WBAUnofficial
A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? (/showthread.php?tid=30119)

Pages: 1 2 3


A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - WorcsWBA - 05-27-2023

Rather than penalties being used to decide drawn play-off games (including semi-finals), wouldn't a fairer way be for whichever of the two clubs that finished the season highest in the league to simply be deemed the winner if the deciding game ends all-square after extra time?

This would:
  • Stop extremely important games being decided by the complete lottery of penalties
  • Provide a greater reward to clubs in play-off places who finish higher up the table
  • Potentially incentivise clubs in play-off places to continue to accumulate points all the way to the end of the season
  • Avoid the regular scenario where both teams increasingly become afraid of losing the deciding games rather than continue trying to win
  • Remove the possibility of players who miss penalties during shoot-outs experiencing mental health issues
  • Be a compromise for those who think there shouldn't be play-offs at all and that the club which finished third in the table should just be promoted
I'm struggling to think of a downside to this alternative method of doing it, which has left me wondering why it's never been done this way? Does anyone know if it's done like this in any other countries?


RE: A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - Logic1 - 05-27-2023

The downside is that the team placed higher in the league would likely play for a draw. I think there should be a replay.


RE: A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - Cunninghamismagic - 05-27-2023

Not sure why penalties are a lottery. Combines finishing skill and goalkeeper skill


RE: A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - Pf1ster - 05-27-2023

(05-27-2023, 08:54 PM)Logic1 Wrote: The downside is that the team placed higher in the league would likely play for a draw. I think there should be a replay.

I agree with a replay. Or just promote the top three, and dispense with play-offs.


RE: A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - Malcolm Tucker - 05-27-2023

(05-27-2023, 08:58 PM)Pf1ster Wrote:
(05-27-2023, 08:54 PM)Logic1 Wrote: The downside is that the team placed higher in the league would likely play for a draw. I think there should be a replay.

I agree with a replay. Or just promote the top three, and dispense with play-offs.

That would leave an obscene number of dead rubber games from March onwards. 

Nothing wrong with the current system IMO. Everyone knows what happens at the end of extra time and both sides have the chance to try and win the game to stop that from happening.


RE: A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - Sliced - 05-27-2023

(05-27-2023, 09:04 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-27-2023, 08:58 PM)Pf1ster Wrote:
(05-27-2023, 08:54 PM)Logic1 Wrote: The downside is that the team placed higher in the league would likely play for a draw. I think there should be a replay.

I agree with a replay. Or just promote the top three, and dispense with play-offs.

That would leave an obscene number of dead rubber games from March onwards. 

Nothing wrong with the current system IMO. Everyone knows what happens at the end of extra time and both sides have the chance to try and win the game to stop that from happening.

Yep


RE: A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - Duffers - 05-27-2023

What’s wrong with penalties anyway?

Both teams have 120 minutes to outscore the other on a neutral ground. Seems a perfectly fair way to settle things if you ask me.


RE: A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - BurleyBaggie - 05-28-2023

I hate this idea that penalties are unfair or a lottery.

It’s literally the opposite. It’s highly skilful, while also mixing skill with attitude.

Lottery suggests it’s luck and it blatantly isn’t.


RE: A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - Calgary_Baggie - 05-28-2023

(05-28-2023, 12:27 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: I hate this idea that penalties are unfair or a lottery.

It’s literally the opposite. It’s highly skilful, while also mixing skill with attitude.

Lottery suggests it’s luck and it blatantly isn’t.

Correct. 

The ultimate test after a long game; skill and composure under extreme pressure. They get paid handsomely for doing something they love so a bit of pressure won't hurt them. Plus it's great to watch.


RE: A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs? - wba13 - 05-28-2023

Yes it’s great to watch but it’s totally wrong. The team who finishes 3rd should get automatic promotion no matter what,forget about the skill of penalties and the skill of goalkeepers. The team coming third has been the 3 rd most consistent of the top sides. How can a team possibly finishes 6th,20 points behind the 3rd placed side be allowed the chance to get promoted. It’s just a money making scheme by the FA. So some think a team who finish 4th 5th or 6th deserves to go up because they have been better over 1 or 2 matches than the side who have been more consistent over the season. It’s totally wrong.
But as I said at the beginning it’s great to watch.