![]() |
|
We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' (/showthread.php?tid=5580) Pages:
1
2
|
We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - Paul Williams's Penalty - 07-26-2019 Remainers adduce the above arguments in their clamour for a 2nd referendum. I have always suspected that if the result in a second referendum was again a leave verdict that it wouldn't break the impasse because the remain diehard MPs still wouldn't vote in any way for Brexit to go ahead. Ignore the sources, these were the top of the Google search. Both Caroline Lucas https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1157329/Brexit-news-latest-Caroline-Lucas-Green-Party-no-deal-second-referendum-Boris-Johnson-live and Jo Swinson https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/9569467/arrogant-lib-dem-boss-jo-swinson-vows-to-reverse-brexit-even-if-britain-votes-for-it-a-second-time/ have said that even if a 2nd referendum was won by leave they'd still try to impede and stop the process of us leaving the EU. So, whilst remainers apparently only have to win once, even if leave wins twice it's STILL not enough. Hardly 'democratic' is it? And so when Clegg's Lib Dems were promising a referendum on the EU was that merely a sham without any intent to honour a leave result? The problem I have is that this devalues the entire electorate. It says 'We will occasionally ask you to to decide matters but we will only implement your decision if we agree'. But hardcore remainers (who are at least, if not more, zealous than the hardcore leavers) either can't see how it devalues us all or don't care as long as we remain. There are some, like Piers Morgan, who can and who would now back leave as a result. But the types who go on marches? Nope. I hope they remember this if ever there is another national referendum and they are on the winning side but some MPs want it to be re-run until their side wins. RE: We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - hudds - 07-26-2019 Fair point. It mirrors how the Leavers' zealots would react to losing another referendum (or several), as well as their oligarch backers. It's why we are at this pass and it's a nightmare. RE: We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - baggy1 - 07-26-2019 Apart from the obvious fact that a couple of MPs still voting against leaving wouldn't stop the UK leaving if the second referendum went the way of leave again then you're spot on. If a 2nd referendum came out with the same result then the vast majority of MPs would vote it through. However you post ignores the point that a 2nd referendum now would be more informed and be a clearer reflection of what the people wanted. But if the vote was to remain that wouldn't stop brexiteers pissing their pants demanding best of 3. Did you come up with any good reasons why leaving is a good idea and not going to end up as an almighty kick in the bollox. I see even Boris is predicting it will come good in 30 years time. Depressing to think that my kids will be near retirement and have had to work 30 years of shit to get to that point. RE: We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - Paul Williams's Penalty - 07-26-2019 (07-26-2019, 01:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Apart from the obvious fact that a couple of MPs still voting against leaving wouldn't stop the UK leaving if the second referendum went the way of leave again then you're spot on. If a 2nd referendum came out with the same result then the vast majority of MPs would vote it through. Spectacular missing of the point, well done. The fact is that people like Swinson and Lucas are not telling the full story when they say they want a final say and to break the impasse. Those only apply for a remain verdict. And if remain won a second referendum why SHOULD leavers accept it, when you didn't accept the 2016 one? Your game, your rules. I can also find no evidence of the Boris quote you make. I can only think that, stupidly, you are confusing Boris for the Jacob Rees-Mogg statement that is lied about by remainers. He did NOT say that we need to wait 50 years to see any benefits from Brexit. He DID say that the opportunities will be over the next 50 years, which is a very, very different statement. Even the caption of this clip lies about what he actually did say, but listen to his words. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=My4UM_zCpk0 As for having to come-up with Brexit benefits, that is a separate debate and not one I need to revisit because it is one that you lost in 2016 and one that has been rehearsed many times here and elsewhere. But you forgot to add 'tangible' to your question, which seems compulsory when remainers bleat this question out. (07-26-2019, 01:23 PM)hudds Wrote: Fair point. Whereas the remain side backers like Branson, the CBI, IMF and investment banks are all altruist remainers, I'm sure. And, no, if we had lost in 2016 I would not have wanted the verdict ignored by Parliament, nor even individual MPs. There's the difference between me and the Swinson-Lucas Axis of Stupidity RE: We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - baggy1 - 07-26-2019 Not missing the point at all - there are some that will find reason to leave or remain and always vote that way. The reality is that a 2nd leave result would break the impasse because the vast majority of the MPs and the country would accept that is what is wanted. There was so much bullshit spread by the leave campaign it means there will always be a big doubt that people knew what they were voting for. The 2nd referendum would be better informed, or are you saying that people know less now that they did at the time. That really is a strange argument you put forward. Just type Boris and 2050 into google - here to help. And if it helps there is a whole thread (at least one) on the subject where you can post of 'tangible' or otherwise benefits of leaving - knock yourself out. RE: We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - hudds - 07-26-2019 (07-26-2019, 01:53 PM)Paul Williams\s Penalty Wrote:I don't disagree with you. I'm just opining that the media baron and oligarchy have been at this for decades and would be as unreasonable and obnoxious if they were to lose or lose again. It's a horrible mess.(07-26-2019, 01:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Apart from the obvious fact that a couple of MPs still voting against leaving wouldn't stop the UK leaving if the second referendum went the way of leave again then you're spot on. If a 2nd referendum came out with the same result then the vast majority of MPs would vote it through. RE: We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - baggy1 - 07-26-2019 (07-26-2019, 01:53 PM)Paul Williams\s Penalty Wrote:(07-26-2019, 01:23 PM)hudds Wrote: Fair point. Is that the same axis of stupidity as Farage-Rees Mogg? Your original point was that some people will never change and that's a fact but you can't use that to justify no requirement for a 2nd referendum. RE: We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - GMBaggie - 07-26-2019 (07-26-2019, 01:59 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not missing the point at all - there are some that will find reason to leave or remain and always vote that way. The reality is that a 2nd leave result would break the impasse because the vast majority of the MPs and the country would accept that is what is wanted. There was so much bullshit spread by the leave campaign it means there will always be a big doubt that people knew what they were voting for. So much bullshit spread by the leave campaign. Irony at its finest. RE: We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - baggy1 - 07-26-2019 (07-26-2019, 02:16 PM)GMBaggie Wrote:(07-26-2019, 01:59 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not missing the point at all - there are some that will find reason to leave or remain and always vote that way. The reality is that a 2nd leave result would break the impasse because the vast majority of the MPs and the country would accept that is what is wanted. There was so much bullshit spread by the leave campaign it means there will always be a big doubt that people knew what they were voting for. I take it that your argument is that there was bullshit on both parts - surely then that would point to needing a 2nd referendum where everyone has had time to understand the reality of it all. RE: We need a 2nd referendum 'final say' and to 'break impasse' - GMBaggie - 07-26-2019 (07-26-2019, 02:18 PM)baggy1 Wrote:And the same should apply to a general election as there is bullshit all round then as well.(07-26-2019, 02:16 PM)GMBaggie Wrote:(07-26-2019, 01:59 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not missing the point at all - there are some that will find reason to leave or remain and always vote that way. The reality is that a 2nd leave result would break the impasse because the vast majority of the MPs and the country would accept that is what is wanted. There was so much bullshit spread by the leave campaign it means there will always be a big doubt that people knew what they were voting for. |