WBAUnofficial
EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' (/showthread.php?tid=4932)

Pages: 1 2 3


EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - dryrun - 06-07-2019

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/48555148

Undoubtedly well-intentioned, but will it address the problem?


RE: EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - Sliced - 06-07-2019

What a load of bollocks. Fantastic way of combatting racism is by putting yourself in a position where you'll have to find a BAME candidate to interview just to tick a box to say you've done it. That's not patronising at all.

It won't make any difference. In a year the rhetoric will be "well, despite the Rooney rule only 8% of BAME candidates got the job, therefore further proving the racism within the selection process of managers". It's one step away from being told who you have to employ, which the media are already trying to do.

If you're good enough, you'll get the job, simple as that. It's bollocks.


RE: EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - albion_pigeon - 06-07-2019

(06-07-2019, 03:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: What a load of bollocks. Fantastic way of combatting racism is by putting yourself in a position where you'll have to find a BAME candidate to interview just to tick a box to say you've done it. That's not patronising at all.

It won't make any difference. In a year the rhetoric will be "well, despite the Rooney rule only 8% of BAME candidates got the job, therefore further proving the racism within the selection process of managers". It's one step away from being told who you have to employ, which the media are already trying to do.

If you're good enough, you'll get the job, simple as that. It's bollocks.

Spot on sliced, it's ludicrous. 

I bet Adrian Durham is creaming in his pants.


RE: EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - karlalb10n - 06-07-2019

In the EFL there are 3 in 72, 4.2%. What percentage of bank managers are BAME I wonder? What a load of old bollocks


RE: EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - Sliced - 06-07-2019

Imagine how often Paul Ince is gonna get rejected at the interview stage of high level jobs, given that he reckons he could've been the Man U manager


RE: EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - WWHO - 06-07-2019

(06-07-2019, 03:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: What a load of bollocks. Fantastic way of combatting racism is by putting yourself in a position where you'll have to find a BAME candidate to interview just to tick a box to say you've done it. That's not patronising at all.

It won't make any difference. In a year the rhetoric will be "well, despite the Rooney rule only 8% of BAME candidates got the job, therefore further proving the racism within the selection process of managers". It's one step away from being told who you have to employ, which the media are already trying to do.

If you're good enough, you'll get the job, simple as that. It's bollocks.

Do you honestly believe that?


RE: EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - Dreamkiller - 06-07-2019

Football's such big business that you'd have to be mad not to employ the best bloke for the job, irrespective of the interviewee's colour. 

If you're racist to the point of putting your hatred of black people before the potential success of your club, then you just ain't giving the black guy the job whether you're forced to interview him or not. 

I'd also hazard a guess that there are more black men employed by football clubs already than in most other industries, so it's hardly like owners and CEOs are going to take fright at the sight of someone who's strangely dark walking around the place.

For this reason, I'm calling full-on pointless tick-box exercise.


RE: EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - Sliced - 06-07-2019

(06-07-2019, 04:03 PM)WWHO Wrote:
(06-07-2019, 03:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: What a load of bollocks. Fantastic way of combatting racism is by putting yourself in a position where you'll have to find a BAME candidate to interview just to tick a box to say you've done it. That's not patronising at all.

It won't make any difference. In a year the rhetoric will be "well, despite the Rooney rule only 8% of BAME candidates got the job, therefore further proving the racism within the selection process of managers". It's one step away from being told who you have to employ, which the media are already trying to do.

If you're good enough, you'll get the job, simple as that. It's bollocks.

Do you honestly believe that?

That's an oversimplification but yes, obviously salary etc. comes into it but if it's decided that you're the best candidate for the job then you'll get it. Also being a football manager is different from many other professions in the sense that there's a lot more head hunting going on and a lot of information is known about the potential candidates before a formal process has even taken place. Frequently a team will have an idea in mind of who they want to take over before the formal process has started. 

This won't change with the Rooney rule. The BAME managers that have shown themselves capable of managing at a high level either have jobs (Nuno) or will get another high level job (Hughton). The ones that have shown themselves not to be good enough (Paul Ince, John Barnes) will continue not to get high level jobs.


RE: EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - 4-hero - 06-07-2019

(06-07-2019, 03:46 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(06-07-2019, 03:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: What a load of bollocks. Fantastic way of combatting racism is by putting yourself in a position where you'll have to find a BAME candidate to interview just to tick a box to say you've done it. That's not patronising at all.

It won't make any difference. In a year the rhetoric will be "well, despite the Rooney rule only 8% of BAME candidates got the job, therefore further proving the racism within the selection process of managers". It's one step away from being told who you have to employ, which the media are already trying to do.

If you're good enough, you'll get the job, simple as that. It's bollocks.

Spot on sliced, it's ludicrous. 

I bet Adrian Durham is creaming in his pants.

He will be shitting his pants if Dwight Yorke gets the Peterboro job


RE: EFL introduces 'Rooney Rule' - Albion - 06-07-2019

Well done. I welcome this rule. People who haven’t suffered racism first hand wouldn’t comprehend nor understand the difficulties facing BAME coaches who are looking to embark a career in football.