![]() |
|
Calmed down - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Calmed down (/showthread.php?tid=40891) |
Calmed down - Birdman1811 - 03-01-2026 I was so, so angry last night with the absolute fuckwitted cowards we seem to have assembled as a football team. Honestly I wouldn't have hit the brakes if any of them stepped out in front of me last night. I've tried to be supportive, stay optimistic, try to explain the issues best I can, them they give that performance yesterday. A day everything went out way, all they had to do was beat a team that belong in the league below, a team that hadn't scored this calender year etc home, a team that is only not bottom because Sheffield Wednesday exist. We barely mastered a chance and conceded two, every single one if them past Bostock should have gone home, looked in the mirror and been violently sick seeing their own reflection. I'm glad it appears Morrison tore them a new asshole and actively called them out by name, they deserve it. They aren't lazy, well mostly, a couple of them, Maja especially, but to not have the guts to even try to make something happen against such a shit team is embarrassing. Just play it safe, take no risks, don't be one caught with the ball, no bravery at all. Now I just hate them, I've accepted relegation, I can't believe it, the sheer incompetence to get this club relegated to League one is staggering. Recruitment is shit, coaching is shit, game management is shit, club ethos just seems to be shit. And all that comes from the top. Unless a total clean sweep is fine in the summer, I expect more of the same next season, the rot has set in. RE: Calmed down - Josh1873 - 03-01-2026 100% this. Good post. RE: Calmed down - Sliced - 03-01-2026 As I've said before, I genuinely don't put a blame on the players for this situation. It's all from above. For anyone wondering what the strategy is with regards to the players: 1. Get rid of higher earners that we can, replace with cheaper from abroad/youth/lower leagues. 2. Any of those that turn out to be decent, sell those on as well and replace. 3. Repeat. So who does that leave you with? A team primarily made up of the ones that no one else wants and the less good players we've signed while the decent ones have been sold off. The managerial strategy is "get in a young up and coming manager without really vetting them". Seemingly because it's progressive, but the manager is the most important decision of the football club and now 3 times in a row we've gotten it completely wrong....and it's quite likely Raphael Wicky would have been a pile of shite too if Nestor chose him. What we have now is a mish mash of players who hardly know each other; a keeper who's never been particularly good but gets zero protection from a centre back partnership (any of them) that hasn't been coached to be a cohesive unit at any point this season. We have what is likely our best centre back out at right back because all of our other right back options are a million miles away from being adequate at this level, Styles who is arguably first name on the team sheet despite being brought in as a utility backup player. Moving into midfield there's Mowatt and Molumby who loads seem to have a problem with one or the other, they clash when playing together but the only other semi-reasonable alternatives are Diakite who is fine at breaking up play but allergic to passing forwards (actually just passing in general, I don't think I've seen a footballer struggle to kick a ball in a straight line before) and Styles who might be ok but we have no viable alternative at left back, so we have to play them. Price was alright initially but he's clearly not a player for a relegation battle, our wide players are children, OAPs or injured and our striking choices are Maja who's unfit, Dike who's not the same after being injured and Heggebo who's out of form. Other than that we're alright. I do take a more che sera sera view than birdy though. I'm not happy with our plight but what will be will be. Eventually we'll get to a League where we start winning some games, even if it's in a few seasons time
RE: Calmed down - man in the corner shop - 03-01-2026 Nestor was just Ron Saunders with a spreadsheet. RE: Calmed down - Derek Hardballs - 03-01-2026 I’ve been hoping my cynicism was wrong but all season and actually since we brought Mowbray back to the club, I’ve lost any faith in the club’s ownership. Only time will tell if they have any plan past flogging our best players and replacing them with inferior ones. If it was as others have argued simply PSR constraints that meant we haven’t been able to put a coherent and effective plan or team together, then I await us correcting this next season. Personally I have my doubts we are going to come back stronger, the mistakes we’ve made have been obvious and inexplicably poor. Not even hindsight can save the clubs blushes. RE: Calmed down - Birdman1811 - 03-01-2026 (03-01-2026, 11:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’ve been hoping my cynicism was wrong but all season and actually since we brought Mowbray back to the club, I’ve lost any faith in the club’s ownership. Only time will tell if they have any plan past flogging our best players and replacing them with inferior ones. If it was as others have argued simply PSR constraints that meant we haven’t been able to put a coherent and effective plan or team together, then I await us correcting this next season. They've shown nothing to suggest they can turn this around. If Ian Pearce is still head of recruitment for next season, if we don't actually try to revamp the squad properly, then it's clear they really don't have a clue. RE: Calmed down - Squid - 03-01-2026 Thing is, if you have to tighten your belt for a while on the playing front, it means your coaching needs to be the best you can afford. That's why I can't criticise the choice of Mowbray, he'd done well enough with Blackburn and Sunderland to indicate that he could keep us ticking along. The subsequent decision-making, has been utterly disastrous. Then we have the most recent transfer window, which was actually worse than the one under Bruce were two transfers collapsed, BTS and Erik Peters would walk into this team. This should be the last acts of Ian Pearce, he needs to gom RE: Calmed down - man in the corner shop - 03-01-2026 (03-01-2026, 11:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’ve been hoping my cynicism was wrong but all season and actually since we brought Mowbray back to the club, I’ve lost any faith in the club’s ownership. Only time will tell if they have any plan past flogging our best players and replacing them with inferior ones. If it was as others have argued simply PSR constraints that meant we haven’t been able to put a coherent and effective plan or team together, then I await us correcting this next season. For me, it was the Mowbray decision that made me lose faith completely. I was fucking furious at the ineptitude. But I only wrote off last season because of that - as it showed a complete lack of ambition and settled for mediocrity and gormlessness. Last summer though, I couldn't have predicted these last 7-8 months. RE: Calmed down - Old Fart - 03-01-2026 Trev the Shed had more idea than this lot. I fear we are in for a period of chaos until a Jeremy Peace character emerges with yet another change of ownership and a clear strategy emerges with the funds and know how required. RE: Calmed down - SW4Baggie - 03-01-2026 I said it 12 months ago, and I stand by it, Nestor was horribly naive and underestimated the Championship and Patel trusted him too much. I think they took one look at the shambles we were under Lai and assumed every Championship club was the same. They thought that a few spreadsheets, some data modelling and a bit of Yank optimism would be enough, but they were very, very wrong. We were a long way behind other clubs even at this level under Gourlay and co, but had parachute payments to cushion the laziness, and then CC’s brilliance papered over the cracks for Bilkul’s first 12 months, but they were too blind to see just how good we had it. Objectively I do not think our recruitment has been terrible, I think we have been able to isolate good players with significant potential that will lead to profits when we sell, and I think we have become increasingly creative with our scouting of late. I also believe we’ve been generally quite successful in convincing players to join us, there have been plenty of signings we have made that I feel other clubs would’ve been interested in, but we appear to have got them over the line without too much fuss. I can understand why Pearce seems to continually receive promotion and plaudits since the new owners came in, because he will have worked at Brighton, and have well versed in their forward thinking methods, and no doubt talks a good game about scouting under realised markets and talent pathways. What we lack however, is football knowledge, it is experience, it is the know how when it comes to building more than just a collection of data on a spreadsheet. It is building a coherent and robust squad, it is understanding how players create something more than the sum of their individual parts. A to translate a culture from the club into something meaningful. Our owners seem to think that positive thinking, their data savviness, all of these methods that they want to bring will drive success. However, what they hugely underestimated was how far behind the average championship club we were. Going forward, my concern is that should Dominic Price become our new director of football, it will be more of the same. He is a 30 something former analyst with a few years of recruitment work at Liverpool under his belt. He has also spent a couple of years in Israel where his claim to fame appears to have been giving Robbie Keane a crack at management. I hope that I am hugely underselling him, and that he can bring that know how in intelligence and execute a plan that has football and not just data points at its heart. As I’ve said many times over, I do think our own care, and I do think they want what’s best for this club however they grossly underestimated the capabilities and standards that are the norm in this division, and hugely overestimated their capabilities in operating at this level. I hope the pause in appointing the director of football, I hope the return of Miles, and I hope the indefinite interim time buying appointment of Mozza is a pause for thought from Patel. I know Lepko has an axe or two that he regularly grinds but his comments about Charlie Melham suggesting Patel is a nice guy but don’t take any opportunity to learn from the advice of other owners, and his constant suggestions that there are plenty of football people offering their assistance and support to the club but not even receiving a reply aligns with my thoughts tha Bilkul believe they know better and this attitude has to change. I wait in hope. |