WBAUnofficial
Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… (/showthread.php?tid=35945)

Pages: 1 2 3


Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - Derek Hardballs - 12-18-2024

The more I read on here the more it becomes apparent whether right, centre or left politically opinions are based from a relative safe distance from the sharp end of those decisions made by government. It’s like every situation is an exercise in academic study, cushioned by relative financial and personal comfort, and with agency to make decisions to compensate for any adverse effects of policy. 

Not everyone is in that position and not everyone has the agency to escape these decisions and no, not everyone can escape their circumstances. Labour imo currently are taking many of their less well educated and well off voters for granted whilst the Tories showed they cared little for anyone but themselves and their friends. Neither frankly are deserving of any praise or credit. 

Look at the insults and remarks levelled at anyone disappointed with Labour's first six months. I’m paraphrasing of course but here’s a few ‘if those criticising can’t look past the right wing media/SM then that’s their problem’ the implication that people are too stupid to make their own minds up on the ability of the current governments performance. Then there is the as ever you’re a NIMBY for wanting to protect small pockets of green spaces and agricultural land in already working class built up areas. (Top tip I couldn’t give a shit what you call me and neither will others when they have houses built in unsuitable areas when there were other better more sustainable long term options).


RE: Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-18-2024

It's a very diverse political spread on this board, and it does lead itself to some interesting discussions from time to time, that's for sure.


RE: Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - Derek Hardballs - 12-18-2024

(12-18-2024, 01:51 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It's a very diverse political spread on this board, and it does lead itself to some interesting discussions from time to time, that's for sure.

The political arc might be wide but given the opinions given are very much from a reasonable comfortable, similar aged demographic perhaps?


RE: Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-18-2024

(12-18-2024, 02:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-18-2024, 01:51 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It's a very diverse political spread on this board, and it does lead itself to some interesting discussions from time to time, that's for sure.

The political arc might be wide but given the opinions given are very much from a reasonable comfortable, similar aged demographic perhaps?

I do lean to the right, but I'm far from comfortable, Dekka. I have to work to pay the bills and the mortgage.


RE: Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - Borin' Baggie - 12-18-2024

The policy consequences from our decades of neglecting critical infrastructure development (housing, energy, transport) affect every single person in this country, fixing that should be the priority to ensure that we can address the issue of people getting less for more and so we're able to actually fund social programmes sustainably and over the medium and long term.

You were literally whining about a park being funded by new housing developments via an S106 as "not helping the working classes", presumably because it's in Warwick District, completely ignorant to the fact that those houses being built are adjacent to working class areas of Leamington (posh people don't live next to industrial estates in former postwar built Council Housing stock) and are there to make it so that young working class people can afford houses where there are jobs, because they sure as hell aren't affording 2-bed terraces going for £375k.

The UK needs to build more houses, the UK needs to densify it's cities to levels similar to other European countries and it needs to build new communities along transport corridors in a similar vein to garden cities principles but it also needs to build houses adjacent to urban areas as we need to get to building 380k per year to stabilise house prices and urban areas are where there are jobs. You objecting to that makes you a NIMBY and I'm absolutely fed up of NIMBYs like you wanting the UK move into managed decline with our lack of critical infrastructure and, therefore, make it impossible to stimulate the growth required to fund critical social programmes. The average age of a first time homeowner is creeping ever closer to middle age because of obstructionist policy on building shit because we pander to NIMBYs.


RE: Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-18-2024

(12-18-2024, 02:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The policy consequences from our decades of neglecting critical infrastructure development (housing, energy, transport) affect every single person in this country, fixing that should be the priority to ensure that we can address the issue of people getting less for more and so we're able to actually fund social programmes sustainably and over the medium and long term.

You were literally whining about a park being funded by new housing developments via an S106 as "not helping the working classes", presumably because it's in Warwick District, completely ignorant to the fact that those houses being built are adjacent to working class areas of Leamington (posh people don't live next to industrial estates in former postwar built Council Housing stock) and are there to make it so that young working class people can afford houses where there are jobs, because they sure as hell aren't affording 2-bed terraces going for £375k.

The UK needs to build more houses, the UK needs to densify it's cities to levels similar to other European countries and it needs to build new communities along transport corridors in a similar vein to garden cities principles but it also needs to build houses adjacent to urban areas as we need to get to building 380k per year to stabilise house prices and urban areas are where there are jobs. You objecting to that makes you a NIMBY and I'm absolutely fed up of NIMBYs like you wanting the UK move into managed decline with our lack of critical infrastructure and, therefore, make it impossible to stimulate the growth required to fund critical social programmes. The average age of a first time homeowner is creeping ever closer to middle age because of obstructionist policy on building shit because we pander to NIMBYs.

And who is going to build these houses? The magic pixies?? Certainly not commercial organisations at those prices. They are responsible to their shareholders and the returns aren't economic for them.

I'm not a NIMBY, I've never objected to a planning application in my life.

Don't keep tell us what is needed, tell us HOW to achieve it. Like a Labour Party manifesto, you are lacking in critical detail. You just don't have the answers, just the ideology.


RE: Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - Protheroe - 12-18-2024

(12-18-2024, 01:20 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The more I read on here the more it becomes apparent whether right, centre or left politically opinions are based from a relative safe distance from the sharp end of those decisions made by government.

So you're only allowed an opinion if you're a direct victim / beneficiary of an individual policy?


RE: Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - Borin' Baggie - 12-18-2024

(12-18-2024, 02:36 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-18-2024, 02:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The policy consequences from our decades of neglecting critical infrastructure development (housing, energy, transport) affect every single person in this country, fixing that should be the priority to ensure that we can address the issue of people getting less for more and so we're able to actually fund social programmes sustainably and over the medium and long term.

You were literally whining about a park being funded by new housing developments via an S106 as "not helping the working classes", presumably because it's in Warwick District, completely ignorant to the fact that those houses being built are adjacent to working class areas of Leamington (posh people don't live next to industrial estates in former postwar built Council Housing stock) and are there to make it so that young working class people can afford houses where there are jobs, because they sure as hell aren't affording 2-bed terraces going for £375k.

The UK needs to build more houses, the UK needs to densify it's cities to levels similar to other European countries and it needs to build new communities along transport corridors in a similar vein to garden cities principles but it also needs to build houses adjacent to urban areas as we need to get to building 380k per year to stabilise house prices and urban areas are where there are jobs. You objecting to that makes you a NIMBY and I'm absolutely fed up of NIMBYs like you wanting the UK move into managed decline with our lack of critical infrastructure and, therefore, make it impossible to stimulate the growth required to fund critical social programmes. The average age of a first time homeowner is creeping ever closer to middle age because of obstructionist policy on building shit because we pander to NIMBYs.

And who is going to build these houses? The magic pixies?? Certainly not commercial organisations at those prices. They are responsible to their shareholders and the returns aren't economic for them.

I'm not a NIMBY, I've never objected to a planning application in my life.

Don't keep tell us what is needed, tell us HOW to achieve it. Like a Labour Party manifesto, you are lacking in critical detail. You just don't have the answers, just the ideology.

I'm not calling you a NIMBY, I'm calling Dekka a NIMBY because he constantly whinges at anyone proposing building houses in the second/third largest urban area in the country.

I'd first and foremost relax the regulatory requirements to build shit through streamlining environmental mitigation strategies and planning to help small businesses to navigate the market as, currently, they can't. I also want more public investment whether that be preparation of key sites through state funds or councils leading on regionally-set zoned and planned estates for the private sector to develop on (in conjunction with elimination of the speculative value penalty levied on the public sector) or through civic works building social houses as happened when we were able to build 350k a year. I also support bringing in a land value tax which would financially penalise large developers that sit on land without building on it. I also recognise the issues with labour restrictions in the construction sector, I fully support the high quality, Passivhaus standard pre-fabs that are going up in Switzerland and Austria, in conjunction with relaxing immigration restrictions on skilled labour and putting more money into training to incentivise tradies taking on apprenticeships by reducing the financial risk associated with that.

Happy? Or are you just going to go on yet another incoherent rant about something you invented in your own head?


RE: Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - CarlosCorbewrong - 12-18-2024

I'd wholeheartedly recommend not taking this board seriously. The whole thing is beyond ridiculous, it's hard to know where to start...


RE: Detached from the consequences of policy decisions… - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-18-2024

(12-18-2024, 02:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-18-2024, 02:36 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-18-2024, 02:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The policy consequences from our decades of neglecting critical infrastructure development (housing, energy, transport) affect every single person in this country, fixing that should be the priority to ensure that we can address the issue of people getting less for more and so we're able to actually fund social programmes sustainably and over the medium and long term.

You were literally whining about a park being funded by new housing developments via an S106 as "not helping the working classes", presumably because it's in Warwick District, completely ignorant to the fact that those houses being built are adjacent to working class areas of Leamington (posh people don't live next to industrial estates in former postwar built Council Housing stock) and are there to make it so that young working class people can afford houses where there are jobs, because they sure as hell aren't affording 2-bed terraces going for £375k.

The UK needs to build more houses, the UK needs to densify it's cities to levels similar to other European countries and it needs to build new communities along transport corridors in a similar vein to garden cities principles but it also needs to build houses adjacent to urban areas as we need to get to building 380k per year to stabilise house prices and urban areas are where there are jobs. You objecting to that makes you a NIMBY and I'm absolutely fed up of NIMBYs like you wanting the UK move into managed decline with our lack of critical infrastructure and, therefore, make it impossible to stimulate the growth required to fund critical social programmes. The average age of a first time homeowner is creeping ever closer to middle age because of obstructionist policy on building shit because we pander to NIMBYs.

And who is going to build these houses? The magic pixies?? Certainly not commercial organisations at those prices. They are responsible to their shareholders and the returns aren't economic for them.

I'm not a NIMBY, I've never objected to a planning application in my life.

Don't keep tell us what is needed, tell us HOW to achieve it. Like a Labour Party manifesto, you are lacking in critical detail. You just don't have the answers, just the ideology.

I'm not calling you a NIMBY, I'm calling Dekka a NIMBY because he constantly whinges at anyone proposing building houses in the second/third largest urban area in the country.

I'd first and foremost relax the regulatory requirements to build shit through streamlining environmental mitigation strategies and planning to help small businesses to navigate the market as, currently, they can't. I also want more public investment whether that be preparation of key sites through state funds or councils leading on regionally-set zoned and planned estates for the private sector to develop on (in conjunction with elimination of the speculative value penalty levied on the public sector) or through civic works building social houses as happened when we were able to build 350k a year. I also support bringing in a land value tax which would financially penalise large developers that sit on land without building on it. I also recognise the issues with labour restrictions in the construction sector, I fully support the high quality, Passivhaus standard pre-fabs that are going up in Switzerland and Austria, in conjunction with relaxing immigration restrictions on skilled labour and putting more money into training to incentivise tradies taking on apprenticeships by reducing the financial risk associated with that.

Happy? Or are you just going to go on yet another incoherent rant about something you invented in your own head?

I agree with you on LVT.

The rest is for the birds. Their isn't the public money to invest in any of it, particularly when Labour keep spunking it on their paymasters. And has previously been said, their isn't the profit for Commercial builders in social projects.

Simplify planning?

 [Image: old-man-yells-at-cloud-v0-rj69nntmlh5c1....d0fc45cf1e]
Massive increases in new-builds just won't happen.