolment is the biggest mis-selling exercise in history. RE: Border force - Shabby Russian - 12-09-2022 The situation we find ourselves in, with an increasing number of workers taking industrial action, primarily, but not exclusively, in the public sector, is due to a combination of good business practice , the prevailing economic situation and the laws of supply and demand. We have a combination of high inflation and full employment. Demand for good labour outstrips supply. To prevent losing quality employees, private sector employers are having to pay wage increases close to it exceeding the rate of inflation. Obviously this causes short term pain to business, who either take a hit on profit or increase the cost of their product/service. But it is a price good businesses will be willing to take to protect the quality of their product/service. Currently average wage increases in the private sector are running comfortably ahead of those in the public sector. The consequence will be a drift of public sector workers to the private sector. Highlighted by the number of vacancies in nursing, teaching etc. Anecdotally we hear of schools and residential care homes losing staff to retail outlets. Ultimately if we care about our public services, and in a democracy we may collectively decide we don't get care enough, we have to pay our public sector workers a competitive wage, to ensure a good quality of service. Ultimately the choice is ours. RE: Border force - baggy1 - 12-09-2022 (12-08-2022, 10:20 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(12-08-2022, 10:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: These brilliant pensions, can you tell me how good they are? Or are they just ‘gold plated’ ‘brilliant’ type pensions without detail. I’ll give you a clue I’ve got a few years of one so I know how ‘brilliant’ they work out to be in real terms. The 1st article you linked is a Daily Mail article. As a journalist do you think that it might be a little skewed to get their angle across. Now if I were a journalist and wanted to get an agenda across do you think it would be a good idea to take the best possible scenario (let’s say a Policeman’s final salary scheme) and measure it against the worst possible scenario (a pension scheme that is getting the legal minimum paid into it) and make a headline for, as you put it, “education’? I’ll give you a real life scenario - I paid 9 years into my public sector pension and will get £5k out of it, so if i dedicated my working life to the public sector of 40 years that would give me £22k. Now we can argue back and forth about how good that is in comparison but you have fallen for the Tory division trap of the race to the bottom. The belief that they want you to have is that public sector workers don’t pay into their pensions, that isn’t true. And by comparing it to the worst type of private pension they can show a stark difference. The reality is that private pension b y employers has only just been made compulsory, when that should have been done years ago, and it can be pretty poor if the employer is doing the bare minimum. Compare that with the best performing public sector pensions and you have a headline for the gullible. RE: Border force - baggy1 - 12-09-2022 (12-08-2022, 10:42 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Like I said Spandau. Many people in the public sector do not know they're born in terms of pension provision. This is either a very ignorant statement by someone who hasn't considered why it is so small, or a deliberate attempt to skew to argument and mislead with an agenda statement. Public sector pension pots are so small because all they hold is the employee portion of the contributions, the government will have to pay their portion whether or not it is held in the same pot so why tie up government money for decades when it can be used elsewhere today. You're applying private sector logic to government spending when they are different beasts. The only reason private sector employers have to pay their funds up front is in case they aren't there to make payments when the time comes. The government will still be there in onef orm or another. RE: Border force - Ossian - 12-09-2022 (12-09-2022, 09:22 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The only reason private sector employers have to pay their funds up front is in case they aren't there to make payments when the time comes. The government will still be there in onef orm or another. Also, B1, it's worth remembering that not all members of private sector defined benefit schemes ended up receiving the pensions they were anticipating and, had it not been for the establishment of the PPF (for which we have Gordon Brown to thank) some would be receiving nothing at all; often a direct consequence of malpractice by employers. RE: Border force - Birdman1811 - 12-09-2022 (12-08-2022, 10:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: These brilliant pensions, can you tell me how good they are? Or are they just ‘gold plated’ ‘brilliant’ type pensions without detail. I’ll give you a clue I’ve got a few years of one so I know how ‘brilliant’ they work out to be in real terms. The NHS one is good to be fair. I do pay over 9% of my salary for the privilege though, worth it. RE: Border force - baggy1 - 12-09-2022 (12-09-2022, 09:58 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:(12-08-2022, 10:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: These brilliant pensions, can you tell me how good they are? Or are they just ‘gold plated’ ‘brilliant’ type pensions without detail. I’ll give you a clue I’ve got a few years of one so I know how ‘brilliant’ they work out to be in real terms. And there are some good ones in there Birdy, which we should all be aiming for not comparing it to the worst private sector ones. Frontline workers should get rewarded for what they do, I have some mates who were coppers and now retired (or close to it) and they've earned the right to enjoy retiring when they are still youngish putting themselves in situations I wouldn't want to find myself in any circumstances. The whole 'Public sector workers have it so good' is just bullshit, especially when it comes along with 'they should be grateful because they get good pensions' line. RE: Border force - Derek Hardballs - 12-09-2022 Was the public sector working better twelve years ago for those that needed it? The answer is a clear yes. Who has been in power for the last twelve years? RE: Border force - Spandaubaggie - 12-09-2022 (12-09-2022, 10:07 AM)baggy1 Wrote:(12-09-2022, 09:58 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:(12-08-2022, 10:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: These brilliant pensions, can you tell me how good they are? Or are they just ‘gold plated’ ‘brilliant’ type pensions without detail. I’ll give you a clue I’ve got a few years of one so I know how ‘brilliant’ they work out to be in real terms. Well leave the public sector because it's so crap then. Get out into my world then where I had no help despite losing a load of work in covid. Where if I''m sick I earn nothing and where I had to take a £25,000 bounce back loan to keep my business afloat during covid. Somehow I doubt you will. RE: Border force - baggy1 - 12-09-2022 I am in the private sector, I've literally posted that in this thread. I worked all through covid as well, none of that namby pamby furlough scheme for me. And you also have the choice to go and work for a company that pays sick pay, you don't have to work for yourself if it is proving too difficult. And I might say that your descent into personal posts whilst debating a serious point is disappointing coming from a poster such as yourself. |