![]() |
|
Surprise - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Surprise (/showthread.php?tid=34540) |
Surprise - Shabby Russian - 07-29-2024 Today's the day Rachel Reeves tells us about the £20b Black hole in the nation's finances, which they have now discovered after opening the 'books' Is it the same 20b the IFS warned us about during the election campaign RE: Surprise - Pontificator - 07-29-2024 (07-29-2024, 06:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Today's the day Rachel Reeves tells us about the £20b Black hole in the nation's finances, which they have now discovered after opening the 'books' Fluff Really, why would anyone get upset about this? Wouldn't you expect it? Remember Cameron talking endlessly about the "structural deficit" and of course the "Labour caused the GFC by borrowing too much" Unchallenged by the media, particularly the BBC and for the record, Ed Miliband. The biggest political lie of the century, possibly ever. Then the infamous "There's no money left note" RE: Surprise - CarlosCorbewrong - 07-29-2024 If the electorate had half a brain cell they’d get much angrier about the ‘new’ deficit figures that they would a silly note. RE: Surprise - Protheroe - 07-29-2024 (07-29-2024, 06:38 AM)Pontificator Wrote: The biggest political lie of the century, possibly ever. Nope. The biggest political lie ever, is that our spending on health and welfare is sustainable. The OBR's long-term projections (from 2022) show debt rising to over 100 per cent of GDP by 2052-53 and reaching 267 per cent of GDP in 50 years if upward pressures on health, pensions and social care spending, and the loss of motoring taxes, are accommodated. Bringing debt back to 75 per cent of GDP – the level at which it stabilised in the Government’s pre-pandemic March 2020 Budget – would need taxes to rise, spending to fall, or a combination of both, amounting to a 1.5 per cent of GDP additional tightening (£37 billion a year in today’s terms) at the beginning of each decade over the next 50 years. [OBR's words - not mine] Unfortunately we're at a tipping point. Reeves faces the prospect or either raising taxes or cutting spending at a time we have the highest peacetime tax burden and ever increasing calls for welfare expenditure. We're already seeing the breakdown of the social contract in £7bn welfare fraud and a similar estimate of £7.5bn in Covid fraud. Starmer spent much of the election campaign chastising people like me for being too pessimistic about growth and tax. Well he's in power now. We know that no government has ever taxed its way to growth. We know that realigning taxes from income to capital will lead to behavioural changes amongst those able to control when and how they take income and capital gains. The increases won't bring in what is estimated, and I can guarantee you that the burden will fall on "working people" in endless fiscal drag (and other stealth taxes) - yet allow Starmer to keep his promise not to increase the rate of taxation. RE: Surprise - Pontificator - 07-29-2024 (07-29-2024, 09:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-29-2024, 06:38 AM)Pontificator Wrote: The biggest political lie of the century, possibly ever. FFS, that public services and the government is in the middle of a massive crisis, is what it is. The blame laid at the Labour government for what Cameron described as debt crisis was a disgrace. It enabled him and Osborne and set this country on a path to the shit show we have now. I doubt Reeves will emulate their stupidity, but I have maintained that the fiscal rule is daft. i agree with you about fiscal drag and if thresholds don't rise it is a tax increass on working people. RE: Surprise - baggy1 - 07-29-2024 I’m confused, is this the OBR that we can trust the output from or the OBR that always get their figures wrong? RE: Surprise - Protheroe - 07-29-2024 (07-29-2024, 10:34 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I’m confused, is this the OBR that we can trust the output from or the OBR that always get their figures wrong? The OBR's projections are generally wrong, but unfortunately for all of us there is no denying the direction of travel on health and welfare spending. The OBR is what you have, and their opinions are also backed up by the Left's favourite think-tanks too. If what I read this morning is correct then in in true Bevanite tradition Labour is stuffing the doctors' mouths with gold, and much more of the public sector looks like it's going to get 175% more than inflation. At the same time Reeves will embark on scrapping capital projects aimed at enabling growth, so it doesn't really take a genius to work out where the money is coming from for the forseeable future. RE: Surprise - Kit Kat Chunky - 07-29-2024 (07-29-2024, 11:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-29-2024, 10:34 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I’m confused, is this the OBR that we can trust the output from or the OBR that always get their figures wrong? And they have opened "Pandora's Box" on Public Sector pay rises as well. I'm not saying that Doctors don't deserve a decent pay rise, but it is the bigger picture. We are going to need some fantastic levels of growth to pay for this, if taxes aren't going up. RE: Surprise - Ted Maul - 07-29-2024 (07-29-2024, 09:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: We know that no government has ever taxed its way to growth. We know that realigning taxes from income to capital will lead to behavioural changes amongst those able to control when and how they take income and capital gains. The increases won't bring in what is estimated, and I can guarantee you that the burden will fall on "working people" in endless fiscal drag (and other stealth taxes) - yet allow Starmer to keep his promise not to increase the rate of taxation. Always very quick to point it out but never willing to criticise or challenge those who take from the system when it suits and leave the "working people" with the bill. RE: Surprise - Kit Kat Chunky - 07-29-2024 (07-29-2024, 12:37 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:(07-29-2024, 09:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: We know that no government has ever taxed its way to growth. We know that realigning taxes from income to capital will lead to behavioural changes amongst those able to control when and how they take income and capital gains. The increases won't bring in what is estimated, and I can guarantee you that the burden will fall on "working people" in endless fiscal drag (and other stealth taxes) - yet allow Starmer to keep his promise not to increase the rate of taxation. Working people are having to foot the bill. Reported (unconfirmed) increases of 10 PPL on fuel duty on the way in the Autumn, increases taxes on pensions on the way as well. This winter is going to be rocky as the unions go in for the kill on wage increases. Do these people deserve decent rises? - yes. Everyone is going to have to pay for them though. |