WBAUnofficial
Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Bottom line now the emotions have settled. (/showthread.php?tid=42112)

Pages: 1 2 3


Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - Lurker#3 - 07-16-2026

It's all good and well getting it right against Mexico, and us progressing through the qualifications, group stages and 2 pretty 'easy' knock out opponents (in the grand scheme). But Tommy Tuchel was appointed to get it right against the better teams, in the big games. The first time he gets in that position he shits in his own hands and claps. 

Should he be sacked? Yes. But that is probably still quite emotionally driven. In reality he won't be, but this has to be his one and only pass. No more chances. Full blown expectation of success from now on. Next failure, he's gone. He doesn't have the same unifying aura Southgate has so he has to deliver success.


RE: Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke - 07-16-2026

Agree with all that. He should be sacked for that, but probably won't be. Given the scale of the debacle and his age and experience, I've no confidence he'll do anything differently next time.


RE: Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - Borin' Baggie - 07-16-2026

Taking Gordon off and ceding control by deploying a low block with 5 defenders with 20 minutes left was moronic.


RE: Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - Ted Maul - 07-16-2026

On reflection, having watched the last half an hour back again I can't believe how many basics he got wrong with those subs.

Giving up the entirety of our midfield, allowing Messi to take up one position (right half space) totally unopposed and pick out cross after cross. Changing to a five which meant we were unable to defended the cross coming in, we had to win the ball in our penalty area.

Argentina are good, they're experienced, they've got quality but to have them on the ropes (as Spain did with France last night) and to do what Tuchel did is inexcusable I'm afraid. One big test and he blew it and it's made even worse by the fact that Scaloni had no choice, he had to throw everything at us, so he'd have known what was coming. An ounce of control in midfield of that game after we scored and with the subs they make we win that game, I'd bet my mortgage on it.

Penny for the thoughts of Mainoo and Wharton watching us finish with O'Reilly in midfield.


RE: Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - Mullers - 07-16-2026

It’s all still very raw - we only kicked off 12 hours ago.

I can understand and to a large extent share the frustration at the tactics deployed in the last 30 mins. But equally, the players opened up too many gaps for Argentina and in some ways, forced Tuchel to make a decision. We scored on ‘55 and that decision (to bring Konsa on for Gordon and change shape) came 17 mins later. We were being hammered during those 17 mins and were lucky to make it to the hydration break unscathed.

Tuchel’s job is to make the big calls. During the tournament, he’s got a lot of them (not all) right. He made one last night that a lot of us wouldn’t have made. I maintain that had it paid off, most people would be lauding a proactive, tactical genius of a manager. Instead, the conversation is about sacking him.

I want us to stick with him for one more tournament. His first in international management has seen us get to the semi finals and be 10 mins away from beating the world champions. I honestly believe we will win Euro 2028, and there’s no reason aside from possible injuries why we shouldn’t.


RE: Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - Josh1873 - 07-16-2026

I think you can say the same about Bellingham and Kane, who have had great tournaments, and are clearly talented players, but were absolutely nowhere to be found yesterday when it mattered against competitive opposition.

It's all well and good turning up against opposition you should be beating on paper, but arguably England's only so called world class players went missing when they were needed the most.

Tuchel deserves criticism, but it's not all on him. The senior and better players didn't really stand up to be counted. They hid when the occasion got too much for them.

Think back to Beckham v Greece where he dragged England to the 2002 World Cup. A performance from somebody like that after England went 1-0 up was needed. Someone to grab the game and the initiative, someone to be brave. Someone to show up when the team needs it most. Instead, the Nation got nothing.


RE: Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - strawman - 07-16-2026

(07-16-2026, 05:43 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It's all good and well getting it right against Mexico, and us progressing through the qualifications, group stages and 2 pretty 'easy' knock out opponents (in the grand scheme). But Tommy Tuchel was appointed to get it right against the better teams, in the big games. The first time he gets in that position he shits in his own hands and claps. 

Should he be sacked? Yes. But that is probably still quite emotionally driven. In reality he won't be, but this has to be his one and only pass. No more chances. Full blown expectation of success from now on. Next failure, he's gone. He doesn't have the same unifying aura Southgate has so he has to deliver success.

Tuchel hung the players out to dry, basically with those tactics he was telling them you are not good enough to compete so see if you can just hang on. Defending on he edge of your own area, even almost on the penalty spot was just negative suicide, seems everyone but Tuchel could see what was coming. 

If you are going to lose at least lose trying to compete and win, nand not just roll over. After the goal that was a surrender so fuck the negative, cowardly waster off now because I bet in the same circumstance he would do exactly the same thing.


RE: Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - Lurker#3 - 07-16-2026

(07-16-2026, 07:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think you can say the same about Bellingham and Kane, who have had great tournaments, and are clearly talented players, but were absolutely nowhere to be found yesterday when it mattered against competitive opposition.

It's all well and good turning up against opposition you should be beating on paper, but arguably our only so called world class players went missing when we needed them most.

Tuchel deserves criticism, but it's not all on him. Our senior and better players didn't really stand up to be counted. They hid when the occasion got too much for them.

Both are world class but they are not Messi and Ronaldo. So they can not be expected to win you a game by themselves. 

Last night was on Tuchel and Tuchel alone. He must do better if he's to remain in post.


RE: Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - carlito baggie - 07-16-2026

So this is how I see it.

After we scored we retreated to our 18 yard line and tried to hold on to what we had.

After 70 mins he had a choice. If he makes positive subs and tries to gain control and we lose the game everyone would be asking why he didn't shore everything up like we did against Mexico.
Instead he makes negative changes , we lose the game and he gets hammered for it.

Small margins but we were playing the World Champions and at that time he needed to be positive and he chose the wrong option.


RE: Bottom line now the emotions have settled. - Josh1873 - 07-16-2026

It really is small margins, if England hold on, I suspect the performance would have been lauded as a masterclass in tactics and game management.