WBAUnofficial
How many fans do we really have? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: How many fans do we really have? (/showthread.php?tid=42976)

Pages: 1 2


How many fans do we really have? - PatelsPlatoon - 10-09-2026

The age old argument over which club is the biggest has always been part of the football fan debate, but I wonder how many fans do we really have, that could be turned into attendees etc.

With Blues coming along tomorrow ready to build a stadium over twice our size, I wonder what we are really capable of.

As a kid I remember the Hawthorns holding 42,000- that was mid 70s but in the all seater stadia era we've watched clubs of less standing bypass us capacity wise- clubs like Sheff U, Middlesbrough, Bristol C etc.

I used to think we were a similar club to West Ham, but they have 50,000 season ticket holders- I know Peace made the mid table championship quip about us, but I genuinely wonder where we really sit as a well-supported club.

Several decent seasons at Prem level doesn't seem to have massively helped us as a draw.

To my mind, I think there's a lot of financially strapped fans of us, which keeps visible attendees lower and the capacity of just under 27,000 doesn't help either.

As for Blues and their stadium, how they are going to fill that is a complete mystery. Decent fan base, but more fickle than ours.


RE: How many fans do we really have? - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 10-09-2026

Think we are equal to Norwich, Ipswich, Hull, Coventry ( no where near us historically, but one team in a decent size city, ) nowadays, none of which really have our history.
Can`t understand Bristol City, no real history, spent decades in lower leagues, usually rubbish, but 2 teams, one even worse than them in a big city. We compete with Villa and Wolves.
Also, the advent of SKY etc, kids grow up supporting Liverpool, Chelsea etc. When Coventry got promoted, it was all over Midlands Today, they interviewed some geezer whose Missus gave birth the same day, had the poor nipper in a Coventry City baby- grow, talked about the kid being Coventry through and through etc.
I said to Mrs Ministry, I hope they interview him again in a few years when, following Coventrys inevitable relegation, and spell in The Championship / League One, bankruptcy, the kid wants a Liverpool shirt for Xmas.


RE: How many fans do we really have? - BertieTheBaggie - 10-09-2026

The build another tier debate has gone very quiet in recent years.

I think our demise in the mid 80s was brutal on us as a club, from which we've never really recovered.

We've Sandwell and Dudley as our neck of the woods and the fringes of Brum, but from about 1990 Villa have reaped huge benefits never seen in the previous century. They had the birth of the Prem coinciding with them in a good era, having Atkinson/Taylor and a couple of league cups and runner-up spots. It also coincided with all the 3 other big West Mids clubs on their doorstep jointly having historically bad times for many years.

Wolves had nearly 20 years out of the top flight, whilst Blues and us had 16.

Without all that I think we'd have 5000 extra hardcore fans, Blues and Wolves would too. Instead it gave Villa every floating fan in a 2 million population.

The height of our ambition is no more than a modest increase in capacity to maybe a shade over 30,000.

I do also question how desolate it is around the Hawthorns entertainment wise. A couple of good pubs nearer the ground from the Smethwick side would help.


RE: How many fans do we really have? - KRO - 10-09-2026

(10-09-2026, 03:11 PM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: The build another tier debate has gone very quiet in recent years.

I think our demise in the mid 80s was brutal on us as a club, from which we've never really recovered.

We've Sandwell and Dudley as our neck of the woods and the fringes of Brum, but from about 1990 Villa have reaped huge benefits never seen in the previous century. They had the birth of the Prem coinciding with them in a good era, having Atkinson/Taylor and a couple of league cups and runner-up spots. It also coincided with all the 3 other big West Mids clubs on their doorstep jointly having historically bad times for many years.

Wolves had nearly 20 years out of the top flight, whilst Blues and us had 16.

Without all that I think we'd have 5000 extra hardcore fans, Blues and Wolves would too. Instead it gave Villa every floating fan in a 2 million population.

The height of our ambition is no more than a modest increase in capacity to maybe a shade over 30,000.

I do also question how desolate it is around the Hawthorns entertainment wise. A couple of good pubs nearer the ground from the Smethwick side would help.
Very good post that


RE: How many fans do we really have? - Tom Joad 25 - 10-09-2026

Good post Bertie. I also totally agree villa were perfectly poised to take advantage of our demise in the 1980s. But it doesn't help when you come from a town like ours. The fringes, Dudley, Stourbridge etc have always been shared with the dings ( the latter these day, villa as well), meaning Albion depend hugely on West Brom itself. Without wanting to cause a political debate, I walk around there regularly and there's very little English spoken around that most densely populated area from the motorway island right through to Carter's Green. I've a mate that grew up just off Lodge Rd right in the town, he moved when he didn't know anyone in the street that had been there more than 5 minutes. We must have lost thousands of fans like this. Go to Barmouth, Aberdovey or anywhere similar and you'll find Albion fans. I look around the area now and wonder where we'll get 10k more regular fans from? Peace was right with his land-locked claim. The dings to the north and Villa and blues to the south leaves us with no room to spread. He could have done much more to cement our place during that brief period we had a smidgeon of being topdog. Cutting the capacity means we can never even boost the average crowd with the odd bumper gate. I reckon we need a period of sustained improvements to do any good.


RE: How many fans do we really have? - RamsAy it - 10-09-2026

We should have a poll on here, as i know quite a lot on here don't /seldom go, including Carlos (aka Soph), Lurker, Duffers, Midge and Birdie and of course all the overseas posters on here.


RE: How many fans do we really have? - Spandaubaggie - 10-09-2026

Whilst I agree that the town of West Brom is the core area of fandom, it’s incredible how many totally detached from the town are fans.
I’m from Bearwood originally and have probably been into West Brom a handful of times in my entire life.
Peace spoke an uncomfortable truth about our support but for all that we’re in a very densely populated area and we are far from a faded force.
Recent history in the Prem means we’re fairly well known internationally too.
In many ways we’re looked at as a similar club to Wolves outside the region.
I’m pleased we’ve now got decent owners but it does concern me a bit that we don’t seem to have the same level of wealth or ambition as the rest of our rivals.
We’re very much in 4th place in the W Mids at the moment.


RE: How many fans do we really have? - Hughie Reed 31 - 10-09-2026

I think we easily have enough fans to fill a 32,000 size ground
The problem is a lot have got out of the habit of going for various
Reasons
you can watch it at home on an illegal stream
Watch at certain pubs
We had a golden opportunity when Mowbray (1st time) Di Matteo Clarke Hodgson
We’re our managers we playing attractive football and on the way to establishing ourselves
As a top league side unfortunately we had Mr Peace who really was only looking for
His personal maximum gain with minimal input not prepared to put in the necessary ground
Infrastructure in place to attract fans we have to accept we live in a poor area the pricing
Got to be right
One of our biggest mistakes appointing Tony Pulis I reckon we lost a good few thousand when
He rocked up

The big job now is to get new fans schools are the way to go give at least a thousand tickets
Free to every home game get them going with their mates lay on some transport invest in the youth
Build a fan base for the future.


RE: How many fans do we really have? - Spandaubaggie - 10-09-2026

Regards enticing new/old fans my personal story is an illustration of what is possible.
Despite decades of support going back to the original Giles era I never had a season ticket until about 5 years ago. We got the cheap season ticket for my lad who was then about 14. I had to get one to accompany him from Solihull way.
I’d done enough to make him a fan, but probably only went 3-4 times a season since he was about 7.
Now I know most folks in the stands around me and despite having now moved further away from the Hawthorns will be there most games.
My lad, 20 now, brings a mate or 2 along as well and although his 2 best mates are typical Man U glory hunters they have more than a passing interest in the Albion.
I would say though there’s nothing that keeps me around the Hawthorns. I spend nothing in the area. We’re more likely to have pints in Brum, as we come in on the train.
If there was a decent boozer or 2 on Halfords Lane it’d be worth it.
Personally I think the club should have saved the Hawthorns pub, bought it and made it into a hub as part of the match day experience.
More needs to be done to make the day more complete.
I would add though I remember several years ago getting stick in better times saying for the occasional fan it’s tough to get more than 2 seats together. It put me off on several occasions in the Prem times.
The limited capacity does make it more difficult- whilst swathes of empty seats aren’t good in the bad times stadium size is a notable indicator of club stature. An extra 5000 capacity would certainly help long term for that reason.


RE: How many fans do we really have? - Vinebaggie - 10-09-2026

In the mid 80s Villas average league attendances in the top flight was 15/16000. Admittedly these were bad times for league attendances, but they have consistently shown the type of ambition we have never seen and been rewarded. Blues I think are showing similar ambition and will in turn benefit. I really think we have the potential as a fan base to get an average attendance of 30,000+ but up to now at least we’ve never had the owners to realise that potential