WBAUnofficial
Folly to talk about medium term plans… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Folly to talk about medium term plans… (/showthread.php?tid=36018)

Pages: 1 2


Folly to talk about medium term plans… - Derek Hardballs - 12-24-2024

if you are going to include managers and their background staff. If we are to go down the money ball route this is now the time to change how the football department works. We have a chance of really putting medium and long term plans in place now, where we will no longer have to overly rely on the current manager/head coach for success.

I don’t think you can ever build around a manager operating in this way, as soon as they have a modicum of success they will leave for bigger/richer clubs. Look at the hole CC departure will bring, it’s not a sustainable model without parachute payments/the attraction of being a Prem club. Time to think differently, put down a blueprint for how we play in the future and don’t put all our eggs into one basket.

You cannot and should not build around a manager at the level we now find ourselves, it was never going to work… get success they leave, don’t have success they get sacked, both scenarios are hugely disruptive if we are relying on this daft… give the manager three, four transfer windows…


RE: Folly to talk about medium term plans… - Squid - 12-24-2024

(12-24-2024, 04:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: if you are going to include managers and their background staff. If we are to go down the money ball route this is now the time to change how the football department works. We have a chance of really putting medium and long term plans in place now, where we will no longer have to overly rely on the current manager/head coach for success.

I don’t think you can ever build around a manager operating in this way, as soon as they have a modicum of success they will leave for bigger/richer clubs. Look at the hole CC departure will bring, it’s not a sustainable model without parachute payments/the attraction of being a Prem club. Time to think differently, put down a blueprint for how we play in the future and don’t put all our eggs into one basket.

You cannot and should not build around a manager at the level we now find ourselves, it was never going to work… get success they leave, don’t have success they get sacked, both scenarios are hugely disruptive if we are relying on this daft… give the manager three, four transfer windows…

"Time to think differently"

This is what most people have been clamouring for on here for years and you would always snort about the impossibility of long term projects

It is very obvious that any club of limited means cannot afford to chop and change between styles of play. Instead there needs to be an overall plan for off and on the pitch that operates regardless of playing or managerial staff.

We have a well-organised, build from the back team and whoever we bring in needs to be able to work with that, not dismantle it.


RE: Folly to talk about medium term plans… - Jerry - 12-24-2024

(12-24-2024, 05:06 PM)Squid Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 04:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: if you are going to include managers and their background staff. If we are to go down the money ball route this is now the time to change how the football department works. We have a chance of really putting medium and long term plans in place now, where we will no longer have to overly rely on the current manager/head coach for success.

I don’t think you can ever build around a manager operating in this way, as soon as they have a modicum of success they will leave for bigger/richer clubs. Look at the hole CC departure will bring, it’s not a sustainable model without parachute payments/the attraction of being a Prem club. Time to think differently, put down a blueprint for how we play in the future and don’t put all our eggs into one basket.

You cannot and should not build around a manager at the level we now find ourselves, it was never going to work… get success they leave, don’t have success they get sacked, both scenarios are hugely disruptive if we are relying on this daft… give the manager three, four transfer windows…

"Time to think differently"

This is what most people have been clamouring for on here for years and you would always snort about the impossibility of long term projects

It is very obvious that any club of limited means cannot afford to chop and change between styles of play. Instead there needs to be an overall plan for off and on the pitch that operates regardless of playing or managerial staff.

We have a well-organised, build from the back team and whoever we bring in needs to be able to work with that, not dismantle it.

This would be going back to Jeremy Peace’s time where we did employ managers to style of play. If you remember managers were only allowed to bring in one coach the rest were Albion coaches. Did it work, well in someways yes but in the end we had to get Pulis in to save us and it stopped. We should have a basic identity in the way we play then get the best manage we can.


RE: Folly to talk about medium term plans… - CarlosCorbewrong - 12-24-2024

Yeah, let’s give the bloke who signed Frambotta more power.


RE: Folly to talk about medium term plans… - Derek Hardballs - 12-24-2024

(12-24-2024, 05:06 PM)Squid Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 04:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: if you are going to include managers and their background staff. If we are to go down the money ball route this is now the time to change how the football department works. We have a chance of really putting medium and long term plans in place now, where we will no longer have to overly rely on the current manager/head coach for success.

I don’t think you can ever build around a manager operating in this way, as soon as they have a modicum of success they will leave for bigger/richer clubs. Look at the hole CC departure will bring, it’s not a sustainable model without parachute payments/the attraction of being a Prem club. Time to think differently, put down a blueprint for how we play in the future and don’t put all our eggs into one basket.

You cannot and should not build around a manager at the level we now find ourselves, it was never going to work… get success they leave, don’t have success they get sacked, both scenarios are hugely disruptive if we are relying on this daft… give the manager three, four transfer windows…

"Time to think differently"

This is what most people have been clamouring for on here for years and you would always snort about the impossibility of long term projects

It is very obvious that any club of limited means cannot afford to chop and change between styles of play. Instead there needs to be an overall plan for off and on the pitch that operates regardless of playing or managerial staff.

We have a well-organised, build from the back team and whoever we bring in needs to be able to work with that, not dismantle it.

I said we needed the best people to make the system work… we were trying to make it happen whilst we had Richard Garlick as Director of Football buying the like of Gamboa, Davidson, Blanco etc, at the same time the club allowed half the squad to leave and employed Mel and Irvine. That was half arsed planning and hardly money ball. 

We have owners at last who may actually put the best people we can afford in the system. Trying to do long term projects when you have two owners looking to sell the club desperately and refusing to invest was never going to work. 

As I said umpteen times any system be it old fashioned or progressive needs the best personnel and owners we haven’t had either since perhaps Ashworth but we then went and replaced him on the cheap due to the owner wanting out.


RE: Folly to talk about medium term plans… - Lurker#3 - 12-24-2024

(12-24-2024, 04:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: if you are going to include managers and their background staff. If we are to go down the money ball route this is now the time to change how the football department works. We have a chance of really putting medium and long term plans in place now, where we will no longer have to overly rely on the current manager/head coach for success.

I don’t think you can ever build around a manager operating in this way, as soon as they have a modicum of success they will leave for bigger/richer clubs. Look at the hole CC departure will bring, it’s not a sustainable model without parachute payments/the attraction of being a Prem club. Time to think differently, put down a blueprint for how we play in the future and don’t put all our eggs into one basket.

You cannot and should not build around a manager at the level we now find ourselves, it was never going to work… get success they leave, don’t have success they get sacked, both scenarios are hugely disruptive if we are relying on this daft… give the manager three, four transfer windows…

Do you mean we need a club philosophy?  Big Grin


RE: Folly to talk about medium term plans… - Derek Hardballs - 12-24-2024

(12-24-2024, 06:17 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 04:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: if you are going to include managers and their background staff. If we are to go down the money ball route this is now the time to change how the football department works. We have a chance of really putting medium and long term plans in place now, where we will no longer have to overly rely on the current manager/head coach for success.

I don’t think you can ever build around a manager operating in this way, as soon as they have a modicum of success they will leave for bigger/richer clubs. Look at the hole CC departure will bring, it’s not a sustainable model without parachute payments/the attraction of being a Prem club. Time to think differently, put down a blueprint for how we play in the future and don’t put all our eggs into one basket.

You cannot and should not build around a manager at the level we now find ourselves, it was never going to work… get success they leave, don’t have success they get sacked, both scenarios are hugely disruptive if we are relying on this daft… give the manager three, four transfer windows…

Do you mean we need a club philosophy?  Big Grin

We just need the club to play in a certain way… I mean you could dress it up with pretentious tosh about philosophies if you want to but surely it is blindingly obvious you don’t go from say Pulis to Bilic straight after each other and hope to do well.


RE: Folly to talk about medium term plans… - Lurker#3 - 12-24-2024

(12-24-2024, 06:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 06:17 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 04:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: if you are going to include managers and their background staff. If we are to go down the money ball route this is now the time to change how the football department works. We have a chance of really putting medium and long term plans in place now, where we will no longer have to overly rely on the current manager/head coach for success.

I don’t think you can ever build around a manager operating in this way, as soon as they have a modicum of success they will leave for bigger/richer clubs. Look at the hole CC departure will bring, it’s not a sustainable model without parachute payments/the attraction of being a Prem club. Time to think differently, put down a blueprint for how we play in the future and don’t put all our eggs into one basket.

You cannot and should not build around a manager at the level we now find ourselves, it was never going to work… get success they leave, don’t have success they get sacked, both scenarios are hugely disruptive if we are relying on this daft… give the manager three, four transfer windows…

Do you mean we need a club philosophy?  Big Grin

We just need the club to play in a certain way… I mean you could dress it up with pretentious tosh about philosophies if you want to but surely it is blindingly obvious you don’t go from say Pulis to Bilic straight after each other and hope to do well.

That's a lot of words to describe a philosophy  Wink


RE: Folly to talk about medium term plans… - Spandaubaggie - 12-24-2024

Simply we have to create an infrastructure where changing coach can’t destabilise the team and club. Peace seemed to have done that then got Pulis!


RE: Folly to talk about medium term plans… - Derek Hardballs - 12-24-2024

(12-24-2024, 08:13 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Simply we have to create an infrastructure where changing coach can’t destabilise the team and club. Peace seemed to have done that then got Pulis!

Really? Mel, Irvine, Garlick, Burton, half the squad went for free and we ended up with a squad of Gamboa, Blanco, Samaras, Davidson etc. if that was a stabilising infrastructure I think we need a flimsy plan on the back of a beer mat.