WBAUnofficial
Just got back, ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Just got back, ratings (/showthread.php?tid=31508)

Pages: 1 2


Just got back, ratings - greetsgreenbaggie - 10-21-2023

Palmer-8 earned us a point
Kipre-7 see above
Barts-7 steady
Pieters-6 legs are gone
Furlong-6 sloppy in possession, poor defending
Chalobah-6 1 decent tackle, pedestrian at best
Mowatt-7 looked our best attacking threat
Phillips-6 winter time form
Wallace-5 captaincy is weighing him down
Diang-6 fleeting views of what he's capable off, didn't touch the ball in the 1st 10 mins
BTA-4 confidence his shot, touch is crap, runs non existent  
Ajaji-6 not a lot to do
Townsend-7 100% improvement on Pieters
Molumby-6 energy
Okay-6 shored up the team
Fellows-6 not enough time to shine

Overall, poor team performance. Need/should be beating these teams!


RE: Just got back, ratings - rsbaggy2 - 10-21-2023

Some very interesting marks there.
Some highly debatable. Phillips, Chalobah and Wallace in particular harsh.


RE: Just got back, ratings - Man from delmonte - 10-21-2023

Got to say I disagree with a few of those comments:
- 'Should be beating these teams' - Plymouth are a very competent side and that comment really smacks of 'big club' arrogance.
- We were very poor first half but completely dominated the second half. Certainly in the third quarter of the game they barely had a kick. We actually lost our grip grip a bit once Chalobah went off.
 - Talking of whom, I thought he played well today. Really got involved and put in a more energetic performance than we normally see from him.
- 6 is very generous for Pieters who was awful. Constantly gave the ball away.
- BTA didn't have one of his best days but not sure his confidence is shot or that he was by far our worst player. He ran, he hustled, he tried. There was wasn't a huge end product but you could say that for most of our attackers. I'm sure someone said a couple of weeks ago he'd been 'found out'. Who said football fans were a fickle bunch eh?

Overall I thought it was a decent performance and a much better game than the scoreline suggested. There were a few boos from some of the knuckle draggers at the back of the Brummie Rd at the end but then again they don't satisfied unless we're winning 5-0 every week.

I think it was just one of those games where things just didn't quite fall for us. There was some very good approach play in the second half, Phillips in particular and Fellows later on really giving their full backs something to thing about. 3 points would have been nice but it didn't happen.


RE: Just got back, ratings - Squid - 10-21-2023

(10-21-2023, 05:54 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Some very interesting marks there.
Some highly debatable. Phillips, Chalobah and Wallace in particular harsh.

I would agree. Okay is overmarked too. Looked sluggish when he came on. Wallace in particular was everywhere, didn't stop trying.

For those who weren't there: Chalobah got a big round of applause when he went off.

Edited to add: Man from Delmonte is spot on.


RE: Just got back, ratings - Sliced - 10-21-2023

Yeah im not sure about that. I definitely wouldn’t have given Chalobah and Diangana the same marks as each other


RE: Just got back, ratings - CA Baggie - 10-21-2023

I’ve no problem with Chalobah’s 6, it was probably his best game for us.

The stand out wrong one is Pieters in comparison to the others. He had an absolute stinker in possession. Probably BTA being the only player on the pitch worse than him. Townsend for Pieters is probably one of the easiest subs we’ll make this season.

Overall just a bit flat, it’s clear we have zero threat up front, I think we’ve just got to hold on in there until we have injured players back. Maja had hardly set the world alight but at least it was another option.


RE: Just got back, ratings - MrFizz - 10-21-2023

(10-21-2023, 06:01 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’ve no problem with Chalobah’s 6, it was probably his best game for us. 

The stand out wrong one is Pieters in comparison to the others.  He had an absolute stinker in possession. Probably BTA being the only player on the pitch worse than him.  Townsend for Pieters is probably one of the easiest subs we’ll make this season.

Overall just a bit flat, it’s clear we have zero threat up front, I think we’ve just got to hold on in there until we have injured players back.  Maja had hardly set the world alight but at least it was another option.

Yep just got to keep going and concentrate on keeping clean sheets until Swift/Maja/Dike are available. Nothing else we can do. Not like the good old days when you could raid someone for a loan striker for a month. Just got to put up with it for now.


RE: Just got back, ratings - Mickyfudge - 10-21-2023

We have got injuries but that is no excuse for how slowly we move the ball .wing backs are non existent too


RE: Just got back, ratings - ElbowGrease1973 II - 10-21-2023

(10-21-2023, 06:06 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(10-21-2023, 06:01 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’ve no problem with Chalobah’s 6, it was probably his best game for us. 

The stand out wrong one is Pieters in comparison to the others.  He had an absolute stinker in possession. Probably BTA being the only player on the pitch worse than him.  Townsend for Pieters is probably one of the easiest subs we’ll make this season.

Overall just a bit flat, it’s clear we have zero threat up front, I think we’ve just got to hold on in there until we have injured players back.  Maja had hardly set the world alight but at least it was another option.

Yep just got to keep going and concentrate on keeping clean sheets until Swift/Maja/Dike are available. Nothing else we can do. Not like the good old days when you could raid someone for a loan striker for a month. Just got to put up with it for now.
It was crying out for a change up for front, but there was nothing on the bench.

I think King Carlos is doing all he can with the tools at his disposal. I think trying to keep it tight defensively and nick a goal is a sensible approach with so many attacking players out.

I was disappointed with Grady today, and thought Fellows was more dangerous in his little cameo.


RE: Just got back, ratings - MancBaggie - 10-21-2023

(10-21-2023, 06:29 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote:
(10-21-2023, 06:06 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(10-21-2023, 06:01 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’ve no problem with Chalobah’s 6, it was probably his best game for us. 

The stand out wrong one is Pieters in comparison to the others.  He had an absolute stinker in possession. Probably BTA being the only player on the pitch worse than him.  Townsend for Pieters is probably one of the easiest subs we’ll make this season.

Overall just a bit flat, it’s clear we have zero threat up front, I think we’ve just got to hold on in there until we have injured players back.  Maja had hardly set the world alight but at least it was another option.

Yep just got to keep going and concentrate on keeping clean sheets until Swift/Maja/Dike are available. Nothing else we can do. Not like the good old days when you could raid someone for a loan striker for a month. Just got to put up with it for now.
It was crying out for a change up for front, but there was nothing on the bench.

I think King Carlos is doing all he can with the tools at his disposal. I think trying to keep it tight defensively and nick a goal is a sensible approach with so many attacking players out.

I was disappointed with Grady today, and thought Fellows was more dangerous in his little cameo.

His selections were ok - Chalobah the only surprise but fair enough with the 2 games in 3 days. 

Defo hamstrung by options. I just don’t get the approach in the first half and why we only pressed for 25 min all game. When we did Plymouth were rattled. Over 90 mins it was marginally better than the Hudds  game - and that’s a low bar