![]() |
|
Thoughts - Ratings - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Thoughts - Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=9287) |
Thoughts - Ratings - SW4Baggie - 03-03-2020 Actually enjoyed the game more than I should a defeat... the positives were that other than the mistakes we equipped ourselves well and could have scored more goals than we did, and there were several bright performances from squad players that’ll give Bilic food for thought. Disappointingly, I think with more considered rotation we could have won both tonight and Saturday, but that’s easily said after the games are done. We gave a fairly decent account of ourselves against a midtable PL side playing their strongest side and coming off the back of a mid season break whereas we’ve had fixtures come thick and fast. It’s a shame to go out in the manner we have, but looking at the last 8, there wasn’t much chance of progression from here, and we have bigger concerns. Bond - 4 - no sane person can possibly call for him to play over SJ. If Sam had stalled on his line like Bond twice, or spilled and parried like he did he’d have been lynched. Gibbs - 6 - a quality player who looked head and shoulders above Rose. Great to have him back. O’Shea - 3 - not a PL CB yet... Joelinton had the beating of him all night. Tough lesson. Bartley - 6 - Standard Bartley, defends well for most of the game but has a ruck in him Furlong - 4 - can see why he doesn’t play with another attacking fullback. Leaves defence too exposed. Brunt - really don’t want to give him the score he deserves. Painful watching him struggle like that. Sad this needs to be his final game. Barry - 2 - one injury too many - absolutely shot. Only a couple wonderful passes stopped it being zero. Harper - 7.5 MOTM - impressive. He’s now displaced CB and GB. Some classy play, always found space. Phillips - 6.5 - started and finished the game well, went missing in the middle. Think his goal will give him a lift Austin - 3 - started well but looked knackered after 15 mins. His all round play was very, very poor. Edwards - 7 - bright and tricky. Very direct and caused problems. Probably his best starting performance. Final ball still needs work. Krov - 7 - completely changed the game and could have been MOTM. His intensity and quality stood out. He’s a PL player and proving me very wrong. Zohore - 6 - a better bet than Austin. Did more in first 5 mins than Charlie all game. Also special mention for the ball bouncing off his head and him having no idea where it landed. Tulloch - no time RE: Thoughts - Ratings - Cunninghamismagic - 03-03-2020 I didn't think Harper was that good (although a tough gig next to the ageing Barry and Brunt). Edwards a strange one. Started brightly. Then looked lost for a big chunk of the game. Then Krov came on and he looked good. Krov MOTM by far. RE: Thoughts - Ratings - Lurker#3 - 03-03-2020 It reads basically word for word what I would have put Sw4. Except for Brunty, thought he did okay once Barry went off and had Harper and Krov doing his running. Thought Harper was superb. His natural appreciation of the ball and composure really stands out. RE: Thoughts - Ratings - TETLEY74 - 03-03-2020 (03-03-2020, 10:03 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: I didn't think Harper was that good (although a tough gig next to the ageing Barry and Brunt). Krov now starting to look like the player we thought we had. Probaly as important to us as Peirera at the moment. RE: Thoughts - Ratings - Shabby Russian - 03-03-2020 Thought Harper was the proverbial curate's egg. Some really nice touches. Think if he is going to be more than just a decent championship player, he needs to be playing the role that Krovonovic is currently playing. I like Edwards but not sure he will ever be more than a good Championship player. I like his positivity and overall he had a decent game, just wasn't involved enough for the first hour. RE: Thoughts - Ratings - Cuzer - 03-03-2020 I saw it a little differently Bond 3 Barely put a foot...or glove wrong in an Albion shirt so far but struggled tonight, sloppy handling, looked short of confidence and at fault for 3rd goal Furlong 7 Thought he played well,defended well in the air, quick across the ground, really feel he should be getting the nod at RB Bartley 6 Thought he did OK, led by example at times and stuck close to Joelinton in the first half OnShea 4 In his favored position he looked out of his depth to me, seemed fazed, and dare I say bullied in the first half by their front two, as per Furlong comments I’m unsure why he’s currently getting the nod Gibbs 5 Much better 2nd half, 90 will do him good, looked rusty as an old gate in the first half Barry 3 Old Father Time has caught up with him I’m afraid, a yard too slow all over the park Brunt 3 See Barry, a shame to see but likely his last game in an Albion shirt Harper 7* Tired towards the end. And a couple of sloppy passes but don’t overlook his other work, some great control, better tempo than before and rove is forward at times Edwards 6 Excellent 2nd half and great play for Kens goal,too tepid first half, must back his ability more Phillips 7 Thought he did well tonight, always a threat, popping up in the box and running in behind Austin 5 Can’t fruit his effort and at times his movement was good tonight but hopeless as a lone striker, which unfortunately for him is how we set up Subs Krovinovic 7 Turned the game, good to see him back to his recent best Zahore 6 Showed why I’ve championed him getting the nod on the bench over Austin, just brings a different dynamic to our play Tulloch Too little time Cuzer RE: Thoughts - Ratings - Sliced - 03-03-2020 Pretty much agree with all that. For his no rating I thought Tulloch was lively RE: Thoughts - Ratings - Tom Joad - 03-03-2020 Phillips MOTM for me. Always a threat and didn't deserve to be on the losing side. I think Brunt or Barry can still play a bit part this season, but certainly not together. Bloody Hell, that alone cost us the tie. I still think Edwards gets a raw deal on here. Still way too early to judge him and he can be a proper handful to defend against. RE: Thoughts - Ratings - devonstroller - 03-03-2020 I thought Furlong did well RE: Thoughts - Ratings - MassDebater - 03-03-2020 A Newcastle fan at the tram stop said we could've had 5 on the second half, which probably explains why I don't feel like I did on Saturday. I think Brunt and Barry together showed their ages, could see what they wanted to do, their legs just couldn't do it. Overall I'm reasonably happy with it. |