WBAUnofficial
Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Bruce set for a squad overhaul (/showthread.php?tid=24895)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Borin' Baggie - 04-13-2022

(04-13-2022, 10:41 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 09:22 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Re. Pulis 

Does anyone know why Crystal Palace played so differently from all his other teams? He was phenomenally successful there and yet it seems like a 'one-off'. As soon as he left he reverted to his usual approach. 

If it was different players - which seems unlikely, it was CP and not Chelsea after all - why did he never bring in that type of player himself? Why did none of his teams even evolve into something like that approach?

I'm not knocking him, just trying to understand his reasoning. At the moment, all I can think of is that the players just ignored him, or there was a coach that had greater influence than Pulis. There's nothing afterwards to suggest Pulis himself changed his approach to football.

Pulis had to deal with what he had at Palace...
 
He immediately signed a couple CBs, Ledley for midfield and I think Chamakh to go up top and it worked for him. When you have as much pace and direct runners as Palace had he was always going to be able to profit from it - he was also very much in shit or bust territory with them where a draw was often not enough.

We played some decent stuff for 3 months under Pulis when we were solid in defence and broke with purpose, I think we had 5 or 6 wins on the spin at home doing it, only for us to revert to type when it went wrong.

The fact that in January 2017 we signed Livermore instead of going for a Morrison (a key player in our wins that season but also having injury problems) replacement really shows that Pulis should not be trusted to bring in his men to shape a squad.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - WorcsWBA - 04-13-2022

(04-13-2022, 09:22 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Re. Pulis 

Does anyone know why Crystal Palace played so differently from all his other teams? He was phenomenally successful there and yet it seems like a 'one-off'. As soon as he left he reverted to his usual approach.

Weren't they already quite badly adrift when he took over and nothing other than wins would do?


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-13-2022

(04-13-2022, 09:57 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 09:42 AM)SophLad Wrote: It suited Anthony Pulis to have a high turnover in his own job due to his financial position.  Part of that model means turning the fans against him.  Regardless of what results immediately preceded the current one - if a Pulis side lost, played awful football etc then the fans were on his back and boards got twitchy. 

Allegedly.

Didn`t Pulis keep Palace up, playing decent stuff, then, request they paid his bonus a month early, then announce he was resigning as some players turned against him ? A few months later, we appoint him. I know the Premier League ruled that he should pay some of the money back but he refused and went to court, which told him to pay all of it back. When he didn`t, Palace issued an order for bailiffs to seize his house / car etc.
About 4 clubs have taken Pulis to court over money.

There was a right old line-up of witnesses telling contrasting tales of the order of events, who said and did what when. The court decided that his witnesses weren't credible and that he had acted dishonestly in obtaining his bonus early then fabricating a reason to resign. 

I've always wondered whether Pulis had an arrangement where he got a percentage of fees when players were sold on. I know this used to be commonplace, but would be surprised if Jezza fell for it. Anyways, it was Pulis who started the speculation about Jonny Evans being worth £30m. "Jonny Evans is my best player. Of course he isn't for sale. But every player has his price". A slice of £30m would have been excellent timing for old Tony, with his Palace troubles. Possibly.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - SW4Baggie - 04-13-2022

(04-13-2022, 11:12 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 10:41 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 09:22 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Re. Pulis 

Does anyone know why Crystal Palace played so differently from all his other teams? He was phenomenally successful there and yet it seems like a 'one-off'. As soon as he left he reverted to his usual approach. 

If it was different players - which seems unlikely, it was CP and not Chelsea after all - why did he never bring in that type of player himself? Why did none of his teams even evolve into something like that approach?

I'm not knocking him, just trying to understand his reasoning. At the moment, all I can think of is that the players just ignored him, or there was a coach that had greater influence than Pulis. There's nothing afterwards to suggest Pulis himself changed his approach to football.

Pulis had to deal with what he had at Palace...
 
He immediately signed a couple CBs, Ledley for midfield and I think Chamakh to go up top and it worked for him. When you have as much pace and direct runners as Palace had he was always going to be able to profit from it - he was also very much in shit or bust territory with them where a draw was often not enough.

We played some decent stuff for 3 months under Pulis when we were solid in defence and broke with purpose, I think we had 5 or 6 wins on the spin at home doing it, only for us to revert to type when it went wrong.

The fact that in January 2017 we signed Livermore instead of going for a Morrison (a key player in our wins that season but also having injury problems) replacement really shows that Pulis should not be trusted to bring in his men to shape a squad.

For me it was “we need to replace Fletcher with someone younger” and then paying a £1m for Gareth Barry!


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-13-2022

(04-13-2022, 01:24 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 11:12 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 10:41 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 09:22 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Re. Pulis 

Does anyone know why Crystal Palace played so differently from all his other teams? He was phenomenally successful there and yet it seems like a 'one-off'. As soon as he left he reverted to his usual approach. 

If it was different players - which seems unlikely, it was CP and not Chelsea after all - why did he never bring in that type of player himself? Why did none of his teams even evolve into something like that approach?

I'm not knocking him, just trying to understand his reasoning. At the moment, all I can think of is that the players just ignored him, or there was a coach that had greater influence than Pulis. There's nothing afterwards to suggest Pulis himself changed his approach to football.

Pulis had to deal with what he had at Palace...
 
He immediately signed a couple CBs, Ledley for midfield and I think Chamakh to go up top and it worked for him. When you have as much pace and direct runners as Palace had he was always going to be able to profit from it - he was also very much in shit or bust territory with them where a draw was often not enough.

We played some decent stuff for 3 months under Pulis when we were solid in defence and broke with purpose, I think we had 5 or 6 wins on the spin at home doing it, only for us to revert to type when it went wrong.

The fact that in January 2017 we signed Livermore instead of going for a Morrison (a key player in our wins that season but also having injury problems) replacement really shows that Pulis should not be trusted to bring in his men to shape a squad.

For me it was “we need to replace Fletcher with someone younger” and then paying a £1m for Gareth Barry!

I said at the time that Barry was the cheapest and laziest signing imaginable. It showed how little Pulis cared about the future of the club, 'cos he knew he wouldn't be there. I'll cut no slack for Barry, fine player though he used to be, he was a total disaster for us. A player of more integrity and better fitness could have made all the difference that season.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - MancBaggie - 04-13-2022

(04-13-2022, 11:16 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 09:22 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Re. Pulis 

Does anyone know why Crystal Palace played so differently from all his other teams? He was phenomenally successful there and yet it seems like a 'one-off'. As soon as he left he reverted to his usual approach.

Weren't they already quite badly adrift when he took over and nothing other than wins would do?

Spot on

They were fugged. He stuck Gayle in and actually played Chamakh as a 10


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Tom Joad - 04-13-2022

The Palace v Pulis court case was one of the few ITK things I've been party to. I had a mate and supplier that was also a big supplier at Palace and a regular face around the hospitality areas. He told me of Pulis's shenanigans at the time and also how furious they were that he buggered off almost straight after getting the cash up front. I can only assume they took a while to gather the legal evidence as Pulis was well into his term at The Hawthorns by the time of the court case, which he apparently had no chance of winning. Whichever solicitor told him he had a good case to defend was laughing all the way to the bank. In hindsight, it showed how desperate we were at the time because a younger Jeremy Peace would not have touched Pulis with a bargepole.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Squid - 04-13-2022

(04-13-2022, 08:25 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: The Palace v Pulis court case was one of the few ITK things I've been party to. I had a mate and supplier that was also a big supplier at Palace and a regular face around the hospitality areas. He told me of Pulis's shenanigans at the time and also how furious they were that he buggered off almost straight after getting the cash up front. I can only assume they took a while to gather the legal evidence as Pulis was well into his term at The Hawthorns by the time of the court case, which he apparently had no chance of winning. Whichever solicitor told him he had a good case to defend was laughing all the way to the bank. In hindsight, it showed how desperate we were at the time because a younger Jeremy Peace would not have touched Pulis with a bargepole.

In fairness, he did the job he was employed to do and any club with functioning management would have said goodbye at the end of the 2016–17 season and had a plan in place for his replacement. Even Pulis wanted out. But no, we gave him a contract extension. The decision that lead to all our recent problems.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Spandaubaggie - 04-14-2022

(04-13-2022, 09:17 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 08:25 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: The Palace v Pulis court case was one of the few ITK things I've been party to. I had a mate and supplier that was also a big supplier at Palace and a regular face around the hospitality areas. He told me of Pulis's shenanigans at the time and also how furious they were that he buggered off almost straight after getting the cash up front. I can only assume they took a while to gather the legal evidence as Pulis was well into his term at The Hawthorns by the time of the court case, which he apparently had no chance of winning. Whichever solicitor told him he had a good case to defend was laughing all the way to the bank. In hindsight, it showed how desperate we were at the time because a younger Jeremy Peace would not have touched Pulis with a bargepole.

In fairness, he did the job he was employed to do and any club with functioning management would have said goodbye at the end of the 2016–17 season and had a plan in place for his replacement. Even Pulis wanted out. But no, we gave him a contract extension. The decision that lead to all our recent problems.
Bang on.

It seemed Peace just wanted to keep him there to protect his asset, without thinking further ahead.

Peace's exit and the cluelessness of the Chinese regime has got us here.

We've been short-sighted throughout the past few years with the first team squad that hold the rest of the club in place, such as reserves, youth etc.

That's why I find the condemnation of Bruce not turning around a club in crisis in 12 games so bonkers.

Our budget is very competitive in the championship. Lest we forget we got Prem parachutes whilst many in the Championship really struggled during covid.

Allowing an experienced manager a proper pre-season and chance to re-arrange the squad best he can, bearing in mind some of the stupid contracts handed out, is the least we can do now.

If Bruce fails to make us a better side come November or so then maybe there may be something better as a plan, but for now we've got to let him use his knowledge of 20 years of being at many clubs like us and hopefully start the rebuild.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Huggybear - 04-14-2022

(04-14-2022, 03:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 09:17 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-13-2022, 08:25 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: The Palace v Pulis court case was one of the few ITK things I've been party to. I had a mate and supplier that was also a big supplier at Palace and a regular face around the hospitality areas. He told me of Pulis's shenanigans at the time and also how furious they were that he buggered off almost straight after getting the cash up front. I can only assume they took a while to gather the legal evidence as Pulis was well into his term at The Hawthorns by the time of the court case, which he apparently had no chance of winning. Whichever solicitor told him he had a good case to defend was laughing all the way to the bank. In hindsight, it showed how desperate we were at the time because a younger Jeremy Peace would not have touched Pulis with a bargepole.

In fairness, he did the job he was employed to do and any club with functioning management would have said goodbye at the end of the 2016–17 season and had a plan in place for his replacement. Even Pulis wanted out. But no, we gave him a contract extension. The decision that lead to all our recent problems.
Bang on.

It seemed Peace just wanted to keep him there to protect his asset, without thinking further ahead.

Peace's exit and the cluelessness of the Chinese regime has got us here.

We've been short-sighted throughout the past few years with the first team squad that hold the rest of the club in place, such as reserves, youth etc.

That's why I find the condemnation of Bruce not turning around a club in crisis in 12 games so bonkers.

Our budget is very competitive in the championship. Lest we forget we got Prem parachutes whilst many in the Championship really struggled during covid.

Allowing an experienced manager a proper pre-season and chance to re-arrange the squad best he can, bearing in mind some of the stupid contracts handed out, is the least we can do now.

If Bruce fails to make us a better side come November or so then maybe there may be something better as a plan, but for now we've got to let him use his knowledge of 20 years of being at many clubs like us and hopefully start the rebuild.
Pulis for all his faults was a far better coach and organiser than Bruce will ever be.Pulis did have a time limit and the more talented players he bought in actually became one of his downfalls.What I don’t understand is that you keep saying you would give Bruce until November,that really is suicidal.We have swapped managers something like four times in six half way through a season and that’s one of the reasons of the huge problems we have.By the way we were not a club in crisis,we were a club in the top six and many a manager would of been beating down the door to get a job like that.