WBAUnofficial
Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? (/showthread.php?tid=32219)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - Derek Hardballs - 01-04-2024

Taking parachute payments and investment from owners out of the equation is any club breaking even? I ask as I am trying to understand those who think we can cut and cut our budget and still be competitive in this league.


RE: Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - Fulham Fallout - 01-04-2024

(01-04-2024, 02:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Taking parachute payments and investment from owners out of the equation is any club breaking even? I ask as I am trying to understand those who think we can cut and cut our budget and still be competitive in this league.

No one mentioned being competitive. 

Developing and / or bringing in young players and selling them for a tidy profit has to be the business model we should be following. 

We can no longer afford to bring in established players for a fee and on high wages.


RE: Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - Ted Maul - 01-04-2024

(01-04-2024, 02:37 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(01-04-2024, 02:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Taking parachute payments and investment from owners out of the equation is any club breaking even? I ask as I am trying to understand those who think we can cut and cut our budget and still be competitive in this league.

No one mentioned being competitive. 

Developing and / or bringing in young players and selling them for a tidy profit has to be the business model we should be following. 

We can no longer afford to bring in established players for a fee and on high wages.

Correct. We wasted our best chance to do this between 2018 and 2021. Now we're constantly chasing our tail and have slipped well into the soup.


RE: Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - Derek Hardballs - 01-04-2024

That wasn’t the question, the question was currently if you exclude those clubs without owners willing and able to invest or in receivership of parachute money are there any clubs who break even in the Championship?

Can you be self sufficient in the Championship for two or three seasons?

In answer to the point about being competitive, how do you become competitive if your squad gets weaker and weaker as you cut your cloth according to dwindling finance? This conveyor belt of youth players who are good to play regularly seems a tad unrealistic currently.


RE: Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - Ted Maul - 01-04-2024

No then. The same goes for pretty much any league.

Even the likes of Brentford and Brighton who have been long held up as models to follow have had extra cash injected in recent seasons.


RE: Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - Remi_Moses - 01-04-2024

Reminomics calculates the average loss per club in the championship is approx £25m per season
Relegated sides with fresh parachute payments help off set any losses. Hence the reason promotion within Two or three seasons is vital to keeping the balance sheet healthy.
After that is sell sell sell, cut cut cut unless the owner has very deep pockets. 
It helps if the club is set up to operate on lower levels of income. For us it's a double whammy. Set up as a premiership club with a championship budget and an owner who has only taken funds out is a recipe for disaster.


RE: Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - baggiedave85 - 01-04-2024

It depends on how you become self sufficient - you either do things on the cheap, and hope, or you grow talent and then sell it on. The likes of Boro and Coventry have done that quite well in recent seasons, buying in good prospects or developing them and then selling them on for big money - Gyorkes, Hamer at Cov, Spence and Tavernier at Boro, but in truth Boro have had a lot of investment over years from Gibson

Unless you luck in one season, I would say its either you become self sufficient and accept you need a luck season (like Luton) or you need the extra investment from outside investors to succeed. A lot of championship teams have significant investments just to stay afloat - take Bristol C for example

As TM just said - the premier league clubs all rely on extra injections and as time has gone on more and more champ clubs have had to do the same to stand any chance of success


RE: Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - Pragmatist - 01-04-2024

(01-04-2024, 03:31 PM)baggiedave85 Wrote: It depends on how you become self sufficient - you either do things on the cheap, and hope, or you grow talent and then sell it on. The likes of Boro and Coventry have done that quite well in recent seasons, buying in good prospects or developing them and then selling them on for big money - Gyorkes, Hamer at Cov, Spence and Tavernier at Boro, but in truth Boro have had a lot of investment over years from Gibson

Unless you luck in one season, I would say its either you become self sufficient and accept you need a luck season (like Luton) or you need the extra investment from outside investors to succeed. A lot of championship teams have significant investments just to stay afloat - take Bristol C for example

As TM just said - the premier league clubs all rely on extra injections and as time has gone on more and more champ clubs have had to do the same to stand any chance of success

Selling players for big profits is the answer.  It rarely weakens the selling club if they reinvest most of the proceeds in good, hungry young players with high resale value.  One star player leaves, sign 3 or 4 with a decent amount of cash left over.  Rinse and repeat.  

Coventry a prime example (although they don’t own their ground).  Sold 2 players for big profits, buy wisely.  They are now just outside the playoffs, in a better position than they were at this time last year.  

In answer to the opening question, I think the answer is generally no (Coventry might be a one-year exception, as might Boro).  Norwich might be one of the closest, Plymouth possibly close too.  The rest - yes as Remi stated, probably £20m-£25m average loss.  Totally unsustainable.


RE: Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - Kit Kat Chunky - 01-04-2024

How much have Blues raked in during the last 5 years by selling youth players?


RE: Is any club in the Championship self sufficient? - Derek Hardballs - 01-04-2024

(01-04-2024, 03:57 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: How much have Blues raked in during the last 5 years by selling youth players?

No idea but not enough for them to be slowly but surely falling apart as a club on and off the pitch.