WBAUnofficial
Corberan with this squad. Question? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Corberan with this squad. Question? (/showthread.php?tid=39413)

Pages: 1 2 3


Corberan with this squad. Question? - Bob Fossil - 11-22-2025

CC has a lot of staunch supporters on this dump so question is:

Where would this squad be with him?

I’d say top 10 still looking at top 6, and I was not a super fan.

If you agree, then surely we need to be looking for another like him rather than giving “time” to this novice before it’s too late.

Or is it all on the squad and they are a lost cause regardless of who’s in charge?

Genuine discussion point not clickbait. I think, if defending Mason, it’s fair to ask what a better coach could achieve and CC is a fair comparison, not a Klopp or Mourhino.


RE: Corberan with this squad. Question? - Birdman1811 - 11-22-2025

We'd defend much better that's for sure, we'd be smarter during games, that alone puts us in top 10. I'd say he'd have us in or very close to playoffs with this squad.


RE: Corberan with this squad. Question? - Jacko - 11-22-2025

In this division. Top 3. The standard is far worse than last season.


RE: Corberan with this squad. Question? - Duffers - 11-22-2025

One thing Corberan instilled that we haven’t had before or since was discipline.

No chance of a stupid sending off like that on his watch, but we’ve had loads since he left.


RE: Corberan with this squad. Question? - Stillclem4england - 11-22-2025

Carlos generally outsmarted his opponent each week.

Mason is generally outsmarted each week.


RE: Corberan with this squad. Question? - Tom Joad 25 - 11-22-2025

Top 6. We concede goals we never used to. We are regularly chasing the play whereas under CC we ran the games. We have a plethora of striking options now as opposed to having to use Jed as CF. Pointless exercise though, we may as well ask where Big Fat Ron would have us.


RE: Corberan with this squad. Question? - Lurker#3 - 11-22-2025

Top 6.


RE: Corberan with this squad. Question? - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-22-2025

Impossible to say, but better than this. Not sure we’d have scored many more but almost certainly we’d have conceded far less.

On the basis that at least two of the losses had turned out to be draws, and one of the draws a win (Pompey being an example of a game that we would have seen out for three points under CC), that puts us about 4th, or possibly even third.

Despite a weaker squad, I think CC would have fared far better this year. Mainly because, bar Cov, nobody really looks all that; and due to his astute preparation CC was very good at winning the percentages. If anything his in-game management was found asking at times, but it was better than this, and both would be the difference. But once again it’s all what-ifs because he turned out to be a little too good for us.


RE: Corberan with this squad. Question? - Tom of the Brom - 11-22-2025

(11-22-2025, 05:18 PM)Duffers Wrote: One thing Corberan instilled that we haven’t had before or since was discipline.

No chance of a stupid sending off like that on his watch, but we’ve had loads since he left.

Except when picked the ball up while in play  Big Grin


RE: Corberan with this squad. Question? - CA Baggie - 11-22-2025

(11-22-2025, 05:26 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Top 6. We concede goals we never used to. We are regularly chasing the play whereas under CC we ran the games. We have a plethora of striking options now as opposed to having to use Jed as CF. Pointless exercise though, we may as well ask where Big Fat Ron would have us.

It’s not about thinking CC is coming back but to add perspective to how Mason is performing with this squad.  

A better question should be do we have the right to expect a CC level manager given our current position and finances.  

Is Mason the best we can afford/attract? 

For those saying to give him more time, I’d genuinely like to know what they’ve seen to work with and continue this experiment.  Not just “we can’t keep changing”.