WBAUnofficial
Contentious decisions by the Ref - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Contentious decisions by the Ref (/showthread.php?tid=7465)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


Contentious decisions by the Ref - Mr Jingles - 11-23-2019

Watched todays highlights many times & I'm still not 100% sure their penalty was correct. It seemed to me that Krov was possibly pushed & then the player fell over him...why would Krov fall over on the 18yd box facing his own goal ?

To balance things up I'm also not convinced that their player deserved a straight red...reckless yes...100% yellow but not a red.

Just my opinion like.


RE: Contentious decisions by the Ref - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-23-2019

I haven't seen it back yet, but the guy was inept.

The most farcical things was the substitutions. He told their first guy to leave at East Stand, so he walks toward the dug-out. Ref yellow cards him. He then continues to walk to the dug-out. I would have shown him a second yellow for dissent at this point.

Next comes our subs, when the nearest exit is the East Stand, yet Hegazi walks to the dug-out. Ref says nothing, no yellow card, and we end up wasting our own time.

Their final sub, ref gestures their guy to the East Stand.

If he can't even manage substitutions, what chance do we have?


RE: Contentious decisions by the Ref - sickParrot - 11-23-2019

To balance it up, I’m sure that Bartley handballed in the first half, looked a stone wall pelanty.


RE: Contentious decisions by the Ref - SW4Baggie - 11-23-2019

Thought he was poor all game... lacked consistency, and their huge ironic roar after he gave them a decision in the first half clearly affected him as he gave them everything following it.

The head injury did it for me.... giving them the goal kick that led to the penalty when it should have either been our throw in or played back to us was a disgrace.


RE: Contentious decisions by the Ref - Boutros - 11-23-2019

(11-23-2019, 07:07 PM)Mr Jingles Wrote: Watched todays highlights many times & I'm still not 100% sure their penalty was correct. It seemed to me that Krov was possibly pushed & then the player fell over him...why would Krov fall over on the 18yd box facing his own goal ?

To balance things up I'm also not convinced that their player deserved a straight red...reckless yes...100% yellow but not a red.

Just my opinion like.

Is exactly how I saw both decisions too.


RE: Contentious decisions by the Ref - wba13 - 11-23-2019

Was just about to state that SW4Baggie , challenge by penalty box we win the ball no foul given pass-it on hand right side then the ref blows for a head injury, he drops the ball for the keeper to pick up and instead of giving it back to us starts the move which ends with the penalty which is also dubious. He was clearly effected by there mocking of him in the first half because every one of our challenges after that seemed to result in a free kick for Wednesday.


RE: Contentious decisions by the Ref - garryowensneck - 11-23-2019

(11-23-2019, 07:26 PM)sickParrot Wrote: To balance it up, I’m sure that Bartley handballed in the first half, looked a stone wall pelanty.

Agree, think only the guy who crossed the ball appealed,  defo got away with that.


RE: Contentious decisions by the Ref - Cunninghamismagic - 11-23-2019

Just watched the highlights. Thought the pen we won was soft at the time. And watching highlights confirmed that. 
For their pen at the time I thought Krov fouled their guy. But the highlights show it was Krov who was fouled.
Definite red card.


RE: Contentious decisions by the Ref - Boutros - 11-23-2019

(11-23-2019, 09:01 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Just watched the highlights. Thought the pen we won was soft at the time. And watching highlights confirmed that. 
For their pen at the time I thought Krov fouled their guy. But the highlights show it was Krov who was fouled.
Definite red card.

Agreed the pen we got looked soft. However, I don’t think the reaction of their keeper helped them. As soon as it was given he was berating the defender for allowing  Pereria to run through unchallenged, at no point did he or his teammates confront the ref thinking he’d made a wrong decision


RE: Contentious decisions by the Ref - sickParrot - 11-23-2019

In the first half we were fouled on the edge of the box, then fouled again near the dugout. Both were sift/borderline yellows. Ref gave neither and after that they seemed to get away with a hell of a lot.