WBAUnofficial
For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives (/showthread.php?tid=3245)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Derek Hardballs - 04-11-2019

Just wondered as there seems to be quite a few underwhelmed by our link with the PNE boss who they want. 

We don’t want dinosaurs
We don’t want a manager with a blip in their CV
We want them to be young and fking hungry 
We want them to play a way we think is the right way

From the list above it’s obvious the job spec is impossible or near to, to please everyone but perhaps fellow posters can give realisticnames of better suited.


RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - SausEggBaton - 04-11-2019

Firstly Derek, the underwhelming factor is, I would like the club to show some fucking ambition!

The current news is like we are about to appoint a fucking roasted Parsnip for the rest of the season.


RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - baggiebloke - 04-11-2019

I'd be fine with AFN.

Ron Atkinson, Ray Harford and Gary Megson underwhelmed fans and proved to be astute hires.


RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Derek Hardballs - 04-11-2019

(04-11-2019, 08:57 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Firstly Derek, the underwhelming factor is, I would like the club to show some fucking ambition!

The current news is like we are about to appoint a fucking roasted Parsnip for the rest of the season.

That’s not answering the question Saus. Who would you have preferred? Just a few names of realistic targets. I imagine some will say Jankovic and Wagner (spelling) but there CVs are patchy with relegation and resignations. 

If he was a foreign manager with a similar CV I suspect the link would be more warmly / excitedly recurved.


RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - backsidebaggie - 04-11-2019

(04-11-2019, 08:57 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Firstly Derek, the underwhelming factor is, I would like the club to show some fucking ambition!

The current news is like we are about to appoint a fucking roasted Parsnip for the rest of the season.

Surely appointing a manager who has won two play offs is showing ambition to win the play offs?


RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Sliced - 04-11-2019

Sacking BD at the point we did could've thrown us into a spiral and absolute chaos, Shan did well to at least ensure we're not going to drop out of the playoffs. Getting anyone in at this point and expecting them to take us up through the playoffs with about 4 games worth of preparation prior and not a full contingent to choose from is a ridiculous ask.

However I'm happy we're at least getting someone in with some football management experience and a decent enough CV. Those who are complaining undoubtedly only had one or two in mind (probably Wagner or Jokanovic) and anyone outside of these would have been given the same reaction. I understand this as making such a bold (or IMO ridiculous) decision to sack a manager in 4th with a few weeks of the season left could have possibly been justified by getting in a spectacular alternative. Alex Neil isn't this, however at this point I would say he's in the top 4 of the realistic options out there.

The goalposts have moved. Alex Neil wouldn't have been acceptable a few weeks ago, but we're such a clusterfuck that now it seems like a decent option.


RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - backsidebaggie - 04-11-2019

(04-11-2019, 09:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: Sacking BD at the point we did could've thrown us into a spiral and absolute chaos, Shan did well to at least ensure we're not going to drop out of the playoffs. Getting anyone in at this point and expecting them to take us up through the playoffs with about 4 games worth of preparation prior and not a full contingent to choose from is a ridiculous ask.

However I'm happy we're at least getting someone in with some football management experience and a decent enough CV. Those who are complaining undoubtedly only had one or two in mind (probably Wagner or Jokanovic) and anyone outside of these would have been given the same reaction. I understand this as making such a bold (or IMO ridiculous) decision to sack a manager in 4th with a few weeks of the season left could have possibly been justified by getting in a spectacular alternative. Alex Neil isn't this, however at this point I would say he's in the top 4 of the realistic options out there.

The goalposts have moved. Alex Neil wouldn't have been acceptable a few weeks ago, but we're such a clusterfuck that now it seems like a decent option.

I don't think the goalposts have moved though, Neil was on the short list immediately and its been a case of the three wins giving albion more time to persuade him/preston. He was as acceptable then as he is now (depending on your viewpoint on him).


RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - ElbowGrease1973 - 04-11-2019

My personal choice would have been Jokanovic, but I don't think he fits the clubs strategy. In that respect, I think Neil is a good fit in terms of the approach the club is taking. He's a young Manager, who brings kids through if they're good enough, and works under a budget. It's all a bit underwhelming, but that's where we are as a club, and not a slight on Neil. Unfortunately we're more Walsall than Wolves in our approach. It seems the ambition is stay solvent first and foremost, with success on the pitch a secondary concern. Let's see where that takes us, if the kids prove good enough and we make some astute purchases, we may challengethe top 6, if not, it's mid-table obscurity.

Splashing the cash doesn't necessarily mean success, but it certainly helps. I can't help but cast envious glances at those clubs that show ambition, because I don't think that's ever going to be us. We're hoping that we can plod along like the tortoise and catch the hare(s) out.


RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Stig of the Dump - 04-11-2019

(04-11-2019, 09:06 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(04-11-2019, 08:57 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Firstly Derek, the underwhelming factor is, I would like the club to show some fucking ambition!

The current news is like we are about to appoint a fucking roasted Parsnip for the rest of the season.

Surely appointing a manager who has won two play offs is showing ambition to win the play offs?

What about the third time rule!

Big Grin


RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Sliced - 04-11-2019

(04-11-2019, 09:19 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I don't think the goalposts have moved though, Neil was on the short list immediately and its been a case of the three wins giving albion more time to persuade him/preston. He was as acceptable then as he is now (depending on your viewpoint on him).

I didn't express myself well, I don't mean for the club. I meant personally for me the goalposts have moved in terms of what is an acceptable replacement. I think the only possible justification for getting rid of Big Dave would have been getting in someone that is (IMO) better than Alex Neil. However we really need someone in asap now, time is running out, and Alex Neil is one of the better options to deal with that problem.