WBAUnofficial
Top Six squad? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Top Six squad? (/showthread.php?tid=37367)

Pages: 1 2


Top Six squad? - ericlegrisly - 04-20-2025

Is it though?

Excluding loans, do the individuals in our matchday squad really lend themselves to being a top six squad?  I'm not sure they do.

Griffiths - don't know yet - maybe
Wildsmith - No
Furlong - Yes
Bartley - No (Certainly not any more)
Heggem - Yes
Ajayi - No
Frabotta - No
Styles - No
Mowatt - Yes
Mulumby - No
Diakite - No
Grant - No
Johnston - Yes
Fellows - Yes
Price - Yes
Diangana - No (or very infrequently)
Swift - No
Wallace - No
Maja - Yes
Dike - Yes
Cole - No
Bany - Don't yet know.

Some are closer to yes than no, and almost all are debatable, but I think, in reality, that's a bang average Champo set of players.

Mid Table Championship club and all that.


RE: Top Six squad? - Bangkokbaggy - 04-20-2025

(04-20-2025, 11:33 AM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it though?

Excluding loans, do the individuals in our matchday squad really lend themselves to being a top six squad?  I'm not sure they do.

Griffiths - don't know yet - maybe
Wildsmith - No
Furlong - Yes
Bartley - No (Certainly not any more)
Heggem - Yes
Ajayi - No
Frabotta - No
Styles - No
Mowatt - Yes
Mulumby - No
Diakite - No
Grant - No
Johnston - Yes
Fellows - Yes
Price - Yes
Diangana - No (or very infrequently)
Swift - No
Wallace - No
Maja - Yes
Dike - Yes
Cole - No
Bany - Don't yet know.

Some are closer to yes than no, and almost all are debatable, but I think, in reality, that's a bang average Champo set of players.

Mid Table Championship club and all that.

Good mangers make a team greater than it's constituent parts! CC did Mowbray cant


RE: Top Six squad? - Heggam Bacon - 04-20-2025

(04-20-2025, 11:33 AM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it though?

Excluding loans, do the individuals in our matchday squad really lend themselves to being a top six squad?  I'm not sure they do.

Griffiths - don't know yet - maybe
Wildsmith - No
Furlong - Yes
Bartley - No (Certainly not any more)
Heggem - Yes
Ajayi - No
Frabotta - No
Styles - No
Mowatt - Yes
Mulumby - No
Diakite - No
Grant - No
Johnston - Yes
Fellows - Yes
Price - Yes
Diangana - No (or very infrequently)
Swift - No
Wallace - No
Maja - Yes
Dike - Yes
Cole - No
Bany - Don't yet know.

Some are closer to yes than no, and almost all are debatable, but I think, in reality, that's a bang average Champo set of players.

Mid Table Championship club and all that.

Harsh on Molumby & Styles.


RE: Top Six squad? - Derek Hardballs - 04-20-2025

Now put GMs first promotion winning team up and see how many would be said to be top six. If a manager has no input into where a squad finishes we may as well not have one.

I’m not saying I agree with the original list, I think there is some over estimation of other teams squads.


RE: Top Six squad? - Josh1873 - 04-20-2025

Styles, Diakite, Molumby, Grant definitely are top 6 quality players.

Ajayi could be under the right system and manager.


RE: Top Six squad? - Heggam Bacon - 04-20-2025

And Diakite must be a least a maybe


RE: Top Six squad? - richbaggie - 04-20-2025

There's absolutely no way this squad is just mid table in a very ordinary division.


RE: Top Six squad? - Stillclem4england - 04-20-2025

(04-20-2025, 11:37 AM)Bangkokbaggy Wrote:
(04-20-2025, 11:33 AM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it though?

Excluding loans, do the individuals in our matchday squad really lend themselves to being a top six squad?  I'm not sure they do.

Griffiths - don't know yet - maybe
Wildsmith - No
Furlong - Yes
Bartley - No (Certainly not any more)
Heggem - Yes
Ajayi - No
Frabotta - No
Styles - No
Mowatt - Yes
Mulumby - No
Diakite - No
Grant - No
Johnston - Yes
Fellows - Yes
Price - Yes
Diangana - No (or very infrequently)
Swift - No
Wallace - No
Maja - Yes
Dike - Yes
Cole - No
Bany - Don't yet know.

Some are closer to yes than no, and almost all are debatable, but I think, in reality, that's a bang average Champo set of players.

Mid Table Championship club and all that.

Good mangers make a team greater than it's constituent parts! CC did Mowbray cant
Spot on that.

Is Bristol’s squad better? Millwall’s? No for me.


RE: Top Six squad? - EastMidsBaggie - 04-20-2025

(04-20-2025, 11:33 AM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it though?

Excluding loans, do the individuals in our matchday squad really lend themselves to being a top six squad?  I'm not sure they do.

Griffiths - don't know yet - maybe
Wildsmith - No
Furlong - Yes
Bartley - No (Certainly not any more)
Heggem - Yes
Ajayi - No
Frabotta - No
Styles - No
Mowatt - Yes
Mulumby - No
Diakite - No
Grant - No
Johnston - Yes
Fellows - Yes
Price - Yes
Diangana - No (or very infrequently)
Swift - No
Wallace - No
Maja - Yes
Dike - Yes
Cole - No
Bany - Don't yet know.

Some are closer to yes than no, and almost all are debatable, but I think, in reality, that's a bang average Champo set of players.

Mid Table Championship club and all that.

You’d have to do a like for like analysis with the other top 6 challengers and also have a ‘benchmark’ quality Top 6 squad to compare.

I don’t see many outstanding squads in the teams just above us and just below us including the over achieving Sunderland squad.


RE: Top Six squad? - richbaggie - 04-20-2025

(04-20-2025, 11:54 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(04-20-2025, 11:37 AM)Bangkokbaggy Wrote:
(04-20-2025, 11:33 AM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it though?

Excluding loans, do the individuals in our matchday squad really lend themselves to being a top six squad?  I'm not sure they do.

Griffiths - don't know yet - maybe
Wildsmith - No
Furlong - Yes
Bartley - No (Certainly not any more)
Heggem - Yes
Ajayi - No
Frabotta - No
Styles - No
Mowatt - Yes
Mulumby - No
Diakite - No
Grant - No
Johnston - Yes
Fellows - Yes
Price - Yes
Diangana - No (or very infrequently)
Swift - No
Wallace - No
Maja - Yes
Dike - Yes
Cole - No
Bany - Don't yet know.

Some are closer to yes than no, and almost all are debatable, but I think, in reality, that's a bang average Champo set of players.

Mid Table Championship club and all that.

Good mangers make a team greater than it's constituent parts! CC did Mowbray cant
Spot on that.

Is Bristol’s squad better? Millwall’s? No for me.

Exactly. Mid table means those you mention plus Blackburn, Swansea, Norwich have better squads as they above midway. 

There's a difference between an underperforming squad and a squad not good enough. Ours is the former even if it's the weakest squad we've had since the turn of the century.