WBAUnofficial
An argument for keeping Mason? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: An argument for keeping Mason? (/showthread.php?tid=39770)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


An argument for keeping Mason? - Spandaubaggie - 12-20-2025

Now, I'm trying to play devil's advocate here, not particularly defending Mason but in the absence of us getting sucked into a dogfight is it as well we keep him?

I almost think this argument is better after another defeat on the road.

My reasoning, or the reasoning of the 3rd person, putting this forward is:-

He's inherited a bit of a hotch potch squad assembled without much of a say so from him.

Us sacking a novice manager we appointed in half a season when we are underperforming makes us look a bit knee jerk.

In the absence of relegation, does it really matter if we finish 7th or 17th, provided he can be shown he is learning?

Also, sometimes you go backwards before going forwards. If we have to reassemble the squad a bit and he gets in his own men in January, is it really such a bad thing allowing the breathing space for him to show us what he can do? I say that knowing coaches have less of an input than they did a couple of decades ago.

I'm not saying I believe all this, I'm on the fence, but I can see an argument for patience provided we don't completely lose the plot.

It's worth adding he really is creating a rod for his back with these away defeats, but I remember missing a goal chance like Isaac Price's playing on the pitch at Four Dwellings in 1981. My excuse is I was 15 and a fringe player who got a few outings in the school team.

At least my effort clipped off the top of the bar. Even now as my pension looms I think I'd have had a chance of burying that one today. The professional pitches now are far better than a school pitch in Quinton over 4 decades ago.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke - 12-21-2025

I think the above reasoning (plus the embarresment of the exec who appointed him) is the reason he'll stay. Outside looking in it appears we've got 'one of those' boards if we sack a guy in his first job after a few months when we're nearer a play off place than the bottom three (in points).

The question is, has he got enough about him to turn it around, and do we have a better alternative? I'm not filled with confidence with either. Going to be a long season that seems to have run out of steam before Christmas.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Hughie Reed 31 - 12-21-2025

I think we are getting past the argument for keeping him
Lost 8 consecutive away games failing to beat both Sheffield Wednesday & Oxford
At home his constant baffling substitutions
If he doesn’t think Bany & Dike are any good don’t put them on the bench
Give some kids a chance until January then change it if not working

I keep saying 16th in this league is not acceptable but going even lower is frightening


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Josh1873 - 12-21-2025

We beat Oxford.

Our home form is pretty good, so he's obviously doing something right in our home games, both in terms of setting us up before KO and in-game management.

I can't defend our away form, it's unacceptable, regardless of how you dress it up. That being said, I do feel like our away schedule has been quite brutal.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Old Fart - 12-21-2025

I saw Alan F Irvine sitting next to David Moyes on MOTD last night.  

He too is a coach destined never to have what it takes to be a successful manager. 

The unfounded optimism that somehow Mason is going to stumble across a winning formula is deluded. 

He's going to get sacked.  It's just a case of how much damage is going to be caused first by a stupidly tolerant but naive club hierarchy.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Lurker#3 - 12-21-2025

(12-20-2025, 11:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:  ...provided he can be shown he is learning?

This is the key thing... How long do we wait to see improvement?


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Hughie Reed 31 - 12-21-2025

(12-21-2025, 10:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: We beat Oxford.

Our home form is pretty good, so he's obviously doing something right in our home games, both in terms of setting us up before KO and in-game management.

I can't defend our away form, it's unacceptable, regardless of how you dress it up. That being said, I do feel like our away schedule has been quite brutal.

So we did my mistake
Still think something has to change.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Stillclem4england - 12-21-2025

(12-21-2025, 10:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-20-2025, 11:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:  ...provided he can be shown he is learning?

This is the key thing... How long do we wait to see improvement?
Correct. I think a style of play would be helpful too.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Scrantonbaggie - 12-21-2025

(12-21-2025, 10:22 AM)Old Fart Wrote: I saw Alan F Irvine sitting next to David Moyes on MOTD last night.  

He too is a coach destined never to have what it takes to be a successful manager. 

The unfounded optimism that somehow Mason is going to stumble across a winning formula is deluded. 

He's going to get sacked.  It's just a case of how much damage is going to be caused first by a stupidly tolerant but naive club hierarchy.

Who will go first.mason or Davies.i know blues fans want him gone..if Mason goes soon then surely Shilen must sanction Nestor in some way..


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - MrBater - 12-21-2025

TBF in the last games we've only conceded because of a penalty.... So maybe things are improving defensively? And no, I've not touched a drop today !