WBAUnofficial
Bloody NIMBY’s… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Bloody NIMBY’s… (/showthread.php?tid=43313)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


Bloody NIMBY’s… - Derek Hardballs - 11-11-2026

Just pre-empting those that think this kind of billionaire owned and public sector accepted behaviour is absolutely fine. It’s clearly not but I’m sure some will argue it is, right up to the point they dump a monstrosity right next to their leafy semi-rural suburban homes. 

This is all perfectly acceptable


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - baggy1 - 11-11-2026

Literally no-one on here has ever argued for that. The only reference to NIMBY's has been in relation to house building, but don't get facts in the way of any of your misplaced rage.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Borin' Baggie - 11-11-2026

Has anyone argued for 18m high 24/7 warehouses right next to a residential area? This is the exact thing that zoning would prevent.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Oscillator - 11-11-2026

What a surprise, greedy billionaires and big businesses screwing people over in the pursuit of money. I've seen a few of these massive warehouses spring up.
Just down the road from me a massive Amazon warehouse was built a little while back. Whilst not exactly right next to me and I'm not really affected by noise, trucks etc I suppose I kind of fall into what you describe.
It was a semi rural area where Sutton Coldfield edges onto the countryside. Besides the impact on the residents it's totally changed the landscape.
Whereas before when you looked down a hill onto countryside from a few miles away all you now see is a great big blue warehouse.
They are also planning on building 5000 new houses on fields that stretch for 3 or 4 miles, ripping out hedgerows in the process. The traffic is already very busy so god knows what it will be like once they all start commuting as well.
I get the argument we need more housing (though the real issue is the housing market more than anything) but given the area I am pretty sure these houses will be out the reach of 1st time buyers and people who need help getting on the housing ladder.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Øssian - 11-11-2026

B1 & BB, thankfully I have no idea what the contents of the OP were/are, but you're both responding to the board equivalent of the village pisshead. Someone who wanders into the bar, sees that there are no arguments going on, so tries his hand at starting a spurious one.

It's become beyond tiresome.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - baggy1 - 11-11-2026

You're right Oss, I did consider not responding but Dekka takes that as he's right so just wanted to clarify.

And Oscilator - are you referring to Tidbury Green by any chance, I drive through there every day scowling at the 'Keep Tidbury Green' signs.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Protheroe - 11-11-2026

Wigan Council designates site as prime employment land in decades old UDP - before housing was built. LA searches would have revealed this to everyone who subsequently proposed to buy a house. People in houses order all sorts of stuff online rather than going to the shops. Logistics developer builds prime warehouse building to serve rapidly expanding home shopping market. Wigan Council grants consent on designated prime employment everyone knew about. If they hadn't then developer would have won on appeal.

Bev Craig, Burnham's successor as Greater Manchester mayor, said she too was concerned. “Old industry wouldn’t have got that close to your house” - with a statement like that I can only assume that Bev Craig has never visited Greater Manchester let alone Birmingham & the Black Country.

Sorry to burst your bubble Dekka, but BB is right. Zoning would have ruled this out - when I was in development Labour Councils had an obsession with mixed-use development, this is just an example of it.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Oscillator - 11-11-2026

(11-11-2026, 11:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You're right Oss, I did consider not responding but Dekka takes that as he's right so just wanted to clarify.

And Oscilator - are you referring to Tidbury Green by any chance, I drive through there every day scowling at the 'Keep Tidbury Green' signs.

No mate - the Amazon warehouse at Minworth and the new Langley development. There is an argument for saying there is already a big Asda nearby but that formed the barrier between the urban development that took place in the 1970s and 80s when the area was transformed from what was truly rural into a suburb and the current countryside. 
It just looks very out of place with huge roadworks and a bridge that goes nowhere. 
Besides the increase in traffic, the destruction of what little wildlife habitat we have left in this country and the pressure on local services (schools are already oversubscribed and just like the rest of the country you can't get a Drs appointment), it appears they are also planning to build more industrial units.
Meanwhile everyone is distracted by the migrant hotel we have down the road where the residents have not caused any issues but the regular protestors have included a suspected murderer, a bloke on child porn charges and people wearing national socialist hoodies


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Protheroe - 11-11-2026

(11-11-2026, 11:37 AM)Oscillator Wrote: What a surprise, greedy billionaires and big businesses screwing people over in the pursuit of money. I've seen a few of these massive warehouses spring up.
Just down the road from me a massive Amazon warehouse was built a little while back. Whilst not exactly right next to me and I'm not really affected by noise, trucks etc I suppose I kind of fall into what you describe.
It was a semi rural area where Sutton Coldfield edges onto the countryside. Besides the impact on the residents it's totally changed the landscape.
Whereas before when you looked down a hill onto countryside from a few miles away all you now see is a great big blue warehouse.
They are also planning on building 5000 new houses on fields that stretch for 3 or 4 miles, ripping out hedgerows in the process. The traffic is already very busy so god knows what it will be like once they all start commuting as well.
I get the argument we need more housing (though the real issue is the housing market more than anything) but given the area I am pretty sure these houses will be out the reach of 1st time buyers and people who need help getting on the housing ladder.

Again, the Peddimore site has been designated as Birmingham City Council's MIS (Major Investment Site) for more than two decades. Development of it should not really come as a surprise to anyone - it's the only decent land asset Birmingham City Council had to sell.

The employment land is being developed by Lord Edmiston (Bob, to me), a lovely fellow who I worked with a lot on site assembly at Witton and Birch Coppice back in the day.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Oscillator - 11-11-2026

(11-11-2026, 12:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Wigan Council designates site as prime employment land in decades old UDP - before housing was built. LA searches would have revealed this to everyone who subsequently proposed to buy a house. People in houses order all sorts of stuff online rather than going to the shops. Logistics developer builds prime warehouse building to serve rapidly expanding home shopping market. Wigan Council grants consent on designated prime employment everyone knew about. If they hadn't then developer would have won on appeal.

Bev Craig, Burnham's successor as Greater Manchester mayor, said she too was concerned. “Old industry wouldn’t have got that close to your house”  -  with a statement like that I can only assume that Bev Craig has never visited Greater Manchester let alone Birmingham & the Black Country.

Sorry to burst your bubble Dekka, but BB is right. Zoning would have ruled this out - when I was in development Labour Councils had an obsession with mixed-use development, this is just an example of it.

The point on zoning is spot on. Have the council never played city skylines?

(11-11-2026, 12:14 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-11-2026, 11:37 AM)Oscillator Wrote: What a surprise, greedy billionaires and big businesses screwing people over in the pursuit of money. I've seen a few of these massive warehouses spring up.
Just down the road from me a massive Amazon warehouse was built a little while back. Whilst not exactly right next to me and I'm not really affected by noise, trucks etc I suppose I kind of fall into what you describe.
It was a semi rural area where Sutton Coldfield edges onto the countryside. Besides the impact on the residents it's totally changed the landscape.
Whereas before when you looked down a hill onto countryside from a few miles away all you now see is a great big blue warehouse.
They are also planning on building 5000 new houses on fields that stretch for 3 or 4 miles, ripping out hedgerows in the process. The traffic is already very busy so god knows what it will be like once they all start commuting as well.
I get the argument we need more housing (though the real issue is the housing market more than anything) but given the area I am pretty sure these houses will be out the reach of 1st time buyers and people who need help getting on the housing ladder.

Again, the Peddimore site has been designated as Birmingham City Council's MIS (Major Investment Site) for more than two decades. Development of it should not really come as a surprise to anyone - it's the only decent land asset Birmingham City Council had to sell.

The employment land is being developed by Lord Edmiston (Bob, to me), a lovely fellow who I worked with a lot on site assembly at Witton and Birch Coppice back in the day.

We all knew Peddimore was going to happen but it's the lack of plan to deal with traffic and the fact we all know it's not really going to solve the housing issues this country faces that is an issue. The developer seems hellbent on ripping out hedgerows despite there being a suitable proposal from local conservative councillors that would mean the hedgerow remaining at the cost of about a 10ft wide strip of land to the project