WBAUnofficial
Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery (/showthread.php?tid=33408)

Pages: 1 2


Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - CarlosCorbewrong - 04-20-2024

Richard Drax, hereditary owner of Drax Hall, a slave plantation populated by two slaving boats owned by his ancestors, will sell the estate to the Barbadian government for market value.

 [font=GuardianTextEgyptian, "Guardian Text Egyptian Web", Georgia, serif]Richard Drax declined to comment. In the past, he has said the role his ancestors played in the slave trade was “deeply, deeply regrettable but no one can be held responsible today for what happened many hundreds of years ago”.[/font]

[font=GuardianTextEgyptian, "Guardian Text Egyptian Web", Georgia, serif]https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2024/apr/20/tory-mp-from-slave-owning-family-set-to-gain-3m-from-sale-of-former-plantation[/font]


RE: Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - Protheroe - 04-21-2024

Yes. Because democracies like Barbados tend to uphold the rule of law.


RE: Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - CarlosCorbewrong - 04-21-2024

(04-21-2024, 01:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Yes. Because democracies like Barbados tend to uphold the rule of law.

It's interesting that you saw the question through a legalistic rather than moralistic lens.


RE: Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - Protheroe - 04-21-2024

(04-21-2024, 01:50 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 01:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Yes. Because democracies like Barbados tend to uphold the rule of law.

It's interesting that you saw the question through a legalistic rather than moralistic lens.

That's because that's how a liberal democratic society works. And thank goodness for that.

There is no moral case for slavery nor is there a case for the summary sequestration of property on moral grounds - if that were to happen, where would it end?


RE: Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - CarlosCorbewrong - 04-22-2024

(04-21-2024, 02:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 01:50 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 01:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Yes. Because democracies like Barbados tend to uphold the rule of law.

It's interesting that you saw the question through a legalistic rather than moralistic lens.

That's because that's how a liberal democratic society works. And thank goodness for that.

There is no moral case for slavery nor is there a case for the summary sequestration of property on moral grounds - if that were to happen, where would it end?

You've narrowed it down to 'summary sequestration' to suit the narrow ethical feamework you live by (can I legally get away with it or not?), conveniently ignoring numerous examples of appropriate reparations made to abused races over centuries.


RE: Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - Protheroe - 04-22-2024

There are plenty of examples of a State paying reparations. Do you have any examples of a private individual being requested to and then paying reparations in a democratic state?


RE: Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - CarlosCorbewrong - 04-22-2024

(04-22-2024, 07:48 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There are plenty of examples of a State paying reparations. Do you have any examples of a private individual being requested to and then paying reparations in a democratic state?

Deflection again, away from your awful moral compass.

Your first statement was there is no moral case for slavery (and therefore presumably profiting from it).

Your second statement was effectively "but it is legal to do that"


RE: Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - Protheroe - 04-22-2024

(04-22-2024, 06:10 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: ignoring numerous examples of appropriate reparations made to abused races over centuries.

I was responding to your specific point (above) which also goes back to my previous point - if you summarily override the rule of law for this individual, then where does it end? 

And if in 100 years something you profit from now is seen as immoral and abolished ought your grandchildren pay the price?


RE: Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - CarlosCorbewrong - 04-22-2024

(04-22-2024, 06:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-22-2024, 06:10 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: ignoring numerous examples of appropriate reparations made to abused races over centuries.

I was responding to your specific point (above) which also goes back to my previous point - if you summarily override the rule of law for this individual, then where does it end? 

And if in 100 years something you profit from now is seen as immoral and abolished ought your grandchildren pay the price?
Should they be able to retain the profits of my immorality? There is no punishment? They just don't get to inherit something they haven't had to work (or kill or enslave) for

Do you think it would be reasonable for the government of Barbados to sequester slave properties, through legislation?


RE: Should modern day MPs be able to retain the assets gained/maintained through slavery - Protheroe - 04-22-2024

The point is, where does it end CC. What is deemed immoral in one age is not in another. Humanity has generally made progress. I don't believe the sins of the father ought to visited upon the son as Ezekiel 18: 19-23 might have put it.

So the answer is no, under the rule of law it is not reasonable for Barbados to sequester property.

I'm travelling through FL, GA & SC later this year ending up in MLK's Atlanta via civil war sites and plantations and I'm sure the subject of reparations is likely to come up. It'll be interesting to hear what those direct descendants have to say. I'll let you know.