![]() |
|
Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. (/showthread.php?tid=36923) Pages:
1
2
|
Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - Lurker#3 - 03-12-2025 Once again we competed brilliantly and defended admirably against a very good opposition. Credit goes to ToMo for changing the shape, correctly, and going with a back 3. It worked really well. Playing out if this shape we seemed to have better patterns of play especially in central areas. We looked to ping the ball into Grady, he must have received 10s of passes into his feet in all sorts of difficult positions but managed to recycle possession, usually under pressure from 2 or 3 opponents. This allowed us to get overloads in wider areas with the wingbacks. As usual however we struggled to commit enough players forward and once we worked the ball into the final third our lack of quality showed. It's an ongoing problem and I still think we need MJ and Grady in that team. In terms of the shape, add Fellows at RWB, MJ for Grant (who was great defensively btw) and Price into the middle and we really could be onto something. Ratings: Wildsmith - 5 - Not a fat lot to do, but that error. My goodness. Only ToMo to blame though as he's been largely poor and made a few mistakes. Needs dropping, he's a competent #2, that's it. Holgate - 8 - Solid for the most part, but a number of brain fart passes as usual. No real errors though and he also played a few really good, incisive passes so those bad passes come as a consequence of his ambition I guess. Diakite - 8 - As I've made clear I think he's got real potential, not sure what his role should be, but a really good option. Solid as a rock, brave, and some really good transitional passes. He really leaned on Holgate and Heggem who both did a great job managing him through the game. Heggem - 8 - Solid as a rock, and seemed to clear everything that was chucked in from their left. Defensive monster. But was a bit slow on the ball a few times when we had chances to get the ball through the lines with Swift and Styles. Price - 7 - Good shift and if he got close to it he tackled it, so competitive, no real impact on the ball. A real find in terms of his versatility and match IQ. I just hope he doesn't suffer because he can play on so many positions. Mowatt - 7 - Collosal shift and some brilliant defensive work. Radar wasn't switched on in possession for the most part though and got caught on the ball a few times. Swift - 8 - I have called for him in the deeper role for 18 months. That's why. Such a clever footballer. Plays cute, incisive passes. Fills gaps defensively. Makes good angles for the defenders to play easy passes into him and plays forward passes nobody else sees. Almost MOTM. Styles - 8 - MOTM for me. Only thing stopping him getting 9/10 was his final pass. His defensive work was superb, including a goal saving challenge at the back post. His running on transitions was key to us getting up the pitch, but when he did break the midfield line he played 2/3 really poor final passes where we had good space in behind. Getting better and better. Armstrong - 5 - Poor. Grady - 7 - Took the ball in some impossible positions, got us turned, brought players into the game and played a couple of really well weighted through balls, could have easily had a couple of assists/goal contribution actions. Cant score higher as his actual output wasn't high enough accept for his defensive work as usual. Grant - 7 - The blokes a work horse. Love his attitude. Subs: Lankshear - 6 - Put himself about and caused a stink. Not much service as we were getting pushed back as the game went on. MJ - 6 - Adds so much threat, nearly won us the game. ToMo - 8 - Great starting formation, and I think given the absences of; Fellows, Furlong and Bartley he put the right team out in defensive and midfield lines. I really like the split forwards shape with a #10. RE: Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - ElbowGrease1973 II - 03-12-2025 Can't argue with much of that Lurker, pretty much as I saw things too. I would have given Grady a 6 personally, but other than this pretty much spot on. I'd drop both Wildsmith and Armstrong for Saturday's game. I've been disappointed with Armstrong's contribution to date, but think he'll be a great option off the bench RE: Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - aj21 - 03-12-2025 Wildsmith 3 MJ 7 Rest spot on. RE: Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - Stillclem4england - 03-12-2025 Mowatt and Mikey too low (both 8) otherwise spot on. RE: Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - SW4Baggie - 03-12-2025 Sounds the "back three is the right shape for us" claxon again ![]() Not sure where Bartley comes back into the back 3 however... Diakite's energy and Holgate's passing are more important to that system than Bartley's overall ability but he's been one of the best CBs in the division this year. As you say Lurker, Fellows or Furlong as RWB and bringing Price into the centre with both Mikey and Grant depending on the opposition, and that side looks very strong. RE: Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - Josh1873 - 03-12-2025 Wildsmith a 0. I'm done with him. Another two points dropped because he isn't competent. Had Griffiths been between the sticks we'd have at least 4 more points than we currently have just from Leeds and Burnley alone. Mowbray has to make the change on Saturday, surely. There's Absolutely zero reason not to. RE: Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - Ted Maul - 03-12-2025 (03-12-2025, 08:33 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Sounds the "back three is the right shape for us" claxon again I agree and have been banging this drum for a while. Disagree re Fellows though, I think he'd be the real loser from us going with a back three. He's not a wing back and I don't think he's got the all round game to play as a ten in the role that Grady or Johnston sometimes play. Allowing for those out of contract and assuming they wont resign the nucleus of a team for next season could look like... Griffiths Taylor Diakite Heggem Furlong Price Mowatt Styles Maja Dike Johnston Potential sale of Fellows to fund a couple of centre halves and the likes of Grant, Bany, Molumby on the bench all of a sudden it looks a half decent squad. RE: Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - Lurker#3 - 03-12-2025 I think Fellows could be more suited to the wingback role, Ted. He doesn't have the technical ability or goal scoring ability to be a wide forward. He also has a good grip of the defensive side of the game. Having the CB/FB occupied by a front three with him arriving later in wide areas with more space on the touchline could be great offensively. I think the back 3 shape offers more tactical flexibility. Against the top teams, three out and out CBs, with Furlong at RWB gives us more defensive structure. Against the teams we need to be breaking down. A back three of Furlong Holgate and Heggem could be more than enough defensively and offer us more in the way of passing ability from the back. RE: Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - Ted Maul - 03-12-2025 It's a fair shout. Might be a moot point as I see the sale of Fellows in the summer being key to us continuing to overhaul the squad. If the sale of Fellows means we can bring in a couple of centre halves that we desperately need then, like with Palmer, it is a sale that makes sense. RE: Burnleh - ratings and thoughts. - sickParrot - 03-12-2025 I dot think Mowbray fancies Fellows defensively, he said something similar about his sub on Saturday. |