![]() |
|
The Band - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: The Band (/showthread.php?tid=30248) Pages:
1
2
|
The Band - Tom Joad - 06-11-2023 Just catching up with Once Were Brothers, the story of the Band. BBC iplayer. I've seen it before but it's really compulsive. It's all opinions of course, but so influential. It's more the music than the tributes but the killer praise came from Clapton. ' I heard them and immediately left the other two (Bruce and Baker)'. For me, they invented Americana, the stuff that refreshes the continuity of rock music. RE: The Band - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 06-12-2023 (06-11-2023, 11:03 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Just catching up with Once Were Brothers, the story of the Band. BBC iplayer. I've seen it before but it's really compulsive. It's all opinions of course, but so influential. It's more the music than the tributes but the killer praise came from Clapton. ' I heard them and immediately left the other two (Bruce and Baker)'. For me, they invented Americana, the stuff that refreshes the continuity of rock music.Do you have any of their Albums Tom ? I got a 'Best Of' type thing a few years back, plus ' Rock Of Ages', a live album. Superb musicians but several had 'issues', especially Danko & Manuel, all fell out with Robertson apparently. Across The Great Divide is a good book about them. Great group. RE: The Band - Tom Joad - 06-12-2023 I had Rock of Ages, The Last Waltz and the Basement Tapes when I had a vinyl player. ( So I still have them somewhere!) I always knewThe Band were good but did not realise just how influential they were, I reckon for me, their music just went on the back burner when punk happened. The tributes in that documentary are something else. Robertson says he was saved by having a young family whereas the others just clattered headlong into hard drugs. Shame about the acrimony and from OWB I can sort of see both sides. I'm going to get Across the Great Divide later plus the Robbie Robertson book. I urge anyone with a love of music to watch that documentary. RE: The Band - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 06-12-2023 (06-12-2023, 08:03 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I had Rock of Ages, The Last Waltz and the Basement Tapes when I had a vinyl player. ( So I still have them somewhere!) Am off work for a few days now, so will try to watch it. may try to get `Stagefright` C.D as well, did once have `The Band`, their second album, but can`t find it now. Do you like any of Creedence Clearwater Revivals stuff? songs about `The Bayou`, freight train to New Orleans etc. RE: The Band - Beachboysbaggie - 06-12-2023 Thanks Tom I’ll definitely give that a watch. The Band are a group I have made an effort to get into. As a big Beatles fan I know they influenced them massively especially for the Let it Be project. I love Rag Mama Rag and Dixie. I bought Big Pink and the Band second album. They have their moments but to me they sound a little like bootlegs, recording quality not great and the arrangements loose. Although maybe that’s the point. RE: The Band - DemonicBaggie - 06-12-2023 Great band. The Last Waltz is a brilliant rock film. RE: The Band - Mr vertical - 06-12-2023 Their first two albums are indispensable imo. The early 00s reissues have a lot of Basement Tapes stuff as well as alternate takes. I love that they had multiple lead singers and such a good grasp of serving the songs instead of all the virtuoso stuff everyone else was doing. Robbie getting the majority of the writing credits certainly upset the others after a while - Levon Helm especially. It's no coincidence that their material wasn't as good once the others stopped contributing so freely, imo. Robbie's book is amazing but a lot of the key players are no longer with us to confirm/deny things - it seems like he met everyone and was present at many seminal musical moments. RE: The Band - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 06-12-2023 (06-12-2023, 01:18 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: Their first two albums are indispensable imo. The early 00s reissues have a lot of Basement Tapes stuff as well as alternate takes. I love that they had multiple lead singers and such a good grasp of serving the songs instead of all the virtuoso stuff everyone else was doing. Robbie getting the majority of the writing credits certainly upset the others after a while - Levon Helm especially. It's no coincidence that their material wasn't as good once the others stopped contributing so freely, imo. Robbie's book is amazing but a lot of the key players are no longer with us to confirm/deny things - it seems like he met everyone and was present at many seminal musical moments.Just watched the film. It seems Robertson had to write all the songs as the others were spaced out and couldn't do it. Then, that may be just his view. RE: The Band - Mr vertical - 06-12-2023 (06-12-2023, 02:14 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:(06-12-2023, 01:18 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: Their first two albums are indispensable imo. The early 00s reissues have a lot of Basement Tapes stuff as well as alternate takes. I love that they had multiple lead singers and such a good grasp of serving the songs instead of all the virtuoso stuff everyone else was doing. Robbie getting the majority of the writing credits certainly upset the others after a while - Levon Helm especially. It's no coincidence that their material wasn't as good once the others stopped contributing so freely, imo. Robbie's book is amazing but a lot of the key players are no longer with us to confirm/deny things - it seems like he met everyone and was present at many seminal musical moments.Just watched the film. It seems Robertson had to write all the songs as the others were spaced out and couldn't do it. Then, that may be just his view. Definitely a lot of gear around for the others and he's got a point. Helm disagreed with the music publishing business' idea of the difference between songwriting and arrangement. RE: The Band - Fido - 06-12-2023 The name Robbie Robertson always brings back memories of the Midnight Line on Beacon Radio as they seemed to play “Somewhere down the Crazy River” every night during the late 80s. I know Nick remembers some of the characters who would phone in after slaughtering a bottle of Claymore or whatever. Led to some very funny evenings. The old fella’s name who wanted capital punishment for parking on double yellows escapes me (it was because he was blind and he may have meant “corporal” instead) but the realisation that his soul mate Ken was gay caused me to wake the whole house one night guffawing with laughter. |