![]() |
|
Ratings v Derby - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Ratings v Derby (/showthread.php?tid=40331) |
Ratings v Derby - Lurker#3 - 01-24-2026 MOL - 5 - Gains a mark for his distribution. Loses 2 for his fuck up as it was that bad. Bielik - 6 - Did well at times especially considering he was playing with a shoulder injury. Proper man but seems his body doesn't agree, his passing is a big plus from the back. Phillips - 6 Better today, but hard to really judge as we had so many players screening him and Derby didn't offer much. Campbell - 6 - Has to play. But again wasn't challenged in what was a really poor game. Price - 6 - Monster shift as usual. One moment of quality with his cross. Wasted at RWB when asked to play so deep and square. If we are going to clunky our way to safety with a flat back 5 like last night, play a defensive RB there. Molumby - 7 - Usual graft, usual benefits, usual issues, gets an assist too for his flick. Diakite - 7 - Good screening for the back 5. Recycled the ball. Not their fault, but Dialumby, won't work long term though. Unless we get the rest of the team absolutely purring. Styles - 6 - Worked hard, struggled to get an involvement in the game though really. But like Price was so deep and square and fixed to his position. Probably instructional. MJ - 6 - Kept trying to make stuff happen, a few nearly moments but largely frustrating, but did lack support and runners so was often crowded out by Derbys midfield and defence. Heggebo - 6 - Usual shift and 3/4 genuinely world class bits of link up play. Like MJ, suffered with lack of runners and support. Grant - Can't judge as was off too early. Subs: SIJ - 5 - Shit further forward. Less shit at LWB. Wallace - 6 - Ran a lot, not much impact. Mepham - 7 - Did well when he came on. Aggressive in the tackle at the back and got his goal. Dike & Maja - ? - To be fair to them they had hardly any service, and we rarely got up to support them. Hard to mark them. Ramsay - 6 - Got it more wrong than right for me last night. Wrong starting XI for the way he set us up - If you're going with a flat back 5 with the instructions to defend from a shape and not really break out from it play Gilchrist as a RB not price, because last night they definitely weren't 'wingbacks'. Wrong subs, we were, as always crying out for more of a threat in the centre of the pitch, but I do kind of understand the reluctance to lose that solidity in CM. Then the straight swap when Bielik went off showed the lack of ambition, fortunately, luck was with us and Mepham scored the equaliser, so I have to separate my feelings and opinions on the game management and the end result a little. It's also worth noting, that whilst I didn't agree with the changes in full, the swaps at 60 mins were technically attacking in nature and timely which is far more than Mason ever dished up. As I said in the match Fred, I will clock it down as the last 'pre season friendly' of his during his first week. He now has a full week having seen his entire squad and would expect to see more threat on the break and more ambition in our attacking play and line ups. Overall - Many got what they wanted last night. "Back to Basics". Deep, compact, little ambition and all of our decent opportunities came via set pieces, bar Molumbys tame effort from the edge of the box. Will that be enough over the remaining if the season? Probably, and I am willing to cut him some slack as long as we are well organised. RE: Ratings v Derby - Stillclem4england - 01-24-2026 Disagree with most of those I’m afraid. That was a decent performance: we set out to be hard to beat and kept shape brilliantly but also moved the ball well enough first half. I know Derby are crap but they are what 7th and we were at their place - where we never get anything - on the back of ten away defeats on the spin. Anyone who thinks we are going to go away and be expansive is insane - that will be the blueprint and we will be hard to break down and try and nick a goal. O’Leary - 2. Punch it you clown. If you asked me who was the worst keeper in the league after Wildsmith at the start of last week I’d have said him. He has looked terrible every time I have ever seen him. Price - 6. Real shift and got forward well. One terrific cross. Styles - 6. Unlucky to be hooked. Bielik- 6. Shame he is made of glass. Phillips - 6. The weakest of the three. Campbell - 8. Outstanding. Didn’t put a foot wrong. Best performance by an Albion defender since Mepham and Phillips at Stoke. Molumby - 7. Just what we needed in this formation. Diakite - 7.5. Wonderful performance. He was everywhere and what a guy for playing so soon after recent events. Mikey - 5. Didn’t offer much. KG - 5. Will be a loss. Heggebo - 7. Battled well and linked play. Subs: SIJ - 5. Poor performance but crossing ok. Wallace - 7. Great energy and really decent. Maja - 5. Not interested. Dike - 4. Looked lost. Mepham - 6. Hopefully finds form now. RE: Ratings v Derby - tHEgLASSdOORS - 01-24-2026 Molumby 6 Diakite 8 Otherwise more or less agree RE: Ratings v Derby - Wednesburybaggie - 01-24-2026 (01-24-2026, 08:15 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Disagree with most of those I’m afraid. That was a decent performance: we set out to be hard to beat and kept shape brilliantly but also moved the ball well enough first half. I know Derby are crap but they are what 7th and we were at their place - where we never get anything - on the back of ten away defeats on the spin. Anyone who thinks we are going to go away and be expansive is insane - that will be the blueprint and we will be hard to break down and try and nick a goal.Very generous giving Sammy the Seal 5. He must have been really, really shit for our fantastic away support to start giving him pelters. RE: Ratings v Derby - Josh1873 - 01-24-2026 I'm finding it difficult to give ratings on quality. I'm really encouraged at the mentality and fight shown. To be in our position, having just lost 0-5 away from home, on a 10 game losing streak away from home, to concede such a sloppy goal and go 1-0 down after being the better side, it would have been so easy to capitulate. We didn't. We carried on. Stuck to our plan. Rolled our sleeves up. Scrapped. And forced a point. It's not spectacular, it's not an amazing result, but what it does do is give me hope and belief. RE: Ratings v Derby - Stillclem4england - 01-24-2026 He was very, very poor. However, he isn’t a bad crosser and put in a decent cross that Price skied. RE: Ratings v Derby - tHEgLASSdOORS - 01-24-2026 (01-24-2026, 08:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm finding it difficult to give ratings on quality. Agreed with all that. My biggest fear is just like in 90/91 we are battling but it’s hard to see us winning games. My instinct is that we will just about survive but so much depends on if and what we being in, especially with Grant and Bielik potentially missing now RE: Ratings v Derby - Lurker#3 - 01-24-2026 (01-24-2026, 08:15 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Disagree with most of those I’m afraid. Yet we had 8 scores the same and I couldn't mark three of them! Football ay?
RE: Ratings v Derby - Stillclem4england - 01-24-2026 (01-24-2026, 09:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(01-24-2026, 08:15 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Disagree with most of those I’m afraid. “Some” RE: Ratings v Derby - Lurker#3 - 01-24-2026 (01-24-2026, 08:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm finding it difficult to give ratings on quality. Good post, Josh. |