WBAUnofficial
Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? (/showthread.php?tid=35748)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - PatelsPlatoon - 11-27-2024

That's how I'd sum us up at the minute.

Too many getting frustrated, but think we are weakened since last season and until we can open the wallet again this is as it is.

Get the home form improved slightly and still think we can make top 6, but if we do as well as last season we've done well.

The moaners who want CC out need to give their heads a wobble in light of our restrictions due to FFP, but they really don't get it.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - Birdman1811 - 11-27-2024

Spot on.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - tHEgLASSdOORS - 11-27-2024

I think it could be simpler in its pragmatism, but overall CC is doing far more right than he is wrong


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - Ted Maul - 11-27-2024

Factor in the injuries and the loss of form of some of our key attacking players from last season and it's not hard to see why we're struggling at the moment.

We've got the foundations in place to kick on once we get players back and players find form again.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - Bob Fossil - 11-27-2024

(11-27-2024, 10:41 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: That's how I'd sum us up at the minute.

Too many getting frustrated, but think we are weakened since last season and until we can open the wallet again this is as it is.

Get the home form improved slightly and still think we can make top 6, but if we do as well as last season we've done well.

The moaners who want CC out need to give their heads a wobble in light of our restrictions due to FFP, but they really don't get it.
Genuine question here PP, I don't necessarily disagree, other than I think you have justified the frustration highlighted in sentence 2 in sentence 3, whereby we need to improve at home and that is the frustration.

Question is though, regarding your final statement, does CC have a free hit this season, regardless, due to the circumstances you describe? If not, what would prompt a rethink?

1 win in 15 / 20 / 25? Flirting with relegation? 

As I said, this is a genuine question, to all those, including myself, who think that CC has something a bit different and we need to stick with him or regret it.
I don't even know my own answer. I would like to think I could offer the free-hit, but I'm not sure I have the patience for a long winless run, or a painful drop down the table.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - richbaggie - 11-27-2024

Most of the negative opinions I see on social media are rarely backed up with any logic or thought.

"The recruitment is shocking" without taking into consideration that we are having to shop with a heavily reduced budget.

"We need to make better substitutions" despite the better players started the match and options are limited on the bench beyond those 1st 11.

"We need to sack the manager and coaching staff", who are all on pretty long contracts and we are still in danger of breaching financial rules.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - wba13 - 11-27-2024

We have stick with Carlos, he has saved us from despair, of the Bruce / Lai era when we were down and out. He has got us to a top 6 side with Ltd budget and until he can have a bit of money to spend he deserves to stay.
We have to remember where we were going 2 years ago and without Carlos and Shilen coming in we were all but down.
They have both put pride back into our club and you can see that the players love playing for Carlos by the effort they put in.
The only way for me that Carlos goes in the next 12 to 18 months is by his own making.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - Stillclem4england - 11-27-2024

Spot on this post.


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - tHEgLASSdOORS - 11-27-2024

(11-27-2024, 11:10 AM)wba13 Wrote: We have stick with Carlos, he has saved us from despair, of the Bruce / Lai era when we were down and out. He has got us to a top 6 side with Ltd budget and until he can have a bit of money to spend he deserves to stay.
We have to remember where we were going 2 years ago and without Carlos and Shilen coming in we were all but down.
They have both put pride back into our club and you can see that the players love playing for Carlos by the effort they put in.
The only way for me that Carlos goes in the next 12 to 18 months is by his own making.

All very true fella


RE: Pragmatic football for a limited squad? - Derek Hardballs - 11-27-2024

(11-27-2024, 11:03 AM)Any of our matches become richbaggie Wrote: Most of the negative opinions I see on social media are rarely backed up with any logic or thought.

"The recruitment is shocking" without taking into consideration that we are having to shop with a heavily reduced budget.

"We need to make better substitutions" despite the better players started the match and options are limited on the bench beyond those 1st 11.

"We need to sack the manager and coaching staff", who are all on pretty long contracts and we are still in danger of breaching financial rules.

The logic of making five subs at the same time every week regardless of what’s occurring on the pitch is a justified criticism of not only ourselves but most clubs in the Championship. If it’s about keeping players fit it is failing, if it’s about offering something different not necessarily better then it’s also failing. If it’s about keeping players from losing form / being jaded it’s failing. Many of our matches become completely disjointed non-events from 70 mins on. The logic behind this are the results we are currently achieving, injuries and form of players. 

Our squad is decent for the Championship not on a par perhaps with some recently relegated teams but the vast majority it stands up to comparison with. 

If performances, tactics and results were associated with say Pulis the clamour for him to be sacked on here would be a lot higher. Judge a manager by results and resources, currently I think CC is just about breaking even, certainly not over achieving as the now double digit run of draws started before our catalogue of injuries is testament to. 

I’m not calling for CC to be sacked it would be the wrong decision currently but no manager should have a free hit and I doubt the owners think they should either. There is room to question the orthodoxy of narrative on here that anyone who dares question CC is an idiotic heretic with a pitch fork in hand, willing to march up to the Halfords Lane glass doors or start an online petition.