WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=8729)

Pages: 1 2


Ratings - Cuzer - 02-01-2020

Comfortable win, if at times a little edgy given our lack of confidence and form
Can’t help thinking if we had Fulham at home with Pereira and Diangana in full flow we would out 5 past them, they really are wide open at the back and look destined for the drop

SJ 6 Not sure if it’s his body language or my perception of him but looks flat, non vocal and a bit like a dead man walking, seems to bicker with his defense all the time, lucky to keep his place but can’t help thinking you need him to be way more assertive between now and May

O Shea 6 Another surprise pick from Slav, not quite sure how Furlong has become the fall guy, he didn OK against a pacywinger but looks like what he is, a centre half at full back, one great block from CMac at 1-0 

Townsend 7 Solid game, didn’t get forward much although more when the game was done at 2-0, stuck close to his wide man who also had good pace...and a shit Jack Grealish cycle helmet haircut

Semi 7 One poor header in the first half put us in trouble but all in all was solid against a Luton team carrying little threat

Bartley 6 Still seemed horizontal at times, couple of high balls he let bounce which was unnecessary, lucky to get the nod over Hegazi for me

Sawyers 6 Steady enough, some better distribution but still slowing things down somewhat when we need to be slicker

Livermore 7 Full of running and energy, worked tirelessly as he does, no complaints

Krovinovic 7 Did well, in good form currently which is a shame as he’ll likely be hooked for Pereira next week, found space and showed good close control on numerous occasions 

Phillips 7 Great ball for 2nd goal, world class cross, was a threat all afternoon

Robinson 8* Lively from the off, as he did at PNE for a wide player he always seems to be in the box when crosses come in, something our wide players currently don’t do enough of, must have had 5 or 6 attempts on goal today which was great to see and will be a real asset in the run in

Austin 5 Worked hard first half, couple of half chances blocked and likely to tap home Robinson’s great cross before Daniels did the work for him, anonymous second half before being hooked. Question marks still remain 

Subs

HRK 7 Lively when came on, caused them problems with his hold up play and movement

Furlong 7 Defensive substitution for Phillips but still got forward we’ll and put some dangerous balls into the box, as said above find it hard he’s the fall guy for some recent defensive calamities 

Harper 6 Good to see him back involved after some better performances in the 23’s

Cuzer


RE: Ratings - TETLEY74 - 02-01-2020

Agree with most of that but would mark Townsend & Krov 8 as I thought both were very good today, agree O'shea is not a full back would like to see him in the centre as he won most of his aerial duels and isn't scared of a challenge or two, not sure what Furlong has done wrong or best RB bar none could even play wide right based on today.


RE: Ratings - igorbalis - 02-01-2020

(02-01-2020, 06:59 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Comfortable win, if at times a little edgy given our lack of confidence and form
Can’t help thinking if we had Fulham at home with Pereira and Diangana in full flow we would out 5 past them, they really are wide open at the back and look destined for the drop

SJ 6 Not sure if it’s his body language or my perception of him but looks flat, non vocal and a bit like a dead man walking, seems to bicker with his defense all the time, lucky to keep his place but can’t help thinking you need him to be way more assertive between now and May

O Shea 6 Another surprise pick from Slav, not quite sure how Furlong has become the fall guy, he didn OK against a pacywinger but looks like what he is, a centre half at full back, one great block from CMac at 1-0 

Townsend 7 Solid game, didn’t get forward much although more when the game was done at 2-0, stuck close to his wide man who also had good pace...and a shit Jack Grealish cycle helmet haircut

Semi 7 One poor header in the first half put us in trouble but all in all was solid against a Luton team carrying little threat

Bartley 6 Still seemed horizontal at times, couple of high balls he let bounce which was unnecessary, lucky to get the nod over Hegazi for me

Sawyers 6 Steady enough, some better distribution but still slowing things down somewhat when we need to be slicker

Livermore 7 Full of running and energy, worked tirelessly as he does, no complaints

Krovinovic 7 Did well, in good form currently which is a shame as he’ll likely be hooked for Pereira next week, found space and showed good close control on numerous occasions 

Phillips 7 Great ball for 2nd goal, world class cross, was a threat all afternoon

Robinson 8* Lively from the off, as he did at PNE for a wide player he always seems to be in the box when crosses come in, something our wide players currently don’t do enough of, must have had 5 or 6 attempts on goal today which was great to see and will be a real asset in the run in

Austin 5 Worked hard first half, couple of half chances blocked and likely to tap home Robinson’s great cross before Daniels did the work for him, anonymous second half before being hooked. Question marks still remain 

Subs

HRK 7 Lively when came on, caused them problems with his hold up play and movement

Furlong 7 Defensive substitution for Phillips but still got forward we’ll and put some dangerous balls into the box, as said above find it hard he’s the fall guy for some recent defensive calamities 

Harper 6 Good to see him back involved after some better performances in the 23’s

Cuzer

fair enough but for me phillips always flatters to deceive, only thing of note was the cross for our second - think Robinson did so much more great debut and unlucky not to score.

HRK did what it says on the tin - but offers so  much more than Austin.

Apart from  a couple of lapses defended well - Oshea did well and thought we never looked in any real danger 

thought for them Lua Lua looked the only threat and he got hooked for 'how many m in Mcmanaman - Jones is a Genius - going down m'lord.

Boing Boing


RE: Ratings - HeathAyIt - 02-01-2020

Livermore and Krov worthy of a bit more.

Dont agree with the emerging consensus 3 or 4 games in that OShea cant be a right back. Make that judgement a little later down the line.


RE: Ratings - TETLEY74 - 02-01-2020

(02-01-2020, 07:15 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Livermore and Krov worthy of a bit more.

Dont agree with the emerging consensus 3 or 4 games in that OShea cant be a right back. Make that judgement a little later down the line.

But is he any better than Furlong in that position that's the question?


RE: Ratings - Biglad - 02-01-2020

O’Shea is young and learning his trade still, will do him no harm playing right back . Dawson was made to play right back for years before moving to his actual position.


RE: Ratings - fbaggy - 02-01-2020

Pretty much agree with Cuzer's marks, you can always argue a point up or down depending on how you see the game.

Was it me but have we ditched the zonal shit at corners? didn't seem quite so rigid and more about picking up runners?


RE: Ratings - Atomic - 02-01-2020

(02-01-2020, 07:18 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(02-01-2020, 07:15 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Livermore and Krov worthy of a bit more.

Dont agree with the emerging consensus 3 or 4 games in that OShea cant be a right back. Make that judgement a little later down the line.

But is he any better than Furlong in that position that's the question?

He's different. He's bigger, more solid and add's height to a defence that doesn't deal well with balls into the box. 

Personally, I thought he did really well today against an athletic and tricky Lua Lua.


RE: Ratings - Mancbaggies - 02-01-2020

Not bad marks Cuz. Poor edgy first half. Much better 2nd after Hal stretched the game. Luton were dire - but we got the job done. Marks

SJ 5.5 dreadful kicking and more poor communication first half when he didn’t even sweep up routine through balls. Better 2nd

O’Shea 7 slow start but aggressive and athletic. Luton’s best players down his side

Townsend 6.5. All effort and steady enough. Lack of pace an issue as got done by the diagonal a lot

Semi 7 way too casual first hour and skinned for penalty shout. Huge goal

Bartley 6.5 first rule of being a CH is not letting the ball bounce. Too casual at times and incredibly was trying to slow the game at 1-0 when we clearly needed a 2nd. 

Livermore 7 good effort and no nonsense. Keeps going when the team doesn’t

Sawyers 6.5 visibly more effort and moved ball better. One stupid moment 2 half

Krov 7 good first 45 and busy and energetic. Really needs to improve end product. Loads of bad decisions 2 half

Phillips 7 often flatters to deceive but aggressive today despite double marking. Poor corner but 2 great crosses

CR 7.5. Easily our pick first half. Good movement and energy. Got his shots off but faded last 15

Austin 5.5. So easy to nullify. Phillips should have put him in but just ineffective 

Hal 7.5. Changed the game. Simple linkplay and movement. Put himself about and made pitch bigger

Furlong 7. Did really well. Quick and gave us an out. Sensibly kept ball in Luton half last 10 - best way to defend a lead


RE: Ratings - TETLEY74 - 02-01-2020

(02-01-2020, 07:57 PM)Atomic Wrote:
(02-01-2020, 07:18 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(02-01-2020, 07:15 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Livermore and Krov worthy of a bit more.

Dont agree with the emerging consensus 3 or 4 games in that OShea cant be a right back. Make that judgement a little later down the line.

But is he any better than Furlong in that position that's the question?

He's different. He's bigger, more solid and add's height to a defence that doesn't deal well with balls into the box. 

Personally, I thought he did really well today against an athletic and tricky Lua Lua.

Agree he did well today not knocking the lad just personally think Furlong a better fullback, however would like to see O'shea at CB as I think he has all the makings to be another Martyn Bennett, Clement, Olson Gmac a no nonsense defender who likes a tackle and takes no prisoner's who can also play abit hence the Bennett reference., I like him.