WBAUnofficial
Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Fair Play to Callum Robinson (/showthread.php?tid=21847)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Birdman1811 - 10-06-2021

It's probably going to be a shock when I say this.

I understand any footballer, or elite athlete of any sport, not having the vaccine.

There are possible side effects, for most they are very minor and short lived, however some aren't, and due to the strain on the bodies professional football has, adding something else could be far more dangerous than we realise, especially when there are possible side effects of heart issues and blood clots. Elite Athletes are very fit, obviously, however tiny issues with the heart are magnified significantly.

I don't actually blame any footballer deciding its not worth the risk right now.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - backsidebaggie - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 02:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:37 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:24 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: There’s not conclusive evidence that you’re more protected by the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

There’s not evidence that you’re less likely to transmit after having had the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

It’s not the same as an unvaccinated person whos never had Covid, if you've had it twice then in theory you should be protected in the instance that you're unlucky enough to get it a third time and the chances of transmission will be lower.

Honestly the main story here is that Robinson has been racially abused, almost certainly as a result of his statement today, but it’s hardly been mentioned.

However there is conclusive proof logically that if you have had covid and are vaccinated then you will definitely be less likely to transmit the virus. Belt and braces as my old man used to say - very true in this situation. This shouldn't be an either / or discussion.

almost definitely*

But again, only as much proof as for having a 3rd and then 4th jab in quick succession, so why are we settling for only two jabs in a short space of time?

The answer is because they've decided that the costs which include the running these trials, and includes assessing the risks of having multiple jabs in a short space of time, isn't worth it.

Write to your Mp's, why settle only for 2 jabs if you're under 50 or 3 if you're over 50? If enough people do it then maybe collectively we can have more doses in a short space of time to reduce transmission further.

Robinson has decided that he doesn't want the vaccine as he's already had COVID and is less likely to transmit it. The backlash against him is real pitchfork stuff unfortunately. You should see the things people are writing on twitter.

Correct Slice. Pitchfork indeed. And this is being encouraged by the media, social media, the government, by labelling people and putting them into two categories. It’s not that simple. Then you have the “virtuous” like DH doing exactly that, increasing the division in society, sewing further seeds of division,  while claiming he’s caring about others. It’s gross.

I’m just thankful that people I come across in life, my friends and family aren’t like that. I’ve not heard any judgment from any of them on either having the vaccine or not. They have it for them, or don’t have it.

Hang on a minute before you drag me into every post on this subject. Let's get this clear I am defending the most vulnerable people's right to live as normal a life as possible. People I might add who would dearly love / give anything for the vaccine to keep them as safe as they can be from getting seriously ill or dying, but for a number of reasons can't have it. They and their families lives have shrank to what others endured for a few months under lockdown, even more so now there are little or no restrictions. Currently there is still no light at the end of the tunnel for them whilst the rest of the population now goes about its normal life to a lesser or greater extent. 

You are making out that people who choose to not have the vaccine are victims but hardly ever mention those whose lives are made more difficult by their decisions, just a throwaway line or two about having to shield / be careful. Cast your mind back to when there was no vaccine for elderly relatives and when people in the 50's, 60, 70's were dying from Covid at a much greater rate, those left behind through no choice of their own by the vaccine roll out are still at that point. They haven't had an opportunity to move on since the pandemic has started. What would make their live easier is for those that can have the jab to have it. If me questioning the choice of those who refuse to have the vaccine and coming to the conclusion I completely disagree with them is wrong and stating as such is gross then so be it. I haven't taken their rights away from making that choice but some have no choice it's worth remembering in all of this. For someone who is all about defending people's rights, it does seem you wish to put the rights of some as greater than others. We all have a responsibility for each other, society falls apart if we do not uphold both rights and responsibilities.

The point is not that you think people should get the vaccine. The point is that you call them selfish, refuse to understand they have reasons even if you disagree with said reasons, and you join in with the generalisation of labelling them anti vax. It’s not about whether you or I believe anyone should have it. It’s recognising that people have valid reasons, and it does not automatically mean they are 5G conspiracy theorists or the like. That’s the divisive bit. You’re not the only one, and as many have said, social media is riddled with it. My point is that splitting into two distinct groups is wrong, childish, lacking in nuance, and extremely divisive.

Society will not fall apart if Callum Robinson, or 10% of people in general don’t want a vaccine. It is not everyone’s responsibility to get it, whether you like it or not. I could say you’re putting the right of the vulnerable above an individuals right not to have the vaccine. That’s the same argument but reversed. You’re putting their rights above others. And round and round we go. 

The fact is, it is not Callum Robinsons responsibility to get the vaccine. It’s a choice for him and it’s none of anyone’s business.

I don’t believe there’s a right or wrong. Get it it don’t get it. That’s fine. But lumping people into two categories, ignoring nuance, is divisive and deliberate in some cases, and many people get swept along by it.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - AmsterdamBaggie - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 02:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's probably going to be a shock when I say this.

I understand any footballer, or elite athlete of any sport, not having the vaccine.

There are possible side effects, for most they are very minor and short lived, however some aren't, and due to the strain on the bodies professional football has, adding something else could be far more dangerous than we realise, especially when there are possible side effects of heart issues and blood clots. Elite Athletes are very fit, obviously, however tiny issues with the heart are magnified significantly.

I don't actually blame any footballer deciding its not worth the risk right now.

Aren't the unknown long term effects on the body more worrying to a professional athlete, than that of a vaccine? It is a respiratory disease, and studies show heart scarring in those that have contracted the virus. Robinson aside, who obviously has a form of immunity, I can't imagine risking my career over something so easily preventable.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Birdman1811 - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 03:06 PM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 02:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's probably going to be a shock when I say this.

I understand any footballer, or elite athlete of any sport, not having the vaccine.

There are possible side effects, for most they are very minor and short lived, however some aren't, and due to the strain on the bodies professional football has, adding something else could be far more dangerous than we realise, especially when there are possible side effects of heart issues and blood clots. Elite Athletes are very fit, obviously, however tiny issues with the heart are magnified significantly.

I don't actually blame any footballer deciding its not worth the risk right now.

Aren't the unknown long term effects on the body more worrying to a professional athlete, than that of a vaccine? It is a respiratory disease, and studies show heart scarring in those that have contracted the virus. Robinson aside, who obviously has a form of immunity, I can't imagine risking my career over something so easily preventable.

Personally I'd take the vaccine, but can understand why some won't too, that's all.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - backsidebaggie - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 03:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 03:06 PM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 02:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's probably going to be a shock when I say this.

I understand any footballer, or elite athlete of any sport, not having the vaccine.

There are possible side effects, for most they are very minor and short lived, however some aren't, and due to the strain on the bodies professional football has, adding something else could be far more dangerous than we realise, especially when there are possible side effects of heart issues and blood clots. Elite Athletes are very fit, obviously, however tiny issues with the heart are magnified significantly.

I don't actually blame any footballer deciding its not worth the risk right now.

Aren't the unknown long term effects on the body more worrying to a professional athlete, than that of a vaccine? It is a respiratory disease, and studies show heart scarring in those that have contracted the virus. Robinson aside, who obviously has a form of immunity, I can't imagine risking my career over something so easily preventable.

Personally I'd take the vaccine, but can understamd why some won't too, that's all.

And that, is a completely sensible stance. Just understanding others have different reasons. If only many others had the same open mindedness as you Birdie.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - baggiebuckster - 10-06-2021

Robinson will get some grief over this but there is no way he is on his own in the football world. I find it pretty obvious that there have to be plenty of unvaccinated players. The Government are trying to get teenage boys to be jabbed and I would argue that some of the biggest influencers to this demographic are pro footballers. And yet I am yet to see one player involved in any form of promotion of the jab unless I missed it.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Peachy - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 03:25 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 03:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 03:06 PM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 02:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's probably going to be a shock when I say this.

I understand any footballer, or elite athlete of any sport, not having the vaccine.

There are possible side effects, for most they are very minor and short lived, however some aren't, and due to the strain on the bodies professional football has, adding something else could be far more dangerous than we realise, especially when there are possible side effects of heart issues and blood clots. Elite Athletes are very fit, obviously, however tiny issues with the heart are magnified significantly.

I don't actually blame any footballer deciding its not worth the risk right now.

Aren't the unknown long term effects on the body more worrying to a professional athlete, than that of a vaccine? It is a respiratory disease, and studies show heart scarring in those that have contracted the virus. Robinson aside, who obviously has a form of immunity, I can't imagine risking my career over something so easily preventable.

Personally I'd take the vaccine, but can understamd why some won't too, that's all.

And that, is a completely sensible stance. Just understanding others have different reasons. If only many others had the same open mindedness as you Birdie.

I feel the same. I've been double jabbed and then caught Covid a few months later and was very grateful i'd been jabbed as it wasn't pleasant even with the jab.

If people choose not to then thats up to them. It really is no skin off my nose. 

The one thing I would say on Robbo is that if you are going to be brave enough to stick your neck above the parapet and say you haven't had the jab then make sure you back that up with the reasons why you have chosen to take that stance. If not then i would have stayed quiet. 

It seems strange to me that you'd put yourself out there, knowing how the social media/TV would jump on it, with the fairly glib statement he did.

I can't stand Klopp but i thought his statement yesterday was great. He said he'd had the jab and had sought advice from his doctors about the effects before making his decision. They reassured him it was safe so he had it done and he urged his players to seek medical advise and then they can make up their own mind.

If Robbo had come out today and gave a reasoned rationale behind his decision the flak would have been nowhere near as bad. Which brings me back to my original point. If you are going to be one of the first footballers to put yourself out there then fucking back it up. Don't just say I'm not having it and leave it at that. He opened himself up to criticism imo and was nieve to think he was going to get anything other than some serious shoe.

I just don't see what he's gained by saying what he has said today?


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - boingingjim - 10-06-2021

Robbo is half the age of Klopp, there is a complete world of difference with COVID based on how old you are.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Spandaubaggie - 10-06-2021

I find it really weird that some are defending him. We’re being told for the good of everyone we should all have the jab and he’s a role model. Stuff on fertility etc is proper conspiracy theory stuff. The chance of side effects are ridiculously minuscule.
There’s no issues taking jabs for foreign exotic hols but Covid has created a different mindset.
There’s 10 percent of the population like this.
I’ll be a sheep on this occasion.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Peachy - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 04:56 PM)boingingjim Wrote: Robbo is half the age of Klopp, there is a complete world of difference with COVID based on how old you are.

Im not talking about the effects of Covid and age. You are missing my point entirely. 

I was talking about how Klopp gave his statement. He backed up what he said with a well reasoned rational. I dont care if he was for or against the vaccine. 

I was merely pointing out that if Robbo had come out with reasons as to why he doesn't want the jab, and put those points across properly, then the more sensible people would have had something to think on. 

Instead he came out with a "I'm not taking it" and nothing else. My point being is he was opening himself up to criticism when in reality he had nothing to really say.

Like my nan used to say "If you have nothing to say then don't say anything at all"!